Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2018 Bar Examinations

2018 Remedial Law, Q11

In 2007, Court of Appeals Justice (CA Justice) Dread Dong (J. Dong) was appointed to the Supreme Court (Court) as Associate Justice. Immediately after the appointment was announced, several groups questioned his qualification to the position on the ground that he was not a natural born Filipino citizen. In the same year, the Court issued an Order enjoining him from accepting the appointment or assuming the position and discharging the functions of his office until he is able to successfully complete all the necessary steps to show that he is a natural born citizen of the Philippines. However, he continued to exercise his functions as CA Justice.
Since the qualification of a natural born citizen applies as well to CA Justices, Atty. Dacio, a practicing lawyer, asked the Office of the Solicitor General (OSG), through a verified request, to initiate a quo warranto proceeding against J. Dong in the latter’s capacity as incumbent CA Justice. The OSG refused to initiate the action on the ground that the issue of J. Dong’s citizenship was still being litigated in another case.
When the OSG refused to initiate a quo warranto proceeding, Atty. Dacio filed a petition for certiorari against the OSG and certiorari and prohibition against J. Dong. The petition for certiorari against the OSG alleged that the OSG committed grave abuse of discretion when it deferred the filing of a quo warranto proceeding against J. Dong, while the petition for certiorari and prohibition against J. Dong asked the Court to order him to cease and desist from further exercising his powers, duties and responsibilities as CA Justice. In both instances, Atty. Dacio relied on the fact that, at the lime of J. Dong’s appointment as CA Justice, his birth certificate indicated that he was a Chinese citizen and his bar records showed that he was a naturalized Filipino citizen.
(a) May the OSG be compelled, in an action for certiorari, to initiate a quo warranto proceeding against J. Dong? (2.5%)
(b) Does Atty. Dacio have the legal personality to initiate the action for certiorari and prohibition against J. Dong? (2.5%)

Quick check

May the Office of the Solicitor General be compelled via certiorari to institute a quo warranto proceeding?

Who has legal standing as a private individual to file an action for quo warranto under Rule 66?

Under Rule 66, Section 1 of the Rules of Court, in whose name is a quo warranto proceeding brought?

Why does a practicing lawyer lacking claim to a judicial office lack locus standi to challenge the justice's title?

Choices available with full access.

What constitutes a valid ground for the OSG to defer filing a quo warranto petition against a public officer?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. OSG Discretionary Power
Under Rule 66 of the Rules of Court, the Office of the Solicitor General exercises discretionary authority in determining whether to initiate a petition for quo warranto against an incumbent public officer. The Solicitor General cannot be compelled through a petition for certiorari or mandamus to file a quo warranto action unless there is a clear showing of grave abuse of discretion. Deferring the filing of a quo warranto suit while the contested qualification or citizenship issue is pending litigation in another forum constitutes a valid exercise of prosecutorial discretion rather than grave abuse.

2. Locus Standi Requirement
Under Rule 65 and Rule 66 of the Rules of Court, a private individual seeking to oust a public officer or challenge title to public office must possess legal standing. To institute an action challenging title to public office directly, the private individual must claim to be entitled to the disputed public position. A practicing lawyer or concerned citizen who does not claim any title or right to the office lacks direct legal interest and locus standi to institute quo warranto, certiorari, or prohibition proceedings against an incumbent judicial officer.

3. Quo Warranto Nature
Quo warranto is an extraordinary legal remedy issued to determine the right of a person to hold a public office or franchise. It is a proceeding brought in the name of the Republic of the Philippines against a person who usurps, intrudes into, or unlawfully holds or exercises a public office. Because public office concerns the public interest, the power to institute quo warranto is primarily vested in the State through the Solicitor General or a public prosecutor, safeguarding public offices from frivolous suits brought by private litigating parties.

TopicsLegal Standing3OSG Discretion1Quo Warranto3

2018 Remedial Law, Q12

Dodo was knocked unconscious in a fist fight with Dindo. He was rushed to the emergency room of the Medical City where he was examined and treated by Dr. Datu. As he was being examined, a plastic sachet appearing to contain shabu fell from Dodo’s jacket which was on a chair beside him. Dodo was thus arrested by the same policemen who assisted him to the hospital. At Dodo’s trial, the public prosecutor called Dr. Datu to the witness stand. When the public prosecutor asked Or. Datu as to what he saw in the emergency room, Dodo’s counsel objected, claiming doctor-patient privilege rule.
How would you rule on the objection? (2.5%)

Quick check

Does the physician-patient privilege apply in criminal prosecutions under Rule 130 of the Rules of Court?

What type of information is protected under the physician-patient privilege rule?

