Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2023 Bar Examinations

2023 Remedial Law, Q16

Vangie filed an action for compulsory recognition with prayer for support against Jay, her putative father. During trial, she presented and identified the following documents on the witness stand: 1) the birth certificate of Vangie reflecting Jay as the father of Vangie per information supplied by the mother of Vangie, but was unsigned by Jay; and 2) letters from the siblings of Jay, addressed to private schools where Vangie was enrolled, which attested that Jay is the father of Vangie and that he regularly supports her education. Rule on the admissibility and sufficiency of the documents as evidence of acts or declarations about pedigree. Explain briefly.

Quick check

Are the letters from Jay's siblings admissible as evidence of acts or declarations about pedigree under Section 41, Rule 130?

What is the evidentiary weight of an unsigned birth certificate supplied solely by the mother in an action for compulsory recognition?

Which of the following is an essential requisite for the admissibility of an act or declaration about pedigree under Rule 130?

Why does a birth certificate prepared without the father's signature fail to establish compulsory recognition?

Choices available with full access.

When may hearsay evidence regarding family reputation or pedigree be admitted under the Rules of Court?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Declaration About Pedigree
Under Section 41, Rule 130 of the Rules of Court, the act or declaration of a person deceased, or unable to testify, in respect to the pedigree of another person related to him or her by birth, adoption, or marriage, is admissible as an exception to the hearsay rule. For this exception to apply, three requisites must concur: the declarant must be dead or unable to testify, the declarant must be related to the person whose pedigree is in question, and the declaration must have been made ante litem motam, or before the controversy arose.

2. Unsigned Birth Certificate
Under the Family Code and established jurisprudence, a birth certificate that is not signed by the putative father lacks evidentiary value to prove filiation or compulsory recognition. Information supplied solely by the mother without the father's express written participation or signature does not bind the alleged father. Consequently, an unsigned birth certificate is inadmissible hearsay and insufficient as a direct or indirect voluntary recognition of paternity, as it fails to demonstrate the putative father's authentic consent or acknowledgment.

3. Letters of Relatives
Written statements or letters from relatives regarding a child's filiation do not constitute admissible evidence of acts or declarations about pedigree unless the declarants are proven to be dead or physically unable to testify in court. Where the declarants are alive and available to take the witness stand, their written declarations presented through another witness constitute inadmissible hearsay. Furthermore, declarations by collateral relatives cannot override the statutory requirement of direct proof of paternity when seeking compulsory recognition against an unwilling putative father.

TopicsActs or Declarations About Pedigree1Compulsory Recognition Evidence1Unsigned Birth Certificate1

2022 Bar Examinations

2022 Remedial Law, Q1

Lebron, a Makati resident, obtained a Php 350,000.00 loan from a bank secured by a real estate mortgage (REM) over his lot located in Quezon City with an assessed value of Php 500,000.00. Lebron failed to pay despite written demands. The bank intends to file an action for judicial foreclosure of the REM. Where should the action for judicial foreclosure of the REM be filed and in which court? Explain briefly. (5 points)

Quick check

In which court should an action for judicial foreclosure of a real estate mortgage be filed if the property in Quezon City has an assessed value of Php 500,000.00?

What determines subject matter jurisdiction over a real action involving land under B.P. Blg. 129, as amended by R.A. No. 11576?

What is the jurisdictional threshold for Regional Trial Courts in real actions under R.A. No. 11576?

Where is the proper venue for filing an action for judicial foreclosure of a real estate mortgage?

Why is the residence of the mortgagor irrelevant in determining the venue for judicial foreclosure?

Learn more about these topics

1. Real Actions
An action for the judicial foreclosure of a real estate mortgage is classified as a real action because it directly involves and affects title to, or interest in, real property. Under Rule 4 of the Rules of Court, real actions must be filed in the court having territorial jurisdiction over the area where the real property, or any portion thereof, is located. The residence of the mortgagor or mortgagee is irrelevant in determining the proper venue for real actions, as venue is governed exclusively by the physical location of the subject real estate.

