Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2015 Bar Examinations

2015 Remedial Law, Q5

Ernie filed a petition for guardianship over the person and properties of his father, Ernesto. Upon receipt of the notice of hearing, Ernesto filed an opposition to the petition. Ernie, before the hearing of the petition, filed a motion to order Ernesto to submit himself for mental and physical examination which the court granted.
After Ernie’s lawyer completed the presentation of evidence in support of the petition and the court’s ruling on the formal offer of evidence, Ernesto’s lawyer filed a demurrer to evidence.
Ernie’s lawyer objected on the ground that a demurrer to evidence is not proper in a special proceeding.
a.) Was Ernie’s counsel’s objection proper? (2%)
b.) If Ernesto defies the court’s order directing him to submit to physical and mental examinations, can the court order his arrest? (2%)

Quick check

Is a demurrer to evidence available in special proceedings such as guardianship?

What is the proper ground for filing a demurrer to evidence after the petitioner rests in a guardianship case?

Can a court order the arrest of a party who refuses to submit to a physical or mental examination under Rule 29?

What sanction may a trial court apply against a party refusing a mental examination order under Rule 28?

Why did the court err if it sustained an objection against a demurrer in a guardianship proceeding?

Learn more about these topics

1. Special Proceedings Demurrer
Under Rule 72, Section 2 of the Rules of Court, the rules governing ordinary civil actions apply suppletorily to special proceedings in the absence of specific applicable provisions. Because special proceedings rules contain no express prohibition against filing a demurrer to evidence, Rule 33 applies suppletorily. After the petitioner rests their case and formally offers evidence, the respondent in a guardianship proceeding may move for dismissal on the ground of insufficiency of evidence. Consequently, an objection contending that a demurrer to evidence is improper in special proceedings is legally erroneous.

2. Physical Examination Order
Rule 28 of the Rules of Court authorizes trial courts to order a party to submit to a physical or mental examination when their mental or physical condition is in controversy, such as in guardianship proceedings. Obtaining an examination order is essential for evaluating capacity. However, because compulsory medical procedures impinge directly upon personal autonomy and physical integrity, the Rules of Court strictly regulate the enforcement measures available to the trial judge when an examinee refuses to comply with an examination order.

3. Refusal Examination Sanctions
Under Rule 29, Section 3(d) of the Rules of Court, a trial court possesses various enforcement sanctions for refusal to obey discovery orders, such as striking out pleadings or staying further proceedings. However, the rule explicitly excludes arrest as a sanction for disobeying an order to submit to a physical or mental examination. While the court may draw adverse evidentiary inferences against the non-complying party or refuse to allow them to present supporting evidence, ordering the physical arrest of an examinee for non-compliance is strictly prohibited.

TopicsDemurrer to Evidence7Guardianship Proceedings1Sanctions for Refusing Examination1

2015 Remedial Law, Q6

A law was passed declaring Mt. Karbungko as a protected area since it as a major watershed. The protected area covered a portion located in Municipality A of the Province I and a portion located in the City of Z of Province II. Maingat is the leader of Samahan ng Tagapag-ingat ng Karbungko (STK), a people’s organization. He learned that a portion of the mountain located in the City of Z of Province II was extremely damaged when it was bulldozed and leveled to the ground, and several trees and plants were cut down and burned by workers of World Pleasure Resorts, Inc. (WPRI) for the construction of a hotel and golf course. Upon inquiry with the project site engineer if they had a permit for the project, Maingat was shown a copy of the Environmental Compliance Certificate (ECC) issued by the DENR-EMB, Regional Director (RD-DENR-EMB). Immediately, Maingat and STK filed a petition for the issuance of a writ of continuing mandamus against RD-DENR-EMB and WPRI with the RTC of Province I, a designated environmental court, as the RD-DENR-EMB negligently issued the ECC to WPRI.
On scrutiny of the petition, the court determined that the area where the alleged actionable neglect or omission subject of the petition took place in the City of Z of Province II, and therefore cognizable by the RTC of Province II. Thus, the court dismissed outright the petition for lack of jurisdiction.
a.) Was the court correct in motu proprio dismissing the petition? (3%)
Assuming that the court did not dismiss the petition, the RD-DENR-EMB in his Comment moved to dismiss the petition on the ground that petitioners failed to appeal the issuance of the ECC and to exhaust administrative remedies provided in the DENR Rules and Regulations.
b.) Should the court dismiss the petition? (3%)

Quick check

Is a trial court authorized to motu proprio dismiss an environmental petition on the ground of improper venue?

