Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2013 Bar Examinations

2013 Remedial Law, Q3

While in his Nissan Patrol and hurrying home to Quezon City from his work in Makati, Gary figured in a vehicular mishap along that portion of EDSA within the City of Mandaluyong. He was bumped from behind by a Ford Expedition SUV driven by Horace who was observed using his cellular phone at the time of the collision. Both vehicles – more than 5 years old – no longer carried insurance other than the compulsory third party liability insurance. Gary suffered physical injuries while his Nissan Patrol sustained damage in excess of Php500,000.
III(A) As counsel for Gary, describe the process you need to undertake starting from the point of the incident if Gary would proceed criminally against Horace, and identify the court with jurisdiction over the case. (3%)
III(B) If Gary chooses to file an independent civil action for damages, explain briefly this type of action: its legal basis; the different approaches in pursuing this type of action; the evidence you would need; and types of defenses you could expect. (5%)

Quick check

Which court has jurisdiction over a criminal case for reckless imprudence resulting in physical injuries and damage to property committed along EDSA in Mandaluyong City?

Under Rule 111 of the Rules of Court, is a prior reservation required to file an independent civil action for quasi-delict under Article 2176 of the Civil Code?

What quantum of evidence is required to establish liability in an independent civil action for damages based on quasi-delict?

What is the legal effect of contributory negligence on the part of the plaintiff in a quasi-delict action under Article 2179 of the Civil Code?

Which statute prohibits the use of mobile communications devices while driving a motor vehicle in the Philippines?

Learn more about these topics

1. Reckless Imprudence Process
To initiate a criminal prosecution for reckless imprudence resulting in physical injuries and damage to property under Article 365 of the Revised Penal Code, the offended party must file a complaint-affidavit supported by police blotter reports, medical certificates, and repair estimates before the Office of the City Prosecutor of Mandaluyong, where the collision occurred. Since the penalty for reckless imprudence resulting in physical injuries and property damage falls within the jurisdiction of First Level Courts, the resulting criminal Information will be filed with and tried by the Metropolitan Trial Court of Mandaluyong.

2. Independent Civil Action
Under Article 2176 of the Civil Code in relation to Rule 111, Section 3 of the Rules of Court, an independent civil action for damages based on quasi-delict may be instituted separately from the criminal action without need of reservation. This civil action proceeds independently of the criminal prosecution and requires only a preponderance of evidence to establish liability. The plaintiff must prove the defendant's negligent act, such as distracted driving using a cellular phone in violation of Republic Act No. 10913, the resulting damage, and the direct causal connection between them.

3. Defenses and Evidence
In an independent civil action for quasi-delict, the plaintiff relies on evidence including official police traffic accident reports, eyewitness testimonies, photographs of vehicle damage, medical receipts, and proof of lost income. Conversely, the defendant driver may raise affirmative defenses such as fortuitous event, mechanical defect, or contributory negligence under Article 2179 of the Civil Code. If contributory negligence is proven, it will not bar recovery but will mitigate the damages awarded. Furthermore, establishing that the plaintiff was guilty of sole proximate negligence would completely defeat the civil claim.

TopicsIndependent Civil Action2Quasi-Delict3Reckless Imprudence6

2013 Remedial Law, Q4

At the Public Attorney’s Office station in Taguig where you are assigned, your work requires you to act as public defender at the local Regional Trial Court and to handle cases involving indigents.
IV(A) In one criminal action for qualified theft where you are the defense attorney, you learned that the woman accused has been in detention for six months, yet she has not been to a courtroom nor seen a judge.
What remedy would you undertake to address the situation and what forum would you use to invoke this relief? (3%)
IV(B) In another case, also for qualified theft, the detained young domestic helper has been brought to court five times in the last six months, but the prosecution has yet to commence the presentation of its evidence. You find that the reason for this is the continued absence of the employer-complainant who is working overseas.
What remedy is appropriate and before which forum would you invoke this relief? (3%)
IV(C) Still in another case, this time for illegal possession of dangerous drugs, the prosecution has rested but you saw from the records that the illegal substance allegedly involved has not been identified by any of the prosecution witnesses nor has it been the subject of any stipulation.
Should you now proceed posthaste to the presentation of defense evidence or consider some other remedy? Explain the remedial steps you propose to undertake. (3%)
IV(D) In one other case, an indigent mother seeks assistance for her 14-year old son who has been arrested and detained for malicious mischief.
Would an application for bail be the appropriate remedy or is there another remedy available? Justify your chosen remedy and outline the appropriate steps to take. (3%)

Quick check

What is the proper procedural remedy for a detainee held for six months without arraignment or seeing a judge?

What is the legal effect of a case dismissal grounded on the violation of the accused's right to a speedy trial?

What procedural step should defense counsel take when the prosecution rests in a drug case without identifying the corpus delicti?

