Dave is on trial for sexual assault of Delly, a law student who sidelines as a call center agent. Dave offers the testimony of Danny, who says that Dave is known in the community as a decent and discerning person. The prosecution presents a rebuttal witness, Dovie, who testifies that, if Dave was reputed to be a good person, that reputation was a misperception because Dave had been previously convicted of homicide.
Is Dovie’s testimony admissible as to the character of Dave? (2.5%)
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
No, Dovie's testimony is not admissible as to the character of Dave. Under Rule 130, Section 54(a)(2) of the Rules of Court, while the prosecution may prove the bad moral character of the accused on rebuttal, such evidence
Unlock the full Remedial Law answers365 days of full access. GCash, Maya and card accepted.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
When may the prosecution present evidence of the bad moral character of the accused in a criminal case?
The prosecution may prove bad moral character only on rebuttal after the accused introduces evidence of good moral character.
What requirement must character evidence satisfy to be admissible in a criminal prosecution?
Character evidence must be pertinent to the moral trait involved in the offense charged.
How must bad moral character be proved when admissible on rebuttal in a criminal trial?
Character evidence must be established by reputation or opinion, not by specific instances of conduct.
Why is a prior conviction for homicide inadmissible to rebut an accused's reputation for decency in a sexual assault case?
Choices available with full access.
Under Rule 130, Section 54, what is the general rule regarding character evidence in criminal cases?
Choices available with full access.
Learn more about these topics
1. Character Evidence Rule
Under Rule 130, Section 54(a) of the Rules of Court, the accused in a criminal case may prove his good moral character if pertinent to the moral trait involved in the offense charged. However, the prosecution cannot present evidence of the bad moral character of the accused unless in rebuttal after the accused has opened the issue by introducing evidence of good moral character. Even on rebuttal, prosecution evidence remains strictly limited to the specific moral trait pertinent to the crime charged.
2. Pertinent Moral Trait
Character evidence offered by either party must relate directly to the moral trait involved in the offense charged. In prosecutions for sexual offenses, the pertinent moral trait involves chastity, modesty, or sexual decency. Rebuttal testimony concerning a completely distinct moral trait, such as peacefulness or non-violence, is irrelevant to a charge of sexual assault. Consequently, evidence showing violent tendencies cannot be admitted on rebuttal to disprove an accused's reputation for decency and sexual morality.
3. Specific Acts Prohibition
When character evidence is admissible, it must be established exclusively through reputation in the community or opinion evidence, not by specific instances of conduct or prior criminal convictions. Demonstrating bad character through specific past wrongful acts violates the fundamental rule against using propensity evidence. A prior conviction for homicide constitutes a specific instance of conduct and is inadmissible as rebuttal character evidence to prove the accused's general bad moral character.