Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2017 Bar Examinations

2017 Remedial Law, Q9

Abraham filed a complaint for damages in the amount of ₱750,000.00 against Salvador in the RTC in Quezon City for the latter’s alleged breach of their contract of services. Salvador promptly filed his answer, and included a counterclaim for ₱250,000.00 arising from the allegedly baseless and malicious claims of Abraham that compelled him to litigate and to engage the services of counsel, and thus caused him to suffer mental anguish.
Noting that the amount of the counterclaim was below the exclusive original jurisdiction of the RTC, Abraham filed a motion to dismiss vis-8-vis the counterclaim on that ground.
Should the counterclaim of Salvador be dismissed? Explain your answer. (4%)

Quick check

Does a Regional Trial Court have jurisdiction over a compulsory counterclaim with an amount below its general jurisdictional threshold?

What test determines whether a counterclaim is compulsory under Rule 6 of the Rules of Court?

How is a counterclaim for damages based on the alleged malicious filing of the main action classified?

What is the consequence if a defendant fails to raise a compulsory counterclaim in his answer?

Choices available with full access.

Which requirement distinguishes a permissive counterclaim from a compulsory counterclaim?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Compulsory Counterclaims
Under Section 7, Rule 6 of the Rules of Court, a compulsory counterclaim is one which, arising out of or connected with the transaction or occurrence constituting the subject matter of the opposing party's claim, does not require for its adjudication the presence of third parties of whom the court cannot acquire jurisdiction. A counterclaim for damages and attorney's fees grounded on the allegedly malicious and unfounded filing of the main complaint is logically related to the principal action. Consequently, such a claim is classified as a compulsory counterclaim that must be set up in the same action.

2. Counterclaim Jurisdiction Rules
In an original action filed before the Regional Trial Court, the court acquires jurisdiction over a compulsory counterclaim regardless of the monetary amount involved. Although first-level courts generally possess exclusive original jurisdiction over money claims below the statutory jurisdictional threshold, this threshold rule applies primarily to initiation of independent principal actions. A compulsory counterclaim is ancillary to the main action; thus, the Regional Trial Court retains jurisdiction over the compulsory counterclaim even if the monetary damages sought fall below its usual minimum jurisdictional amount.

3. Permissive Versus Compulsory
The distinction between compulsory and permissive counterclaims is crucial for jurisdictional and procedural purposes. A permissive counterclaim arises from an independent transaction or occurrence not logically connected to the main cause of action and requires an independent jurisdictional basis, as well as the payment of docket fees. In contrast, a compulsory counterclaim is inherently linked to the plaintiff's cause of action, is barred if not raised in the answer, and falls within the trial court's ancillary jurisdiction regardless of whether the monetary claim meets the court's general jurisdictional threshold.

TopicsCompulsory Counterclaims2Counterclaim Jurisdiction1Jurisdiction Over Counterclaims1

2017 Remedial Law, Q10

On the basis of an alleged promissory note executed by Harold in favor of Ramon, the latter filed a complaint for ₱950,000.00 against the former in the RTC of Davao City. In an unverified answer, Harold specifically denied the genuineness of the promissory note. During the trial, Harold sought to offer the testimonies of the following: (1) the testimony of an NBI handwriting expert to prove the forgery of his signature; and (2) the testimony of a credible witness to prove that if ever Harold had executed the note in favor of Ramon, the same was not supported by a consideration.
May Ramon validly object to the proposed testimonies? Give a brief explanation of your answer. (5%)

Quick check

What is the legal effect under Rule 8, Section 8 when a party fails to specifically deny an actionable document under oath?

Which of the following defenses is barred by an implied admission of an actionable document's genuineness?

May a defendant who filed an unverified answer present evidence to prove lack of consideration for a promissory note?

What does due execution of an actionable document specifically signify under procedural rules?

Choices available with full access.

How should a plaintiff object when a defendant with an unverified answer attempts to present expert testimony to prove forgery?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Actionable Documents Denial
Under Rule 8, Section 8 of the Rules of Court, when an action or defense is founded upon a written instrument, the genuineness and due execution of the instrument are deemed admitted unless the adverse party specifically denies them under oath. A failure to specifically deny an actionable document under oath constitutes an implied admission of its authenticity and execution. Consequently, the party failing to verify their denial is precluded from introducing evidence to prove forgery or non-execution during trial.

2. Implied Admission Scope
The implied admission resulting from the failure to deny an actionable document under oath is limited to its genuineness and due execution. Genuineness means that the signature is authentic and not forged, while due execution means that the document was signed voluntarily and with authority. However, this implied admission does not extend to other defenses, such as lack or failure of consideration, fraud, payment, or usury. Therefore, a party may still present evidence to establish those affirmative defenses.

