Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2010 Bar Examinations

2010 Remedial Law, Q3

Anabel filed a complaint against B for unlawful detainer before the Municipal Trial Court (MTC) of Candaba, Pampanga. After the issues had been joined, the MTC dismissed the complaint for lack of jurisdiction after noting that the action was one for accion publiciana.
Anabel appealed the dismissal to the RTC which affirmed it and accordingly dismissed her appeal. She elevates the case to the Court of Appeals, which remands the case to the RTC. Is the appellate court correct? Explain. (3%)

Quick check

Is the Court of Appeals correct in remanding a dismissed unlawful detainer case to the RTC if the RTC has original jurisdiction over the resulting accion publiciana?

What is the nature of an accion publiciana in Philippine remedial law?

What should the RTC do when an MTC order dismissing an action without trial for lack of jurisdiction is appealed to it, if the RTC has original jurisdiction?

Which court has jurisdiction over an unlawful detainer complaint filed within one year from the demand to vacate?

Under Rule 40, what is the procedural consequence when the RTC erroneously affirms an MTC dismissal instead of trying the case on its merits?

Learn more about these topics

1. Rule 40 Appeals
Under Section 8, Rule 40 of the Rules of Court, when an appeal is taken from an order of a Municipal Trial Court dismissing a case without a trial on the merits for lack of jurisdiction, the Regional Trial Court shall not dismiss the appeal if it has original jurisdiction over the subject matter. Instead, the Regional Trial Court must assume original jurisdiction and try the case as if it had been originally filed before it. This procedural rule prevents unnecessary delays and repeated refilings of civil actions.

2. Accion Publiciana Jurisdiction
An accion publiciana is a plenary civil action for the recovery of the better right of possession of real property when the dispossession has lasted for more than one year. Unlike unlawful detainer or forcible entry actions which fall under the exclusive original jurisdiction of Municipal Trial Courts, an accion publiciana falls under the original jurisdiction of the Regional Trial Court or Municipal Trial Court depending on the assessed value of the real property involved.

3. Remand to RTC
When the Regional Trial Court erroneously affirms a Municipal Trial Court's dismissal for lack of jurisdiction instead of assuming original jurisdiction over the case as mandated by Rule 40, the Court of Appeals acts properly by remanding the case to the Regional Trial Court. The remand directs the Regional Trial Court to conduct a full trial on the merits under its original jurisdiction, ensuring that the parties receive a complete adjudication of their possessory rights.

TopicsAccion Publiciana Jurisdiction1Rule 40 Section 8 Appeal1Unlawful Detainer Rules1

2010 Remedial Law, Q4

X was driving the dump truck of Y along Cattleya Street in Sta. Maria, Bulacan. Due to his negligence, X hit and injured V who was crossing the street. Lawyer L, who witnessed the incident, offered his legal services to V.
V, who suffered physical injuries including a fractured wrist bone, underwent surgery to screw a metal plate to his wrist bone.
On complaint of V, a criminal case for Reckless Imprudence Resulting in Serious Physical Injuries was filed against X before the Municipal Trial Court (MTC) of Sta. Maria. Atty. L, the private prosecutor, did not reserve the filing of a separate civil action.
V subsequently filed a complaint for Damages against X and Y before the Regional Trial Court of Pangasinan in Urdaneta where he resides. In his “Certification Against Forum Shopping,” V made no mention of the pendency of the criminal case in Sta. Maria.
a. Is V guilty of forum shopping? (2%)
b. Instead of filing an Answer, X and Y move to dismiss the complaint for damages on the ground of litis pendentia. Is the motion meritorious? Explain. (2%)
c. Suppose only X was named as defendant in the complaint for damages, may he move for the dismissal of the complaint for failure of V to implead Y as an indispensable party? (2%)
d. X moved for the suspension of the proceedings in the criminal case to await the decision in the civil case. For his part, Y moved for the suspension of the civil case to await the decision in the criminal case. Which of them is correct? Explain. (2%)
e. Atty. L offered in the criminal case his affidavit respecting what he witnessed during the incident. X’s lawyer wanted to cross-examine Atty. L who, however, objected on the ground of lawyer-client privilege. Rule on the objection. (2%)

Quick check

Why does a separate civil action for damages based on quasi-delict not constitute litis pendentia during a pending criminal prosecution?

What is the nature of the liability between an employer and a negligent driver in a quasi-delict action for damages?

Is an employer an indispensable party in a quasi-delict complaint filed against a negligent driver?

Which case is suspended when both an independent civil action and a criminal action arising from the same act are pending?

Why is an attorney's eyewitness testimony regarding a traffic accident not protected by attorney-client privilege?

Learn more about these topics

1. Independent Civil Actions
Under Article 31 of the Civil Code and Rule 111 of the Rules of Court, an independent civil action based on quasi-delict may proceed independently of the criminal action. Because the civil action for quasi-delict is distinct and separate from the criminal prosecution for reckless imprudence, the institution of a civil complaint for damages during the pendency of the criminal case does not constitute forum shopping or litis pendentia.

