Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2015 Bar Examinations

2015 Remedial Law, Q15

Water Builders, a construction company based in Makati City, entered into a construction agreement with Super Powers, Inc., an energy company based in
Manila, for the construction of a mini hydro electric plant. Water Builders failed to complete the project within the stipulated duration. Super Powers cancelled the contract. Water Builders filed a request for arbitration with the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission (CIAC). After due proceedings, CIAC rendered judgment in favor of Super Powers, Inc. ordering Water Builders to pay the former P10 million, the full amount of the down payment paid, and P2 million by way of liquidated damages. Dissatisfied with the CIAC’s judgment, Water Builders, pursuant to the Special Rules of Court on Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR Rules) filed with the RTC of Pasay City a petition to vacate the arbitral award. Super Powers, Inc., in its opposition, moved to dismiss the petition, invoking the ADR Rules, on the ground of improper venue as neither of the parties were doing business in Pasay City.
Should Water Builders’ petition be dismissed? (3%)

Quick check

Where should a petition to vacate a domestic arbitral award be filed under the Special ADR Rules?

Which judicial body has appellate jurisdiction to review or set aside arbitral awards rendered by the CIAC?

Do Regional Trial Courts have jurisdiction to vacate arbitral awards issued by the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission?

What is the proper procedural ground for dismissing Water Builders' petition filed in the RTC of Pasay City?

Choices available with full access.

Under Executive Order No 1008, what type of disputes fall under the original and exclusive jurisdiction of the CIAC?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Domestic Arbitration Venue
Under Rule 11 of the Special Rules of Court on Alternative Dispute Resolution, a petition to vacate a domestic arbitral award must be filed in the Regional Trial Court where any of the parties resides, has its principal place of business, or where the arbitration proceedings were conducted. Filing the petition in a court where neither party resides or conducts business, and where arbitration did not take place, constitutes improper venue. Venue in special ADR proceedings is procedural and designed to ensure proper territorial connection.

2. CIAC Arbitral Jurisdiction
Under Executive Order No 1008 and prevailing jurisprudence, arbitral awards rendered by the Construction Industry Arbitration Commission are appealable directly to the Court of Appeals under Rule 43 of the Rules of Court on questions of fact, law, or mixed questions. Regional Trial Courts do not possess judicial authority or jurisdiction to review, vacate, or modify CIAC arbitral awards under the Special ADR Rules. Resorting to the Regional Trial Court to vacate a CIAC award is procedurally infirm.

3. Dismissal of Petition
A petition to vacate an arbitral award filed in the wrong forum suffers from fatal procedural and jurisdictional defects. When a party files a petition to vacate a CIAC award before a Regional Trial Court that also lacks territorial venue, the petition is subject to immediate dismissal upon proper motion. Objections based on improper venue under the Special ADR Rules and lack of subject matter jurisdiction over CIAC awards compel the court to dismiss the petition, directing the party to pursue the appropriate appellate remedy.

TopicsCIAC Arbitral Award1Special ADR Rules1Venue and Jurisdiction1

2015 Remedial Law, Q16

AA, a twelve-year-old girl, while walking alone met BB, a teenage boy who befriended her. Later, BB brought AA to a nearby shanty where he raped her. The Information for rape filed against BB states:
“On or about October 30, 2015, in the City of S.P. and within the jurisdiction of this Honorable Court, the accused, a minor, fifteen (15) years old with lewd design and by means of force, violence and intimidation, did then and there, willfully, unlawfully and feloniously had sexual intercourse with AA, a minor, twelve (12) years old against the latter’s will and consent.”
At the trial, the prosecutor called to the witness stand AA as his first witness and manifested that he be allowed to ask leading questions in conducting his direct examination pursuant to the Rule on the Examination of a Child Witness. BB’s counsel objected on the ground that the prosecutor has not conducted a competency examination on the witness, a requirement before the rule cited can be applied in the case.
a.) Is BB’s counsel correct? (3%)
In order to obviate the counsel’s argument on the competency of AA as prosecution witness, the judge motu proprio conducted his voir dire examination on AA.
b.) Was the action taken by the judge proper? (2%)
After the prosecution had rested its case, BB’ s counsel filed with leave a demurrer to evidence, seeking the dismissal of the case on the ground that the prosecutor failed to present any evidence on BB’ s minority as alleged in the Information.
c.) Should the court grant the demurrer? (3%)

Quick check

What is the legal presumption regarding a child witness under the Rule on Examination of a Child Witness?

