Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2018 Bar Examinations

2018 Remedial Law, Q16

Danjo, a stay-in gardener at the Dy family home in Quezon City, applied for overseas employment in Riyadh as a flower arranger. After he left for abroad, Dino Dy, head of the family, discovered that all his wristwatches were missing. Dino followed Danjo’s lnstagram account and in one instance saw Danjo wearing his Rolex watch. He filed a complaint for qualified theft against Danjo with the Office of the Prosecutor (OP), Quezon City. The subpoena with the affidavit-complaint was served on Denden, Danjo’s wife, at their house. No counter-affidavit was filed by Danjo who continued to work in Riyadh. After conducting a preliminary investigation, the OP found probable cause against Danjo and subsequently filed the information for qualified theft before the RTC of Quezon City. The court likewise found probable cause and issued in 2016 a warrant for Danjo’s arrest.
Danjo was repatriated to the Philippines in 2018. While Danjo was lurking outside the Dys’ house, which was only about 100 meters away from the police station, SPO1 Dody recognized Danjo. Realizing that the police station had a copy of Danjo’s warrant of arrest, SPO1 Dody immediately pursued and arrested Danjo.
(a) Was the warrant of arrest issued against Danjo who was not in the Philippines valid? (2.5%)
(b) Can the warrant of arrest be served on Danjo upon his return? (2.5%)

Quick check

Is jurisdiction over the person of the accused required for the issuance of a valid warrant of arrest?

Does a warrant of arrest issued by a Philippine Regional Trial Court prescribe or become stale after ten days?

How is jurisdiction over the person of the accused acquired in criminal proceedings?

What is the legal effect of serving a preliminary investigation subpoena at the last known address of an OFW accused?

Choices available with full access.

When may a law enforcement officer serve an arrest warrant issued two years prior against a repatriated accused?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Arrest Warrant Validity
Under the Rules of Criminal Procedure, jurisdiction over the person of the accused is not a requirement for the valid conduct of a preliminary investigation or the judicial issuance of a warrant of arrest. As long as subpoena was validly served at the last known residence of the accused in the Philippines, the investigating prosecutor may find probable cause and file the criminal information. Upon filing, the trial court judge may independently evaluate the prosecutor's resolution and issue a valid warrant of arrest notwithstanding the temporary absence of the accused from the country.

2. Lifetime of Warrant
Under Rule 113, Section 4 of the Rules of Court, a warrant of arrest does not prescribe or become stale over time. Unlike a search warrant, which has a strict statutory validity period of ten days, a warrant of arrest remains active and enforceable indefinitely until it is fully executed by arresting the accused, or until it is formally recalled or quashed by the issuing court. Consequently, law enforcement officers possess full legal authority to execute an outstanding warrant of arrest whenever the returning accused is located within Philippine jurisdiction.

3. Jurisdiction Over Accused
Jurisdiction over the person of the accused is acquired either by his voluntary appearance or by his arrest pursuant to a lawful warrant. While a trial court cannot proceed to arraignment and trial in absentia without first acquiring jurisdiction over the person of the accused, the lack of personal jurisdiction does not invalidate the preliminary investigation, the criminal information, or the warrant of arrest itself. Once the accused returns to the country and is apprehended by police officers, jurisdiction over his person attaches, enabling the trial court to proceed with arraignment.

TopicsPreliminary Investigation Jurisdiction1Rule 113 Rules of Court1Warrant of Arrest Validity1

2018 Remedial Law, Q17

Don Deles, a contractor, was sued together with Mayor Dante Dungo and Congressman Dal Dilim for malversation of public funds before the Office of the Ombudsman. Danny Din, a material witness of the complainant Diego Domingo, was hired as an engineer by a construction company in Qatar, and had to depart in two (2) months. To perpetuate Danny Din’s testimony, Diego Domingo applied for his conditional examination before the Sandiganbayan.
Should the application for conditional examination of Danny Din be granted? (2.5%)

Quick check

When may a prosecution witness be conditionally examined under Rule 119, Section 15 of the Rules of Court?

What is a required ground for the conditional examination of a prosecution witness under Rule 119?

Why is an application for conditional examination before the Sandiganbayan premature during preliminary investigation?

Under Rule 119, Section 15, which entity conducts the preliminary investigation for Ombudsman cases?

Choices available with full access.

What must the Sandiganbayan do with an application for conditional examination filed before the criminal information is lodged?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Examination Requirements
Under Rule 119, Section 15 of the Revised Rules of Criminal Procedure, the conditional examination of a prosecution witness may be taken only before the court where the criminal case is currently pending. For a witness about to leave the Philippines without a definite date of returning, the application must be made to the trial court having jurisdiction over the case. Where no criminal information has been filed in court and the case remains at the preliminary investigation stage, the trial court lacks jurisdiction to order or conduct a conditional examination.

