Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2015 Bar Examinations

2015 Remedial Law, Q10

An information for murder was filed against Rapido. The RTC judge, after personally evaluating the prosecutor’s resolution, documents and parties’ affidavits submitted by the prosecutor, found probable cause and issued a warrant of arrest. Rapido’s lawyer examined the rollo of the case and found that it only contained the copy of the information, the submissions of the prosecutor and a copy of the warrant of arrest. Immediately, Rapido’s counsel filed a motion to quash the arrest warrant for being void, citing as grounds:
a.) The judge before issuing the warrant did not personally conduct a searching examination of the prosecution witnesses in violation of his client’s constitutionally-mandated rights;
b.) There was no prior order finding probable cause before the judge issued the arrest warrant.
May the warrant of arrest be quashed on the grounds cited by Rapido’s counsel? State your reason for each ground. (4%)

Quick check

What is required of a judge when determining probable cause for the issuance of a warrant of arrest?

Is a trial judge required to personally examine prosecution witnesses before issuing an arrest warrant?

Does the absence of a separate prior order finding probable cause render an arrest warrant void?

When may a trial judge personally conduct a searching examination of witnesses in determining probable cause?

Choices available with full access.

What is the proper action on a motion to quash an arrest warrant based on lack of personal witness examination by the judge?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Judicial Probable Cause
Under Section 2, Article III of the Constitution and Rule 112, Section 5 of the Rules of Criminal Procedure, a judge issuing a warrant of arrest is only required to personally evaluate the resolution of the prosecutor and its supporting documents. The judge is not mandated to personally conduct a searching examination of the complainant and witnesses. Personal examination is only discretionary when the judge finds the prosecutor's report and submitted affidavits insufficient to establish probable cause for issuing an arrest warrant.

2. Warrant Order Requirement
The absence of a separate, prior written order finding probable cause does not invalidate a warrant of arrest. The actual issuance of the warrant itself carries the legal presumption that the trial judge personally evaluated the evidence and determined the existence of probable cause. The Constitution and procedural rules do not require a formal written resolution or separate order prior to or accompanying the issuance of a warrant of arrest.

3. Motion to Quash
A motion to quash a warrant of arrest on the grounds of lack of personal examination or absence of a prior written order must be denied when the record shows judicial compliance. When the trial judge personally reviews the prosecutor's summary, information, and supporting affidavits before issuing the warrant, the constitutional mandate is fully satisfied. Allegations of procedural irregularity without proof that the judge failed to personally evaluate the records will not justify quashing the warrant.

TopicsJudicial Evaluation1Probable Cause1Warrant of Arrest3

2015 Remedial Law, Q11

The Ombudsman found probable cause to charge with plunder the provincial governor, vice governor, treasurer, budget officer, and accountant. An Information for plunder was filed with the Sandiganbayan against the provincial officials except for the treasurer who was granted immunity when he agreed to cooperate with the Ombudsman in the prosecution of the case. Immediately, the governor filed with the Sandiganbayan a petition for certiorari against the Ombudsman claiming there was grave abuse of discretion in excluding the treasurer from the Information.
a.) Was the remedy taken by the governor correct? (2%)
b.) Will the writ of mandamus lie to compel the Ombudsman to include the treasurer in the Information? (3%)
c.) Can the Special Prosecutor move for the discharge of the budget officer to corroborate the testimony of the treasurer in the course of presenting its evidence? (2%)

Quick check

In which court should a petition for certiorari under Rule 65 be filed to question a resolution of the Ombudsman in a criminal case?

Will a writ of mandamus lie to compel the Ombudsman to include a person in a criminal Information?

What is required under Rule 119, Section 17 before an accused may be discharged to become a state witness?

Why is discharging an accused merely to corroborate existing prosecution testimony improper under Rule 119?

Choices available with full access.

Does the Sandiganbayan possess jurisdiction over a Rule 65 petition for certiorari challenging an Ombudsman resolution in a criminal proceeding?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Certiorari Jurisdiction
Under Section 14 of Republic Act No. 6770 and established jurisprudence, decisions or resolutions of the Ombudsman in criminal matters finding probable cause or granting immunity may only be questioned via a petition for certiorari under Rule 65 filed before the Supreme Court. The Sandiganbayan has no jurisdiction over extraordinary writs of certiorari seeking to annul or modify interlocutory orders or investigatory resolutions of the Ombudsman. Consequently, filing a certiorari petition with the Sandiganbayan to challenge the Ombudsman's exclusion of a co-accused from the criminal Information is procedurally improper.

2. Mandamus Against Discretion
The writ of mandamus is an extraordinary remedy that lies only to compel the performance of a ministerial duty clearly enjoined by law. It cannot be issued to direct or control the exercise of discretion by an executive officer or administrative body. The Ombudsman possesses broad discretionary authority under Section 17 of Republic Act No. 6770 to grant immunity from prosecution to any person whose testimony is necessary in criminal proceedings. Because granting immunity and determining whom to prosecute involve discretionary prosecutorial functions, mandamus will not lie to compel the Ombudsman to include a witness in an Information.

