Bar Subject: Remedial Law

2014 Bar Examinations

2014 Remedial Law, Q7

Co Batong, a Taipan, filed a civil action for damages with the Regional Trial Court (RTC) of Parañaque City against Jose Penduko, a news reporter of the Philippine Times, a newspaper of general circulation printed and published in Parañaque City. The complaint alleged, among others, that Jose Penduko wrote malicious and defamatory imputations against Co Batong; that Co Batong’s business address is in Makati City; and that the libelous article was first printed and published in Parañaque City. The complaint prayed that Jose Penduko be held liable to pay P200,000.00, as moral damages; P150,000.00, as exemplary damages; and P50,000.00, as attorney’s fees.
Jose Penduko filed a Motion to Dismiss on the following grounds:
1. The RTC is without jurisdiction because under the Totality Rule, the claim for damages in the amount of P350,000.00 fall within the exclusive original jurisdiction of the Metropolitan Trial Court (MeTC) of Parañaque City.
2. The venue is improperly laid because what the complaint alleged is Co Batong’s business address and not his residence address.
Are the grounds invoked in the Motion to Dismiss proper? (4%)

Quick check

Which court has exclusive original jurisdiction over civil actions for damages arising from libel regardless of the amount claimed?

Where may a civil action for damages arising from libel be properly filed under Article 360 of the Revised Penal Code?

Does the Totality Rule apply in determining court jurisdiction over civil actions for damages arising from libel?

Is alleging the business address of the private complainant in a libel complaint sufficient to lay proper venue if the place of first publication is also alleged?

Choices available with full access.

What is the legal effect of filing a civil action for libel in the Metropolitan Trial Court when the damages claimed are below P400,000.00?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Libel Jurisdiction
Under Article 360 of the Revised Penal Code, the Regional Trial Court possesses exclusive original jurisdiction over all civil actions for damages arising from written defamation or libel, regardless of the total monetary damages claimed. The jurisdictional threshold limits under the Totality Rule do not apply to libel suits. Municipal Trial Courts have no jurisdiction over civil or criminal cases for libel, making an RTC filing proper regardless of whether the claim falls below standard jurisdictional amounts.

2. Libel Venue Rules
Article 360 of the Revised Penal Code provides specific and exclusive venue rules for libel suits. A civil action for damages arising from libel may be filed either in the Regional Trial Court of the province or city where the libelous article was printed and first published, or where the private complainant actually resided at the time of the commission of the offense. Alleging the place of first printing and publication in the complaint is sufficient to establish proper venue in that trial court.

3. Totality Rule Inapplicability
The Totality Rule under the Judiciary Reorganization Act applies to general civil actions where jurisdiction is determined by the total aggregate amount of monetary claims. However, special laws and explicit statutory provisions override general jurisdictional rules. Because Article 360 of the Revised Penal Code specifically confers exclusive original jurisdiction over libel cases upon the Regional Trial Court, the aggregate amount of moral damages, exemplary damages, and attorney's fees is completely immaterial to determining judicial competence.

TopicsArticle 360 RPC1Libel Jurisdiction1Venue in Libel Cases1

2014 Remedial Law, Q8

Johnny, a naturalized citizen of the United States of America (USA) but formerly a Filipino citizen, executed a notarial will in accordance with the laws of the State of California, USA. Johnny, at the time of his death, was survived by his niece Anastacia, an American citizen residing at the condominium unit of Johnny located at Fort Bonifacio, Taguig City; a younger brother, Bartolome, who manages Johnny’s fish pond in Lingayen, Pangasinan; and a younger sister, Christina, who manages Johnny’s rental condominium units in Makati City. Johnny’s entire estate which he inherited from his parents is valued at P200 million. Johnny appointed Anastacia as executrix of his will. (4%)
(A) Can Johnny’s notarial will be probated before the proper court in the Philippines?
(B) Is Anastacia qualified to be the executrix of Johnny’s notarial will?

Quick check

Can a foreign will executed by an alien abroad be originally probated in the Philippines if the decedent left property in the country?

Is an American citizen residing in Taguig City qualified to be appointed as an executrix of a foreign will probated in the Philippines?

Where is the proper venue for the settlement of the estate of a non-resident alien who died leaving properties in Taguig, Makati, and Pangasinan?

Which of the following is an explicit ground for disqualification of an executor under Rule 78, Section 1 of the Rules of Court?

Choices available with full access.

Under Article 816 of the Civil Code, what law governs the formal validity of a will executed abroad by an alien?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Foreign Will Probate
Under Rule 76 of the Rules of Court and Article 816 of the Civil Code, a will executed abroad by an alien in accordance with the laws of the place of execution or residence may be probated in the Philippines. Our courts have jurisdiction to probate a foreign will if the decedent left real or personal estate in the Philippines, even prior to or without requiring previous probate proceedings in a foreign tribunal. The law does not mandate prior foreign probate as a jurisdictional condition precedent for allowance of a foreign will in local courts.