Under Republic Act No. 9344, what is the criminal responsibility of a 14-year-old child who commits malicious mischief?

Which forum possesses jurisdiction to entertain a petition for a writ of habeas corpus?

Learn more about these topics

1. Habeas Corpus Relief
Under Rule 102 of the Rules of Court, a petition for a writ of habeas corpus is the appropriate remedy when a person is illegally deprived of liberty or where the due process of law has been denied. When an accused is detained for six months without arraignment or judicial appearance, the detention becomes arbitrary and illegal. The petition may be filed with the Regional Trial Court, Court of Appeals, or Supreme Court to compel the producing authority to justify the detention or release the detainee.

2. Speedy Trial Dismissal
Under Rule 119 of the Rules of Court and Republic Act No. 8493, an accused possesses a constitutional right to a speedy trial. When the prosecution repeatedly fails to commence presenting evidence due to the continuous absence of the complaining witness, the defense may file a motion to dismiss for failure to prosecute and violation of speedy trial rights. A dismissal grounded on the denial of the right to speedy trial is equivalent to an acquittal and bars double jeopardy.

3. Demurrer and Immunity
Under Rule 119, Section 23 of the Rules of Court, a demurrer to evidence allows the accused to move for dismissal after the prosecution rests on the ground of insufficiency of evidence, such as when corpus delicti is not identified. Separately, under Republic Act No. 9344, a child fifteen years of age or under at the time of the offense is exempt from criminal liability. The proper remedy is not bail but a motion for immediate release and dismissal.

TopicsDemurrer to Evidence7Habeas Corpus3Right to Speedy Trial2

2013 Remedial Law, Q5

The spouses Juan reside in Quezon City. With their lottery winnings, they purchased a parcel of land in Tagaytay City for P100,000.00. In a recent trip to their Tagaytay property, they were surprised to see hastily assembled shelters of light materials occupied by several families of informal settlers who were not there when they last visited the property three (3) months ago.
To rid the spouses’ Tagaytay property of these informal settlers, briefly discuss the legal remedy you, as their counsel, would use; the steps you would take; the court where you would file your remedy if the need arises; and the reason/s for your actions. (7%)

Quick check

What is the proper legal remedy of a landowner to recover physical possession from informal settlers who entered by stealth within the past three months?

Which court has exclusive original jurisdiction over an action for forcible entry regardless of the assessed value of the property?

Where is the proper venue for filing an action for forcible entry involving land located in Tagaytay City owned by residents of Quezon City?

Within what period from discovery of dispossession by stealth must an action for forcible entry be filed?

What procedural rules govern the trial of forcible entry cases before the Municipal Trial Court?

Learn more about these topics

1. Forcible Entry Elements
Under Rule 70 of the Rules of Court, an action for forcible entry is the proper legal remedy when a registered landowner is deprived of physical possession of real property through force, intimidation, threat, strategy, or stealth. The prior physical possession of the owner is legally recognized, and the unlawful entry by informal settlers without knowledge or consent constitutes entry by stealth. The key element is that the action must be filed within one year from the date of actual entry or from the discovery of the unlawful dispossession by the landowner.

2. Ejectment Venue Rules
Under Rule 4 of the Rules of Court, actions for forcible entry and unlawful detainer are real actions. Venue is local and lies exclusively in the Municipal Trial Court of the municipality or city wherein the real property involved, or a portion thereof, is situated. Even if the landowners reside in a different municipality or city, the statutory rule on venue for real actions strictly mandates that the complaint must be filed in the MTC having territorial jurisdiction over the physical location of the land.

3. Exclusive Original Jurisdiction
Under Batas Pambansa Blg. 129, as amended, Municipal Trial Courts possess exclusive original jurisdiction over all ejectment cases, including forcible entry and unlawful detainer, regardless of the assessed value of the real property involved or the amount of damages claimed. Furthermore, summary procedure governs ejectment proceedings to ensure an expeditious and inexpensive determination of physical possession. Before filing the complaint in court, a formal demand to vacate is typically served upon the informal settlers to establish clear legal notice.

TopicsAction for Forcible Entry1MTCC Exclusive Jurisdiction1Rule 70 Ejectment Venue1

2013 Remedial Law, Q6

While leisurely walking along the street near her house in Marikina, Patty unknowingly stepped on a garden tool left behind by CCC, a construction company based in Makati. She lost her balance as a consequence and fell into an open manhole. Fortunately, Patty suffered no major injuries except for contusions, bruises and scratches that did not require any hospitalization. However, she lost self-esteem, suffered embarrassment and ridicule, and had bouts of anxiety and bad dreams about the accident. She wants vindication for her uncalled for experience and hires you to act as counsel for her and to do whatever is necessary to recover at least Php100,000 for what she suffered.
What action or actions may Patty pursue, against whom, where (court and venue), and under what legal basis? (7%)

Quick check

Under Article 2189 of the Civil Code, when is a local government unit liable for injuries caused by an open manhole on a public street?

