Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2014 Bar Examinations

2014 Remedial Law, Q12

Mary Jane met Shiela May at the recruitment agency where they both applied for overseas employment. They exchanged pleasantries, including details of their personal circumstances. Fortunately, Mary Jane was deployed to work as front desk receptionist at a hotel in Abu Dhabi where she met Sultan Ahmed who proposed marriage, to which she readily accepted. Unfortunately for Shiela May, she was not deployed to work abroad, and this made her envious of Mary Jane.
Mary Jane returned to the Philippines to prepare for her wedding. She secured from the National Statistics Office (NSO) a Certificate of No Marriage. It turned out from the NSO records that Mary Jane had previously contracted marriage with John Starr, a British citizen, which she never did. The purported marriage between Mary Jane and John Starr contained all the required pertinent details on Mary Jane. Mary Jane later on learned that Shiela May is the best friend of John Starr.
As a lawyer, Mary Jane seeks your advice on her predicament. What legal remedy will you avail to enable Mary Jane to contract marriage with Sultan Ahmed? (4%)

Quick check

What is the proper judicial remedy to expunge a registered marriage certificate where the petitioner's identity was fraudulently used in a simulated marriage?

Under the doctrine in Republic v. Olaybar, why is a petition for declaration of nullity of marriage inappropriate for a simulated marriage?

Who are the indispensable parties that must be impleaded in a Rule 108 petition to cancel a simulated marriage entry?

Which court has subject matter jurisdiction over a petition for cancellation of entry in the civil registry under Rule 108?

Choices available with full access.

What procedural requirement ensures that a Rule 108 proceeding for cancellation of entry is adversarial in nature?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Rule 108 Proceedings
Under Rule 108 of the Rules of Court, a verified petition may be filed in the Regional Trial Court to cancel or correct entries in the civil registry, including simulated or void marriage records. Where a party never consented to nor participated in any marriage ceremony, the registered marriage certificate is a nullity. A Rule 108 petition provides the appropriate judicial mechanism to expunge fictitious records and restore the true civil status of the affected party, provided that all indispensable parties are properly impleaded.

2. Republic v. Olaybar
In Republic v. Olaybar, the Supreme Court ruled that a petition for cancellation of entry under Rule 108 is the proper remedy when a person's name and personal details were fraudulently used by an imposter to contract a simulated marriage. Because no real marriage ever took place between the actual parties, an action for declaration of nullity of marriage under Rule 47 or Article 36 is inappropriate. A Rule 108 proceeding effectively clears civil registry records upon proof of identity theft and non-participation.

3. Indispensable Parties Requirement
Rule 108 mandates an adversarial proceeding where all persons who have or claim any interest that would be affected by the cancellation or correction must be notified and impleaded. In a petition seeking to cancel a simulated marriage entry, the local civil registrar, the alleged spouse named in the certificate, and any interested private individuals must be served with summons and published notice. Strict compliance with publication and jurisdictional notice guarantees due process before the trial court orders the entry cancelled.

TopicsCorrection of Civil Registry1Rule 108 Cancellation of Entry2Simulated Marriage Records1

2014 Remedial Law, Q13

A foreign dog trained to sniff dangerous drugs from packages, was hired by FDP Corporation, a door to door forwarder company, to sniff packages in their depot at the international airport. In one of the routinary inspections of packages waiting to be sent to the United States of America (USA), the dog sat beside one of the packages, a signal that the package contained dangerous drugs. Thereafter, the guards opened the package and found two (2) kilograms of cocaine. The owner of the package was arrested and charges were filed against him. During the trial, the prosecution, through the trainer who was present during the incident and an expert in this kind of field, testified that the dog was highly trained to sniff packages to determine if the contents were dangerous drugs and the sniffing technique of these highly trained dogs was accepted worldwide and had been successful in dangerous drugs operations. The prosecution moved to admit this evidence to justify the opening of the package. The accused objected on the grounds that: (i) the guards had no personal knowledge of the contents of the package before it was opened; (ii) the testimony of the trainer of the dog is hearsay; and (iii) the accused could not cross-examine the dog. Decide. (4%)

Quick check

Why is evidence of dangerous drugs discovered by private forwarder guards admissible in a criminal prosecution?

How is the testimony of a dog trainer regarding a drug-sniffing dog's reaction evaluated under the Rules of Evidence?

Does the constitutional right of an accused to confront witnesses extend to cross-examining a drug detection dog?

What is the legal status of contraband opened and discovered by private security guards without police participation?

Choices available with full access.

