Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2013 Bar Examinations

2013 Remedial Law, Q8

On his way to the PNP Academy in Silang, Cavite on board a public transport bus as a passenger, Police Inspector Masigasig of the Valenzuela Police witnessed an on-going armed robbery while the bus was traversing Makati. His alertness and training enabled him to foil the robbery and to subdue the malefactor. He disarmed the felon and while frisking him, discovered another handgun tucked in his waist. He seized both handguns and the malefactor was later charged with the separate crimes of robbery and illegal possession of firearm.
VIII(A) Where should Police Inspector Masigasig bring the felon for criminal processing? To Silang, Cavite where he is bound; to Makati where the bus actually was when the felonies took place; or back to Valenzuela where he is stationed? Which court has jurisdiction over the criminal cases? (3%)
VIII(B) May the charges of robbery and illegal possession of firearm be filed directly by the investigating prosecutor with the appropriate court without a preliminary investigation? (4%)

Quick check

Where must a person arrested in flagrante delicto for a crime committed in Makati City be brought for criminal processing?

Which court has territorial jurisdiction over a crime of robbery committed on a public bus traversing Makati City?

When may an Information be filed directly in court without a prior preliminary investigation under Rule 112, Section 6?

What is the primary purpose of an inquest proceeding conducted by a prosecutor?

Choices available with full access.

Under Rule 113, Section 5(a), what constitutes a valid in flagrante delicto warrantless arrest?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Criminal Venue Jurisdiction
Under Rule 110, Section 15 of the Rules of Court, criminal actions must be instituted and tried in the court of the municipality or territory where the offense was committed or where any of its essential ingredients occurred. Venue in criminal cases is jurisdictional. A police officer who effects a lawful arrest must bring the arrested person to the proper police authorities in the municipality or city where the crime took place, establishing territorial jurisdiction in the courts of that place.

2. Inquest Proceedings
Under Rule 112, Section 6 of the Rules of Court, when a person is lawfully arrested without a warrant for an offense requiring a preliminary investigation, an Information may be filed directly in court without a preliminary investigation, provided an inquest has been conducted by an inquest prosecutor. The inquest proceeding is an informal and summary investigation conducted by a public prosecutor in criminal cases involving persons arrested and detained without a warrant of arrest for the purpose of determining whether said person should remain under custody and correspondingly charged in court.

3. Warrantless Arrest Validity
Under Rule 113, Section 5 of the Rules of Court, a peace officer or a private person may make a lawful arrest without a warrant when, in their presence, the person to be arrested has committed, is actually committing, or is attempting to commit an offense (in flagrante delicto). Evidence seized pursuant to a search incident to a lawful warrantless arrest, such as weapons found on the suspect's person, is admissible in court and supports immediate criminal processing via inquest.

TopicsCriminal Venue Jurisdiction1Inquest Proceedings3Warrantless Arrest Procedure1

2013 Remedial Law, Q9

For over a year, Nenita had been estranged from her husband Walter because of the latter’s suspicion that she was having an affair with Vladimir, a barangay kagawad who lived in nearby Mandaluyong. Nenita lived in the meantime with her sister in Makati. One day, the house of Nenita’s sister inexplicably burned almost to the ground. Nenita and her sister were caught inside the house but Nenita survived as she fled in time, while her sister tried to save belongings and was caught inside when the house collapsed.
As she was running away from the burning house, Nenita was surprised to see her husband also running away from the scene. Dr. Carlos, Walter’s psychiatrist who lived near the burned house and whom Walter medically consulted after the fire, also saw Walter in the vicinity some minutes before the fire. Coincidentally, Fr. Platino, the parish priest who regularly hears Walter’s confession and who heard it after the fire, also encountered him not too far away from the burned house.
Walter was charged with arson and at his trial, the prosecution moved to introduce the testimonies of Nenita, the doctor and the priest-confessor, who all saw Walter at the vicinity of the fire at about the time of the fire.
IX(A) May the testimony of Nenita be allowed over the objection of Walter? (3%)
IX(B) May the testimony of Dr. Carlos, Walter’s psychiatrist, be allowed over Walter’s objection? (3%)
IX(C) May the testimony of Fr. Platino, the priest-confessor, be allowed over Walter’s objection? (3%)

Quick check

When may a wife testify against her husband in a criminal prosecution over his objection under the Rules on Evidence?

Why is the testimony of the psychiatrist regarding seeing the accused near the crime scene admissible over objection?

Under what condition does the priest-penitent privilege apply to exclude a clergyman's testimony under Rule 130?

What is the legal effect of an act of arson committed by a husband on a dwelling occupied by his estranged wife?