Where should a petition for a writ of continuing mandamus be filed under the Rules of Procedure for Environmental Cases?

What is the consequence of failing to appeal the issuance of an ECC to the DENR Secretary before filing a petition for continuing mandamus?

When does the extraordinary remedy of a writ of continuing mandamus lie against an administrative agency officer?

Choices available with full access.

What is the proper administrative remedy to challenge an ECC issued by a DENR-EMB Regional Director?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Improper Venue Dismissal
Under Rule 9, Section 1 of the Rules of Court and the Rules of Procedure for Environmental Cases, improper venue is not a jurisdictional ground for the motu proprio dismissal of a petition. Venue in environmental actions is procedural and intended for the convenience of the parties. While a petition for a writ of continuing mandamus should be filed in the Regional Trial Court exercising territorial jurisdiction over the area where the actionable neglect took place, courts cannot dismiss an action on the ground of improper venue unless the respondent formally raises venue as an affirmative defense.

2. Administrative Remedies Exhaustion
Under the doctrine of exhaustion of administrative remedies, a party seeking judicial relief against an administrative decision or action must first exhaust all available administrative remedies before resorting to court action. Under the DENR Rules and Regulations governing Environmental Compliance Certificates (ECCs), an aggrieved party must appeal the issuance of an ECC by a Regional Director to the DENR Secretary. Filing a petition for continuing mandamus without pursuing an administrative appeal violates this doctrine, rendering the petition premature and subject to dismissal.

3. Continuing Mandamus Scope
A writ of continuing mandamus is a special civil action available under the Rules of Procedure for Environmental Cases to compel a government agency or officer to perform an act specifically enjoined by law as a duty. However, the extraordinary writ lies only when there is no other plain, speedy, and adequate remedy in the ordinary course of law. Where an administrative appeal mechanism is provided by agency regulations to review and set aside an allegedly negligent ECC, judicial intervention via continuing mandamus is unavailable until administrative remedies are fully exhausted.

TopicsExhaustion of Administrative Remedies3Venue in Environmental Cases1Writ of Continuing Mandamus3

2015 Remedial Law, Q7

Plaintiff sued defendant for collection of P 1 million based on the latter’s promissory note. The complaint alleges, among others:
1) Defendant borrowed P1 million from plaintiff as evidenced by a duly executed promissory note;
2) The promissory note reads:
“Makati, Philippines
Dec. 30, 2014
For value received from plaintiff, defendant promises to pay plaintiff Pl million, twelve (12) months from the above indicated date without necessity of demand.
Signed
Defendant”
A copy of the promissory note is attached as Annex “A.”
Defendant, in his verified answer, alleged among others:
1) Defendant specifically denies the allegation in paragraphs 1 and 2 of the complaint, the truth being defendant did not execute any promissory note in favor of plaintiff, or
2) Defendant has paid the Ill million claimed in the promissory note (Annex “A” of the Complaint) as evidenced by an “Acknowledgment Receipt” duly executed by plaintiff on January 30, 2015 in Manila with his spouse signing as witness.
A copy of the “Acknowledgment Receipt” is attached as Annex “1” hereof.
Plaintiff filed a motion for judgment on the pleadings on the ground that defendant’s answer failed to tender an issue as the allegations therein on his defenses are sham for being inconsistent; hence, no defense at all. Defendant filed an opposition claiming his answer tendered an issue.
a.) Is judgment on the pleadings proper? (3%)
Defendant filed a motion for summary judgment on the ground that there are no longer any triable genuine issues of facts.
b.) Should the court grant defendant’s motion for summary judgment? (3%)

Quick check

Under Rule 8, Section 2 of the Rules of Court, is a defendant allowed to plead inconsistent or alternative defenses in an answer?

