Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2017 Bar Examinations

2017 Remedial Law, Q4

Give brief answers to the following:
(a) What is the doctrine of hierarchy of courts? (2%)
(b) What is the Harmless Error Rule in relation to appeals? (2%)
(c) When does a public prosecutor conduct an inquest instead of a preliminary investigation? (2%)

Quick check

What does the doctrine of hierarchy of courts mandate when multiple courts share concurrent jurisdiction?

Under the Harmless Error Rule, when may an appellate court set aside or modify a judgment due to trial errors?

When is a public prosecutor required to conduct an inquest proceeding instead of a regular preliminary investigation?

What option is available to an arrestee who is subjected to an inquest proceeding but desires a preliminary investigation?

What is the primary purpose of an inquest proceeding conducted by a public prosecutor?

Learn more about these topics

1. Hierarchy of Courts
The doctrine of hierarchy of courts dictates that where courts have concurrent jurisdiction over a matter, recourse must first be made to the lowest court possessing appropriate jurisdiction. Litigants do not have unfettered discretion to directly invoke the Supreme Court's jurisdiction, as it is primarily a court of last resort. Direct invocation of higher courts' jurisdiction is allowed only when special and important reasons, clearly stated in the petition, justify a direct resort to the highest tribunal.

2. Harmless Error Rule
Under the Harmless Error Rule embodied in Section 6, Rule 51 of the Rules of Court, no error in either the admission or exclusion of evidence and no error or defect in any ruling or order is ground for granting a new trial or for setting aside, modifying, or disturbing a judgment or order, unless refusal to take such action appears to the court inconsistent with substantial justice. Appellate courts must disregard procedural or technical errors that do not affect the substantial rights of the parties.

3. Inquest Proceedings
An inquest is an informal and summary investigation conducted by a public prosecutor in criminal cases involving persons arrested and detained without a warrant. Its purpose is to determine whether the warrantless arrest was made in accordance with Section 5, Rule 113 of the Rules of Court and whether there is probable cause to hold the arrestee for trial. It replaces a regular preliminary investigation unless the arrestee waives the provisions of Article 125 of the Revised Penal Code and requests a full preliminary investigation.

TopicsDoctrine of Hierarchy of Courts1Harmless Error Rule1Inquest Proceedings3

2017 Remedial Law, Q5

After working for 25 years in the Middle East, Evan returned to the Philippines to retire in Manila, the place of his birth and childhood. Ten years before his retirement, he bought for cash in his name a house and lot in Malate, Manila. Six months after his return, he learned that his house and lot were the subject of foreclosure proceedings commenced by ABC Bank on the basis of a promissory note and a deed of real estate mortgage he had allegedly executed in favor of ABC Bank five years earlier.
Knowing that he was not in the country at the time the promissory note and deed of mortgage were supposedly executed, Evan forthwith initiated a complaint in the RTC of Manila praying that the subject documents be declared null and void.
ABC Bank filed a motion to dismiss Evan’s complaint on the ground of improper venue on the basis of a stipulation in both documents designating Quezon City as the exclusive venue in the event of litigation between the parties arising out of the loan and mortgage.
Should the motion to dismiss of ABC Bank be granted? Explain your answer. (5%)

Quick check

Does an exclusive venue stipulation bind a party who files an action to annul a contract on the ground of forgery?

According to Briones v. Court of Appeals, why can a party disavow an exclusive venue clause in a forged mortgage?

What language is required to make a venue stipulation in a written contract exclusive and restrictive?

Where should a personal action be filed under Rule 4 of the Rules of Civil Procedure in the absence of a valid venue agreement?

What is the proper ruling on a defendant bank's motion to dismiss based on an exclusive venue clause if the plaintiff alleges forgery?

Learn more about these topics

1. Exclusive Venue Stipulations
Under Rule 4 of the Rules of Court, parties may agree in writing on an exclusive venue for litigation arising from a contract. However, for a venue stipulation to be restrictive and binding, it must use clear and qualifying words such as 'exclusively', 'only', or 'solely'. An exclusive venue clause limits the place of filing to the specified court and precludes the general rules on venue in personal or real actions, provided that the underlying contract containing the clause is valid, enforceable, and not directly repudiated by the plaintiff.

2. Unenforceability in Forgery
An exclusive venue stipulation cannot be enforced against a party who assails the contract itself on the ground of forgery. As established in Briones v. Court of Appeals, enforcing a venue clause in a contract whose execution is completely denied would prematurely presuppose the validity of the forged document. When a complaint directly attacks the authenticity and existence of a contract, the plaintiff is not bound by the venue provision contained therein, and venue is properly determined under the general rules of civil procedure.