Which court has jurisdiction over an independent civil action for damages where the total claim is Php100,000?

Under Article 2219 of the Civil Code, when may moral damages be recovered in a quasi-delict action?

Where is the proper venue for a personal civil action for damages filed by an individual against a corporate defendant?

Choices available with full access.

What degree of negligence or fault must be proven to establish civil liability in a quasi-delict action under Article 2176?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Quasi-Delict Liability
Under Article 2176 of the Civil Code, whoever by act or omission causes damage to another, there being fault or negligence, is obliged to pay for the damage done. A private construction company that leaves tools unattended on a public street creates an unreasonable hazard. When such negligence directly causes physical injuries and consequential emotional distress, the negligent party is civilly liable for actual and moral damages under Article 2219 of the Civil Code.

2. Municipal Public Liability
Under Article 2189 of the Civil Code, provinces, cities, and municipalities are liable for damages for the death of, or injuries suffered by, any person by reason of the defective condition of roads, streets, bridges, public buildings, and other public works under their control or supervision. An open, unguarded manhole on a public street constitutes a dangerous defect, rendering the local government unit solidarily or concurrently liable for injuries sustained by pedestrians.

3. Jurisdiction and Venue
Under Batas Pambansa Blg. 129, as amended, First Level Courts possess exclusive original jurisdiction over civil actions for damages where the total monetary claim does not exceed the statutory threshold. For a claim of Php100,000, the Metropolitan Trial Court is the proper trial court. Under Rule 4 of the Rules of Court, venue for personal actions lies at the option of the plaintiff, either where the plaintiff resides or where the defendant resides.

TopicsArticle 2189 Civil Code1MeTC Jurisdiction1Quasi-Delict3

2013 Remedial Law, Q7

You are the defense counsel of Angela Bituin who has been charged under RA 3019 ( Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act ) before the Sandiganbayan. While Angela has posted bail, she has yet to be arraigned. Angela revealed to you that she has not been investigated for any offense and that it was only when police officers showed up at her residence with a warrant of arrest that she learned of the pending case against her. She wonders why she has been charged before the Sandiganbayan when she is not in government service.
VII(A) What “before-trial” remedy would you invoke in Angela’s behalf to address the fact that she had not been investigated at all, and how would you avail of this remedy? (4%)
VII(B) What “during-trial” remedy can you use to allow an early evaluation of the prosecution evidence without the need of presenting defense evidence; when and how can you avail of this remedy? (4%)

Quick check

What is the proper procedural remedy of an accused charged before the Sandiganbayan who was completely denied a preliminary investigation?

When may the defense file a demurrer to evidence in a criminal prosecution under Rule 119 of the Rules of Court?

What is the consequence of filing a demurrer to evidence without leave of court if the demurrer is subsequently denied?

May a private individual who is not in government service be charged before the Sandiganbayan under R.A. 3019?

Choices available with full access.

Within what non-extendible period after the prosecution rests may the defense move for leave of court to file a demurrer to evidence?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Preliminary Investigation Motion
Under Rule 112 of the Rules of Court, an accused who was arrested without a warrant or who was denied a preliminary investigation has the legal right to move for a preliminary investigation before arraignment. When an accused is charged before the Sandiganbayan under Republic Act No. 3019 without prior notice or preliminary investigation by the Office of the Ombudsman, defense counsel may file a motion to suspend proceedings and defer arraignment. The trial court must grant the motion and remand the case to the Ombudsman to respect the constitutional due process rights of the accused.

2. Demurrer to Evidence
Under Rule 119, Section 23 of the Rules of Court, after the prosecution rests its case, the defense may move for the dismissal of the criminal action on the ground of insufficiency of evidence by filing a demurrer to evidence. This remedy allows an early evaluation of the prosecution's evidence without requiring the defense to present its own evidence. A demurrer may be filed either with leave of court within a non-extendible period of ten days after the prosecution rests, or without leave of court, subject to procedural consequences regarding the waiver of defense evidence.

3. Private Party Jurisdiction
Under Republic Act No. 3019 and jurisprudence governing the Sandiganbayan's jurisdiction, private individuals who act in conspiracy with public officers in committing graft and corrupt practices may be properly indicted and tried jointly before the Sandiganbayan. Although the accused is not a government employee or public officer, co-conspirators in graft offenses share criminal liability with public officials. However, the prosecution must establish the existence of conspiracy with a public officer falling within the original exclusive jurisdiction of the Sandiganbayan to sustain the charge against the private individual.

TopicsDemurrer to Evidence7Preliminary Investigation Motion1Sandiganbayan Jurisdiction4