2. Jurisdiction Thresholds
Subject matter jurisdiction over real actions is determined by the assessed value of the real property as mandated by Batas Pambansa Blg. 129, as amended by Republic Act No. 11576. Under the amended jurisdictional rules, the Regional Trial Court exercises exclusive original jurisdiction over real actions where the assessed value of the property exceeds Php 400,000.00. First-level courts (Metropolitan Trial Courts, Municipal Trial Courts, and Municipal Circuit Trial Courts) exercise exclusive original jurisdiction if the assessed value of the real property does not exceed Php 400,000.00.

3. Venue Rules
Proper venue in judicial foreclosure cases is mandatory and dictated by the territorial location of the mortgaged property. Filing a real action in a court located outside the judicial region or territorial jurisdiction where the property is situated constitutes improper venue. While improper venue may be waived if not timely raised in an answer, adhering to statutory venue rules ensures orderly procedure and prevents dismissal upon motion. Where the mortgaged land lies in Quezon City, the action must be commenced exclusively in the courts of Quezon City.

TopicsJudicial Foreclosure Jurisdiction1Real Actions Venue2Real Estate Mortgage4

2022 Remedial Law, Q2

Asya, Inc. sued Kobe, a resident of Bukidnon. To serve summons, the sheriff waited in the lobby of Makati Hotel (MH), where Kobe stays whenever he is in Manila. The sheriff failed to serve the summons because Kobe left the hotel for an emergency. Hours later, the sheriff asked the front desk about Kobe’s whereabouts and his room number. The hotel refused to disclose on grounds of confidentiality. The sheriff tried again the next day, but Kobe was in a conference until midnight. So, the following day, the sheriff left the summons and a copy of the complaint with MH’s chief security officer (CSO), even as the CSO refused because Kobe had already checked out by then. The sheriff thereafter filed his return, stating the dates, times and places of his attempts, the name of the CSO, and the fact that the complaint was served with the summons. When Kobe did not file an Answer, Asya, Inc. moved to declare him in default. Was there a valid substituted service of summons? Explain briefly. (5 points)

Quick check

Was the substituted service of summons upon Makati Hotel's Chief Security Officer valid?

What is the legal effect of serving summons on a hotel security officer after the defendant guest has already checked out?

Under Rule 14 of the Rules of Civil Procedure, when is substituted service of summons permitted?

Which of the following is NOT a valid ground for declaring a defendant in default?

What must a sheriff's return explicitly state to justify resort to substituted service of summons?

Learn more about these topics

1. Substituted Service Requisites
Under Rule 14 of the Rules of Civil Procedure, service of summons upon a defendant must be made by personal service whenever practicable. Substituted service is an extraordinary method that may be resorted to only when personal service cannot be effected despite diligent efforts within a reasonable period. The sheriff's return must explicitly detail the impossibility of personal service, the specific dates and times of the attempts, and strict compliance with statutory modes. Failure to strictly comply with substituted service requirements renders the service invalid and deprives the trial court of jurisdiction over the person of the defendant.

2. Security Officer Service
Section 6 of Rule 14 authorizes substituted service by leaving copies of the summons with a chief security officer or officer in charge of a building only under specific statutory conditions. This particular mode applies exclusively to homeowners' communities or condominium buildings where the defendant physically resides or maintains an office. A hotel is neither a homeowners' community nor a condominium complex. Serving summons upon a hotel chief security officer does not comply with Rule 14, as hotel security officers lack statutory authority to receive judicial summons on behalf of hotel guests.

3. Residence Requirement
For substituted service to be validly effected at a person's residence or dwelling house, the defendant must actually reside or be found in the premises at the time service is attempted. Where a defendant is a transient guest who has checked out of a hotel prior to the delivery of the summons, the hotel ceases to be a place where the defendant may be found. Leaving court process with hotel personnel after the guest's checkout is legally ineffective because no valid service can be made at a location where the defendant no longer maintains physical presence.