3. Personal Action Venue
Venue depends on whether an action is classified as a real action or a personal action. Real actions affect title to, or possession of, real property, and must be commenced in the court having jurisdiction over the area where the real property is situated. Personal actions may be filed where the plaintiff or defendant resides, at the election of the plaintiff. Where a property owner seeks to nullify a forged mortgage and promissory note to prevent foreclosure, venue is properly laid in the place where the property or plaintiff resides.

TopicsExclusive Venue Stipulation2Real Actions Venue2Venue in Assailed Contracts1

2017 Remedial Law, Q6

Hanna, a resident of Manila, filed a complaint for the partition of a large tract of land located in Oriental Mindoro. She impleaded her two brothers John and Adrian as defendants but did not implead Leica and Agatha, her two sisters who were permanent residents of Australia.
Arguing that there could be no final determination of the case without impleading all indispensable parties, John and Adrian moved to dismiss the complaint.
Does the trial court have a reason to deny the motion? Explain your answer. (4%)

Quick check

Is the non-joinder of an indispensable party a valid ground for an immediate motion to dismiss under the Rules of Court?

What is the proper initial action of a trial court when an indispensable party is omitted from a complaint for partition?

Who are considered indispensable parties in a judicial action for partition of inherited real property?

When may a trial court validly dismiss an action based on the non-joinder of an indispensable party?

Choices available with full access.

How should summons be served on an omitted co-heir who resides permanently in Australia after being impleaded in a real action for partition?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Non-Joinder of Parties
Under Rule 3, Section 11 of the Rules of Court, neither misjoinder nor non-joinder of parties is a ground for dismissing an action. Non-joinder of an indispensable party does not automatically divest the court of jurisdiction or warrant immediate dismissal. The proper procedural remedy is for the trial court to order the inclusion of the omitted indispensable party at any stage of the proceedings, either upon motion or motu proprio. Dismissal is warranted only if the plaintiff refuses or fails to comply with the court order directing the impleading of the indispensable party.

2. Indispensable Parties Rule
An indispensable party is a party-in-interest without whom no final determination can be had of an action. In an action for partition of real property, all co-heirs, co-owners, or persons claiming an interest in the property are indispensable parties because any judgment rendered without them would be ineffectual and void. The court cannot proceed to divide property or declare shares without binding all co-owners. However, while their presence is mandatory to render a valid judgment, their initial omission in the complaint requires an order for their inclusion rather than summary dismissal of the suit.

3. Action for Partition
Partition is a special civil action governed by Rule 69 of the Rules of Court, aimed at terminating co-ownership among co-heirs or co-owners. The action involves two distinct phases: first, determining whether co-ownership exists and whether partition is proper; and second, the actual accounting and division of the property. Because the decree of partition directly affects the property rights and shares of all co-owners, every co-heir must be made a party. If co-heirs residing abroad are omitted, they must be impleaded and served with summons, if necessary through extraterritorial service under Rule 14.

TopicsIndispensable Parties2Non-Joinder of Parties3Partition of Real Property1

2017 Remedial Law, Q7

Elise obtained a loan of ₱3 Million from Merchant Bank. Aside from executing a promissory note in favor of Merchant Bank, she executed a deed of real estate mortgage over her house and lot as security for her obligation. The loan fell due but remained unpaid; hence, Merchant Bank filed an action against Elise to foreclose the real estate mortgage. A month after, and while the foreclosure suit was pending, Merchant Bank also filed an action to recover the principal sum of ₱3 Million against Elise based on the same promissory note previously executed by the latter.
In opposing the motion of Elise to dismiss the second action on the ground of splitting of a single cause of action, Merchant Bank argued that the ground relied upon by Elise was devoid of any legal basis considering that the two actions were based on separate contracts, namely, the contract of loan evidenced by the promissory note, and the deed of real estate mortgage.
Is there a splitting of a single cause of action? Explain your answer. (4%)

Quick check

What is the legal effect when a creditor files both a foreclosure suit and a collection suit for the same debt?

Which rule governs the election of remedies when a loan obligation secured by a mortgage defaults?

What is the principal cause of action in a loan secured by a real estate mortgage upon default?

How does Philippine law classify a real estate mortgage in relation to a promissory note?

Choices available with full access.

If a bank files a judicial foreclosure suit first, what happens to its right to file a personal collection suit?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Single Cause Action
A single cause of action arises from a single delict or breach of an obligation. In a contract of loan secured by a real estate mortgage, the non-payment of the principal debt upon maturity constitutes the sole cause of action. Although the loan agreement and the mortgage deed are separate instruments, they stem from the single obligation to repay the borrowed amount. Dividing the creditor's claim into separate actions for foreclosure and collection constitutes improper splitting of a single cause of action under Rule 2 of the Rules of Court.