2. Executor Qualifications
Under Rule 78, Section 1 of the Rules of Court, no person is competent to serve as an executor or administrator who is a minor, non-resident of the Philippines, or declared by the court unfit to execute the duties of the trust by reason of drunkenness, improvidence, or lack of understanding or integrity. Alienage or foreign citizenship is not a ground for disqualification of an executor. As long as an alien executor actually resides in the Philippines and possesses full legal capacity, the court may issue letters testamentary.

3. Special Proceedings Venue
Under Rule 73, Section 1 of the Rules of Court, if the decedent was an inhabitant of a foreign country at the time of death, the venue for the settlement of his estate lies in the Regional Trial Court of any province or city in which he left property. Where a non-resident decedent leaves real properties situated in multiple cities, the court first taking cognizance of the settlement proceedings acquires exclusive jurisdiction to probate the will and administer the entire estate.

TopicsProbate of Foreign Wills1Qualifications of Executor1Rule 76 Settlement of Estate1

2014 Remedial Law, Q9

Bayani, an overseas worker based in Dubai, issued in favor of Agente, a special power of attorney to sell his house and lot. Agente was able to sell the property but failed to remit the proceeds to Bayani, as agreed upon. On his return to the Philippines, Bayani, by way of a demand letter duly received by Agente, sought to recover the amount due him. Agente failed to return the amount as he had used it for the construction of his own house. Thus, Bayani filed an action against Agente for sum of money with damages. Bayani subsequently filed an ex-parte motion for the issuance of a writ of preliminary attachment duly supported by an affidavit. The court granted the ex-parte motion and issued a writ of preliminary attachment upon Bayani’s posting of the required bond. Bayani prayed that the court’s sheriff
be deputized to serve and implement the writ of attachment. On November 19, 2013, the Sheriff served upon Agente the writ of attachment and levied on the latter’s house and lot. On November 20, 2013, the Sheriff served on Agente summons and a copy of the complaint. On November 22, 2013, Agente filed an Answer with Motion to Discharge the Writ of Attachment alleging that at the time the writ of preliminary attachment was issued, he has not been served with summons and, therefore, it was improperly issued. (4%)
(A) Is Agente correct?
(B) Was the writ of preliminary attachment properly executed?

Quick check

May a trial court validly issue an ex parte order of preliminary attachment prior to service of summons upon the defendant?

What requirement must be satisfied before a sheriff can validly enforce a levy under a writ of preliminary attachment?

What is the legal status of a levy on attachment executed by a sheriff one day before serving summons on the defendant?

What is the proper ground for a motion to discharge when a levy on attachment is executed prior to service of summons?

Choices available with full access.

Which ground under Rule 57 justifies the application for preliminary attachment against an agent who misappropriated proceeds of sale?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Ex Parte Issuance
Under Rule 57, Section 2 of the Rules of Court, a writ of preliminary attachment may be validly issued ex parte even prior to the service of summons upon the defendant. The court acquires jurisdiction to issue the provisional order of attachment upon the filing of the application, affidavit, and required applicant's bond. The stage of issuance is distinct from the stage of enforcement or levy, and prior acquisition of jurisdiction over the person of the defendant is not a prerequisite for the grant of an ex parte order of attachment.

2. Contemporaneous Service Rule
Under Rule 57, Section 5 of the Rules of Court, no levy on attachment shall be enforced unless preceded or accompanied by service of summons, complaint, application for attachment, order of attachment, and applicant's bond upon the defendant. This requirement of contemporaneous service ensures due process and establishes jurisdiction over the person of the defendant before or at the moment the levy takes effect. Enforcement of a writ of attachment prior to serving summons renders the levy invalid, null, and void.

3. Invalid Levy Remedy
When a writ of preliminary attachment is validly issued but improperly enforced due to premature levy before service of summons, the proper remedy of the defendant is to move for the discharge or lifting of the invalid levy rather than attacking the issuance of the writ itself. The improper execution does not retroactively invalidate the underlying judicial order granting attachment. The sheriff must re-serve or properly execute the writ in strict compliance with the rule on contemporaneous service of summons.

TopicsContemporaneous Service Rule1Ex Parte Issuance2Preliminary Attachment5

2014 Remedial Law, Q10

Prince Chong entered into a lease contract with King Kong over a commercial building where the former conducted his hardware business. The lease contract stipulated, among others, a monthly rental of P50,000.00 for a four (4)-year period commencing on January 1, 2010. On January 1, 2013, Prince Chong died. Kin Il Chong was appointed administrator of the estate of Prince Chong, but the former failed to pay the rentals for the months of January to June 2013 despite King Kong’s written demands. Thus, on July 1, 2013, King Kong filed with the Regional Trial Court (RTC) an action for rescission of contract with damages and payment of accrued rentals as of June 30, 2013. (4%)
(A) Can Kin Il Chong move to dismiss the complaint on the ground that the RTC is without jurisdiction since the amount claimed is only P300,000.00?
(B) If the rentals accrued during the lifetime of Prince Chong, and King Kong also filed the complaint for sum of money during that time, will the action be dismissible upon Prince Chong’s death during the pendency of the case?