2. Solidary Tort Liability
Under Article 2194 of the Civil Code, the responsibility of two or more persons who are liable for a quasi-delict is solidary. Joint tortfeasors, including an employer and a negligent employee, are solidarily liable to the injured party. Because solidary obligations allow the creditor to enforce the claim against any one or all of the solidary debtors, the employer is merely a necessary party rather than an indispensable party in a quasi-delict suit.

3. Attorney-Client Privilege Scope
Under Rule 130 of the Rules of Court, the attorney-client privilege protects confidential communications made by a client to an attorney in the course of professional employment. The privilege does not extend to personal observations made by an attorney as an eyewitness to an accident prior to or outside of any attorney-client relationship. An affidavit testifying to facts observed first-hand as a witness is not privileged and is subject to cross-examination.

TopicsAttorney-Client Privilege Scope1Quasi-Delict Independent Civil Action1Solidary Liability in Torts1

2010 Remedial Law, Q5

Charisse, alleging that she was a resident of Lapu-Lapu City, filed a complaint for damages against Atlanta Bank before the RTC of Lapu-Lapu City, following the dishonor of a check she drew in favor of Shirley against her current account which she maintained in the bank’s local branch.
The bank filed a Motion to Dismiss the complaint on the ground that it failed to state a cause of action, but it was denied. It thus filed an Answer.
a. In the course of the trial, Charisse admitted that she was a US citizen residing in Los Angeles, California and that she was temporarily billeted at the Pescado Hotel in Lapu-Lapu City, drawing the bank to file another motion to dismiss, this time on the ground of improper venue, since Charisse is not a resident of Lapu-Lapu City.
Charisse opposed the motion citing the “omnibus motion rule.” Rule on the motion. (3%)
b. Suppose Charisse did not raise the “omnibus motion rule,” can the judge proceed to resolve the motion to dismiss? Explain. (3%)
c. Suppose the judge correctly denied the second motion to dismiss and rendered judgment in favor of Charisse, ordering the bank to pay her P100,000 in damages plus legal interest. The judgment became final and executory in 2008. To date, Charisse has not moved to execute the judgment. The bank is concerned that its liability will increase with the delay because of the interest on the judgment award.
As counsel of the bank, what move should you take? (3%)

Quick check

What is the legal effect when a defendant fails to raise improper venue in a motion to dismiss or in its answer?

May a trial judge motu proprio dismiss a civil complaint on the ground of improper venue?

What procedural remedy is available to a judgment debtor to stop the running of legal interest when the judgment creditor fails to execute a final judgment?

Which of the following defenses is NOT waived if omitted from a motion to dismiss or answer under Rule 9?

Under the Omnibus Motion Rule, what is required of a motion attacking a pleading, order, judgment, or proceeding?

Learn more about these topics

1. Waiver of Venue
Under Rule 9 of the Rules of Court, defenses and objections not pleaded either in a motion to dismiss or in the answer are deemed waived, except for lack of jurisdiction over the subject matter, litis pendentia, res judicata, and prescription. Improper venue is a personal defense that is strictly for the benefit of the defendant. If a defendant fails to raise improper venue in a motion to dismiss or in its answer, the objection is deemed waived and cannot be raised in a subsequent motion.

2. Motu Proprio Dismissal
Under Philippine remedial law, a trial court judge cannot motu proprio dismiss a civil action on the ground of improper venue. Improper venue is not one of the non-waivable grounds under Section 1, Rule 9 of the Rules of Court upon which a court may dismiss a case on its own initiative. Because venue is purely procedural and subject to waiver by the parties, a court must proceed with the case unless a timely objection is raised by the defendant in the proper motion or pleading.

3. Consignation of Judgment
Under Article 1256 of the Civil Code, consignation is the act of depositing the thing or sum due with the proper judicial authority when the creditor refuses without just cause to accept payment or cannot be located. When a judgment award becomes final and executory and the judgment creditor fails or delays in moving for execution, the judgment debtor may validly tender payment and consign the judgment amount in court. Consignation halts the running of legal interest on the judgment award.

TopicsImproper Venue Waiver1Judgment Debt Consignation1Omnibus Motion Rule1

2010 Remedial Law, Q6

Antique dealer Mercedes borrowed P1,000,000 from antique collector Benjamin. Mercedes issued a postdated check in the same amount to Benjamin to cover the debt.
On the due date of the check, Benjamin deposited it but it was dishonored. As despite demands, Mercedes failed to make good the check, Benjamin filed in January 2009 a complaint for collection of sum of money before the RTC of Davao.
Mercedes filed in February 2009 her Answer with Counterclaim, alleging that before the filing of the case, she and Benjamin had entered into a dacion en pago agreement in which her vintage ₱1,000,000 Rolex watch which was taken by Benjamin for sale on commission was applied to settle her indebtedness; and that she incurred expenses in defending what she termed a “frivolous lawsuit.” She accordingly prayed for ₱50,000 damages.
a. Benjamin soon after moved for the dismissal of the case. The trial court accordingly dismissed the complaint. And it also dismissed the Counterclaim.
Mercedes moved for a reconsideration of the dismissal of the Counterclaim. Pass upon Mercedes’ motion. (3%)
b. Suppose there was no Counterclaim and Benjamin’s complaint was not dismissed, and judgment was rendered against Mercedes for ₱1,000,000. The judgment became final and executory and a writ of execution was correspondingly issued.
Since Mercedes did not have cash to settle the judgment debt, she offered her Toyota Camry model 2008 valued at P1.2 million. The Sheriff, however, on request of Benjamin, seized Mercedes’ 17th century ivory image of the La Sagrada Familia estimated to be worth over ₱1,000,000.
Was the Sheriff’s action in order? (3%)

Quick check

What is the effect under Rule 17 on a pending counterclaim when the court grants a plaintiff's motion to dismiss the complaint?