How should a trial court rule on a physician-patient privilege objection raised during a criminal drug trial?

Is a doctor's plain visual observation of a sachet falling from a patient's jacket protected by medical privilege?

Choices available with full access.

Under Rule 130, Section 24(c), who is the holder of the physician-patient privilege who may object to disclosure?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Physician-Patient Privilege Inapplicability
Under Rule 130, Section 24(c) of the Rules of Court, the physician-patient privilege applies strictly and exclusively to civil cases. It cannot be invoked in criminal prosecutions to exclude testimony or evidence. The public policy rationale behind limiting the privilege to civil cases is to prevent the privilege from being utilized as a shield to suppress vital evidence in criminal prosecutions where the State has an overriding interest in prosecuting crimes and establishing truth.

2. Scope of Confidentiality
The physician-patient privilege protects only confidential communications made for the purpose of medical diagnosis or treatment, as well as advice or information acquired by the physician in attending to the patient in a professional capacity. Plain visual observations of physical objects—such as a plastic sachet falling from a patient's clothing in an emergency room—do not constitute confidential communications or disclosures made for medical treatment. Consequently, such visual observations fall outside the protective scope of the privilege.

3. Overruling Objections
When an objection based on physician-patient privilege is raised in a criminal proceeding, the trial court must overrule the objection. Because the privilege is unavailable in criminal trials and does not extend to observable physical facts unrelated to medical examination, the physician is a competent witness to testify regarding what he observed. Allowing the physician to testify as to observable facts does not violate medical confidentiality or statutory privilege rules.

TopicsAdmissibility of Evidence5Physician-Patient Privilege3Rule 130 Rules of Court2

2018 Remedial Law, Q13

Denny is on trial for homicide. The prosecution calls Danilo, a police officer, who interviewed the victim, Drew, shortly after the shooting. Danila’s testimony is being offered by the prosecution for purposes of proving that (i) Drew is now dead; (ii) while in the emergency room, Drew was posting his medical condition on Facebook and was “liking” the posts of his Facebook friends; (iii) Drew asked the nurse for water but was refused because he was bleeding, which subsequently angered Drew; and (iv) that before dying, Drew signed a statement in which he identified Denny as the shooter.
Is the proposed testimony of Danilo admissible? (2.5%)

Quick check

Is an out-of-court statement identifying an assailant admissible as a dying declaration if the victim lacked consciousness of impending death?

Under the doctrine of independently relevant statements, why are certain out-of-court statements admissible in evidence?

What is the legal effect of a victim casually browsing social media shortly before dying on his dying declaration?

How does Rule 130 of the Rules of Court classify witness testimony regarding observable physical acts and emotional reactions?

Choices available with full access.

Which exception to the hearsay rule requires that the declarant be dead or unable to testify when his declaration is offered?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Dying Declaration Requisites
Under Rule 130, Section 38 of the Rules of Court, a dying declaration is an out-of-court statement made by a dying person under the consciousness of an impending death regarding the cause and surrounding circumstances of his death. For the declaration to be admissible as an exception to the hearsay rule, the declarant must be conscious of impending death at the time the statement is made. If the declarant displays casual behavior indicating hope or lack of apprehension of imminent death, the statement fails to qualify as a dying declaration and remains inadmissible hearsay.

2. Independently Relevant Statements
The doctrine of independently relevant statements applies when an out-of-court statement is offered in evidence not to prove the truth of the facts asserted therein, but merely to establish the fact that the statement was made or to show the declarant's mental state, reaction, or emotional condition. Statements offered as independently relevant facts are non-hearsay and are completely admissible. Witness testimony regarding observable acts, emotional outbursts, or contemporaneous conduct of a victim falls outside the hearsay prohibition and may be admitted to establish state of mind or surrounding circumstances.

3. Proof of Fact
Testimony by a witness regarding an undisputed physical fact, such as the actual death of a person, or observable physical acts performed by another individual, constitutes direct evidence of perceived facts rather than hearsay. When a police officer testifies to facts directly observed by him or facts that are not subject to dispute, such testimony is fully admissible. However, double hearsay or unsworn out-of-court identification statements that do not satisfy the strict requisites of recognized exceptions cannot be admitted to establish the identity of the alleged perpetrator.

TopicsDying Declaration Requisites1Hearsay Rule Exceptions2Independently Relevant Statements2

2018 Remedial Law, Q14

Dave is on trial for sexual assault of Delly, a law student who sidelines as a call center agent. Dave offers the testimony of Danny, who says that Dave is known in the community as a decent and discerning person. The prosecution presents a rebuttal witness, Dovie, who testifies that, if Dave was reputed to be a good person, that reputation was a misperception because Dave had been previously convicted of homicide.
Is Dovie’s testimony admissible as to the character of Dave? (2.5%)

Quick check

When may the prosecution present evidence of the bad moral character of the accused in a criminal case?

