Bar Subject: Civil Law

2018 Bar Examinations

2018 Civil Law, Q7

Sydney, during her lifetime, was a successful lawyer. By her own choice, she remained unmarried and devoted all her time to taking care of her nephew and two (2) nieces: Socrates, Saffinia, and Sophia. She wrote a will giving all her properties remaining upon her death to the three (3) of them. The will was admitted to probate during her lifetime. Later, she decided to make a new will giving all her remaining properties only to the two (2) girls, Saffinia and Sophia. She then tore up the previously probated will. The second will was presented for probate only after her death. However, the probate court found the second will to be void for failure to comply with formal requirements.
(a) Will the doctrine of dependent relative revocation apply? (2.5%)
(b) Will your answer be the same if the second will was found to be valid but both Saffinia and Sophia renounce their inheritance? (2.5%)

Quick check

What is required for the doctrine of dependent relative revocation to apply when revoking a prior will?

Under Article 830 of the Civil Code, what happens when a prior probated will is physically torn up with an absolute intent to revoke it?

What is the legal effect if a subsequent will is declared void for failure to comply with formal statutory requirements?

Under Article 832 of the Civil Code, what is the effect on a prior revoked will if the instituted heirs in a valid second will renounce their inheritance?

Choices available with full access.

Why did the doctrine of dependent relative revocation NOT apply to revive Sydney's first probated will?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Dependent Relative Revocation
Under the doctrine of dependent relative revocation, the failure of a new testamentary disposition raises a presumption that the revocation of a prior will was dependent on the validity of the replacement. However, if the act of revoking the first will was absolute and driven by an intentional desire to revoke rather than a mistaken belief in the validity of the new disposition, the doctrine does not apply. If the physical destruction of the prior will was intended to permanently cancel it regardless, the prior will remains revoked and cannot be revived.

2. Void Subsequent Will
Under Article 830 of the Civil Code, a physical act of destruction like tearing or burning a will with animus revocandi validly revokes the instrument. When a subsequent will attempting to substitute dispositions fails and is declared void for non-compliance with formal statutory requirements, it produces no legal effect whatsoever. Consequently, if the tearing of the prior probated will was done with an absolute intention to revoke it, the void second will cannot save the destroyed first will, causing the estate to devolve by operation of law through intestate succession.

3. Renunciation by Heirs
Under Article 832 of the Civil Code, a revocation made in a subsequent valid will takes effect even if the new will becomes inoperative by reason of the incapacity of the heirs, devises, or legatees designated therein, or by their renunciation. The revocation of the prior disposition is absolute upon the execution of a valid revoking instrument. Therefore, if the second will complied with all formal requisites but the instituted heirs subsequently repudiated their inheritance, the prior revoked will is not revived, and the estate passes to legal heirs via intestacy.

TopicsArticle 832 Civil Code1Dependent Relative Revocation1Revocation of Wills1

2018 Civil Law, Q8

Sofronio was a married father of two when he had a brief fling with Sabrina, resulting in her pregnancy and the birth of their son Sinforoso. Though his wife knew nothing of the affair, Sofronio regretted it, but secretly provided child support for Sinforoso. Unfortunately, when Sinforoso was 10 years old, Sofronio died. Only Sofronio’s father, Salumbides, knew of Sabrina and Sinforoso. For the purpose of providing support to Sinforoso, Salumbides gave Sabrina usufructruary · rights over one of his properties – a house and lot – to last until Sinforoso reaches the age of majority. Sabrina was given possession of the property on the basis of caucion juratoria. Two (2) years after the creation of the usufruct, the house accidentally burned down, and three (3) years thereafter, Sinforoso died before he could reach the age of 18.
Will the usufruct continue after the house has burned down? If yes, will it continue after Sinforoso’s death? (2.5%)

Quick check

Under Article 607 of the Civil Code, what happens to a usufruct over a house and lot when the house is accidentally destroyed by fire?

Under Article 606 of the Civil Code, when does a usufruct granted until a third person reaches majority terminate if that person dies prematurely?

Under Article 587 of the Civil Code, what is caucion juratoria?

Why did the usufruct constituted by Salumbides over his house and lot NOT terminate when the house burned down?

Choices available with full access.

Why was the usufruct extinguished upon the death of 13-year-old Sinforoso before reaching majority?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Destruction of Building
Under Article 607 of the Civil Code, if a building forming part of a usufruct is destroyed in any manner whatsoever, the usufructuary has the right to make use of the land and the remaining materials. The destruction of the structure alone does not extinguish the usufruct over the immovable property as a whole. The usufruct continues over the land on which the building stood and over any salvageable materials, allowing the usufructuary to continue exercising possessory rights over the underlying real property.

