Bar Subject: Civil Law

2025 Bar Examinations

2025 Civil Law, Q1

A leased out his penthouse condominium unit to B. Unfortunately, A figured in an accident and perished, leaving his son, C, as his sole heir. Subsequently, C demanded that B vacate the premises by noon of the following day. B refused, showing C the duly executed lease agreement between her and A. B claimed that she has a right to remain in the unit since the term of the lease was yet to expire. C countered that he had nothing to do with the lease contract as it was executed between his father and B and therefore does not bind him. Is C correct? Reason(s).

Quick check

Under Article 1311 of the Civil Code, who among the following are bound by the rights and obligations arising from a contract?

What comprises the inheritance of a decedent under Article 776 of the Civil Code?

What is the general effect of a lessor's death on an existing contract of lease prior to its expiration?

Why was C bound by the contract of lease executed between his deceased father A and tenant B?

Which of the following exceptions prevents contractual obligations from binding an heir under Article 1311 of the Civil Code?

Learn more about these topics

1. Relativity of Contracts
Under Article 1311 of the Civil Code, contracts take effect between the parties, their assigns, and heirs. This principle of relativity dictates that rights and obligations arising from a contract are transmissible to the heirs upon the death of a contracting party. Unless a contract is purely personal by its nature, restricted by explicit stipulation, or rendered intransmissible by provision of law, an heir inherits both the benefits and burdens established by the decedent's agreements. Consequently, heirs cannot disavow contracts entered into by their predecessors in interest.

2. Transmission of Inheritance
Under Article 776 of the Civil Code, the inheritance includes all the property, rights, and obligations of a person which are not extinguished by his death. Successional rights are transmitted from the exact moment of the decedent's death. An heir steps directly into the legal shoes of the deceased, succeeding to all transmissible contractual rights and liabilities. Because an heir acquires the property subject to existing encumbrances and obligations, he must respect all valid legal commitments, such as outstanding lease contracts, that were lawfully created by the decedent during his lifetime.

3. Transmissibility of Lease
A contract of lease is essentially an agreement involving property rights and enjoyment, making it inherently transmissible to heirs upon the death of either party. Unlike contracts that rely on personal qualifications, a lease does not terminate upon the death of the lessor or lessee unless the contract explicitly provides for its termination. The lessor's heir inherits the property subject to the existing lease burden and remains bound to respect the tenant's right of peaceful possession until the full expiration of the stipulated lease term.

TopicsArticle 1311 Civil Code4Relativity of Contracts2Transmission of Lease1

2025 Civil Law, Q2

In a desperate attempt to dispose of her assets, X, a fugitive from justice, called her friend, Y, instructing him to sell her house and lot located at Forbes Park to the first interested buyer for not less than PHP 250 million. Y offered the property for sale to his boss, Z. Enticed by the offer, Z asked Y for a copy of the title and proof of Y’s authority to sell the property. Y presented the title of the property, claiming that his possession of the title was sufficient proof of his authority to sell the property. Relying on the representation of Y, Z bought the property from Y, the agent of X. Is the sale valid? Reason(s).

Quick check

Under Article 1874 of the Civil Code, what is the required form for an agent's authority to sell a piece of land?

What is the legal effect under Article 1874 of a sale of land executed by an agent with only oral authorization?

Under Article 1878 of the Civil Code, which of the following acts requires a special power of attorney?

Does an agent's possession of the owner's duplicate certificate of title constitute written authority to sell real property?

What duty is imposed on a buyer who purchases real property through a representative or agent?

Learn more about these topics

1. Sale of Land
Under Article 1874 of the Civil Code, when a sale of a piece of land or any interest therein is conducted through an agent, the agent's authority must be explicitly in writing; otherwise, the sale is void. This requirement is mandatory and statutory, designed to safeguard land ownership and prevent unauthorized dispositions. Verbal authorization or telephonic instructions from the principal do not suffice to grant legal authority to sell land. Without a written power of attorney executed by the land owner, any sale executed by the agent produces no legal force or effect against the principal.