Under Rule 130 of the Rules of Evidence, when is opinion evidence of an expert witness admissible in court?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Private Search Doctrine
Under established constitutional jurisprudence, the protection against unreasonable searches and seizures under Article III, Section 2 of the Constitution applies exclusively as a restraint upon government authorities and state agents. Searches conducted by private individuals or employees of private entities, such as airport forwarder guards acting on their own initiative without state intervention or police inducement, fall outside the scope of constitutional protection. Consequently, contraband discovered during a purely private search is fully admissible in evidence in a subsequent criminal prosecution.

2. Dog Handler Testimony
Testimony provided by a qualified dog trainer regarding the training, track record, and behavioral reaction of a drug-sniffing dog is admissible as expert opinion under Rule 130 of the Rules of Evidence. The trainer testifies from personal knowledge regarding the physical observations of the dog's behavior and established detection techniques. Such testimony does not constitute hearsay because the handler is describing observed physical conduct and expert evaluations, and the witness is available in court for full cross-examination.

3. Object Identification Instruments
A highly trained drug-sniffing dog is not a witness under the law, but rather a specialized detection instrument utilized to locate concealed contraband. The constitutional right of an accused to confront and cross-examine witnesses under Article III, Section 14 applies exclusively to human declarants who render testimony or statements. Because a detection dog cannot take an oath or offer testimonial statements, the requirement of cross-examination is completely satisfied by cross-examining the human handler who observed and interpreted the dog's physical reactions.

TopicsExclusionary Rule Inapplicability1Expert Testimony Admissibility1Private Search Doctrine1

2014 Remedial Law, Q14

When a Municipal Trial Court (MTC), pursuant to its delegated jurisdiction, renders an adverse judgment in an application for land registration, the aggrieved party’s remedy is: (1%)
(A) ordinary appeal to the Regional Trial Court
(B) petition for review on certiorari to the Supreme Court
(C) ordinary appeal to the Court of Appeals
(D) petition for review to the Court of Appeals

Quick check

Where is an adverse judgment of a Municipal Trial Court rendered pursuant to delegated land registration jurisdiction appealable?

Under Section 34 of B.P. Blg. 129, what is the jurisdictional property value threshold for MTC delegated land registration jurisdiction?

What procedural rule governs ordinary appeals to the Court of Appeals from MTC decisions in delegated land registration cases?

Why is an MTC decision in a delegated land registration case not appealable to the Regional Trial Court under Rule 40?

Choices available with full access.

What is the period for filing a notice of appeal from an MTC decision in a delegated land registration case?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Delegated Land Jurisdiction
Under Section 34 of Batas Pambansa Blg. 129, as amended by Republic Act No. 7691, First Level Courts may be assigned delegated jurisdiction by the Supreme Court to hear and determine cadastral or land registration cases in specific instances. This delegated jurisdiction applies where there is no controversy or contest over the lot, or where the value of the lot does not exceed One Hundred Thousand Pesos (P100,000.00). In exercising delegated jurisdiction, Municipal Trial Courts act with the same judicial authority as Regional Trial Courts handling land registration matters.

2. Appellate Remedy Rule
Decisions of Municipal Trial Courts rendered pursuant to their delegated land registration jurisdiction are appealable in the same manner as decisions of Regional Trial Courts. Under Rule 41 of the Rules of Court, an appeal from an adverse judgment of a trial court in the exercise of its original or delegated jurisdiction in land registration cases is taken to the Court of Appeals via ordinary appeal. The appeal is perfected by filing a notice of appeal with the trial court within fifteen days from notice of the judgment.

3. Direct CA Appeal
When a Municipal Trial Court exercises delegated jurisdiction in land registration cases, its decision is not appealable to the Regional Trial Court. Ordinary appeal to the Regional Trial Court under Rule 40 applies exclusively to judgments rendered by First Level Courts in the exercise of their ordinary original jurisdiction. Because delegated jurisdiction elevates the First Level Court's authority to that of an RTC in land registration cases, bypassing the RTC and appealing directly to the Court of Appeals is procedurally required.

TopicsAppeals to Court of Appeals1BP 129 Section 341Delegated Land Jurisdiction1

2014 Remedial Law, Q15

The Ombudsman, after conducting the requisite preliminary investigation, found probable cause to charge Gov. Matigas in conspiracy with Carpintero, a private individual, for violating Section 3(e) of Republic Act (RA) No. 3019 (Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act, as amended). Before the information could be filed with the Sandiganbayan, Gov. Matigas was killed in an ambush. This, notwithstanding, an information was filed against Gov. Matigas and Carpintero.
At the Sandiganbayan, Carpintero through counsel, filed a Motion to Quash the Information, on the ground of lack of jurisdiction of the Sandiganbayan, arguing that with the death of Gov. Matigas, there is no public officer charged in the information. Is the motion to quash legally tenable? (4%)

Quick check

Does the death of a public officer prior to filing an Information divest the Sandiganbayan of jurisdiction over a private co-conspirator?

