Elise obtained a loan of ₱3 Million from Merchant Bank. Aside from executing a promissory note in favor of Merchant Bank, she executed a deed of real estate mortgage over her house and lot as security for her obligation. The loan fell due but remained unpaid; hence, Merchant Bank filed an action against Elise to foreclose the real estate mortgage. A month after, and while the foreclosure suit was pending, Merchant Bank also filed an action to recover the principal sum of ₱3 Million against Elise based on the same promissory note previously executed by the latter.
In opposing the motion of Elise to dismiss the second action on the ground of splitting of a single cause of action, Merchant Bank argued that the ground relied upon by Elise was devoid of any legal basis considering that the two actions were based on separate contracts, namely, the contract of loan evidenced by the promissory note, and the deed of real estate mortgage.
Is there a splitting of a single cause of action? Explain your answer. (4%)
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
Yes, there is a splitting of a single cause of action. Under Rule 2, Section 4 of the Rules of Court and settled jurisprudence (Bachrach Motor Co. v. Icarangal; Marilag v. Martinez), a loan secured by a mortgage gives rise to
Unlock the full Remedial Law answers365 days of full access. GCash, Maya and card accepted.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
What is the legal effect when a creditor files both a foreclosure suit and a collection suit for the same debt?
A loan secured by a mortgage gives rise to a single cause of action, making collection and foreclosure alternative remedies.
Which rule governs the election of remedies when a loan obligation secured by a mortgage defaults?
The remedies of personal collection and real foreclosure are alternative and mutually exclusive.
What is the principal cause of action in a loan secured by a real estate mortgage upon default?
The non-payment of the principal debt constitutes the single cause of action in a secured loan.
How does Philippine law classify a real estate mortgage in relation to a promissory note?
Choices available with full access.
If a bank files a judicial foreclosure suit first, what happens to its right to file a personal collection suit?
Choices available with full access.
Learn more about these topics
1. Single Cause Action
A single cause of action arises from a single delict or breach of an obligation. In a contract of loan secured by a real estate mortgage, the non-payment of the principal debt upon maturity constitutes the sole cause of action. Although the loan agreement and the mortgage deed are separate instruments, they stem from the single obligation to repay the borrowed amount. Dividing the creditor's claim into separate actions for foreclosure and collection constitutes improper splitting of a single cause of action under Rule 2 of the Rules of Court.
2. Alternative Remedies Rule
When a mortgage secures a loan, the mortgagee-creditor possesses two distinct remedies upon default: a personal action for collection of the debt or a real action for judicial or extrajudicial foreclosure of the mortgage. Under established jurisprudence, these remedies are alternative, complete, and mutually exclusive, rather than cumulative. Electing to institute a judicial foreclosure suit operates as a waiver of the personal action for collection, preventing the creditor from simultaneously or subsequently filing a separate collection suit based on the same debt.
3. Accessory Mortgage Nature
A real estate mortgage is merely an accessory contract created to guarantee the fulfillment of a principal loan obligation. It has no independent existence separate from the principal debt. Consequently, while the promissory note and mortgage deed constitute distinct legal documents, the underlying liability remains singular. Attempting to enforce the principal debt in one proceeding while foreclosing the mortgage in another violates procedural rules against multiplicity of suits and results in the dismissal of the second action.