3. Want of Consideration
Want or lack of consideration is an affirmative defense that does not contest the genuineness or due execution of a promissory note or actionable document. A promissory note is presumed to have been issued for a valuable consideration under the Rules on Evidence. However, this presumption is disputable and may be overcome by parol or testimonial evidence. Because proving want of consideration does not contradict the authenticity of the debtor's signature, such evidence remains admissible despite an unverified answer.

TopicsActionable Documents3Specific Denial Under Oath2Want of Consideration1

2017 Remedial Law, Q11

A. Teddy filed against Buboy an action for rescission of a contract for the sale of a commercial lot. After having been told by the wife of Buboy that her husband was out of town and would not be back until after a couple of days, the sheriff requested the wife to just receive the summons in behalf of her husband. The wife acceded to the request, received the summons and a copy of the complaint, and signed for the same.
(a) Was there a valid service of summons upon Buboy? Explain your answer briefly. (3%)
(b) If Buboy files a motion to dismiss the complaint based on the twin grounds of lack of jurisdiction over his person and prescription of the cause of action, may he be deemed to have voluntarily submitted himself to the jurisdiction of the court? Explain your answer briefly (3%).
B. What is the mode of appeal applicable to the following cases, and what issues may be raised before the reviewing court/tribunal?
(a) The decision or final order of the National Labor Relations Commission. (1.5%)
(b) The judgment or final order of the RTC in the exercise of its appellate jurisdiction. (1.5%)

Quick check

When is substituted service of summons upon an individual defendant valid under Rule 14?

Does filing a motion to dismiss on the ground of lack of jurisdiction over the person along with prescription constitute voluntary appearance?

What is the proper remedy to challenge a decision or final order rendered by the National Labor Relations Commission?

What is the mode of appeal from a judgment rendered by the Regional Trial Court in the exercise of its appellate jurisdiction?

Choices available with full access.

What issues may be raised in a petition for review under Rule 42 before the Court of Appeals?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Substituted Service Summons
Under Rule 14 of the Rules of Court, personal service of summons is the preferred mode. Substituted service is an extraordinary method that becomes valid only when personal service cannot be effected within a reasonable time despite diligent efforts by the sheriff. To justify substituted service, the sheriff's return must explicitly detail facts showing at least three unsuccessful attempts on at least two different dates. Merely leaving summons with a spouse after learning that the defendant is briefly out of town fails the diligence requirement, rendering the substituted service invalid for lack of jurisdiction over the person.

2. Omnibus Voluntary Appearance
Under Rule 14, Section 23 of the Rules of Court, a defendant's voluntary appearance in court is equivalent to service of summons. However, filing a motion to dismiss based on lack of jurisdiction over the person does not constitute voluntary submission. Furthermore, under the omnibus motion rule, including other affirmative grounds for dismissal—such as prescription or lack of cause of action—alongside lack of jurisdiction over the person does not amount to a waiver of the jurisdictional defense or a voluntary submission to the court's jurisdiction.

3. Appellate Modes Overview
Judicial and quasi-judicial determinations are reviewed through distinct procedural vehicles depending on the rendering tribunal. Decisions of the National Labor Relations Commission are not appealable; instead, they are subject to a special civil action for certiorari under Rule 65 before the Court of Appeals on the sole ground of grave abuse of discretion. In contrast, final judgments rendered by the Regional Trial Court in the exercise of its appellate jurisdiction are appealable to the Court of Appeals via a petition for review under Rule 42, raising questions of fact, law, or mixed questions of fact and law.

TopicsModes of Appeal1Substituted Service of Summons2Voluntary Appearance2

2017 Remedial Law, Q12

A. Judgment was rendered against defendant Jaypee in an action for unlawful detainer. The judgment ordered Jaypee to vacate and to pay attorney’s fees in favor of Bart, the plaintiff.
To prevent the immediate execution of the judgment, would you advise the posting of a supersedeas bond as counsel for Jaypee? Explain your answer briefly? (2%).
B. A temporary restraining order (TRO) was issued on September 20, 2017 by the RTC against defendant Jeff enjoining him from entering the land of Regan, the plaintiff.
On October 9, 2017, upon application of Regan, the trial court, allegedly in the interest of justice, extended the TRO for another 20 days based on the same ground for which the TRO was issued.
On October 15, 2017, Jeff entered the land subject of the TRO.
May Jeff be liable for contempt of court? Why? (4%)

Quick check

To stay the immediate execution of an ejectment judgment awarding attorney's fees but no back rentals, is a supersedeas bond required?

