Bar Subject: Civil Law

2018 Bar Examinations

2018 Civil Law, Q17

Sofia and Semuel, both unmarried, lived together for many years in the Philippines and begot three children. While Sofia stayed in the Philippines with the children, Semuel went abroad to work and became a naturalized German citizen. He met someone in Germany whom he wanted to marry. Semuel thereafter came home and filed a petition with the Regional Trial Court (RTC) for partition ofthe common properties acquired during his union with Sofia in the Philippines. The properties acquired during the union consisted of a house and lot in Cavite worth PhP2 million, and some personal properties, including cash in bank amounting to PhP1 million. All these properties were acquired using Samuel’s salaries and wages since Sofia was a stay-at-home mother. In retaliation, Sofia filed an action, on behalf of their minor children, for support.
(a) How should the properties be partitioned? (2.5%)
(b) Should Semuel be required to support the minor children? (2.5%)

Quick check

Under Article 147 of the Family Code, what governs property acquired by a man and woman living together without legal impediment?

How does Article 147 of the Family Code view the efforts of a stay-at-home partner who manages the household during cohabitation?

Why is Sofia entitled to a 50% share in the house, lot, and bank cash despite having no financial salary?

What is the effect of Semuel becoming a naturalized German citizen on his legal obligation to support his minor children?

Choices available with full access.

Under Articles 194 and 195 of the Family Code, what is included in the statutory obligation of child support?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Cohabitation Property Co-Ownership
Under Article 147 of the Family Code, when a man and a woman who are capacitated to marry each other live exclusively together as husband and wife without the benefit of marriage, their wages and salaries shall be owned by them in equal shares. Furthermore, the property acquired by either of them through their work or industry shall be governed by the rules on co-ownership. The law expressly deems the care and maintenance of the family and household by one partner as a valid joint contribution to the acquisition of common property, entitling both partners to equal shares.

2. Family Care Contribution
Under Philippine civil law, a stay-at-home partner in an informal cohabitation without legal impediment is not deprived of property rights simply because she did not earn a direct financial income. Article 147 of the Family Code recognizes that managing the household, taking care of the home, and nurturing the children constitute a valuable financial and economic contribution. Therefore, even if all real and personal properties were purchased exclusively from the salaries and earnings of the working partner, the domestic efforts of the stay-at-home partner guarantee her an equal fifty percent co-ownership share upon partition.

3. Support for Children
Under Articles 194 and 195 of the Family Code, parents are legally obliged to provide support to their illegitimate children. Support encompasses everything indispensable for sustenance, dwelling, clothing, medical attendance, education, and transportation in proportion to the financial resources of the obligor and the needs of the recipient. A parent's acquisition of foreign citizenship, such as German naturalization, does not extinguish or relieve him of his personal obligation to support his minor children in the Philippines, as statutory child support obligations are strictly enforced under Philippine public policy.

TopicsArticle 147 Family Code6Cohabitation Property Partition1Support for Illegitimate Children1

2018 Civil Law, Q18

Shasha purchased an airline ticket from Sea Airlines (SAL) covering Manila-Bangkok- Hanoi-Manila. The ticket was exclusively endorsable to Siam Airlines (SMA). The contract of air transportation was between Shasha and SAL, with the latter endorsing to SMA the Hanoi-Manila segment of the journey. All her flights were confirmed by SAL before she left Manila. Shasha took the flight from Manila to Bangkok on board SAL using the ticket. When she arrived in Bangkok, she went to the SAL ticket counter and confirmed her return trip from Hanoi to Manila on board SMA Flight No. SA 888. On the date of her return trip, she checked in for SMA Flight No. SA 888, boarded the plane, and before she could even settle in on her assigned seat, she was off-loaded and treated rudely by the crew. She lost her luggage and missed an important business meeting. She thereafter filed a complaint solely against SAL and argued that it was solidarily liable with SMA for the damages she suffered since the latter was only an agent of the former.
(a) Should either, or both, SAL and SMA be held liable for damages that Shasha suffered? (2.5%)
(b) Assuming that one is an agent of the other, is the agency coupled with interest? (2.5%)

Quick check

Under China Airlines v. Chiok, what is the legal liability of a ticket-issuing carrier when a passenger is wrongfully offloaded by an endorsing airline?