2. Alternative Remedies Rule
When a mortgage secures a loan, the mortgagee-creditor possesses two distinct remedies upon default: a personal action for collection of the debt or a real action for judicial or extrajudicial foreclosure of the mortgage. Under established jurisprudence, these remedies are alternative, complete, and mutually exclusive, rather than cumulative. Electing to institute a judicial foreclosure suit operates as a waiver of the personal action for collection, preventing the creditor from simultaneously or subsequently filing a separate collection suit based on the same debt.

3. Accessory Mortgage Nature
A real estate mortgage is merely an accessory contract created to guarantee the fulfillment of a principal loan obligation. It has no independent existence separate from the principal debt. Consequently, while the promissory note and mortgage deed constitute distinct legal documents, the underlying liability remains singular. Attempting to enforce the principal debt in one proceeding while foreclosing the mortgage in another violates procedural rules against multiplicity of suits and results in the dismissal of the second action.

TopicsMortgage Collection Remedies1Real Estate Mortgage4Splitting Cause Action1

2017 Remedial Law, Q8

A. Laura was the lessee of an apartment unit owned by Louie. When the lease expired, Laura refused to vacate the property. Her refusal prompted Louie to file an action for unlawful detainer against Laura who failed to answer the complaint within the reglementary period.
Louie then filed a motion to declare Laura in default. Should the motion be granted? Explain your answer. (3%)
B. Agatha filed a complaint against Yana in the RTC in Makati City to collect ₱350,000.00, an amount representing the unpaid balance on the price of the car Yana had bought from Agatha. Realizing a jurisdictional error in filing the complaint in the RTC, Agatha filed a notice of dismissal before she was served with the answer of Yana. The RTC issued an order confirming the dismissal.
Three months later, Agatha filed another complaint against Yana based on the same cause of action this time in the MeTC of Makati City. However, for reasons personal to her, Agatha decided to have the complaint dismissed without prejudice by filing a notice of dismissal prior to the service of the answer of Yana. Hence, the case was dismissed by the MeTC.
A month later, Agatha refiled the complaint against Yana in the same MeTC.
May Yana successfully invoke the Two-Dismissal Rule to bar Agatha’s third complaint? Explain your answer. (3%)

Quick check

Should a motion to declare the defendant in default be granted in an unlawful detainer case governed by summary procedure?

What action must the court take when the defendant in an unlawful detainer suit fails to file an answer on time?

When does a second voluntary dismissal by notice under Rule 17, Section 1 operate as an adjudication upon the merits?

Why is the Two-Dismissal Rule inapplicable when the first action was voluntarily dismissed in a court lacking jurisdiction?

Choices available with full access.

Under Rule 17, Section 1, until when may a plaintiff dismiss an action as a matter of right by filing a notice of dismissal?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Prohibited Default Motions
Under the Rules on Summary Procedure and Rule 70 of the Rules of Court, a motion to declare the defendant in default is explicitly listed as a prohibited motion. In summary ejectment proceedings, such as unlawful detainer, the failure of the defendant to file an answer within the prescribed reglementary period does not entitle the plaintiff to a default declaration. Instead, the court is mandated motu proprio or on motion to render judgment as may be warranted by the facts alleged in the complaint, thereby ensuring the speedy and summary disposition of ejectment cases without procedural delays.

2. Two-Dismissal Rule Requisites
Under Rule 17, Section 1 of the Rules of Court, the Two-Dismissal Rule provides that a second notice of voluntary dismissal filed by the plaintiff operates as an adjudication upon the merits when filed by a plaintiff who has once dismissed an action based on or including the same claim. However, jurisprudence dictates that for the Two-Dismissal Rule to operate as res judicata barring a third complaint, both prior actions must have been filed in and voluntarily dismissed by a court of competent jurisdiction. A dismissal in a court lacking subject-matter jurisdiction cannot be counted.

3. Jurisdiction Defect Effect
Subject-matter jurisdiction is conferred solely by law and is determined by the allegations of the complaint and the amount of the monetary claim. In money claims outside Metro Manila exceeding ₱300,000 up to ₱400,000 (or under current jurisdictional thresholds), filing a ₱350,000 claim in a court lacking jurisdiction renders the proceedings void. Because a court without subject-matter jurisdiction has no authority to take cognizance of the case, a voluntary dismissal filed therein does not constitute a valid first dismissal for purposes of applying the bar under the Two-Dismissal Rule.

TopicsJurisdiction Over Money Claims1Prohibited Motions in Summary Procedure1Two-Dismissal Rule3