3. State Witness Discharge
Under Rule 119, Section 17 of the Rules of Criminal Procedure, the court may discharge an accused to become a state witness only if there is absolute necessity for their testimony. Absolute necessity means that the prosecution has no other direct or corroborative evidence to establish the crime charged. Where the prosecution already possesses sufficient testimony from an immune witness covering the essential elements of the offense, discharging another co-accused merely to corroborate that existing testimony fails the strict test of absolute necessity, rendering a motion for discharge improper.

TopicsCertiorari Jurisdiction1Discharge of State Witness2Ombudsman Immunity Grant1

2015 Remedial Law, Q12

Paz was awakened by a commotion coming from a condo unit next to hers. Alarmed, she called up the nearby police station. PO 1 Remus and P02 Romulus proceeded to the condo unit identified by Paz. PO 1 Remus knocked at the door and when a man opened the door, POI Remus and his companions introduced themselves as police officers. The man readily identified himself as Oasis Jung and gestured to them to come in. Inside, the police officers saw a young lady with her nose bleeding and face swollen. Asked by P02 Romulus what happened, the lady responded that she was beaten up by Oasis Jung. The police officers arrested Oasis Jung and brought him and the young lady back to the police station. PO1 Remus took the young lady’s statement who identified herself as AA. She narrated that she is a sixteen-year-old high school student; that previous to the incident, she had sexual intercourse with Oasis Jung at least five times on different occasions and she was paid P5,000.00 each time and it was the first time that Oasis Jung physically hurt her. P02 Romulus detained Oasis Jung at the station’s jail. After the inquest proceeding, the public prosecutor filed an information for Violation of R.A. No. 9262 (The VA WC Law) for physical violence and five separate informations for violation of R.A. No. 7610 (The Child Abuse Law). Oasis Jung’s lawyer filed a motion to be admitted to bail but the court issued an order that approval of his bail bond shall be made only after his arraignment.
a.) Did the court properly impose that bail condition? (3%)
Before arraignment, Oasis Jung’s lawyer moved to quash the other four separate informations for violation of the child abuse law invoking the single larceny rule.
b.) Should the motion to quash be granted? (2%)
c.) After his release from detention on bail, can Oasis Jung still question the validity of his arrest? (2%)

Quick check

Is prior arraignment a valid prerequisite for the approval of a bail bond under Rule 114?

Does the single larceny doctrine apply to multiple separate violations of R.A. No. 7610?

Can an accused who posts bail still challenge the legality of their warrantless arrest?

Why did the trial court err in ordering that approval of bail be made only after arraignment?

Choices available with full access.

What is the effect of committing paid sexual intercourse with a minor on five separate occasions?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Right to Bail
Under Rule 114 of the Rules of Court and the Constitution, the right to bail is a fundamental constitutional right available to any person in custody who is not charged with a capital offense where evidence of guilt is strong. Arraignment is not a prerequisite to the grant or approval of bail. Conditioning the approval of a bail bond upon prior arraignment effectively denies the accused their constitutional right to immediate provisional liberty. The trial court must promptly act upon an application for bail once the required bond is posted and approved, without awaiting arraignment.

2. Single Larceny Rule
The single larceny rule dictates that the taking of several properties belonging to different persons or the same person at the same time and place constitutes only a single offense of theft. This rule is strictly confined to crimes against property, specifically theft. It cannot be extended or applied to distinct sexual offenses or acts of child abuse under Republic Act No. 7610. Each act of paid sexual intercourse committed on five separate and distinct occasions constitutes an independent criminal intent and a separate violation of the law, justifying five individual informations.

3. Arrest Waiver Rule
Under Rule 114, Section 26 of the Rules of Court, posting bail no longer operates as a waiver of the right of an accused to question the validity of their arrest or the lack of preliminary investigation. An accused who posts bail and is released from custody retains the legal right to challenge the legality of the warrantless arrest, provided that the objection is raised before entering a plea during arraignment. Consequently, posting bail does not estop the accused from filing a motion to quash the information based on illegal arrest.

TopicsChild Abuse Law (R.A. 7610)1Legality of Arrest1Right to Bail1

2015 Remedial Law, Q13

Jaime was convicted for murder by the Regional Trial Court of Davao City in a decision promulgated on September 30, 2015. On October 5, 2015, Jaime filed a Motion for New Trial on the ground that errors of law and irregularities prejudicial to his rights were committed during his trial. On October 7, 2015, the private prosecutor, with the conformity of the public prosecutor, filed an Opposition to Jaime’s motion. On October 9, 2015, the court granted Jaime’s motion. On October 12, 2015, the public prosecutor filed a motion for reconsideration. The court issued an Order dated October 16, 2015 denying the public prosecutor’s motion for reconsideration. The public prosecutor received his copy of the order of denial on October 20, 2015 while the private prosecutor received his copy on October 26, 2015.
a.) What is the remedy available to the prosecution from the court’s order granting Jaime’s motion for new trial? (3%)
b.) In what court and within what period should a remedy be availed of? (1%)
c.) Who should pursue the remedy? (2%)

Quick check

What is the proper remedy for the prosecution against an order granting a motion for new trial in a criminal case?

