Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2016 Bar Examinations

2016 Remedial Law, Q20

Royal Bank (Royal) filed a complaint for a sum of money against Ervin and Jude before the RTC of Manila. The initiatory pleading averred that on February 14, 2010, Ervin obtained a loan from Royal in the amount of Pl Million, as evidenced by Promissory Note No. 007 (PN) signed by Ervin. Jude signed a Surety Agreement binding herself as surety for the loan. Royal made a final demand on February 14, 2015 for Ervin and Jude (defendants) to pay, but the latter failed to pay. Royal prayed that defendants Ervin and Jude be ordered to pay the amount of P1 Million plus interests.
In their answer, Ervin admitted that he obtained the loan from Royal and signed the PN. Jude also admitted that she signed the Surety Agreement. Defendants pointed out that the PN did not provide the due date for payment, and that the loan has not yet matured as the maturity date was left blank to be agreed upon by the parties at a later date. Defendants filed a Motion for a Judgment on the Pleadings on the ground that there is no genuine issue presented by the parties’ submissions. Royal opposed the motion on the ground that the PN’ s maturity is an issue that must be threshed out during trial.
[a] Resolve the motion with reasons. (2.5%)
[b] Distinguish “Summary Judgment” and “Judgment on the Pleadings.” (2.5%)

Quick check

Who may move for a judgment on the pleadings under Rule 34 of the Rules of Court?

What is the fundamental distinction between a judgment on the pleadings and a summary judgment?

Why is a defendant barred from filing a motion for judgment on the pleadings against their own answer?

What is the legal effect when a defendant's answer raises an affirmative defense that a loan obligation has not yet matured?

Choices available with full access.

Which party may move for a summary judgment under Rule 35 of the Rules of Court?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Pleadings Judgment Nature
Under Rule 34 of the Rules of Court, a judgment on the pleadings is available exclusively to the claiming party when an answer fails to tender an issue or otherwise admits the material allegations of the adverse party's pleading. A defending party cannot move for judgment on the pleadings because filing such a motion presupposes that the defending party's own answer tendered no issue or admitted liability. Where the answer raises an affirmative defense or denies material allegations, a judgment on the pleadings is improper and must be denied.

2. Summary Judgment Distinctions
Rule 35 of the Rules of Court governs summary judgments, which may be sought by either a claiming or defending party when there is no genuine issue as to any material fact. Unlike a judgment on the pleadings, which relies solely on the allegations in the pleadings, a summary judgment relies on supporting affidavits, depositions, or admissions to establish that an ostensible issue raised in the pleadings is non-genuine or sham. Consequently, summary judgment resolves cases where issues appear on paper but lack real factual basis.

3. Loan Maturity Issues
When an answer in an action for a sum of money alleges that a promissory note has not yet matured because the due date was left blank to be agreed upon later, it raises a genuine factual issue. Such an affirmative defense directly tenders an issue regarding the enforceability and maturity of the obligation. Because the resolution of this issue requires the presentation of evidence during trial, neither a judgment on the pleadings nor a summary judgment may be granted to dispose of the action prematurely.

TopicsJudgment on the Pleadings4Rule 34 and Rule 351Summary Judgment4

2015 Bar Examinations

2015 Remedial Law, Q1

Lender extended to Borrower a Pl00,000.00 loan covered by a promissory note. Later, Borrower obtained another Pl00,000.00 loan again covered by a promissory note. Still later, Borrower obtained a P300,000.00 loan secured by a real estate mortgage on his land valued at 11500,000.00. Borrower defaulted on his payments when the loans matured. Despite demand to pay the llS00,000.00 loan, Borrower refused to pay. Lender, applying the totality rule, filed against Borrower with the Regional Trial Court (RTC) of Manila, a collection suit for P500,000.00.
a.) Did Lender correctly apply the totality rule and the rule on joinder of causes of action? (2%)
At the trial, Borrower’s lawyer, while cross-examining Lender, successfully elicited an admission from the latter that the two promissory notes have been paid. Thereafter, Borrower’s lawyer filed a motion to dismiss the case on the ground that as proven only P300,000.00 was the amount due to Lender and which claim is within the exclusive original jurisdiction of the Metropolitan Trial Court. He further argued that lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter can be raised at any stage of the proceedings.
b.) Should the court dismiss the case? (3%)

Quick check

What rule governs subject matter jurisdiction when multiple money claims against the same debtor are joined in one complaint?

What is the legal effect when a mortgage creditor files an ordinary civil action for collection of a debt?

Under the doctrine of adherence to jurisdiction, when is subject matter jurisdiction determined in a civil action?

If trial evidence subsequently shows the principal debt is reduced below the court's jurisdictional threshold, what should the court do?

Which of the following conditions is required for a valid joinder of causes of action under Rule 2, Section 5?