2. No Pending Case
The jurisdiction of a court to entertain provisional remedies or procedural applications in criminal cases attaches only upon the formal filing of the criminal information. During the preliminary investigation phase conducted by the Office of the Ombudsman, no court has acquired jurisdiction over the subject matter or the criminal action. Consequently, an application filed before the Sandiganbayan to perpetuate or conditionally examine a witness before information is filed is premature and must be denied for lack of jurisdiction over the case.

3. Prosecution Witness Deposition
Rule 119, Section 15 provides a specific procedure for perpetuating prosecution testimony when a material witness is too sick or infirm, or must depart from the Philippines with no definite return date. Unlike depositions in civil cases under Rule 23, conditional examination of a prosecution witness in criminal proceedings requires a pending criminal action before a trial court. The prosecution cannot utilize conditional examination before the Sandiganbayan while the case is still under preliminary investigation by the Ombudsman.

TopicsConditional Examination of Witness1Rule 119 Rules of Court1Sandiganbayan Jurisdiction4

2018 Remedial Law, Q18

The Republic of the Philippines (Republic) filed a complaint with the Sandiganbayan in connection with the sequestered assets and properties of Demo Companies Inc. (Demo) and impleaded its officers and directors. Since the complaint did not include Demo as defendant, the Sandiganbayan issued a Resolution where it ordered Demo to be impleaded. Thereafter, the Republic filed an amended complaint naming Demo as additional defendant, which amendment was later admitted.
Demo filed a motion for bill of particulars for the Republic to clarify certain matters in its amended complaint. The Sandiganbayan immediately granted the motion. Upon submission of the bill of particulars by the Republic, Demo filed a motion to dismiss arguing that the answers in the bill of particulars were indefinite and deficient responses to the question of what the alleged illegally acquired funds or properties of Demo were. The Sandiganbayan dismissed the case.
(a) Was the Sandiganbayan correct in dismissing the case? (2.5%)
(b) What can the defendant, in a civil case, do in the event that his motion for bill of particulars is denied? (2.5%)

Quick check

What is the legal consequence under Rule 12, Section 4 if a plaintiff insufficiently complies with an order for a bill of particulars?

Upon service of an order denying a motion for a bill of particulars, what is the reglementary period for the defendant to file an answer?

What extraordinary remedy is available to a defendant if the denial of his motion for a bill of particulars is tainted with grave abuse of discretion?

Under Rule 12, Section 1, what is the primary purpose of filing a motion for a bill of particulars?

Choices available with full access.

How does a bill of particulars affect the original pleading it seeks to clarify or amplify?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Bill of Particulars
Under Rule 12 of the Rules of Court, a party may move for a bill of particulars to enable him properly to prepare his responsive pleading or to prepare for trial. A bill of particulars becomes part of the pleading it amends. If the order directing the submission of a bill of particulars is not obeyed, or is obeyed insufficiently, the court may order the striking out of the pleading or the portions thereof to which the order was directed, or make such other order as it deems just, including dismissal of the action.

2. Dismissal for Non-Compliance
Under Rule 17, Section 3 in relation to Rule 12, Section 4 of the Rules of Court, failure to comply with a lawful court order requiring a sufficient bill of particulars justifies the dismissal of the complaint. When a party fails to sufficiently clarify indefinite and vague allegations despite a direct judicial order, the court possesses inherent power to dismiss the action. Such dismissal operates as an adjudication upon the merits unless otherwise provided by the court in its order of dismissal.

3. Remedies Upon Denial
Under Rule 12, Section 5 of the Rules of Court, if a motion for a bill of particulars is denied, the moving party must file his responsive pleading within the remaining period to which he was entitled at the time of filing his motion, which shall not be less than five days in any event. If the order denying the motion for a bill of particulars is tainted with grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction, the defendant may file a special civil action for certiorari under Rule 65.

TopicsBill of Particulars1Motion to Dismiss4Rule 12 Rules of Court1

2018 Remedial Law, Q19

Drylvik, a German national, married Dara, a Filipina, in Dusseldorf, Germany. When the marriage collapsed, Dara filed a petition for declaration of nullity of marriage before the RTC of Manila. Drylvik, on the other hand, was able to obtain a divorce decree from the German Family Court. The decree, in essence, states:
The marriage of the Parties contracted on xxx before the Civil Registrar of Dusseldorf is hereby dissolved. The parental custody of the children Diktor and Daus is granted to the father.
Drylvik filed a motion to dismiss in the RTC of Manila on the ground that the court no longer had jurisdiction over the matter as a decree of divorce had already been promulgated dissolving his marriage to Dara. Dara objected, saying that while she was not challenging the divorce decree, the case in the RTC still had to proceed for the purpose of determining the issue of the children’s custody. Drylvik counters that the issue had been disposed of in the divorce decree, thus constituting res judicata.
(a) Should Drylvik’s motion to dismiss be granted? (2.5%)
(b) Is a foreign divorce decree between a foreign spouse and a Filipino spouse, uncontested by both parties, sufficient by itself to cancel the entry in the civil registry pertaining to the spouses’ marriage? (2.5%)

Quick check

Does a foreign divorce decree automatically operate as res judicata in Philippine courts?