2. Term of Usufruct
Under Article 606 of the Civil Code, a usufruct granted for the time that may elapse before a third person attains a certain age shall continue for the number of years specified, even if the third person should die before that age, unless such usufruct has been expressly granted only in consideration of the existence of such person. When a usufruct is created specifically for the support and benefit of a named beneficiary, it is granted strictly in consideration of his existence and terminates upon his death.

3. Caucion Juratoria Remedy
Under Article 587 of the Civil Code, when a usufructuary cannot give proper security or bond, she may be allowed under caucion juratoria to take possession of the property, including a house and furniture necessary for her family. The usufructuary promises under oath to fulfill her legal duties and take proper care of the property. While caucion juratoria dispenses with the requirement of posting a financial bond due to poverty or necessity, it does not alter the statutory grounds for the termination or extinction of the usufruct.

TopicsArticle 606 Usufruct Termination1Article 607 Civil Code1Usufruct Destruction of Building1

2018 Civil Law, Q9

Newlyweds Sam and Sienna had contracted with Sangria Hotel for their wedding reception. The couple was so unhappy with the service, claiming, among other things, that there was an unreasonable delay in the service of dinner and that certain items promised were unavailable. The hotel claims that, while there was a delay in the service of the meals, the same was occasioned by the sudden increase of guests to 450 from the guaranteed expected number of 350, as stated in the Banquet and Meeting Services Contract. In the action for damages for breach of contract instituted by the couple, they claimed that the Banquet and Meeting Services Contract was a contract of adhesion since they only provided the number of guests and chose the menu. On the other hand, the hotel’s defense was that the proximate cause of the complainant’s injury was the unexpected increase in their guests, and this was what set the chain of events that resulted in the alleged inconveniences.
(a) Does the doctrine of proximate cause apply in this case? (2.5%)
(b) Was the Banquet and Meeting Services Contract a contract of adhesion? If yes, is the contract void? (2.5%)

Quick check

Why is the doctrine of proximate cause inapplicable in an action for breach of contract?

What is the legal status of a contract of adhesion under Philippine civil law?

Under Article 1170 of the Civil Code, who among the following is liable for damages?

In Spouses Guanio v. Makati Shangri-La Hotel, why was the banquet services contract declared valid despite being a contract of adhesion?

Choices available with full access.

What must a plaintiff prove to recover damages in an action based on culpa contractual?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Proximate Cause Inapplicability
Under the landmark ruling in Spouses Guanio v. Makati Shangri-La Hotel, the doctrine of proximate cause applies strictly to actions based on quasi-delicts or torts. In actions for breach of contract (culpa contractual), a pre-existing contractual relation exists between the parties. The obligation to perform in good faith arises directly from the contract itself under Article 1159 of the Civil Code. Consequently, proof of proximate cause is not required to establish liability for contractual breach; rather, liability attaches upon proof of the existence of the contract and its non-performance, subject to valid defenses such as fortuitous event.

2. Contract of Adhesion
A contract of adhesion is an agreement wherein one party prepares the stipulations in a printed form, while the other party merely signs or 'adheres' to it on a take-it-or-leave-it basis. Contracts of adhesion are not invalid per se. They are as binding and enforceable as ordinary contracts because the party who adheres to the agreement remains completely free to reject it entirely. Such contracts become invalid or void only when the adhering party is forced or coerced into signing, or when the terms are grossly unfair, unconscionable, or contrary to law, morals, or public policy.

3. Contractual Breach Liability
Under Article 1170 of the Civil Code, those who in the performance of their obligations are guilty of fraud, negligence, or delay, and those who in any manner contravene the tenor thereof, are liable for damages. In a contract for banquet services, the hotel is bound to execute its contractual promises with ordinary diligence. While an unexpected influx of guests may mitigate or explain operational delays, it does not completely absolve the obligor of contractual liability if the hotel failed to exercise reasonable care and diligence in managing the reception and servicing the attendees.

TopicsContract of Adhesion Validity1Culpa Contractual Damages1Proximate Cause in Contracts1

2018 Civil Law, Q10

Sinclair and Steffi had an illicit relationship while Sinclair was married to another. The relationship produced a daughter Sabina, who grew up with her mother. For most parts of Sabina’s youth, Steffi spent for her support and education. When Sabina was 21 years old, Sinclair’s wife of many years died. Sinclair and Steffi lost no time in legitimizing their relationship. After the 40-day prayers for Sinclair’s late wife, Sinclair and Steffi got married without a marriage license, claiming that they have been cohabiting for the last 20 years.
After graduating from college, Sabina decided to enroll in law school. Sinclair said that he was not willing to pay for her school fees since she was no longer a minor. Sinclair claimed that, if Sabina wanted to be a lawyer, she had to work and spend for her law education.
(a) What is Sabina’s filiation status? (2.5%)
(b) Is Sinclair legally required to finance Sabina’s law education? (2.5%)

Quick check

Under Article 177 of the Family Code, who among the following children may be validly legitimated by the subsequent marriage of their parents?