What is the maximum non-extendible period of validity for a temporary restraining order issued by a Regional Trial Court?

Can a Regional Trial Court validly extend a twenty-day temporary restraining order based on the same ground previously raised?

May a defendant be cited for indirect contempt for entering land after the expiration of a void temporary restraining order extension?

Choices available with full access.

What essential condition must be satisfied to stay immediate execution of an ejectment judgment awarding unpaid monthly rentals?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Supersedeas Bond Purpose
Under Rule 70, Section 19 of the Rules of Court, a judgment in an unlawful detainer suit is immediately executory. To stay execution pending appeal, the defendant must perfect an appeal, file a sufficient supersedeas bond, and periodically deposit the adjudged rent or reasonable value of use. However, a supersedeas bond is required only to cover unpaid back rentals, damages, and costs awarded in the judgment. When the judgment awards only attorney's fees without any back rentals or monetary damages, no supersedeas bond is necessary to stay immediate execution.

2. Restraining Order Duration
Under Rule 58, Section 5 of the Rules of Court, a temporary restraining order issued by a Regional Trial Court is effective for a non-extendible period of twenty days from service on the party sought to be enjoined. The twenty-day period is inseverable and strictly non-renewable. A trial court has no authority to extend a temporary restraining order beyond twenty days on the same ground for which it was originally issued. Upon the expiration of twenty days, the restraining order automatically lapses without requiring any court order to declare its termination.

3. Contempt Disobedience Element
For a party to be held in indirect contempt under Rule 71 of the Rules of Court for willful disobedience, there must exist a valid, subsisting, and lawful court order or writ at the time of the alleged violation. If a temporary restraining order has automatically expired by operation of law prior to the act complained of, any purported judicial order extending its duration on the same ground is void ab initio. Entering the subject land after the expiration of a void extension does not constitute willful disobedience of a lawful order.

TopicsContempt of Court1Supersedeas Bond Requisites1Temporary Restraining Order Duration1

2017 Remedial Law, Q13

Police officers arrested Mr. Druggie in a buy-bust operation and confiscated from him 10 sachets of shabu and several marked genuine peso bills worth ₱5,000.00 used as the buy-bust money during the buy-bust operation.
At the trial of Mr. Druggie for violation of R.A. No. 9165 (Comprehensive Dangerous Drug Act of 2002), the Prosecution offered in evidence, among others, photocopies of the confiscated marked genuine peso bills. The photocopies were offered to prove that Mr. Druggie had engaged at the time of his arrest in the illegal selling of dangerous drugs.
Invoking the Best Evidence Rule, Atty. Maya Bang, the defense counsel, objected to the admissibility of the photocopies of the confiscated marked genuine peso bills.
Should the trial judge sustain the objection of the defense counsel? Briefly explain your answer (5%)

Quick check

When does the Original Document Rule under Rule 130 of the Rules of Court apply in judicial proceedings?

How is marked money used in a buy-bust operation classified under the Rules on Evidence?

Should an objection based on the Best Evidence Rule against photocopies of marked money be sustained?

What is the primary purpose of presenting marked money in a drug buy-bust prosecution?

Choices available with full access.

Is the physical production of original marked peso bills indispensable for a drug conviction under R.A. No. 9165?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Original Document Scope
Under Rule 130, Section 3 of the Rules of Court, the Original Document Rule (formerly the Best Evidence Rule) applies exclusively when the subject of inquiry in a judicial proceeding is the contents of a written document. When the purpose of introducing evidence is merely to establish the existence, execution, or identity of an object, rather than the terms and written statements contained within it, the Original Document Rule does not apply. Consequently, secondary or illustrative evidence may be admitted without accounting for the original physical object.

2. Marked Money Character
In criminal prosecutions for the illegal sale of dangerous drugs under Republic Act No. 9165, marked genuine peso bills utilized by law enforcement officers during a buy-bust operation constitute real or object evidence. They are presented to prove the occurrence of the illicit transaction and the exchange of consideration, not to enforce or interpret the written text inscribed on the currency. Because marked money serves as corpus delicti or object evidence, it falls outside the restrictive purview of documentary evidence under the rules.

3. Admissibility Secondary Photocopies
Photocopies of marked bills are fully admissible in drug prosecutions to corroborate the testimony of buy-bust team members regarding the illegal sale. The non-production of the original marked bills or currency serial numbers does not invalidate the drug conviction, provided the sale of dangerous drugs is adequately proven by credible testimonial evidence. Objections premised on the Original Document Rule against photocopies of marked money are properly overruled because the marked bills are offered as object evidence proving the physical transaction.

TopicsBuy-Bust Marked Money1Object Evidence1Original Document Rule4