Under Article 1927 of the Civil Code, when is an agency considered coupled with an interest?

Why was Siam Airlines (SMA) NOT held legally liable for damages in the lawsuit filed by Shasha?

What relationship exists between a ticket-issuing airline and an endorsing carrying airline under a contract of air carriage?

Choices available with full access.

Why is an agency coupled with an interest when an airline ticket is exclusively endorsable to a specific carrying airline?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Issuing Carrier Liability
Under the doctrine established in China Airlines v. Chiok, a ticket-issuing airline remains liable as principal for the breach of a contract of carriage, even if the breach occurs on a flight segment operated by another endorsing carrier. The contract of air transportation is perfected between the passenger and the issuing carrier upon ticket purchase. The endorsing airline acts merely as an agent or subcontractor of the issuing carrier in performing the transportation. Consequently, the principal issuing carrier cannot evade liability for damages resulting from the offloading or mistreatment of a passenger by the carrying airline.

2. Agency Coupled Interest
Under Article 1927 of the Civil Code, an agency cannot be revoked if a bilateral contract depends upon it, or if it is the means of fulfilling an obligation already contracted, or if a partner is appointed manager of a partnership in the contract of partnership. An agency is coupled with an interest when the agent has a material or economic stake in the execution of the power granted. Where an airline ticket is exclusively endorsable to a specific carrying airline, both carriers possess a mutual economic interest in performing the contract of carriage.

3. Non-Impleaded Party Liability
Under Philippine civil procedure and due process, a person or entity who is not impleaded as a party defendant in a civil lawsuit cannot be held legally liable for damages. While an endorsing carrier may be jointly or solidarily liable in tort or contract, no monetary judgment or legal finding of liability can be validly rendered against it if the plaintiff chooses to file the action exclusively against the ticket-issuing carrier. Due process demands that every defendant be properly summoned and given an opportunity to present its defense.

TopicsAgency Coupled with Interest3Contract of Air Carriage Breach1Ticket-Issuing Carrier Liability1

2018 Civil Law, Q19

Sebastian, who has a pending assessment from the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR), was required to post a bond. He entered into an agreement with Solid Surety Company (SSC) for SSC to issue a bond in favor of the BIR to secure payment of his taxes, if found to be due. In consideration of the issuance of the bond, he executed an Indemnity Agreement with SSC whereby he agreed to indemnify the latter in the event that he was found liable to pay the tax. The BIR eventually decided against Sebastian, and judicially commenced action against both Sebastian and SSC to recover Sebastian’s unpaid taxes. Simultaneously, BIR also initiated action to foreclose on the bond. Even before paying the BIR, SSC sought indemnity from Sebastian on the basis of the Indemnity Agreement. Sebastian refused to pay since SSC had not paid the BIR anything yet, and alleged that the provision in the Indemnity Agreement which allowed SSC to recover from him, by mere demand, even if it (SSC) had not yet paid the creditor, was void for being contrary to law and public policy.
Can Sebastian legally refuse to pay SSC? (2.5%)

Quick check

Under Security Bank and Trust Co. v. Globe Assurance Co., when may a surety seek indemnity from the principal debtor under an express indemnity agreement?

Under Article 1306 of the Civil Code, what limits the freedom of contracting parties to establish contractual stipulations?

Under Article 2071 of the Civil Code, when may a guarantor or surety proceed against the principal debtor even before paying?

Why was Sebastian's refusal to indemnify Solid Surety Company (SSC) legally unmeritorious?

Choices available with full access.

