Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2010 Bar Examinations

2010 Remedial Law, Q18

While window-shopping at the mall on August 4, 2008, Dante lost his organizer including his credit card and billing statement. Two days later, upon reporting the matter to the credit card company, he learned that a one-way airplane ticket was purchased online using his credit card for a flight to Milan in mid- August 2008. Upon extensive inquiry with the airline company, Dante discovered that the plane ticket was under the name of one Dina Meril. Dante approaches you for legal advice.
a. What is the proper procedure to prevent Dina from leaving the Philippines? (2%)
b. Suppose an Information is filed against Dina on August 12, 2008 and she is immediately arrested. What pieces of electronic evidence will Dante have to secure in order to prove the fraudulent online transaction? (2%)

Quick check

How can the prosecution prevent an accused in a pending criminal case before the RTC from fleeing the Philippines?

Under the Rules on Electronic Evidence, how are electronic data messages authenticated in court?

Which of the following constitutes admissible electronic evidence to prove a fraudulent online purchase?

Which court has the authority to issue a Hold Departure Order in criminal cases under Supreme Court guidelines?

Choices available with full access.

What is the evidentiary weight of an authenticated electronic document under the Rules on Electronic Evidence?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Hold Departure Order
Under circulars of the Supreme Court and rules of criminal procedure, a Hold Departure Order (HDO) may be issued by the Regional Trial Court in criminal cases within its jurisdiction. Once an Information is filed in court, the prosecution or private complainant may file an urgent motion for the issuance of an HDO to command the Bureau of Immigration to prevent the accused from departing Philippine territory. An HDO ensures that the accused remains within the court's jurisdiction to face trial and prevents the evasion of criminal liability.

2. Electronic Evidence Rules
Under the Rules on Electronic Evidence (A.M. No. 01-7-01-SC), an electronic document or data message is admissible in evidence if it complies with the rules on admissibility prescribed by the Rules of Court and is authenticated. To prove a fraudulent online transaction, the prosecution must present electronic data messages such as computer printouts of the credit card billing statement, the online ticket booking confirmation, and the electronic purchase receipt. These electronic records serve as the functional equivalent of written documents in establishing credit card fraud.

3. Electronic Document Authentication
Under Rule 5 of the Rules on Electronic Evidence, electronic documents are authenticated by evidence showing that the document had at all times been kept in a reliable manner or by testimony demonstrating the integrity and accuracy of the computer system. In credit card fraud cases, presenting the digital audit trail, system transaction logs from the credit card company, and official booking records from the airline company establishes the authenticity of the fraudulent transaction and links the unauthorized purchase directly to the online user.

TopicsElectronic Evidence Authenticity1Hold Departure Order1Rules on Electronic Evidence5

2010 Remedial Law, Q19

1. Enumerate the requisites of a “trial in absentia” (2%) and a “promulgation of judgment in absentia” (2%).
2. Name two instances where the trial court can hold the accused civilly liable even if he is acquitted. (2%)

Quick check

Which of the following is an essential requisite for holding a valid trial in absentia under the Rules of Court?

How is a judgment of conviction promulgated if the accused unjustifiably fails to appear despite due notice?

When does the acquittal of an accused in a criminal case extinguish his civil liability arising from the offense?

What is the legal consequence if an accused fails to appear for promulgation of judgment without justifiable cause?

Choices available with full access.

In which scenario may the trial court properly hold an accused civilly liable despite an acquittal in a criminal case?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Trial in Absentia
Under Section 14(2), Article III of the 1987 Constitution and Rule 115 of the Rules of Court, a trial in absentia may proceed provided the accused has been validly arraigned, duly notified of the trial or hearing, and his failure to appear is unjustifiable. This constitutional provision ensures that an accused cannot delay or defeat the administration of justice by deliberately absconding or refusing to appear after jurisdiction over his person has been acquired. The right to be present during trial is deemed waived upon satisfaction of these mandatory procedural requisites.

