Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2014 Bar Examinations

2014 Remedial Law, Q2

McJolly is a trouble-maker of sorts, always getting into brushes with the law. In one incident, he drove his Humvee recklessly, hitting a pedicab which sent its river and passengers in different directions. The pedicab driver died, while two (2) of the passengers suffered slight physical injuries. Two (2) Informations were then filed against McJolly. One, for Reckless Imprudence Resulting in Homicide and Damage to Property, and two, for Reckless Imprudence Resulting in Slight Physical Injuries. The latter case was scheduled for arraignment earlier, on which occasion McJolly immediately pleaded guilty. He was meted out the penalty of public censure. A month later, the case for reckless imprudence resulting in homicide was also set for arraignment. Instead of pleading, McJolly interposed the defense of double jeopardy. Resolve. (4%)

Quick check

What is the primary gravamen of offenses punished under Article 365 of the Revised Penal Code?

According to the Ivler v. Modesto-San Pedro doctrine, how is reckless imprudence classified under Philippine criminal law?

What is the effect of a guilty plea to reckless imprudence resulting in slight physical injuries on a pending charge for homicide from the same accident?

Which of the following is a requisite for double jeopardy to attach upon a prior conviction?

Why cannot the prosecution split a single reckless driving incident into multiple criminal informations for separate results?

Learn more about these topics

1. Single Quasi-Offense Rule
Under Article 365 of the Revised Penal Code, reckless imprudence is treated as a single quasi-offense where the criminal act is the negligent execution itself rather than its various resulting consequences. Jurisprudence establishes that reckless driving constitutes one indivisible offense regardless of how many persons are injured or killed, or how much property is damaged. Prosecuting an accused for separate offenses arising from a single negligent act violates the fundamental principle against splitting a single crime into multiple component prosecutions.

2. Double Jeopardy Defense
Double jeopardy attaches when a defendant is placed on trial before a court of competent jurisdiction upon a valid complaint or information after pleading to the charge. A prior conviction or acquittal of reckless imprudence bars any subsequent criminal prosecution for the same negligent act. Because reckless imprudence is a single offense, a final conviction or guilty plea to one resulting injury exhausts the state's power to prosecute the accused for other consequences stemming from that exact same incident.

3. Ivler Doctrine Application
The Supreme Court ruled in Ivler v. Modesto-San Pedro that reckless imprudence resulting in slight physical injuries and reckless imprudence resulting in homicide are not distinct offenses when originating from one reckless driving incident. Once an accused pleads guilty and is sentenced for reckless imprudence resulting in minor injuries, double jeopardy immediately bars prosecution for reckless imprudence resulting in homicide. The prosecution cannot multiply charges by splitting the diverse physical and material outcomes of a single imprudent act.

TopicsDouble Jeopardy7Ivler v Modesto-San Pedro2Reckless Imprudence6

2014 Remedial Law, Q3

While passing by a dark uninhabited part of their barangay, PO2 Asintado observed shadows and heard screams from a distance. PO2 Asintado hid himself behind the bushes and saw a man beating a woman whom he recognized as his neighbor, Kulasa. When Kulasa was already in agony, the man stabbed her and she fell on the ground. The man hurriedly left thereafter.
PO2 Asintado immediately went to Kulasa’s rescue. Kulasa, who was then in a state of hysteria, kept mentioning to PO2 Asintado “Si Rene, gusto akong patayin! Sinaksak niya ako!” When PO2 Asintado was about to carry her, Kulasa refused and said “Kaya ko. Mababaw lang to. Habulin mo si Rene.”
The following day, Rene learned of Kulasa’s death and, bothered by his conscience, surrendered to the authorities with his counsel. As his surrender was broadcasted all over media, Rene opted to release his statement to the press which goes:
“I believe that I am entitled to the presumption of innocence until my guilt is proven beyond reasonable doubt. Although I admit that I performed acts that may take one’s life away, I hope and pray that justice will be served the right way. God bless us all. (Sgd.) Rene”
The trial court convicted Rene of homicide on the basis of PO2 Asintado’s testimony, Kulasa’s statements, and Rene’s statement to the press. On appeal, Rene raises the following errors:
1. The trial court erred in giving weight to PO2 Asintado’s testimony, as the latter did not have any personal knowledge of the facts in issue, and violated Rene’s right to due process when it considered Kulasa’s statements despite lack of opportunity for her cross-examination.
2. The trial court erred in holding that Rene’s statement to the press was a confession which, standing alone, would be sufficient to warrant conviction. Resolve. (4%)

Quick check

Why is the victim's statement identifying her assailant immediately after being stabbed admissible despite the lack of cross-examination?