Who has the primary right to select which property shall be levied upon to satisfy a money judgment under Rule 39?

What option is available to a defendant whose counterclaim is pending when the plaintiff moves to dismiss the main complaint?

If a judgment obligor offers a sufficient motor vehicle to satisfy a money judgment, may the sheriff seize a different property requested by the creditor?

Choices available with full access.

Under Section 2 of Rule 17, within how many days from notice of the motion to dismiss must a defendant manifest preference to prosecute a counterclaim in the same action?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Counterclaim Survival Rules
Under Section 2, Rule 17 of the Rules of Court, if a counterclaim has been pleaded by a defendant prior to the service upon him of the plaintiff's motion for dismissal, the dismissal of the complaint shall be limited to the complaint itself. The dismissal of the main action shall be without prejudice to the right of the defendant to prosecute his counterclaim in a separate action or to express his preference to have his counterclaim resolved in the same action.

2. Execution Property Selection
Under Section 9(b), Rule 39 of the Rules of Court, if the judgment obligor cannot pay all or part of the judgment debt in cash, the judgment obligor has the primary option to choose which of his personal or real properties shall be levied upon by the sheriff to satisfy the execution. The judgment creditor or the sheriff cannot override the judgment obligor's valid choice of sufficient non-exempt property to satisfy the money judgment.

3. Dismissal Upon Motion
When a plaintiff files a motion to dismiss his own complaint after the defendant has filed an answer containing a counterclaim, the court may grant the dismissal of the complaint. However, the trial court cannot automatically dismiss the defendant's counterclaim along with the main complaint. The court must give the defendant the opportunity to express whether he prefers to prosecute his counterclaim in the same proceeding or in a separate civil action.

TopicsCompulsory Counterclaim Survival1Dismissal of Complaint Effect1Execution Levy Property Selection1

2010 Remedial Law, Q7

As Cicero was walking down a dark alley one midnight, he saw an “owner-type jeepney” approaching him. Sensing that the occupants of the vehicle were up to no good, he darted into a corner and ran. The occupants of the vehicle − elements from the Western Police District − gave chase and apprehended him.
The police apprehended Cicero, frisked him and found a sachet of 0.09 gram of shabu tucked in his waist and a Swiss knife in his secret pocket, and detained him thereafter. Is the arrest and body-search legal? (3%)

Quick check

What is required under Rule 113 for a warrantless arrest in flagrante delicto to be constitutionally valid?

Does a person's act of running away upon seeing an approaching unmarked vehicle at midnight justify a warrantless arrest?

What degree of suspicion is required to conduct a valid stop-and-frisk search under Philippine jurisprudence?

What is the legal status of drug evidence seized during an unlawful warrantless arrest and body-search?

Choices available with full access.

What is the legal relationship between a warrantless arrest and a search incidental to a lawful arrest?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Warrantless Arrest Rules
Under Section 5, Rule 113 of the Rules of Court, a warrantless arrest by a peace officer is lawful only when the person to be arrested has committed, is actually committing, or is attempting to commit an offense in the officer's presence; when an offense has just been committed and the officer has probable cause based on personal knowledge of facts; or when the person is an escaped prisoner. Flight alone from approaching individuals in an unmarked vehicle at midnight does not constitute an overt illegal act or afford probable cause to justify a warrantless arrest.

2. Stop and Frisk
A valid stop-and-frisk search is a limited protective search for concealed weapons allowed when a police officer observes unusual conduct that leads him reasonably to conclude, in light of his experience, that criminal activity may be afoot. For a stop-and-frisk search to be constitutionally valid, it must be supported by genuine, articulable suspicion of criminal activity rather than mere suspicion or flight. A search conducted without genuine articulable suspicion renders the search illegal and any evidence seized during the search inadmissible in court.

3. Exclusionary Rule
Under Section 3(2), Article III of the 1987 Philippine Constitution, any evidence obtained in violation of the right against unreasonable searches and seizures is inadmissible for any purpose in any proceeding. This exclusionary rule, commonly known as the fruit of the poisonous tree doctrine, mandates that evidence seized pursuant to an unlawful warrantless arrest or illegal body-search cannot be used by the prosecution to establish guilt. Consequently, drugs and weapons confiscated during an illegal search must be excluded from the criminal proceedings.

TopicsExclusionary Rule Inadmissibility1Stop and Frisk Search2Warrantless Arrest Rules1