What requirement must character evidence satisfy to be admissible in a criminal prosecution?

How must bad moral character be proved when admissible on rebuttal in a criminal trial?

Why is a prior conviction for homicide inadmissible to rebut an accused's reputation for decency in a sexual assault case?

Choices available with full access.

Under Rule 130, Section 54, what is the general rule regarding character evidence in criminal cases?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Character Evidence Rule
Under Rule 130, Section 54(a) of the Rules of Court, the accused in a criminal case may prove his good moral character if pertinent to the moral trait involved in the offense charged. However, the prosecution cannot present evidence of the bad moral character of the accused unless in rebuttal after the accused has opened the issue by introducing evidence of good moral character. Even on rebuttal, prosecution evidence remains strictly limited to the specific moral trait pertinent to the crime charged.

2. Pertinent Moral Trait
Character evidence offered by either party must relate directly to the moral trait involved in the offense charged. In prosecutions for sexual offenses, the pertinent moral trait involves chastity, modesty, or sexual decency. Rebuttal testimony concerning a completely distinct moral trait, such as peacefulness or non-violence, is irrelevant to a charge of sexual assault. Consequently, evidence showing violent tendencies cannot be admitted on rebuttal to disprove an accused's reputation for decency and sexual morality.

3. Specific Acts Prohibition
When character evidence is admissible, it must be established exclusively through reputation in the community or opinion evidence, not by specific instances of conduct or prior criminal convictions. Demonstrating bad character through specific past wrongful acts violates the fundamental rule against using propensity evidence. A prior conviction for homicide constitutes a specific instance of conduct and is inadmissible as rebuttal character evidence to prove the accused's general bad moral character.

TopicsCharacter Evidence1Rebuttal Evidence1Rule 130 Rules of Court2

2018 Remedial Law, Q15

Atty. Dalmacio, the Director of the National Bureau of Investigation, applied for a search warrant before the Executive Judge of RTC Manila. He alleged in his application that a certain alias Django was keeping about 10 kilos of shabu in a wooden cabinet located at Dillian’s Store in Paseo de Sta. Rosa, Laguna. The Executive Judge of Manila personally examined Atty. Dalmacio and his witnesses and thereafter issued the search warrant particularly describing the place to be
searched and the items to be seized.
(a) Can the search warrant issued by the Executive Judge of Manila be enforced in Laguna? (2.5%)
(b) Can the legal concept of “venue is jurisdictional” be validly raised in applications for search warrants? (2.5%)

Quick check

Can a search warrant issued by an Executive Judge of RTC Manila upon application by the NBI Director be enforced in Laguna?

Why is the principle 'venue is jurisdictional' inapplicable to search warrant applications?

Which law enforcement officials are authorized to apply for nationwide search warrants under A.M. No. 99-20-09-SC?

What is the procedural nature of an application for a search warrant under Rule 126?

Choices available with full access.

Which trial courts possess special authority to issue nationwide search warrants for heinous crimes and illegal drugs?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Search Warrant Venue
Under Rule 126 of the Rules of Court and A.M. No. 99-20-09-SC, Executive Judges of the Regional Trial Courts of Manila and Quezon City have special authority to act on search warrant applications filed by the National Bureau of Investigation or Philippine National Police for heinous crimes and dangerous drugs. Search warrants issued pursuant to this special authority are enforceable nationwide. Consequently, a search warrant issued by an Executive Judge of RTC Manila for a drug offense in Laguna is valid and enforceable.

2. Nature of Application
An application for a search warrant is a special criminal process and a judicial search order, not a criminal action. Unlike criminal prosecutions where venue is jurisdictional because the court acquires jurisdiction over the offense based on the place where the crime was committed, venue in a search warrant application is purely procedural. Because search warrant proceedings do not try or adjudicate criminal liability, the principle that venue is jurisdictional cannot be raised to invalidate a search warrant issued by a competent court.

3. Executive Judge Authority
Under Supreme Court administrative guidelines, specific Executive Judges are granted expanded territorial authority to issue search warrants for compelling law enforcement reasons. When law enforcement agencies like the National Bureau of Investigation file applications involving major offenses like illegal drugs, the designated Executive Judges may issue warrants to be served outside their territorial jurisdiction. This statutory exception ensures effective prosecution of organized criminal activities without being restricted by traditional judicial territorial boundaries.

TopicsA.M. No. 99-20-09-SC1Search Warrant Enforceability1Venue in Search Warrants1