Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2012 Bar Examinations

2012 Remedial Law, Q8

A sues B for collection of a sum of money. Alleging fraud in the contracting of the loan, A applies for preliminary attachment with the court. The Court issues the preliminary attachment after A files a bond. While summons on B was yet unserved, the sheriff attached B’s properties. Afterwards, summons was duly served on B. 8 moves to lift the attachment. Rule on this. (5%)
Discuss the three (3) Stages of Court Diversion in connection with Alternative Dispute Resolution. (5%)

Quick check

What is required under Rule 57 for a writ of preliminary attachment to be validly enforced against a defendant's property?

What is the legal effect of a sheriff levying on a defendant's property under preliminary attachment before serving summons?

What is the first stage of Court Diversion in Philippine Alternative Dispute Resolution?

Who acts as the mediator-conciliator during the Judicial Dispute Resolution (JDR) stage of court diversion?

Choices available with full access.

What procedural remedy should a defendant pursue when preliminary attachment is enforced prior to service of summons?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Preliminary Attachment Enforcement
Under Rule 57, Section 5 of the Rules of Court, no levy on preliminary attachment shall be enforced unless preceded or contemporaneously accompanied by service of summons on the defendant. Although a court acquires jurisdiction over the main action upon filing of the complaint and payment of legal fees, it cannot enforce a writ of preliminary attachment without prior or contemporaneous service of summons. A levy made prior to service of summons is void and legally ineffective, and subsequent service of summons does not retroactively cure the defect.

2. Court Diversion Stages
Court Diversion under the Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) framework in the Philippines proceeds through three distinct stages designed to encourage out-of-court settlements. The first stage is Court-Annexed Mediation (CAM), conducted by accredited mediators of the Philippine Mediation Center. If CAM fails, the case enters Judicial Dispute Resolution (JDR), where the trial judge acts as a mediator-conciliator. If JDR is unsuccessful, the case proceeds to trial before another judge, and if appealed, it enters Court-Appealed Mediation at the appellate level.

3. Enforceability of Attachment
The requirement of prior or contemporaneous service of summons protects the constitutional right to due process of the property owner. Because preliminary attachment is a harsh and extraordinary provisional remedy, strict compliance with statutory procedure is required. Where a sheriff attaches properties before serving summons on the defendant, the attachment is void ab initio. The proper procedural remedy for the aggrieved defendant is to file a motion to discharge or lift the attachment based on the illegal enforcement.

TopicsContemporaneous Service of Summons2Court Diversion Stages1Preliminary Attachment Rules1

2012 Remedial Law, Q9

X, an undersecretary of DENR, was charged before the Sandiganbayan for malversation of public funds allegedly committed when he was still the Mayor of a town in Rizal. After arraignment, the prosecution moved that X be preventively suspended. X opposed the motion arguing that he was now occupying a position different from that which the Information charged him and therefore, there is no more possibility that he can intimidate witnesses and hamper the prosecution. Decide. Suppose X files a Motion to Quash challenging the validity of the Information and the Sandiganbayan denies the same, will there still be a need to conduct a pre-suspension hearing? Explain. (5%)
Briefly discuss/differentiate the following kinds of Attachment:
preliminary attachment, garnishment, levy on execution, warrant of seizure and warrant of distraint and levy. (5%)

Quick check

Under Section 13 of R.A. 3019, when is preventive suspension mandatory for an incumbent public officer?

Why is a separate pre-suspension hearing unnecessary after the court denies an accused officer's Motion to Quash?

What distinguishes garnishment from an ordinary levy on real property?

What is the specific legal purpose of a warrant of distraint and levy?

Choices available with full access.

Which writ is issued at the commencement of an action to secure a debtor's property for potential judgment satisfaction?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Preventive Suspension Rules
Under Section 13 of Republic Act No. 3019, preventive suspension is mandatory for any incumbent public officer facing a valid Information involving fraud, malversation, or corrupt practices. The statutory purpose of preventive suspension is to prevent the officer from hampering prosecution, tampering with evidence, or committing further acts of misconduct. Jurisprudence establishes that preventive suspension applies regardless of whether the accused public officer now holds a different office or position from the one occupied when the alleged offense was committed, provided the officer remains in public service during the pendency of the criminal proceedings.

2. Pre-Suspension Hearing
A pre-suspension hearing is required before issuing a preventive suspension order to afford the accused public officer due process and an opportunity to challenge the validity of the Information. However, where the accused files a Motion to Quash challenging the validity of the Information and the trial court or Sandiganbayan formally hears and denies the motion, the requirement of a pre-suspension hearing is fully satisfied. The judicial determination upholding the Information's validity during the motion to quash proceedings obviates the need for conducting a redundant pre-suspension hearing.

3. Modes of Attachment
Different modes of attachment serve distinct legal procedures. Preliminary attachment is a provisional remedy issued at the inception of litigation to secure potential judgments against a debtor's property. Garnishment is a species of attachment targeting credits, debts, or bank deposits owed by a third party to the defendant. Levy on execution enforces a final and executory judgment by seizing property to satisfy a court award. Warrants of seizure confiscate contraband or instrumentalities of crime in criminal procedure, while warrants of distraint and levy are administrative remedies utilized to collect delinquent taxes.