Learn more about these topics

1. Totality Rule Application
Under Rule 2, Section 5 of the Rules of Court, where a plaintiff has several claims against the same defendant arising out of different transactions, the claims may be joined in a single complaint. When claims are joined primarily for the recovery of money, the aggregate amount of all claims determines the jurisdictional venue and tribunal under the Totality Rule. By electing to file an ordinary collection suit for all three matured loans, the creditor effectively converts the obligation into personal money claims, thereby allowing the total sum to govern subject matter jurisdiction.

2. Adherence to Jurisdiction
Under the well-established doctrine of adherence to jurisdiction, jurisdiction over the subject matter is determined by the allegations of the complaint at the time of its filing. Once jurisdiction vests in the trial court based on the initial aggregate claim in the complaint, it remains with that court until the final disposition of the case. Subsequent events during trial, such as the reduction of the amount due through admissions or partial payments, do not oust the court of jurisdiction that has already validly attached.

3. Waiver of Mortgage
A mortgage creditor holding a real estate mortgage has alternative remedies upon the debtor's default: either file a personal action for collection of debt or institute a real action for judicial foreclosure of the mortgage. These remedies are alternative and mutually exclusive. By choosing to file a personal collection suit for the total debt, the creditor waives the real estate mortgage security. Consequently, the secured loan is treated as a simple money claim and properly joined with the other unsecured promissory note claims.

TopicsAdherence to Jurisdiction1Joinder of Causes of Action3Totality Rule2

2015 Remedial Law, Q2

Circe filed with the RTC a complaint for the foreclosure of real estate mortgage against siblings Scylla and Charybdis, co-owners of the property and cosignatories to the mortgage deed. The siblings permanently reside in Athens, Greece. Circe tipped off Sheriff Pluto that Scylla is on a balikbayan trip and is billeted at the Century Plaza Hotel in Pasay City. Sheriff Pluto went to the hotel and personally served Scylla the summons, but the latter refused to receive summons for Charybdis as she was not authorized to do so. Sheriff Pluto requested Scylla for the email address and fax number of Charybdis which the latter readily gave. Sheriff Pluto, in his return of the summons, stated that “Summons for Scylla was served personally as shown by her signature on the receiving copy of the summons. Summons on Charybdis was served pursuant to the amendment of Rule 14 by facsimile transmittal of the summons and complaint on defendant’s fax number as evidenced by transmission verification report automatically generated by the fax machine indicating that it was received by the fax number to which it was sent on the date and time indicated therein.”
Circe, sixty (60) days after her receipt of Sheriff Pluto’s return, filed a Motion to Declare Charybdis in default as Charybdis did not file any responsive pleading.
a.) Should the court declare Charybdis in default? (2%)
Scylla seasonably filed her answer setting forth therein as a defense that Charybdis had paid the mortgage debt.
b.) On the premise that Charybdis was properly declared in default, what is the effect of Scylla’s answer to the complaint? (2%)

Quick check

What is an indispensable requirement before extraterritorial service of summons may be effected upon a non-resident defendant in a quasi in rem action?

Is a sheriff authorized to unilaterally serve summons by facsimile on a non-resident defendant without a court order?

What is the legal effect when summons is served on a non-resident defendant without prior leave of court?

Under Rule 9, Section 3(c), what is the effect of an answer filed by one co-defendant setting up a common defense in a joint action?

Why can a non-resident defendant not be declared in default if summons was served without prior leave of court?

Learn more about these topics

1. Extraterritorial Summons Service
Under Rule 14, Section 17 of the Rules of Court, when a defendant does not reside and is not found in the Philippines and the action is quasi in rem, service of summons requires prior leave of court. Extraterritorial service may be effected by personal service outside the Philippines, publication, or in any other manner the court may deem sufficient. A sheriff cannot unilaterally serve summons on a non-resident defendant by facsimile or email without an explicit court order granting leave for extraterritorial service.

2. Leave of Court
Extraterritorial service of summons without prior court authorization is invalid and fails to confer jurisdiction over the person of a non-resident defendant. While electronic transmission or facsimile is permitted under amended rules of civil procedure, it remains subject to the indispensable requirement of a motion and judicial leave. Because Sheriff Pluto attempted facsimile service on Charybdis unilaterally without obtaining court approval, the service was legally ineffective, and Charybdis cannot be declared in default for failing to file a responsive pleading.

3. Common Cause Effect
Under Rule 9, Section 3(c) of the Rules of Court, when a complaint states a common cause of action against several defendants who are co-owners or co-obligors, an answer filed by one defending party inures to the benefit of any defaulting co-defendant. If one defendant seasonably files an answer alleging a common defense—such as the full payment and extinguishment of the underlying mortgage debt—the trial court must try the case upon the answer so filed and render judgment based on the evidence presented.