When is a judgment on the pleadings proper under Rule 34 of the Rules of Court?

What is the defining test for determining whether a summary judgment is appropriate under Rule 35?

Why was the plaintiff's motion for judgment on the pleadings improper in this collection suit?

Choices available with full access.

Why should the trial court deny the defendant's motion for summary judgment in this case?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Alternative Defenses Rule
Under Rule 8, Section 2 of the Rules of Court, a party may set forth two or more statements of defense alternatively or hypothetically, either in one defense or in separate defenses. The fact that alternative defenses may be inconsistent with one another does not render the pleading a sham or invalid. A defendant is legally permitted to deny the execution of an actionable document while simultaneously pleading payment in the alternative. Consequently, an answer setting up alternative defenses validly tenders factual issues for trial.

2. Judgment on Pleadings
Under Rule 34 of the Rules of Court, a judgment on the pleadings is proper only when an answer fails to tender an issue, or otherwise admits the material allegations of the adverse party's pleading. Where the defendant's answer specifically denies material allegations of the complaint or raises affirmative defenses, an issue of fact is properly joined. Because pleading alternative defenses is explicitly allowed by procedural rules, an answer containing inconsistent defenses does not constitute an admission of liability or justify a judgment on the pleadings.

3. Summary Judgment Test
Under Rule 35 of the Rules of Court, summary judgment is proper only when the pleadings, supporting affidavits, depositions, and admissions show that there is no genuine issue as to any material fact. A genuine issue is an issue of fact which calls for the presentation of evidence, as distinguished from a sham, fictitious, or contrived issue. When the parties dispute both the due execution of a promissory note and the fact of payment, genuine triable issues of material fact exist, precluding summary judgment.

TopicsAlternative Defenses1Judgment on the Pleadings4Summary Judgment4

2015 Remedial Law, Q8

Aldrin entered into a contract to sell with Neil over a parcel of land. The contract stipulated a P500,000.00 down payment upon signing and the balance payable in twelve (12) monthly installments of Pl00,000.00. Aldrin paid the down payment and had paid three (3) monthly installments when he found out that Neil had sold the same property to Yuri for Pl.5 million paid in cash. Aldrin sued Neil for specific performance with damages with the RTC. Yuri, with leave of court, filed an answer-in-intervention as he had already obtained a TCT in his name. After trial, the court rendered judgment ordering Aldrin to pay all the installments due, the cancellation of Yuri’s title, and Neil to execute a deed of sale in favor of Aldrin. When the judgment became final and executory, Aldrin paid Neil all the installments but the latter refused to execute the deed of sale in favor of the former.
Aldrin filed a “Petition for the Issuance of a Writ of Execution” with proper notice of hearing. The petition alleged, among others, that the decision had become final and executory and he is entitled to the issuance of the writ of execution as a matter of right. Neil filed a motion to dismiss the petition on the ground that it lacked the required certification against forum shopping.
a.) Should the court grant Neil’s Motion to Dismiss? (3%)
Despite the issuance of the writ of execution directing Neil to execute the deed of sale in favor of Aldrin, the former obstinately refused to execute the deed.
b.) What is Aldrin’s remedy? (2%)

Quick check

Is a certification against forum shopping required in a petition for the issuance of a writ of execution?

What is the proper remedy if a judgment debtor obstinately refuses to execute a deed of sale despite a writ of execution?

What is the legal effect when a court-appointed person executes a deed of conveyance under Rule 39, Section 10(a)?

Why should the trial court deny Neil's motion to dismiss Aldrin's petition for a writ of execution?

Choices available with full access.

When does the issuance of a writ of execution become a matter of right for the prevailing party?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Forum Shopping Certification
Under Rule 7, Section 5 of the Rules of Court, a certification against forum shopping is required only in initiatory pleadings that commence an action or proceeding. It is not required in post-judgment motions or petitions seeking the issuance of a writ of execution. Because a motion or petition for a writ of execution is a post-judgment relief aimed merely at enforcing a final and executory judgment, the absence of a forum shopping certificate does not warrant the dismissal of the petition.