TopicsChief Security Officer Service1Rule 14 Service of Summons1Substituted Service of Summons2

2022 Remedial Law, Q3

Ten days after service of summons, defendant Kay filed a motion to dismiss the complaint for collection of sum of money against her on the ground of improper service of summons, on the basis of which the court did not acquire jurisdiction over her person. If you were the judge, how would you rule? Explain briefly. (5 points)

Quick check

Under the amended Rules of Civil Procedure, which of the following is a valid ground for a motion to dismiss?

How must the defense of lack of jurisdiction over the person of the defendant be raised under the amended rules?

What should a trial court do if a defendant files a motion to dismiss based solely on improper service of summons?

What is the remedy of the trial court if it finds during the hearing on affirmative defenses that summons was improperly served?

How many exclusive grounds are allowed for a motion to dismiss under Section 12, Rule 15 of the Rules of Civil Procedure?

Learn more about these topics

1. Prohibited Motions
Under Section 12, Rule 15 of the amended Rules of Civil Procedure, a motion to dismiss is generally a prohibited motion. The court shall not entertain any motion to dismiss except on four exclusive grounds: lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter, litis pendentia, res judicata, and prescription. Any motion to dismiss filed on grounds other than these four exceptions must be denied outright by the trial court.

2. Jurisdiction Over Defendant
Under the amended Rules of Civil Procedure, lack of jurisdiction over the person of the defendant due to improper service of summons is no longer a valid ground for a motion to dismiss. Instead, Section 12, Rule 8 mandates that this ground must be raised as an affirmative defense in the answer. The court may then conduct a summary hearing on such affirmative defense within fifteen calendar days from the filing of the answer.

3. Affirmative Defenses
When the defense of lack of jurisdiction over the person is raised as an affirmative defense in the answer, the trial court has the discretion to conduct a summary hearing thereon. If the court finds that summons was improperly served, it shall order the re-issuance and proper service of summons rather than dismissing the action outright. This procedural rule ensures that cases are decided on their merits while affording the defendant proper due process.

TopicsAffirmative Defenses2Lack of Jurisdiction Over Person1Prohibited Motion to Dismiss1

2022 Remedial Law, Q4

[This item has two questions.] Attorney Woo, the newly-hired lawyer of a law firm, booked Samurai Express, a duly accredited courier service within the National Capital Judicial Region, to serve a copy of a motion for reconsideration to Attorney Han, counsel for the adverse party, whose office is in the City of Manila. Attorney Han moved to deny the motion for failure to contain a written explanation as to why the motion was not served personally.

Quick check

Is a written explanation required when serving a motion via accredited courier under the 2019 Amendments to Rule 13?

What constitutes proper proof of service when a motion is served through an accredited courier service?

What is the legal effect of serving a motion via an accredited courier without attaching a written explanation?

Under Section 3, Rule 13 of the Rules of Civil Procedure, which of the following is an authorized mode of service?

When is service of a pleading by an accredited courier deemed complete under Rule 13?

Learn more about these topics

1. Accredited Courier
Under Rule 13 of the 2019 Amendments to the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure, service by accredited courier is an officially recognized mode of service and filing. The requirement of incorporating a written explanation for resorting to non-personal service was completely deleted under the 2019 amendments. Consequently, a party may validly serve pleadings or motions through an accredited courier service within the judicial region without needing to explain or justify why personal service was not utilized.

2. Proof of Service
Under Section 17, Rule 13 of the Rules of Court, proof of service of a pleading or motion by an accredited courier service is established by two requisite documents. First, an affidavit of service executed by the person who brought the paper to the accredited courier service provider. Second, the official receipt issued by the courier or the official document tracking number. Submitting both the affidavit and the receipt or tracking number provides full legal proof of service.

3. Written Explanation Deletion
Prior to the 2019 Amendments to the Rules of Civil Procedure, personal service was the general rule, and any resort to non-personal service required a written explanation attached to the pleading. The 2019 Amendments eliminated this requirement. Under the current rules, failure to include a written explanation for non-personal service no longer invalidates the service nor serves as a valid ground to deny or dismiss a motion or pleading.

TopicsAccredited Courier Service1Proof of Service1Rule 13 Service1