2. Authority to Sell
Under Article 1878 of the Civil Code, a special power of attorney is required for an agent to enter into any contract by which the ownership of an immovable is transmitted or acquired. The requirement of a special power ensures that the principal's clear and express intention to convey real property is established in writing. Possession of the owner's duplicate certificate of title by an agent does not substitute for or imply written authority to sell. Anyone dealing with an agent regarding real property must verify the existence and scope of the agent's written power.

3. Void Contracts
A contract of sale of land entered into by an agent lacking written authority is null and void ab initio under Article 1874 of the Civil Code. A void contract produces no legal rights, obligations, or consequences whatsoever, and cannot be ratified. Buyers dealing with an agent without verifying his written authority act at their own peril. Even if a buyer acts in good faith and relies on the agent's possession of the title, the statutory requirement of written agency remains indispensable, rendering the sale completely void and incapable of transferring ownership.

TopicsArticle 1874 Civil Code3Sale of Land1Special Power of Attorney3

2025 Civil Law, Q3

The government owned a 12-hectare land in Cavite classified as forest land. Informal settlers built shanty houses on the land since it was flat and there were no trees planted thereon. In 2023, the government decided to plant Narra trees on the land and demanded that the informal settlers vacate the same. A, owner of one of the shanty houses, refused, claiming that he already owned the portion of the property he was occupying by virtue of acquisitive prescription. Is the claim of A meritorious? Decide with reason(s).

Quick check

Which of the following describes the legal nature of forest lands under Philippine law?

Under Article 1113 of the Civil Code, which properties are susceptible of acquisitive prescription?

Does forest land lose its inalienable classification if it is completely stripped of trees and becomes flat terrain?

What is the legal status of an informal settler's possession of public forest land for over thirty years?

Which branch of government possesses the exclusive prerogative to classify public lands as alienable and disposable?

Learn more about these topics

1. Public Dominion
Under Article 420 of the Civil Code, properties of public dominion, such as forest lands, rivers, and shores, are intended for public use or public service. Because they belong to the State for the benefit of the collective public, these properties are held in trust and are strictly inalienable and indisposable. They cannot be leased, encumbered, or alienated to private individuals by any government official without an express legislative act or executive reclassification converting them into alienable agricultural land. Consequently, private persons cannot acquire any vested property rights over public dominion lands.

2. Acquisitive Prescription
Under Article 1113 of the Civil Code, only property and rights that are susceptible of appropriation may be the object of prescription. Properties of public dominion are explicitly outside the commerce of man and cannot be acquired through acquisitive prescription, regardless of how long the possession or occupation continues. Even open, continuous, exclusive, and notorious possession for decades will not ripen into private title or ownership over inalienable public land. Any private occupation of public dominion property is considered a mere tolerance by the government and creates no legal right in favor of the possessor.

3. Forest Land
Forest lands retain their legal classification as inalienable public dominion regardless of their actual physical condition or appearance. Land classified as forest land does not lose its character simply because it has been cleared of trees, developed into agricultural land, or settled by informal occupants. Classification of public lands is an exclusive prerogative of the Executive Department, exercised through official proclamation. Until a formal reclassification declaring forest land as alienable and disposable agricultural land is officially issued, the property remains strictly inalienable public land immune from private appropriation or prescription.

TopicsAcquisitive Prescription2Article 420 Civil Code1Forest Lands1

2025 Civil Law, Q4

A, a member of a popular boy band in the Philippines, got his girlfriend, B, pregnant. A and B got married in Hong Kong where the legal age to get married was at least 15 years old. At the time of their marriage, A and B were 17 and 16 years old, respectively, and were both Filipino citizens. Subsequently, A continued with his career while B hid her pregnancy in the United States of America. She only returned to the Philippines after she gave birth to their son. By then though, B was already tired of being A’s deep dark secret. She thus filed a petition for declaration of nullity of marriage on the ground that her marriage with A is void. Will the petition prosper? Reason(s).

Quick check

Under Article 15 of the Civil Code, which law governs the legal capacity of a Filipino citizen to contract marriage while abroad?

Under Article 35(1) of the Family Code, what is the legal status of a marriage contracted by a person who is seventeen years old?

What is the general rule under Article 26 of the Family Code regarding marriages celebrated outside the Philippines?

Which of the following constitutes an exception to the validity of foreign marriages under Article 26 of the Family Code?