TopicsDeclaration of Default1Effect of Answer by Co-Defendant1Extraterritorial Service of Summons2

2015 Remedial Law, Q3

Juliet invoking the provisions of the Rule on Violence Against Women and their Children filed with the RTC designated as a Family Court a petition for issuance of a Temporary Protection Order (TPO) against her husband, Romeo. The Family Court issued a 30-day TPO against Romeo. A day before the expiration of the TPO, Juliet filed a motion for extension. Romeo in his opposition raised, among others, the constitutionality of R.A. No. 9262 (The VAWC Law) arguing that the law authorizing the issuance of a TPO violates the equal protection and due process clauses of the 1987 Constitution. The Family Court judge, in granting the motion for extension of the TPO, declined to rule on the constitutionality of R.A. No. 9262. The Family Court judge reasoned that Family Courts are without jurisdiction to pass upon constitutional issues, being a special court of limited jurisdiction and R.A. No. 8369, the law creating the Family Courts, does not provide for such jurisdiction. Is the Family Court judge correct when he declined to resolve the constitutionality of R.A. No. 9262? (3%)

Quick check

Do Family Courts created under R.A. No. 8369 have jurisdiction to resolve constitutional issues?

What is the landmark case where the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of R.A. No. 9262?

Why does R.A. No. 9262 not violate the Equal Protection Clause of the 1987 Constitution?

Does the ex parte issuance of a Temporary Protection Order under R.A. No. 9262 violate procedural due process?

What should a trial court judge do when the constitutionality of a statute is properly raised as lis mota?

Learn more about these topics

1. Family Court Jurisdiction
Under Republic Act No. 8369, Family Courts are designated Regional Trial Courts possessing jurisdiction over family cases. Designation as a special court does not diminish or divest a Regional Trial Court of its inherent judicial authority under the Constitution. A Family Court retains the full judicial power of a Regional Trial Court, including the authority to pass upon constitutional questions when properly raised by a party during litigation. Declining jurisdiction over constitutional issues on the ground of being a special court is legally erroneous.

2. Judicial Review Power
The power of judicial review is vested in the Supreme Court and all lower courts, including Regional Trial Courts. When the constitutionality of a statute, such as Republic Act No. 9262, is directly challenged as a defense in a case, trial courts are bound to resolve the constitutional issue if it is the very lis mota of the controversy. Courts cannot evade resolving constitutional challenges properly brought before them simply because the law involved falls under a specialized subject matter.

3. Constitutionality of VAWC
In Garcia v. Drilon, the Supreme Court squarely upheld the constitutional validity of Republic Act No. 9262, ruling that the law does not violate the equal protection or due process clauses of the Constitution. Gender-based statutory protection is based on substantial distinctions, as women and children are historically more vulnerable to domestic violence. Furthermore, the ex parte issuance of temporary protection orders is a valid exercise of state police power designed to prevent further harm.

TopicsConstitutionality of VAWC Law1Family Courts Jurisdiction1Judicial Power3

2015 Remedial Law, Q4

Strauss filed a complaint against Wagner for cancellation of title. Wagner moved to dismiss the complaint because Grieg, to whom he mortgaged the property as duly annotated in the TCT, was not impleaded as defendant.
a.) Should the complaint be dismissed? (3%)
b.) If the case should proceed to trial without Grieg being impleaded as a party to the case, what is his remedy to protect his interest? (2%)

Quick check

What is the proper procedural effect of the non-joinder of an indispensable party under Rule 3, Section 11?

Why is a registered mortgagee considered an indispensable party in an action for cancellation of title?

What should a trial court judge do when a defendant files a motion to dismiss based on non-joinder of an indispensable party?

What is the appropriate remedy for an omitted indispensable party if the trial proceeds without them being impleaded?

What happens if a trial court proceeds to final judgment without acquiring jurisdiction over an indispensable party?

Learn more about these topics

1. Non-Joinder of Parties
Under Rule 3, Section 11 of the Rules of Court, neither misjoinder nor non-joinder of parties is a ground for the dismissal of an action. Parties may be dropped or added by order of the court on motion of any party or on its own initiative at any stage of the action and on such terms as are just. When an indispensable party is omitted from a complaint, the trial court should not immediately dismiss the case, but must instead order the plaintiff to implead the omitted party within a specified period.

2. Indispensable Parties Rule
An indispensable party is a party-in-interest without whom no final determination can be had of an action. In an action for the cancellation of a certificate of title, a registered mortgagee whose lien is duly annotated on the title is an indispensable party. Any judgment canceling the title directly affects and impairs the mortgagee's real right and security interest. Consequently, the court cannot render a valid and final decree affecting the property without acquiring jurisdiction over the registered mortgagee.

3. Remedy of Intervention
Under Rule 19, Section 1 of the Rules of Court, a person who has a legal interest in the matter in litigation or in the success of either of the parties may be permitted by the court to intervene in the action. If a case proceeds to trial without an indispensable party being impleaded, that omitted party may file a motion for intervention before the rendition of judgment. Intervention allows the mortgagee to formally enter the proceedings, submit pleadings, and protect their registered real property interest.

TopicsIndispensable Parties2Motion for Intervention1Non-Joinder of Parties3