Choices available with full access.

What type of information is protected under the physician-patient privilege in Philippine evidence law?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Marital Disqualification Exception
Under Rule 130, Section 22 of the Rules on Evidence, neither spouse may testify for or against the other without consent during marriage, except in a civil case by one against the other, or in a criminal case for a crime committed by one against the other or the latter's direct descendants or ascendants. Arson of the dwelling where the wife resides, endangering her life, is deemed a crime committed against the wife. Thus, the marital disqualification rule cannot be invoked by the accused husband to prevent his estranged wife from testifying against him in court.

2. Physician-Patient Privilege
Under Rule 130, Section 24(c) of the Rules on Evidence, the physician-patient privilege disqualifies a physician from testifying on any advice or treatment given or information acquired in attending a patient in a professional capacity, which would blacken the patient's reputation. However, this privilege applies strictly to confidential communications and observations made within the scope of professional medical examination or treatment. Merely observing the patient physically present in a public street or neighborhood outside the consultation room is an unprivileged personal observation.

3. Priest-Penitent Privilege
Under Rule 130, Section 24(d) of the Rules on Evidence, a minister or priest cannot be examined as to any confession made to him in his professional character in the course of discipline enjoined by the church. For the privilege to apply, the statement must be a penitential confession made under the seal of secrecy. Merely witnessing or encountering the penitent physically present near a crime scene prior to or outside of a formal sacramental confession is an independent physical observation not protected by the privilege.

TopicsMarital Disqualification Rule4Physician-Patient Privilege3Priest-Penitent Privilege1

2013 Remedial Law, Q10

As a new lawyer, Attorney Novato limited his practice to small claims cases, legal counseling and the notarization of documents. He put up a solo practice law office and was assisted by his wife who served as his secretary/helper. He used a makeshift hut in a vacant lot near the local courts and a local transport regulatory agency. With this practice and location, he did not have big-time clients but enjoyed heavy patronage assisting walk-in clients.
X(A) What role can Attorney Novato play in small claims cases when lawyers are not allowed to appear as counsel in these cases? (3%)
X(B) What legal remedy, if any, may Attorney Novato pursue for a client who loses in a small claims case and before which tribunal or court may this be pursued? (4%)

Quick check

What is the extent of a lawyer's permissible participation in small claims cases under the Revised Rules?

Is a judgment rendered by a First Level Court in a small claims case subject to ordinary appeal?

What is the proper legal remedy for a losing party in a small claims case involving grave abuse of discretion?

Which court has original jurisdiction to entertain a Rule 65 petition challenging a small claims judgment?

Choices available with full access.

Why are lawyers prohibited from appearing for litigants during small claims court hearings?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Small Claims Role
Under the Revised Rules on Small Claims Cases, lawyers are strictly prohibited from appearing as counsel during court hearings. However, an attorney may assist a litigant prior to the hearing by providing legal advice and preparing the necessary forms, such as drafting the Statement of Claim or Response with attached supporting documents. This behind-the-scenes legal assistance ensures that unrepresented litigants properly present their claims or defenses while fully complying with the procedural prohibition against formal legal representation in court.

2. Unappealable Small Claims
Decisions rendered by First Level Courts in small claims cases are final, executory, and non-appealable under the Rules on Expedited Procedures. The rule aims to provide a fast, inexpensive, and summary settlement of money claims without prolonged litigation. Because no ordinary appeal lies from a small claims judgment, a party who suffers an adverse ruling cannot file a notice of appeal or a motion for reconsideration before the issuing trial court.

3. Rule 65 Certiorari
Although a small claims judgment is final and unappealable, an aggrieved party is not completely without legal recourse. If the First Level Court acted without or in excess of jurisdiction, or with grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction, the losing litigant may file a special civil action for certiorari under Rule 65. This petition must be filed before the Regional Trial Court within sixty days from notice of the judgment.

TopicsRepresentation Prohibition1Rule 65 Certiorari5Small Claims Practice1

2012 Bar Examinations

2012 Remedial Law, Q1

After an information for rape was filed in the RTC, the DOJ Secretary, acting on the accused’s petition for review, reversed the investigating prosecutor’s finding of probable cause. Upon order of the DOJ Secretary, the trial prosecutor filed a Motion to Withdraw Information which the judge granted. The order of the judge stated only the following:
“Based on the review by the DOJ Secretary of the findings of the investigating prosecutor during the preliminary investigation, the Court agrees that there is no sufficient evidence against the accused to sustain the allegation in the information. The motion to withdraw Information is, therefore, granted.”
If you were the private prosecutor, what should you do? Explain. (5%)
A was charged with a non-bailable offense. At the time when the warrant of arrest was issued, he was confined in the hospital and could not obtain a valid clearance to leave the hospital. He filed a petition for bail saying therein that he be considered as having placed himself under the jurisdiction of the court. May the court entertain his petition? Why or why not? (5%)

Quick check

What is the legal duty of a trial judge when resolving a motion to withdraw Information based on a DOJ Secretary's review?