When is a competency examination of a child witness required under the rules?

Is a trial judge authorized to motu proprio conduct a voir dire examination on a child witness?

On what ground may a court grant a demurrer to evidence in a criminal prosecution?

Choices available with full access.

Is the minority of the accused an essential element of the crime of rape?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Child Witness Presumption
Under the Rule on Examination of a Child Witness (A.M. No. 00-4-07-SC), every child is presumed qualified to be a witness. Prior competency examination is not a prerequisite before the prosecutor may conduct direct examination or ask leading questions. A competency examination is conducted only when the court finds that substantial doubt exists regarding the child's capacity to perceive, remember, communicate, distinguish truth from falsehood, or appreciate the duty to tell the truth. Hence, objecting to a child witness's testimony without demonstrating such doubt is legally baseless.

2. Judicial Voir Dire
The trial court possesses inherent power and discretion to motu proprio conduct a voir dire examination to evaluate the competency of a child witness. While a child is presumed competent under the rules, the judge may evaluate the witness at any stage of the proceedings to satisfy judicial inquiry regarding capacity and truthfulness. Conducting a voir dire examination motu proprio ensures the protection of the child witness while safeguarding the integrity of the trial proceedings, making the judge's action entirely proper and within judicial authority.

3. Demurrer in Rape
Under Rule 119, Section 23 of the Rules of Criminal Procedure, a demurrer to evidence is granted only when the prosecution's evidence fails to show sufficient proof to sustain a conviction for the offense charged. In a prosecution for rape, the minority of the accused is not an essential element of the crime, but a matter pertaining to juvenile delinquency law or penalty modification. Failure to present independent proof of the accused's minority does not warrant the dismissal of the rape charge upon a demurrer to evidence.

TopicsChild Witness Competency2Demurrer to Evidence7Voir Dire Examination1

2015 Remedial Law, Q17

Hercules was walking near a police station when a police officer signaled for him to approach. As soon as Hercules came near, the police officer frisked him but the latter found no contraband. The police officer told Hercules to get inside the police station. Inside the police station, Hercules asked the police officer, “Sir, may problema po ba?” Instead of replying, the police officer locked up Hercules inside the police station jail.
a.) What is the remedy available to Hercules to secure his immediate release from detention? (2%)
b.) If Hercules filed with the Ombudsman a complaint for warrantless search, as counsel for the police officer, what defense will you raise for the dismissal of the complaint? (3%)
c.) If Hercules opts to file a civil action against the police officer, will he have a cause of action? (3%)

Quick check

What is the primary legal remedy to secure the immediate release of a person illegally detained without a warrant?

Under what doctrine may a police officer conduct a limited protective search of a citizen without a warrant?

Under Article 32 of the Civil Code, what is required to establish a cause of action against an officer for violating constitutional rights?

Why is a petition for habeas corpus proper for Hercules in this scenario?

Choices available with full access.

What defense may a police officer raise against an administrative complaint for conducting a warrantless frisk?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Habeas Corpus Remedy
Under Rule 102 of the Rules of Court, the writ of habeas corpus extends to all cases of illegal confinement or detention by which any person is deprived of personal liberty. Where an individual is restrained without a valid warrant of arrest, judicial commitment order, or pending criminal charge, detention is illegal. The petition for a writ of habeas corpus is the primary, direct, and expeditious remedy to compel the detaining officer to produce the person in court and justify the legal restraint, failing which the court will order immediate release.