Why was the Hong Kong marriage between seventeen-year-old A and sixteen-year-old B void under Philippine law?

Learn more about these topics

1. Nationality Principle
Under Article 15 of the Civil Code, laws relating to family rights and duties, or to the status, condition and legal capacity of persons are binding upon citizens of the Philippines, even though living abroad. This nationality principle dictates that a Filipino citizen carries Philippine personal law regarding legal capacity wherever he or she goes. Consequently, a Filipino's capacity to contract marriage is governed strictly by Philippine law regardless of the place where the marriage ceremony is celebrated or whether foreign laws permit marriage at a lower age.

2. Foreign Marriages
Under Article 26 of the Family Code, all marriages solemnized outside the Philippines, in accordance with the laws in force in the country where they were solemnized, and valid there as such, shall also be valid in this country. However, Article 26 explicitly provides exceptions to this general rule of lex loci celebrationis. Foreign marriages celebrated abroad by Filipinos remain void ab initio in the Philippines if they violate fundamental prohibitions under Philippine law, specifically including marriages contracted by any party who is below eighteen years of age.

3. Minimum Age Requisite
Under Articles 5 and 35(1) of the Family Code, contracting parties must be at least eighteen years of age to possess the essential legal capacity to marry. Any marriage contracted by a party below eighteen years of age is null and void from the beginning. Because minimum age is an indispensable essential requisite for marriage, parental consent cannot cure or validate a marriage contracted by a minor. Even if celebrated in a foreign jurisdiction that allows underage marriages, an exception under Article 26 renders the marriage void ab initio under Philippine law.

TopicsArticle 15 Civil Code2Article 35(1) Family Code1Foreign Marriages1

2025 Civil Law, Q5

A, B, and C are co-owners of a three-hectare agricultural land with a fair market value of PHP 9 million or PHP 3 million per hectare. A offered to sell his share to B and C for a total amount of PHP 10 million. B and C declined the offer and asked A to reduce the purchase price to PHP 3 million, the prevailing fair market value of the land per hectare. A refused and instead sold his one-hectare share to X for PHP 10 million. May B and C go to court for the reduction of the purchase price so they can exercise their right of legal redemption? Reason(s).

Quick check

Under Article 1620 of the Civil Code, when may a co-owner exercise the right of legal redemption?

What amount must a redeeming co-owner pay under Article 1620 if the price of the sale to a third person is grossly excessive?

What is the underlying public policy behind granting co-owners the right of legal redemption under Philippine civil law?

What remedy is available to co-owners if a selling co-owner and a buyer collude to fix an exorbitant price to block legal redemption?

Which of the following is a requisite for the exercise of legal redemption by a co-owner under Article 1620?

Learn more about these topics

1. Legal Redemption
Under Article 1620 of the Civil Code, a co-owner has the legal right to redeem the share of another co-owner that is sold to a third person. Legal redemption among co-owners aims to minimize co-ownership, which the law considers inherently precarious, and to avoid introducing an unwanted stranger into the co-ownership. To exercise this right, the property must be owned in common, the share must be sold to a non-co-owner, and the redemption must be exercised within the statutory thirty-day period following written notice of the sale.

2. Grossly Excessive Price
Under Article 1620 of the Civil Code, if the purchase price of the alienated co-owner's share is grossly excessive, the redemptioner is not obligated to pay the inflated contract price but shall pay only a reasonable price. This provision prevents a selling co-owner and a third-party buyer from colluding to fix an exorbitant or simulated purchase price specifically designed to frustrate and defeat the remaining co-owners' legal right of redemption. In such instances, the court may intervene upon proper petition to determine and fix the fair and reasonable redemption price.

3. Co-Ownership Redemption
The primary policy underlying the right of legal redemption among co-owners is to reduce the number of co-owners and ultimately terminate the community of property. Co-ownership is often a source of discord and inefficient property administration. By granting co-owners a preferential right to acquire a selling co-owner's undivided share at a reasonable price, the law seeks to consolidate ownership in fewer hands. This public policy rationale justifies judicial intervention to adjust unconscionable contract prices that would otherwise effectively bar co-owners from exercising their statutory redemption privilege.

TopicsArticle 1620 Civil Code1Grossly Excessive Price1Right of Legal Redemption1