Why can Sabina NOT be legitimated by the subsequent marriage of Sinclair and Steffi?

Under Article 194 of the Family Code, what is included in the legal definition of support?

Does a parent's legal duty to provide support for a child's professional education terminate upon the child reaching majority age?

Choices available with full access.

Why is Sinclair legally obligated to finance Sabina's law school education despite her being 21 years old?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Legitimation Requisites
Under Article 177 of the Family Code, legitimation takes place by the subsequent valid marriage between parents who, at the time of the conception of the child, were not disqualified by any impediment to marry each other. If at the time of conception either parent was married to another person, an impediment existed that legally prevents legitimation. Consequently, a subsequent marriage between the parents after the death of the spouse does not legitimize a child conceived during the subsistence of the prior marriage.

2. Scope of Support
Under Article 194 of the Family Code, support comprises everything indispensable for sustenance, dwelling, clothing, medical attendance, education, and transportation, in keeping with the financial capacity of the family. Education includes schooling or training for some profession, trade, or vocation, even beyond the age of majority. Therefore, a parent's legal obligation to provide support for a child's professional education does not terminate automatically upon the child attaining the age of majority.

3. Illegitimate Child Support
Under Article 195 in relation to Article 196 of the Family Code, parents are legally obliged to support their illegitimate children. The right to receive support is an inherent consequence of filiation and parental relationship. An illegitimate child who is recognized or whose filiation is duly established is entitled to demand support from her parent, including necessary financial assistance for professional education, regardless of whether the parent is living with or married to the child's mother.

TopicsArticle 177 Family Code1Illegitimate Child Legitimation1Support for Higher Education1

2018 Civil Law, Q11

Samantha sold all her business interest in a sole proprietorship to Sergio for the amount of PhP1 million. Under the sale agreement, Samantha was supposed to pay for all prior unpaid utility bills incurred by the sole proprietorship. A month after the Contract to Sell was executed, Samantha still had not paid the PhP50,000 electricity bills incurred prior to the sale. Since Sergio could not operate the business without electricity and the utility company refused to restore electricity services unless the unpaid bills were settled in full, Sergio had to pay the unpaid electricity bills. When the date for payment arrived, Sergio only tendered PhP950,000 representing the full purchase price, less the amount he paid for the unpaid utility bills. Samantha refused to accept the tender on the ground that she was the one supposed to pay the bills and Sergio did not have authorization to pay on her behalf.
(a) What is the effect of payment made by Sergio without the knowledge and consent of Samantha? (2.5%)
(b) Is Samantha guilty of mora accipiendi? (2.5%)

Quick check

Under Article 1302(3) of the Civil Code, when does legal subrogation take place without the debtor's consent?

Who is considered a 'person interested in the fulfillment of the obligation' under Article 1302(3)?

Under Article 1279 of the Civil Code, what happens when two persons become mutual creditors and debtors of each other?

What is the legal effect of a creditor's unjustifiable refusal to accept a valid tender of payment?

Choices available with full access.

Why was Samantha guilty of mora accipiendi when she refused Sergio's tender of PhP950,000?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Legal Subrogation
Under Article 1302, paragraph 3 of the Civil Code, legal subrogation takes place when a person interested in the fulfillment of the obligation pays the debt, even without the knowledge or consent of the debtor. An interested person is one who has a legal interest in paying the obligation because he would be affected by its non-fulfillment. Payment by an interested third party transfers to him all the rights, actions, and remedies pertaining to the creditor against the debtor, allowing him to enforce the credit and demand full reimbursement.

2. Legal Compensation
Under Article 1279 of the Civil Code, legal compensation takes place by operation of law when two persons, in their own right, are creditors and debtors of each other. Both debts must consist in a sum of money, be due, liquidated, and demandable, and neither must be subject to any retention or controversy commenced by third persons. When legal subrogation makes the buyer a creditor of the seller for the utility debt, legal compensation automatically extinguishes both debts to the concurrent amount, leaving only the remaining balance due on the purchase price.

3. Mora Accipiendi
Under Article 1169 of the Civil Code, mora accipiendi or creditor's default occurs when the creditor unjustifiably refuses to accept a valid tender of performance or payment offered by the debtor. For mora accipiendi to exist, the debtor must offer a valid tender of payment that complies with the exact amount legally due. When a buyer validly deducts a compensated credit and tenders the remaining purchase price, the seller's refusal to accept payment without lawful justification constitutes mora accipiendi, shifting the risks of loss and interest to the creditor.

TopicsArticle 1302 Civil Code1Legal Compensation Requirements1Mora Accipiendi Default1