From which date is the 60-day period for filing a petition for certiorari counted in this criminal case?

Who has exclusive legal authority to file a petition for certiorari on behalf of the People before the Court of Appeals?

In which court should the prosecution file the petition for certiorari challenging the order of the Davao City RTC?

Choices available with full access.

Why is an ordinary appeal unavailable to the prosecution against an order granting a new trial?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Interlocutory Order Remedy
Under Rule 65 of the Rules of Court, an order granting a motion for new trial in a criminal case is interlocutory in nature and not subject to an ordinary appeal. Because an appeal is unavailable, the proper remedy for the prosecution to challenge an order granting a new trial issued with grave abuse of discretion is a special civil action for certiorari. Certiorari serves to rectify jurisdictional errors or grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction committed by the trial court in granting a new trial.

2. Certiorari Filing Period
Under Rule 65, Section 4 of the Rules of Court, a petition for certiorari must be filed not later than sixty days from notice of the judgment, order, or resolution, or from notice of the denial of a timely motion for reconsideration. In criminal proceedings, notice to the public prosecutor who has direction and control of the prosecution constitutes legal notice to the State. Thus, the sixty-day period within which to file the petition before the Court of Appeals is reckoned from the date the public prosecutor receives the order.

3. Representation Authority OSG
Under the Administrative Code and settled jurisprudence, the Office of the Solicitor General possesses exclusive authority to represent the People of the Philippines in appeals and special civil actions brought before the Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court. While a private prosecutor may participate in trial proceedings under the control of the public prosecutor, the private prosecutor lacks legal personality to independently initiate appellate proceedings or file a petition for certiorari in criminal cases without the conformity and authority of the Solicitor General.

TopicsMotion for New Trial1OSG Representation Authority1Petition for Certiorari4

2015 Remedial Law, Q14

Pedro was charged with theft for stealing Juan’s cellphone worth P20,000.00. Prosecutor Marilag at the pre-trial submitted the judicial affidavit of Juan attaching the receipt for the purchase of the cellphone to prove civil liability. She also submitted the judicial affidavit of Mario, an eyewitness who narrated therein how Pedro stole Juan’s cellphone.
At the trial, Pedro’s lawyer objected to the prosecution’s use of judicial affidavits of her witnesses considering the imposable penalty on the offense with which his client was charged.
a.) Is Pedro’s lawyer correct in objecting to the judicial affidavit of Mario? (2%)
b.) Is Pedro’s lawyer correct in objecting to the judicial affidavit of Juan? (2%)
At the conclusion of the prosecution’s presentation of evidence, Prosecutor Marilag orally offered the receipt attached to Juan’s judicial affidavit, which the court admitted over the objection of Pedro’s lawyer.
After Pedro’s presentation of his evidence, the court rendered judgment finding him guilty as charged and holding him civilly liable for P20,000.00.
Pedro’s lawyer seasonably filed a motion for reconsideration of the decision asserting that the court erred in awarding the civil liability on the basis of Juan’s judicial affidavit, a documentary evidence which Prosecutor Marilag failed to orally offer.
c.) Is the motion for reconsideration meritorious? (2%)

Quick check

What is the applicability threshold of the Judicial Affidavit Rule in criminal prosecutions based on imposable penalty?

Does the Judicial Affidavit Rule apply to prove civil liability in criminal cases with penalties exceeding six years?

What is the legal classification of a judicial affidavit submitted in court proceedings?

How must documentary evidence attached to a judicial affidavit be offered to be considered by the trial court?

Choices available with full access.

Why was Pedro's motion for reconsideration regarding the civil liability award properly denied?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Judicial Affidavit Rule
Under Section 1 of the Judicial Affidavit Rule (A.M. No. 12-8-8-SC), judicial affidavits apply to all criminal actions where the maximum imposable penalty does not exceed six years. For theft of property valued at P20,000.00 under the Revised Penal Code, as amended by Republic Act No. 10951, the imposable penalty is arresto mayor to prision correccional, which does not exceed six years. Consequently, the prosecution's submission of a judicial affidavit for an eyewitness to establish criminal liability is procedurally valid and compliant with the rule.

2. Civil Aspect Evidence
Under Section 1(a)(1) of the Judicial Affidavit Rule, judicial affidavits apply to the civil aspect of any criminal action, regardless of the imposable penalty for the underlying offense. Even if a criminal offense carries a penalty exceeding six years, judicial affidavits remain fully permissible to establish civil liability and monetary damages. Therefore, submitting the victim's judicial affidavit to prove civil liability for the stolen cellphone is proper and immune to procedural objection.

3. Oral Formal Offer
A judicial affidavit serves as the direct testimony of a witness and constitutes testimonial evidence rather than documentary evidence. The documents attached to a judicial affidavit, such as a purchase receipt, retain their character as documentary exhibits. Under the Judicial Affidavit Rule and the Rules of Criminal Procedure, documentary evidence must be formally offered orally upon the termination of the presentation of evidence. When the prosecutor orally offers the attached receipt and the court admits it, civil liability is properly substantiated.

TopicsCivil Aspect of Offenses1Formal Offer of Evidence1Judicial Affidavit Rule2