2. Promulgation in Absentia
Under Rule 120, Section 6 of the Rules of Court, if the accused fails to appear without justifiable cause during the scheduled promulgation of judgment despite due notice, the judgment shall be promulgated by recording it in the criminal docket and serving a copy thereof upon the accused or his counsel. Promulgation in absentia is valid and effective. Consequently, the accused loses remedies against the judgment, such as bail or appeal, unless he surrenders within fifteen days and proves that his absence was due to a justifiable cause.

3. Civil Liability Acquittal
Under Rule 120, Section 2 of the Rules of Court and Article 29 of the Civil Code, an acquittal in a criminal case does not automatically extinguish the civil liability of the accused. Extinction of the penal action results in extinction of the civil action only if there is a finding in the final judgment that the act or omission from which the civil liability might arise did not exist. Where acquittal is based on reasonable doubt or where the court declares that the liability is purely civil, the court may properly hold the accused civilly liable.

TopicsCivil Liability Upon Acquittal1Promulgation in Absentia2Trial in Absentia1

2010 Remedial Law, Q20

Azenith, the cashier of Temptation Investments, Inc. (Temptation, Inc.) with principal offices in Cebu City, is equally hated and loved by her co-employees because she extends cash advances or “vales” to her colleagues whom she likes. One morning, Azenith discovers an anonymous letter inserted under the door of her office threatening to kill her.
Azenith promptly reports the matter to her superior Joshua, who thereupon conducts an internal investigation to verify the said threat.
Claiming that the threat is real, Temptation, Inc. opts to transfer Azenith to its Palawan Office, a move she resists in view of the company’s refusal to disclose the results of its investigation.
Decrying the move as a virtual deprivation of her employment, Azenith files a petition for the issuance of a writ of habeas data before the Regional Trial Court (RTC) to enjoin Temptation, Inc. from transferring her on the ground that the company’s refusal to provide her with a copy of the investigation results compromises her right to life, liberty and privacy.
Resolve the petition. Explain. (5%)

Quick check

When is the writ of habeas data available against a private individual or entity?

Is an ordinary private employer conducting an internal security investigation subject to a writ of habeas data?

What is the proper legal remedy for an employee who claims that a company transfer constitutes constructive dismissal?

What specific constitutional right is directly protected and safeguarded by the writ of habeas data?

Choices available with full access.

How should a Regional Trial Court rule on a habeas data petition filed to stop an employment transfer and compel disclosure of internal investigation results?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Habeas Data Scope
Under Section 1 of the Rule on the Writ of Habeas Data (A.M. No. 08-1-16-SC), the writ is a judicial remedy available to any person whose right to privacy in life, liberty, or security is violated or threatened by an unlawful act or omission of a public official or employee, or of a private individual or entity engaged in the gathering, collecting, or storing of data or information regarding the person, family, home, or correspondence of the aggrieved party. It is not an all-encompassing remedy for commercial, labor, or administrative disputes.

2. Data Gathering Requirement
To successfully petition for a writ of habeas data against a private corporation, the respondent must be an entity engaged in the business of gathering, collecting, or storing data or information regarding the aggrieved person. An ordinary private employer conducting a discrete internal investigation into a security threat against its employee does not automatically fall under the definition of a data-gathering entity. Consequently, the employer's refusal to disclose internal investigation results does not warrant the issuance of the writ.

3. Labor Dispute Boundaries
The writ of habeas data cannot be utilized as a substitute for labor law remedies to challenge employment transfers or corporate management decisions. When an employee resists a transfer to a branch office and decries it as constructive dismissal or deprivation of employment, the appropriate forum is the National Labor Relations Commission through a labor dispute proceeding. Invoking constitutional writs like habeas data to resolve routine employment disputes or enforce disclosure of internal personnel files is an improper misuse of extraordinary legal remedies.

TopicsHabeas Data Availability1Management Prerogative Labor1Writ of Habeas Data4