2. Stop and Frisk
Under constitutional law and criminal procedure, a stop-and-frisk search is a recognized exception to the warrant requirement, permitting a police officer to conduct a limited protective search for weapons. To be valid, the search must be prompted by genuine reasonable suspicion based on specific and articulable facts, rather than mere suspicion or rumor. In administrative proceedings against an officer, demonstrating reasonable suspicion and reliance on the presumption of regularity in the performance of official functions serves as a defense to charges of illegal search.

3. Civil Action Rights
Under Article 32 of the Civil Code of the Philippines, any public officer or employee who directly or indirectly obstructs, defeats, violates, or impairs any constitutional right of a citizen, such as freedom from unreasonable search or arbitrary detention, is civilly liable for damages. This independent civil action requires no proof of malice or bad faith, establishing a cause of action against officers who detain citizens without legal cause or conduct unlawful searches, thereby ensuring accountability for civil rights violations.

TopicsAction for Damages (Article 32)1Stop and Frisk Search2Writ of Habeas Corpus3

2015 Remedial Law, Q18

The residents of Mt. Ahohoy, headed by Masigasig, formed a nongovernmental organization – Alyansa Laban sa Minahan sa Ahohoy (ALMA) to protest the mining operations of Oro Negro Mining in the mountain. ALMA members picketed daily at the entrance of the mining site blocking the ingress and egress of trucks and equipment of Oro Negro, hampering its operations. Masigasig had an altercation with Mapusok arising from the complaint of the mining engineer of Oro Negro that one of their trucks was destroyed by ALMA members. Mapusok is the leader of the Association of Peace Keepers of Ahohoy (APKA), a civilian volunteer organization serving as auxiliary force of the local police to maintain peace and order in the area. Subsequently, Masigasig disappeared. Mayumi, the wife of Masigasig, and the members of ALMA searched for Masigasig, but all their efforts proved futile. Mapagmatyag, a member of ALMA, learned from Maingay, a member of APKA, during their binge drinking that Masigasig was abducted by other members of APKA, on order of Mapusok. Mayumi and ALMA sought the assistance of the local police to search for Masigasig, but they refused to extend their cooperation.
Immediately, Mayumi filed with the RTC, a petition for the issuance of the writ of amparo against Mapusok and APKA. ALMA also filed a petition for the issuance of the writ of amparo with the Court of Appeals against Mapusok and APKA. Respondents Mapusok and APKA, in their Return filed with the RTC, raised among their defenses that they are not agents of the State; hence, cannot be impleaded as respondents in an amparo petition.
a.) Is their defense tenable? (3%)
Respondents Mapusok and APKA, in their Return filed with the Court of Appeals, raised as their defense that the petition should be dismissed on the ground that ALMA cannot file the petition because of the earlier petition filed by Mayumi with the RTC.
b.) Are respondents correct in raising their defense? (3%)
c.) Mayumi later filed separate criminal and civil actions against Mapusok. How will the cases affect the amparo petition she earlier filed? (1%)

Quick check

Does the Writ of Amparo apply to threats or violations committed by private individuals and non-state entities?

What is the order of preference in filing a petition for a Writ of Amparo if the victim disappeared?

What happens to a pending petition for the Writ of Amparo when a criminal action is subsequently filed against the respondent?

Why is ALMA's separate petition for a Writ of Amparo before the Court of Appeals subject to dismissal?

Choices available with full access.

Which court has territorial jurisdiction over a petition for the issuance of a Writ of Amparo?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Amparo Scope
Under the Rule on the Writ of Amparo (A.M. No. 07-9-12-SC), the remedy covers violations or threats to the right to life, liberty, and security committed by public officers or private individuals and entities. Private individuals acting as civilian volunteer organizations or private security auxiliary forces cannot claim exemption from amparo petitions on the ground of being non-state agents. Where the petition alleges enforced disappearance or threat committed by private individuals, the writ lies against them, rendering their defense of non-agency untenable.