Quick check

Which court has exclusive original jurisdiction over an action for rescission of a lease contract regardless of the amount of accrued rentals claimed?

What happens to a pending civil action for a contractual money claim when the defendant dies before final judgment is rendered?

How is a final money judgment obtained against a defendant who died during the pendency of a contractual action enforced?

What is the primary test to determine whether a civil action is incapable of pecuniary estimation under B.P. Blg. 129?

Choices available with full access.

Within what period must an executor or administrator be substituted as a party when a defendant dies during a pending money suit?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Rescission Jurisdiction
Under Section 19(1) of Batas Pambansa Blg. 129, actions in which the subject of the litigation is incapable of pecuniary estimation fall within the exclusive original jurisdiction of the Regional Trial Court. An action for rescission of a lease contract seeks to restore the status quo ante rather than merely collect a debt. Although a claim for unpaid rentals and damages is included, the primary relief of rescission renders the subject matter incapable of pecuniary estimation, vesting subject matter jurisdiction exclusively in the Regional Trial Court regardless of the monetary amount claimed.

2. Surviving Money Actions
Under Rule 3, Section 20 of the Revised Rules of Court, when an action is for recovery of money arising from contract, express or implied, and the defendant dies before entry of final judgment, the case shall not be dismissed. Instead, the action continues against the estate of the deceased defendant. The executor or administrator of the estate is substituted as defendant, and the court retains jurisdiction over the case until final judgment. Any monetary award obtained by the plaintiff is subsequently enforced as a claim against the estate under Rule 86.

3. Party Substitution Rule
When a party to a pending contractual money action dies prior to final judgment, procedural due process mandates the formal substitution of the legal representative of the deceased. The trial court orders the legal representative, administrator, or executor of the estate to appear and be substituted within thirty days from notice. This procedural mechanism ensures that the rights of the estate are fully protected during litigation, preventing the automatic abatement of contractual actions and preserving the jurisdiction of the court to render a binding judgment.

TopicsActions Surviving Death1Incapable of Pecuniary Estimation3Rule 3 Section 201

2014 Remedial Law, Q11

A search warrant was issued for the purpose of looking for unlicensed firearms in the house of Ass-asin, a notorious gun for hire. When the police served the warrant, they also sought the assistance of barangay tanods who were assigned to look at other portions of the premises around the house. In a nipa hut thirty (30) meters away from the house of Ass-asin, a barangay tanod came upon a kilo of marijuana that was wrapped in newsprint. He took it and this was later used by the authorities to charge Ass-asin with illegal possession of marijuana. Ass-asin objected to the introduction of such evidence claiming that it was illegally seized. Is the objection of Assasin valid? (4%)

Quick check

What is the legal consequence when police officers search an unlisted structure located thirty meters away from the house designated in a search warrant?

Why is the plain view doctrine inapplicable to a package of marijuana wrapped in newsprint seized during a search?

What requirement under Rule 126 of the Rules of Criminal Procedure prevents exploratory search operations by police officers?

Under the exclusionary rule, what happens to evidence obtained through an illegal search and seizure?

Choices available with full access.

Who bears the burden of proving that a warrantless search falls under a recognized exception to the warrant requirement?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Remedial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Particularity of Search
Under the Constitution and Rule 126 of the Rules of Criminal Procedure, a search warrant must particularly describe the place to be searched and the persons or things to be seized. Officers executing the warrant cannot extend the search to locations outside the specified premises. Searching an adjacent structure not mentioned in the warrant, such as a detached nipa hut located thirty meters away from the target house, exceeds the spatial boundary of the warrant. Any evidence seized beyond the designated area is void for lack of judicial authorization.

2. Plain View Doctrine
The plain view doctrine permits police officers to seize contraband without a warrant only if they are legally present at the site, the discovery of the evidence is inadvertent, and the incriminating nature of the item is immediately apparent. Where an object is concealed or wrapped in newsprint, its illegal nature is not immediately apparent to the naked eye. Searching inside opaque packages or wrappings without prior justification constitutes an illegal warrantless search, rendering the plain view exception inapplicable.

3. Exclusionary Rule Effect
Under Article III, Section 3(2) of the 1990 Constitution, any evidence obtained in violation of the right against unreasonable searches and seizures is inadmissible for any purpose in any proceeding. Known as the exclusionary rule or fruit of the poisonous tree doctrine, this constitutional prohibition completely bars the prosecution from introducing illegally seized items in evidence against an accused. The invalidity of the search corrupts the evidence, requiring its total suppression regardless of its probative value in proving guilt.

TopicsExclusionary Rule11Plain View Doctrine2Search Warrant Scope1