What is required before a foreign divorce decree can affect a civil registry entry in the Philippines?

Under Section 48(b) of Rule 39, what is the evidentiary effect of a foreign judgment against a person?

How must foreign laws and foreign divorce decrees be established in Philippine judicial proceedings?

Choices available with full access.

Why is an uncontested foreign divorce decree insufficient by itself to cancel a marriage record?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Foreign Judgment Recognition
Under Rule 39, Section 48(b) of the Rules of Court, a judgment or final order of a foreign court against a person creates merely a presumptive evidence of a right as between the parties and their successors in interest. Philippine courts do not take judicial notice of foreign judgments or foreign laws. Consequently, a foreign divorce decree cannot automatically operate as res judicata or be enforced in the Philippines without being first formally pleaded, proved as a fact under the Rules of Evidence, and judicially recognized by a competent Philippine trial court.

2. Res Judicata Defense
For a foreign divorce judgment to be validly invoked as res judicata in a pending domestic action, the party pleading it must establish that the foreign court had jurisdiction, that the judgment is final and valid under the foreign law, and that the foreign law itself was properly proven in evidence. Until a competent Philippine court issues a judicial decree recognizing the foreign divorce judgment, the foreign decree produces no legal effect in Philippine jurisdiction and cannot serve as a ground for dismissing a domestic petition under the principle of res judicata.

3. Civil Registry Cancellation
Under Rule 108 of the Rules of Court, a foreign divorce decree obtained by a foreign spouse is not self-executing and cannot by itself authorize the Civil Registrar to cancel or annotate the marriage entry. To cancel or amend an entry in the civil registry, the interested party must file a verified petition for judicial recognition of the foreign divorce under Rule 108. In this proceeding, both the foreign divorce decree and the national law of the foreign spouse permitting divorce must be presented and proven as facts.

TopicsForeign Divorce Recognition3Rule 108 Cancellation of Entry2Rule 39 Rules of Court1

2018 Remedial Law, Q20

Dominic was appointed special administrator of the Estate of Dakota Dragon. Delton, husband of Dakota, together with their five (5) children, opposed the appointment of Dominic claiming that he (Dominic) was just a stepbrother of Dakota. After giving Dominic the chance to comment, the court issued an Order affirming the appointment of Dominic.
(a) What is the remedy available to the oppositors? (2.5%)
(b) If there are no qualified heirs, can the government initiate escheat proceedings over the assets of the deceased? To whom, in particular, shall the estate of the deceased go and for whose benefit? (2.5%)

Quick check

What is the proper remedy to challenge an order appointing or affirming a special administrator?

Why is an order appointing a special administrator non-appealable under Rule 109?

Who is authorized to initiate escheat proceedings on behalf of the government under Rule 91?

Where is escheated real property assigned under Rule 91, Section 3 of the Rules of Court?

Choices available with full access.

For whose benefit shall escheated properties be held and used by the recipient municipality or city?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Special Administrator Order
Under Rule 109, Section 1 and Rule 80, Section 1 of the Rules of Court, an order appointing a special administrator is interlocutory in nature and non-appealable. Because no appeal may be taken from an interlocutory order, the proper procedural remedy available to an aggrieved party is a special civil action for certiorari under Rule 65 on the ground of grave abuse of discretion.

2. Escheat Proceedings
Under Rule 91, Section 1 of the Rules of Court, when a person dies intestate leaving seized real or personal property in the Philippines and leaving no heir or person entitled to the same by law, the Solicitor General or his representative may file a petition for escheat in the Regional Trial Court. Escheat is a special proceeding whereby the State claims the estate of a deceased person who leaves no valid heirs.

3. Escheated Property Allocation
Under Rule 91, Section 3 of the Rules of Court, escheated personal property is assigned to the municipality or city where the deceased last resided, while real property is assigned to the municipality or city in which it is situated. The escheated estate shall be held and used for the benefit of public schools and charitable institutions or centers in the respective local government units.

TopicsEscheat Proceedings1Rule 109 Rules of Court1Special Administrator1