2. Order of Preference
Under Section 2 of the Rule on the Writ of Amparo, the right to file the petition belongs primarily to the aggrieved party. If the aggrieved party disappears, the rule establishes an exclusive order of preference: first, the spouse, children, and parents; second, other relatives within the fourth degree of consanguinity or affinity; and third, any concerned citizen or organization. The filing of a petition by a person higher in the order of preference precludes lower-ranked entities, such as an NGO, from subsequently or simultaneously filing a separate petition.

3. Case Consolidation
Under Section 21 of the Rule on the Writ of Amparo, when a criminal action is subsequently filed after an amparo petition, the amparo petition shall be consolidated with the criminal action. Moreover, under Section 22, if a criminal action was filed first, no separate amparo petition may be filed, but the relief may be sought in the criminal case. Consolidation ensures that evidence and interim reliefs regarding the threat or disappearance are evaluated together within the criminal prosecution, avoiding conflicting judicial rulings.

TopicsConsolidation of Amparo Proceedings1Order of Preference in Amparo1Writ of Amparo7

2014 Bar Examinations

2014 Remedial Law, Q1

Ludong, Balatong, and Labong were charged with murder. After trial, the court announced that the case was considered submitted for decision. Subsequently, the Clerk of Court issued the notices of promulgation of judgment which were duly received. On promulgation day, Ludong and his lawyer appeared. The lawyers of Balatong and Labong appeared but without their clients and failed to satisfactorily explain their absence when queried by the court. Thus, the judge ordered the Clerk of Court to proceed with the reading of the judgment convicting all the accused. With respect to Balatong and Labong, the judge ordered that the judgment be entered in the criminal docket and copies be furnished their lawyers. The lawyers of Ludong, Balatong, and Labong filed within the reglementary period a Joint Motion for Reconsideration. The court favorably granted the motion of Ludong downgrading his conviction from murder to homicide but denied the motion as regards Balatong and Labong. (4%)
(A) Was the court correct in taking cognizance of the Joint Motion for Reconsideration?
(B) Can Balatong and Labong appeal their conviction in case Ludong accepts his conviction for homicide?

Quick check

What is the legal effect when an accused fails to appear at the promulgation of judgment without justifiable cause?

How may an absent accused regain the right to file a motion for reconsideration or appeal after promulgation?

Under Rule 120, Section 6, how is judgment promulgated against an accused who unjustifiably fails to appear?

What happens to a joint motion for reconsideration filed on behalf of both an appearing accused and non-appearing co-accused?

Within what period from promulgation in absentia must an absent accused surrender and move for leave to avail of remedies?

Learn more about these topics

1. Promulgation in Absentia
Under Rule 120, Section 6 of the Revised Rules of Criminal Procedure, judgment is promulgated by reading it in the presence of the accused and any judge of the court in which it was rendered. If the conviction is for a light offense, the judgment may be read in the presence of counsel or representative. However, if the accused fails to appear at the scheduled promulgation without justifiable cause, the judgment shall be promulgated by recording it in the criminal docket and serving a copy upon the accused or counsel, whereupon the accused forfeits remedies against the judgment.

2. Forfeiture of Remedies
An accused who fails to appear at the promulgation of judgment without justifiable cause loses the remedies available under the Rules, such as filing a motion for new trial, motion for reconsideration, or an appeal. The forfeiture of remedies is an administrative and procedural sanction imposed for disobeying court orders and fleeing judicial jurisdiction. Unless the absent accused surrenders and files a motion for leave to avail of remedies within fifteen days from promulgation, showing justifiable cause for the absence, the conviction becomes final and executory.

3. Remedy of Accused
To regain standing and avail of post-promulgation remedies, an absent accused must surrender to the custody of the law within fifteen days from recording of the judgment in the docket. Within the same period, the accused must file a motion for leave to avail of remedies, proving that the failure to appear at promulgation was due to a justifiable cause. If the court grants leave, the accused may then file a motion for reconsideration, motion for new trial, or notice of appeal within fifteen days from notice of the order granting leave.

TopicsForfeiture of Remedies1Promulgation of Judgment1Rule 120 Section 61