What constitutes grave abuse of discretion when a trial judge grants a motion to withdraw Information?

When is an accused considered under the custody of the law for purposes of applying for bail?

Can a court entertain a bail petition from an accused confined in a hospital who voluntarily submits to its jurisdiction?

What is the proper remedy of a private prosecutor against a judge's order blindly granting a motion to withdraw Information?

Learn more about these topics

1. Independent Judicial Assessment
Under established criminal procedure jurisprudence, once an Information is filed in court, any disposition of the case rests within the exclusive sound discretion of the trial judge. While the Secretary of Justice may review the resolution of the investigating prosecutor, the trial judge cannot blindly follow or adopt the Secretary's findings. The judge is legally mandated to make an independent assessment of the evidence on record before granting or denying a motion to withdraw the Information. Failure to exercise independent judicial judgment constitutes grave abuse of discretion reviewable via certiorari under Rule 65.

2. Custody of Law
To apply for bail, an accused must be in the custody of the law or otherwise deprived of liberty. Physical confinement in a hospital due to illness, coupled with an express voluntary submission to the jurisdiction of the trial court, constitutes constructive custody of the law. Under these circumstances, physical detention inside a jail cell is not strictly required for the court to acquire jurisdiction over the person of the accused. Consequently, the trial court has authority to entertain and resolve the petition for bail filed by the hospitalized accused.

3. Certiorari Remedies
When a trial judge grants a motion to withdraw an Information by merely echoing the conclusions of the Executive Branch without making independent factual findings, the private prosecutor may seek judicial relief. The private prosecutor must first file a motion for reconsideration to give the trial court an opportunity to correct its error. If the motion is denied, a special civil action for certiorari under Rule 65 may be instituted before the appellate court on the ground that the trial judge abdicated judicial responsibility, thereby committing grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack of jurisdiction.

TopicsCustody of Law for Bail1Independent Judicial Assessment1Motion to Withdraw Information1

2012 Remedial Law, Q2

Discuss the “chain of custody” principle with respect to evidence seized under R.A. 9165 or the Comprehensive Dangerous Drugs Act of 2002. (5%)
What do you understand about the “precautionary principle” under the Rules of Procedure for Environmental Cases? (5%)

Quick check

What is the primary objective of the chain of custody rule under Section 21 of R.A. 9165?

Under the Rules of Procedure for Environmental Cases, when does the precautionary principle apply?

What is the legal effect of an unexplained break in the chain of custody of seized illicit drugs?

How does the precautionary principle alter the traditional burden of proof in environmental litigation?

Which Supreme Court issuance governs the application of the precautionary principle in Philippine courts?

Learn more about these topics

1. Chain of Custody
Under Section 21 of Republic Act No. 9165, the chain of custody rule establishes a mandatory procedure for handling seized illegal drugs. It requires accounting for every person who handled, tested, and stored the dangerous drugs from the initial time of seizure and marking until final presentation as evidence in court. This strict evidentiary requirement guarantees that the dangerous drug offered in court is the exact identity and in the same condition as that seized from the accused, thereby preserving the integrity of the corpus delicti and preventing evidentiary tampering or substitution.

2. Precautionary Principle
Under Rule 20 of the Rules of Procedure for Environmental Cases (A.M. No. 09-6-8-SC), the precautionary principle applies when human activities threaten serious or irreversible environmental damage. Where there is a lack of full scientific certainty, it should not be used as a reason for postponing cost-effective measures to prevent environmental degradation. This principle shifts the burden of proof to the proponent of an activity to demonstrate that their actions will not cause harm, thereby prioritizing environmental protection and human health in judicial decision-making.

3. Evidentiary Burdens
Both the chain of custody requirement and the precautionary principle serve to address evidentiary challenges in specialized litigation. In criminal drug prosecutions, the prosecution bears the burden of establishing an unbroken chain of custody beyond reasonable doubt to secure a conviction. Conversely, in environmental litigation, the precautionary principle relaxes traditional burdens of proof by allowing courts to issue protective orders despite scientific uncertainty, ensuring that potential ecological threats are mitigated before catastrophic damage occurs.

TopicsChain of Custody4Precautionary Principle3Rules of Procedure for Environmental Cases1