TopicsAnti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act7Attachment and Execution Modes1Preventive Suspension Rules1

2012 Remedial Law, Q10

Where and how will you appeal the following:
(1) An order of execution issued by the RTC. (1%)
(2) Judgment of RTC denying a petition for Writ of Amparo. (1%)
(3) Judgment of MTC on a land registration case based on its delegated jurisdiction. (1%)
(4) A decision of the Court of Tax Appeal’s First Division. (1%)
A files a Complaint against 8 for recovery of title and possession of land situated in Makati with the RTC of Pasig. B files a Motion to Dismiss for improper venue. The RTC Pasig Judge denies B’s Motion to Dismiss, which obviously was incorrect. Alleging that the RTC Judge “unlawfully neglected the performance of an act which the law specifically enjoins as a duty resulting from an office”, 8 files a Petition for Mandamus against the judge. Will Mandamus lie? Reasons. (3%)
What are the jurisdictional facts that must be alleged in a petition for probate of a will? How do you bring before the court these jurisdictional facts? (3%)

Quick check

How is a judgment of a Municipal Trial Court in a land registration case under its delegated jurisdiction appealed?

What is the proper judicial remedy to appeal an RTC judgment denying a petition for Writ of Amparo?

Why will a petition for mandamus NOT lie to challenge a judge's erroneous denial of a motion to dismiss?

What is the proper procedure to appeal a decision rendered by the First Division of the Court of Tax Appeals?

Choices available with full access.

How are jurisdictional facts brought before the court in a petition for probate of a will?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Appellate Remedies
Under Philippine procedural rules, judicial decisions must be appealed through specific statutory channels. An order of execution issued by the Regional Trial Court is interlocutory and reviewable via certiorari under Rule 65. Judgments denying a Writ of Amparo are appealable directly to the Supreme Court under Rule 45 on questions of law and fact. MTC judgments in land registration cases under delegated jurisdiction appeal to the Court of Appeals under Rule 41. Finally, decisions of a Court of Tax Appeals Division must be appealed to the CTA En Banc.

2. Mandamus Restrictions
Mandamus is an extraordinary writ issued to compel the performance of a purely ministerial duty enjoined by law. It does not lie to control or review discretionary judicial rulings, such as the denial of a motion to dismiss based on improper venue. Ruling on a motion to dismiss involves the exercise of judicial discretion rather than a ministerial duty. Where a judge erroneously denies a motion to dismiss, the proper remedy is a petition for certiorari under Rule 65 alleging grave abuse of discretion, rather than a petition for mandamus.

3. Probate Jurisdictional Facts
In a petition for probate of a will, the jurisdictional facts that must be alleged in the verified petition are the death of the testator, his residence at the time of death or the location of his estate if a non-resident, and the gross value of the estate. These jurisdictional facts are brought before the court by filing the verified petition containing these allegations and by publishing the order fixing the time and place for proving the will in a newspaper of general circulation, alongside serving notice to known heirs and legatees.

TopicsAppellate Remedies1Mandamus Restrictions1Probate Jurisdictional Facts1

2010 Bar Examinations

2010 Remedial Law, Q1

On March 12, 2008, Mabini was charged with Murder for fatally stabbing Emilio.
To prove the qualifying circumstance of evident premeditation, the prosecution introduced on December 11, 2009 a text message, which Mabini’s estranged wife Gregoria had sent to Emilio on the eve of his death, reading: “Honey, pa2tayin u ni Mabini. Mtgal n nyang plano i2. Mg ingat u bka ma tsugi k.”
a. A subpoena ad testificandum was served on Gregoria for her to be presented for the purpose of identifying her cellphone and the text message. Mabini objected to her presentation on the ground of marital privilege. Resolve. (3%)
b. Suppose Mabini’s objection in question A was sustained. The prosecution thereupon announced that it would be presenting Emilio’s wife Graciana to identify Emilio’s cellphone bearing Gregoria’s text message. Mabini objected again. Rule on the objection. (2%)
c. If Mabini’s objection in question B was overruled, can he object to the presentation of the text message on the ground that it is hearsay? (2%)
d. Suppose that shortly before he expired, Emilio was able to send a text message to his wife Graciana reading “Nasaksak ako. D na me makahinga. Si Mabini ang may gawa ni2.” Is this text message admissible as a dying declaration? Explain. (3%)

Quick check

What is the legal effect of the spousal disqualification rule under Rule 130 of the Rules of Court?

Who may validly identify and authenticate a text message as electronic evidence under the Rules on Electronic Evidence?

Why is an out-of-court text message sent by a third party inadmissible to prove the truth of its contents?

Which of the following is a requisite for a statement to be admissible as a dying declaration?

How does the spousal disqualification rule affect the admissibility of a text message presented through a third party?