What requirement must be satisfied for an extrajudicial admission made to news reporters to support a criminal conviction?

Under Rule 130, Section 22, when does a witness possess personal knowledge sufficient to testify in court?

How are voluntary statements made by an accused to media broadcast journalists treated under the Rules of Evidence?

What is the effect of an eyewitness hiding in bushes while observing a violent crime taking place?

Learn more about these topics

1. Res Gestae Exception
Under Rule 130, Section 44 of the Revised Rules on Evidence, statements made by a person while a startling occurrence is taking place or immediately prior or subsequent thereto with respect to the circumstances thereof may be given in evidence as part of the res gestae. The victim's spontaneous utterance right after being stabbed, identifying her assailant while still under the influence of a startling occurrence, is admissible as an exception to the hearsay rule. Such declarations carry high trustworthiness due to their spontaneity and lack of opportunity for fabrication.

2. Extrajudicial Press Admissions
Voluntary statements made by an accused to news reporters or the press during a media broadcast are admissible in evidence as extrajudicial admissions under Rule 130, Section 27. An extrajudicial admission is not governed by the constitutional custodial investigation rules if made spontaneously to news journalists rather than law enforcement officers. While an uncorroborated extrajudicial admission may be insufficient to convict standing alone, it provides strong corroborative evidence of guilt when coupled with independent proof of corpus delicti and credible eyewitness testimony.

3. Personal Knowledge Rule
Under Rule 130, Section 22 of the Revised Rules on Evidence, a witness can testify only to those facts which he knows of his personal knowledge, derived from his own perception. An eyewitness who personally observes an assailant beating and stabbing a victim from a nearby vantage point possesses direct personal knowledge of the assault. The credibility and weight of such eyewitness testimony remain intact even if the witness hid during the attack, provided his sensory perceptions of the event were clear and uninhibited.

TopicsExtrajudicial Admissions1Personal Knowledge Rule2Res Gestae Exception2

2014 Remedial Law, Q4

An order of the court requiring a retroactive re-dating of an order, judgment or document filing be entered or recorded in a judgment is: (1%)
(A) pro hac vice
(B) non pro tunc
(C) confession relicta verificatione
(D) nolle prosequi

Quick check

What is the primary purpose of a nunc pro tunc judgment or order issued by a trial court?

Can a court use a nunc pro tunc order to alter or modify the substantive terms of a final judgment?

What does the Latin procedural phrase "pro hac vice" mean when used in judicial rulings?

Which of the following describes the legal concept of "nolle prosequi" in criminal procedure?

From what date does a valid nunc pro tunc order take legal effect?

Learn more about these topics

1. Nunc Pro Tunc
A nunc pro tunc order is issued by a court to record a prior judicial act that was actually performed but omitted from the formal record through inadvertence or mistake. Its purpose is to make the record speak the truth as of the date the judicial action was actually taken. A nunc pro tunc order cannot be used to modify, alter, or reverse a judgment, nor can it supply judicial action that was not actually rendered at the earlier date.

2. Scope of Correction
The office of a nunc pro tunc entry is restricted to placing upon the record evidence of a judicial action that was previously made but not properly entered. It operates retroactively to the date when the judgment or order was originally rendered. Courts cannot use a nunc pro tunc order to correct judicial errors, supply omitted judicial conclusions, or alter substantive rights of the parties after a judgment has attained finality.

3. Common Legal Terms
Understanding Latin procedural maxims is essential in Philippine remedial law. Aside from nunc pro tunc, terms such as pro hac vice refer to rulings made for a particular occasion without creating precedent, while nolle prosequi signifies a formal entry by the prosecution declaring that a criminal case will not be further prosecuted. Recognizing these distinctions ensures precise application of procedural remedies and judicial orders during litigation.

TopicsJudgments and Orders1Nunc Pro Tunc1Remedial Law Terms1

2014 Remedial Law, Q5

Landlord, a resident of Quezon City, entered into a lease contract with Tenant, a resident of Marikina City, over a residential house in Las Piñas City. The lease contract provided, among others, for a monthly rental of P25,000.00, plus ten percent (10%) interest rate in case of non-payment on its due date. Subsequently, Landlord migrated to the United States of America (USA) but granted in favor of his sister Maria, a special power of attorney to manage the property and file and defend suits over the property rented out to Tenant. Tenant failed to pay the rentals due for five (5) months.
Maria asks your legal advice on how she can expeditiously collect from Tenant the unpaid rentals plus interests due. (6%)
(A) What judicial remedy would you recommend to Maria?
(B) Where is the proper venue of the judicial remedy which you recommended?
(C) If Maria insists on filing an ejectment suit against Tenant, when do you reckon the one (1)-year period within which to file the action?