What is the legal effect of the death of a public officer prior to the filing of an Information for violation of RA 3019?

Under People v. Go, why does a private individual remain liable under Section 3(e) of RA 3019 despite the death of the public officer?

Which court has exclusive original jurisdiction over a private individual charged in conspiracy with a governor for violating RA 3019?

Choices available with full access.

What is the proper action of the Sandiganbayan on a Motion to Quash filed by a private co-conspirator grounded on the death of the public officer?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Sandiganbayan Jurisdiction
Under Republic Act No. 8249, the Sandiganbayan possesses exclusive original jurisdiction over criminal cases involving public officers enumerated under the law, as well as private individuals charged as co-conspirators. The jurisdictional character of the court is determined by the allegations in the Information at the time of filing. When a private individual is indicted for conspiring with a public officer in violating Republic Act No. 3019, the Sandiganbayan acquires jurisdiction over the offense and the private defendant, which jurisdiction continues until the final termination of the case.

2. Public Officer Death
Under Article 89 of the Revised Penal Code and established jurisprudence in People v. Go, the death of an accused prior to the filing of the Information extinguishes only his personal criminal liability. The death of a public officer co-conspirator neither extinguishes the underlying crime nor obliterates the conspiracy established during preliminary investigation. A private individual who conspired with the deceased public officer remains criminally liable under Section 3(e) of Republic Act No. 3019 and can be prosecuted independently before the Sandiganbayan.

3. Motion to Quash
A motion to quash an Information under Rule 117 of the Rules of Criminal Procedure must be anchored on specific statutory grounds, such as lack of jurisdiction over the offense charged. Where the Information properly alleges that a private individual acted in conspiracy with a public officer to violate anti-graft laws, the demise of the public officer before judicial filing does not divest the Sandiganbayan of subject matter jurisdiction. Consequently, a motion to quash filed by the surviving private co-conspirator on jurisdictional grounds must be denied.

TopicsDeath of Co-Conspirator2RA 3019 Section 3(e)2Sandiganbayan Jurisdiction4

2014 Remedial Law, Q16

Plaintiff filed a complaint denominated as accion publiciana, against defendant. In his answer, defendant alleged that he had no interest over the land in question, except as lessee of Z. Plaintiff subsequently filed an affidavit of Z, the lessor of defendant, stating that Z had sold to plaintiff all his rights and interests in the property as shown by a deed of transfer attached to the affidavit. Thus, plaintiff may ask the court to render: (1%)
(A) summary judgment
(B) judgment on the pleadings
(C) partial judgment
(D) judgment by default

Quick check

When is summary judgment under Rule 35 of the Rules of Court appropriate in a civil action?

What is a genuine issue of fact under Rule 35 of the Rules of Court?

How does summary judgment differ from a judgment on the pleadings under Rule 34?

What is an accion publiciana under Philippine remedial law?

Choices available with full access.

What is the legal effect when a lessor transfers all rights in a property to a third-party buyer during a lease?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Summary Judgment Rule
Under Rule 35, Section 1 of the Rules of Court, a party seeking to recover upon a claim may move for summary judgment supported by affidavits, depositions, or admissions. Summary judgment is appropriate when the pleadings, supporting affidavits, and admissions demonstrate that there is no genuine issue as to any material fact, except as to the amount of damages. When supporting affidavits show that no real factual issue exists between the parties, the court may render summary judgment without conducting a full trial on the merits.

2. Genuine Issue Test
A genuine issue is an issue of fact that requires the presentation of evidence, as distinguished from a sham, fictitious, contrived, or false issue. Where the defendant's answer appears to raise an issue but the supporting affidavits and attached documentary evidence unequivocally demonstrate that the defense is without substance, no genuine issue of fact exists. In such cases, summary judgment expedites litigation by eliminating unnecessary and costly trials where the legal outcome is clear based on uncontroverted evidentiary materials.

3. Accion Publiciana Nature
An accion publiciana is an ordinary civil proceeding for the recovery of the better right of possession of real property independently of title. It is brought when the dispossession has lasted for more than one year and the jurisdiction belongs to the proper trial court based on the assessed value of the property. When the defendant's right of possession is derived solely from a lease contract and the lessor transfers all rights to the plaintiff, the lessee loses legal standing to contest possession against the new owner.

TopicsAccion Publiciana3Rule 35 Civil Procedure1Summary Judgment4