Learn more about these topics

1. Marital Disqualification Rule
Under Section 23, Rule 130 of the Rules of Court, a husband or wife cannot testify against the other spouse during marriage without the consent of the affected spouse, except in a civil case by one against the other or in a criminal case for a crime committed by one against the other or the latter's direct descendants or ascendants. This privilege applies strictly to spousal testimony in court. However, non-spousal third parties are not barred from testifying or presenting physical or electronic evidence obtained from independent sources.

2. Electronic Evidence Rules
Under the Rules on Electronic Evidence, an electronic message or text message is functional as documentary evidence if authenticated by a witness who either authored it, received it, or observed its receipt. A third-party witness who lawfully possesses a mobile device containing a text message may testify to authenticate the receipt and contents of that electronic communication. While authentication permits the introduction of the electronic document, its ultimate admissibility remains subject to general exclusionary rules of evidence, including hearsay and spousal privilege.

3. Dying Declaration Exception
Under Section 38, Rule 130 of the Rules of Court, a statement made by a dying person under the consciousness of impending death is admissible as evidence in a criminal case where the declarant's death is the subject of inquiry. To qualify as an admissible dying declaration, the statement must concern the cause and surrounding circumstances of the declarant's impending death, and the declarant must have been competent as a witness had he survived. A text message sent by a fatally injured victim immediately prior to expiring satisfies these requirements.

TopicsDying Declaration Exceptions1Marital Disqualification Rule4Rules on Electronic Evidence5

2010 Remedial Law, Q2

On August 13, 2008, A, as shipper and consignee, loaded on the M/V Atlantis in Legaspi City 100,000 pieces of century eggs. The shipment arrived in Manila totally damaged on August 14, 2008. A filed before the Metropolitan Trial Court (MeTC) of Manila a complaint against B Super Lines, Inc. (B Lines), owner of the M/V Atlantis, for recovery of damages amounting to ₱167,899. He attached to the complaint the Bill of Lading.
a. B Lines filed a Motion to Dismiss upon the ground that the Regional Trial Court has exclusive original jurisdiction over “all actions in admiralty and maritime” claims. In his Reply, A contended that while the action is indeed “admiralty and maritime” in nature, it is the amount of the claim, not the nature of the action, that governs jurisdiction. Pass on the Motion to Dismiss. (3%)
b. The MeTC denied the Motion in question A. B Lines thus filed an Answer raising the defense that under the Bill of Lading it issued to A, its liability was limited to ₱10,000.
At the pre-trial conference, B Lines defined as one of the issues whether the stipulation limiting its liability to ₱10,000 binds A. A countered that this was no longer in issue as B Lines had failed to deny under oath the Bill of Lading. Which of the parties is correct? Explain. (3%)
c. On July 21, 2009, B Lines served on A a “Notice to Take Deposition,” setting the deposition on July 29, 2009 at 8:30 a.m. at the office of its counsel in Makati. A failed to appear at the deposition-taking, despite notice. As counsel for B Lines, how would you proceed? (3%)

Quick check

How is jurisdiction over admiralty and maritime claims determined under Batas Pambansa Blg. 129?

What is deemed admitted when a party fails to specifically deny an actionable document under oath under Rule 8?

Which court has exclusive original jurisdiction over an admiralty claim for damages amounting to ₱167,899 filed in Metro Manila?

What procedural sanction may the court impose under Rule 29 if a plaintiff willfully fails to appear for a deposition after proper notice?

What does an implied admission of 'genuineness and due execution' of a bill of lading mean under the Rules of Court?

Learn more about these topics

1. Admiralty Jurisdiction
Under Batas Pambansa Blg. 129, as amended, jurisdiction over admiralty and maritime actions is determined by the total amount of the claim. If the claim does not exceed the jurisdictional threshold for Regional Trial Courts, exclusive original jurisdiction belongs to the first-level courts, such as the Metropolitan Trial Courts. Consequently, when a claim for damages arising from sea freight carriage falls below the statutory threshold, the Municipal Trial Court or Metropolitan Trial Court properly retains jurisdiction over the admiralty action regardless of its maritime nature.

2. Actionable Documents Rule
Under Section 8, Rule 8 of the Rules of Court, when an action or defense is founded upon a written instrument attached to the pleading, its genuineness and due execution are deemed admitted unless specifically denied under oath. However, an implied admission by failure to deny under oath extends only to the authenticity and execution of the document, such as the signatures and delivery. It does not admit the legal conclusions, terms, or validity of specific stipulations, such as liability limitation clauses contained within the instrument.

3. Deposition Sanctions
Under Section 5, Rule 29 of the Rules of Court, if a party willfully fails to appear before the officer who is to take his deposition after being served with proper notice, the court on motion may strike out all or any part of any pleading of that party, dismiss the action or proceeding or any part thereof, or enter a judgment by default against that party. This discovery sanction enforces compliance with deposition procedures and prevents a non-compliant party from delaying litigation without legal justification.

TopicsActionable Documents Rule1Admiralty Jurisdiction1Refusal to Attend Deposition1