2. Execution of Conveyances
Under Rule 39, Section 10(a) of the Rules of Court, when a judgment directs a party to execute a conveyance of land or deliver a deed or other documents, and the disobedient party fails or obstinately refuses to comply within the specified time, the court may direct the act to be done at the cost of the disobedient party by some other person appointed by the court. The act when so done has like effect as if done by the disobedient party.

3. Writ of Execution
When a judgment becomes final and executory, the prevailing party is entitled to a writ of execution as a matter of right. Execution cannot be defeated or delayed by technical objections raised against post-judgment enforcement motions. Once the court acquires jurisdiction over the main case and renders a final decree, enforcing that decree through execution is a ministerial duty of the tribunal, ensuring that prevailing litigants obtain complete judicial relief without unnecessary procedural hurdles.

TopicsCertification Against Forum Shopping3Execution of Conveyances1Writ of Execution1

2015 Remedial Law, Q9

Hades, an American citizen, through a dating website, got acquainted with Persephone, a Filipina. Hades came to the Philippines and proceeded to Baguio City where Persephone resides. Hades and Persephone contracted marriage, solemnized by the Metropolitan Trial Court judge of Makati City. After the wedding, Hades flew back to California, United States of America, to wind up his business affairs. On his return to the Philippines, Hades discovered that Persephone had an illicit affair with Phanes. Immediately, Hades returned to the United States and was able to obtain a valid divorce decree from the Superior Court of the County of San Mateo, California, a court of competent jurisdiction against Persephone. Hades desires to marry Hestia, also a Filipina, whom he met at Baccus Grill in Pasay City.
a.) As Hades’ lawyer, what petition should you file in order that your client can avoid prosecution for bigamy ifhe desires to marry Hestia? (2%)
b.) In what court should you file the petition? (1%)
c.) What is the essential requisite that you must comply with for the purpose of establishing jurisdictional facts before the court can hear the petition? (3%)

Quick check

What legal remedy must an alien spouse pursue in the Philippines to establish capacity to remarry after obtaining a foreign divorce decree?

In which court should a petition for judicial recognition of foreign divorce be filed under Rule 108?

What is the indispensable jurisdictional requirement before a trial court can hear a petition for recognition of foreign divorce under Rule 108?

Why is judicial recognition of a foreign divorce required before an alien spouse can validly remarry a Filipina in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

What is the nature of a Rule 108 proceeding for the recognition of a foreign divorce decree?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Foreign Divorce Recognition
Under Article 26(2) of the Family Code and Rule 108 of the Rules of Court, a divorce validly obtained abroad by an alien spouse must be judicially recognized in the Philippines before it can produce legal effects. The foreign divorce decree does not automatically operate to terminate the marriage under Philippine law. Judicial recognition is necessary to establish the alien spouse's capacity to remarry and to update the civil registry, thereby protecting the party from bigamy prosecution upon contracting a subsequent marriage.

2. Rule 108 Venue
Under Rule 108, Section 1 of the Rules of Court, a petition for the cancellation or correction of entries in the civil registry, including the judicial recognition of a foreign divorce decree, must be filed in the Regional Trial Court of the province or city where the civil registry located is situated. Where the marriage between the parties was solemnized and registered in Makati City, the petition must be brought before the Regional Trial Court of Makati City to properly acquire venue and subject matter authority.

3. Mandatory Publication Requirement
Under Rule 108, Section 4 of the Rules of Court, publication of the court order setting the petition for hearing in a newspaper of general circulation once a week for three consecutive weeks is an indispensable jurisdictional requirement. Because Rule 108 proceedings are in rem and affect civil status, strict compliance with publication binds the whole world. Failure to comply with this publication requirement deprives the trial court of jurisdiction to hear and decide the petition for judicial recognition.

TopicsPublication Requirement1Recognition of Foreign Divorce2Rule 108 Cancellation and Correction1