Quick check

What is the jurisdictional threshold for money claims covered by the Small Claims Procedure under the Rules on Expedited Procedure?

Where is the proper venue for a small claims action to collect unpaid lease rentals?

From what point is the one-year period to file an action for unlawful detainer reckoned?

What type of legal action is a pure collection suit for unpaid monthly rentals without a prayer for ejectment?

May a principal landlord who has migrated abroad institute a small claims action through an attorney-in-fact?

Learn more about these topics

1. Small Claims Action
Under the Rules on Expedited Procedure, a civil action for money claims not exceeding One Million Pesos (P1,000,000), exclusive of interest and costs, falls under the Procedure for Small Claims Cases. This judicial remedy provides an expeditious and inexpensive process for recovery of unpaid rentals and accrued contractual interest. Small claims actions are conducted using simplified statement of claim forms without formal trial pleadings, technical evidentiary rules, or mandatory representation by legal counsel.

2. Personal Action Venue
Under Rule 4, Section 2 of the Rules of Court, personal actions may be commenced and tried where the plaintiff or any of the principal plaintiffs resides, or where the defendant or any of the principal defendants resides, at the election of the plaintiff. In small claims actions for unpaid lease obligations, the venue lies either in the municipality or city where the landlord resides or where the tenant resides. The location of the leased real property is immaterial in purely personal collection suits.

3. Unlawful Detainer Reckoning
Under Rule 70 of the Rules of Court, an action for unlawful detainer must be filed within one year from the date of the last demand to vacate the premises and pay rentals. Where the tenant's initial entry was lawful but became illegal due to non-payment of rent, the one-year prescriptive period does not run from the default date, but is strictly reckoned from the date when the tenant receives the final demand letter to vacate.

TopicsSmall Claims Procedure2Unlawful Detainer Reckoning Period1Venue of Personal Actions1

2014 Remedial Law, Q6

As a rule, courts may not grant an application for provisional remedy without complying with the requirements of notice and hearing. These requirements, however, may be dispensed with in an application for: (1%)
(A) writ of preliminary injunction
(B) writ for preliminary attachment
(C) an order granting support pendente lite
(D) a writ of replevin

Quick check

Which provisional remedy may be issued by the court ex parte without prior notice and hearing to the adverse party?

Why does Rule 57 allow an order of preliminary attachment to be granted ex parte?

Which of the following provisional remedies strictly requires prior notice and hearing before it can be granted?

What must an applicant for preliminary attachment submit to the court prior to the issuance of the writ?

Choices available with full access.

Under Rule 60 of the Rules of Court, when may a party apply for a writ of replevin?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Ex Parte Attachment
Under Rule 57, Section 2 of the Rules of Court, an order of preliminary attachment may be issued ex parte, dispensing with prior notice and hearing. Prior notice is not required because alerting the adverse party could prompt the fraudulent disposal, concealment, or removal of properties intended to satisfy a potential judgment. The applicant must strictly satisfy the statutory requirements by filing a verified application, executed affidavit, and the required applicant's bond before the writ may be issued by the court.

2. Hearing Requirements
Unlike preliminary attachment, provisional remedies such as preliminary injunction and support pendente lite generally require notice and hearing before issuance. A preliminary injunction cannot be granted without notice and a formal hearing, as it directly restrains or mandates specific acts by the adverse party. Similarly, support pendente lite requires notice and hearing to determine the legal obligation to support and the financial capacity of the obligor, ensuring due process is strictly accorded to both parties prior to issuing provisional relief.

3. Replevin and Notice
A writ of replevin under Rule 60 allows the recovery of personal property upon the filing of an application, affidavit, and bond. While replevin may be applied for at the commencement of the action or at any time before answer, courts require strict compliance with bond and affidavit requirements. Obtaining provisional remedies ex parte remains an exceptional rule limited primarily to preliminary attachment to prevent irreparable frustration of prospective judicial execution against absconding or fraudulent debtors.

TopicsEx Parte Issuance2Preliminary Attachment5Provisional Remedies2