What is the legal effect of a contractual provision allowing a surety to recover from the principal debtor upon mere demand before paying the creditor?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Indemnity Agreement Validity
Under Security Bank and Trust Co. v. Globe Assurance Co., a stipulation in an indemnity agreement allowing the surety to recover from the principal debtor as soon as liability attaches under the bond—even before actual payment by the surety to the creditor—is valid and enforceable. Such a stipulation does not violate law, morals, good customs, public order, or public policy. The liability of the indemnitor arises directly from the contractual agreement executed between the parties.

2. Freedom of Contract
Under Article 1306 of the Civil Code, contracting parties may establish such stipulations, clauses, terms, and conditions as they may deem convenient, provided they are not contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order, or public policy. An indemnity clause permitting demand upon mere accrual of liability is a valid exercise of freedom of contract. The principal debtor is bound by the terms he freely accepted when obtaining the surety bond.

3. Surety Indemnity Rights
Under Article 2071 of the Civil Code, a guarantor or surety may proceed against the principal debtor even before paying the debt when the debtor is sued for payment or when the debt becomes demandable. This statutory provision safeguards the surety against potential insolvency of the principal debtor. When coupled with an express indemnity agreement authorizing immediate recovery upon demand, the surety possesses a clear legal right to demand indemnity from the debtor.

TopicsArticle 1306 Civil Code3Indemnity Agreement Validity1Surety Bond Liability1

2018 Civil Law, Q20

Simeon was returning to Manila after spending a weekend with his parents in Sariaya, Quezon. He boarded a bus operated by the Sabbit Bus Line (SBL) on August 30, 2013. In the middle of the journey, the bus collided with a truck coming from the opposite direction, which was overtaking the vehicle in front of the truck. Though the driver of the SBL bus tried to avoid the truck, a mishap occurred as the truck hit the left side of the bus. As a result of the accident, Simeon suffered a fractured leg and was unable to report for work for one week. He sued SBL for actual and moral damages. SBL raised the defense that it was the driver of the truck who was at fault, and that it exercised the diligence of a good father of a family in the selection and supervision of its driver.
(a) Is SBL liable for actual damages? Moral damages? (2.5%)
(b) Will SBL be liable to pay interest if it is required to pay damages, and delays in the payment of the judgment award? What is the rate of interest, and from when should the interest start running? (2.5%)

Quick check

Under Article 1733 of the Civil Code, what degree of diligence is required of common carriers in transporting passengers?

Can a common carrier escape liability for passenger injury in a breach of contract suit by proving due diligence in selecting employees?

When may moral damages be awarded to a passenger in a suit for breach of contract of carriage under Article 2220?

Under Nacar v. Gallery Frames, what is the applicable legal interest rate on a final and executory monetary judgment award?

Choices available with full access.

Why was Sabbit Bus Line (SBL) held liable for actual damages to Simeon despite the collision being caused by an overtaking truck?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Extraordinary Diligence Duty
Under Article 1733 of the Civil Code, common carriers are bound to observe extraordinary diligence for the safety of the passengers transported by them, according to all the circumstances of each case. Under Article 1759, common carriers are liable for the death of or injuries to passengers through the negligence or willful acts of the former's employees. The defense of exercising the diligence of a good father of a family in the selection and supervision of employees is not available to a common carrier in an action based on culpa contractual.

2. Moral Damages Requisites
Under Article 2220 of the Civil Code, moral damages may be awarded in breaches of contract where the defendant acted fraudulently or in bad faith. In contracts of common carriage under Article 1764 in relation to Article 2206, moral damages may also be awarded if the breach results in the death of a passenger. Where a passenger suffers physical injuries in a traffic accident without any showing of bad faith, fraud, or gross negligence amounting to bad faith on the part of the carrier, moral damages cannot be validly awarded.

3. Legal Interest Computation
Under the doctrine established in Nacar v. Gallery Frames, when the judgment of the court awarding a sum of money becomes final and executory, the rate of legal interest shall be six percent per annum from such finality until its satisfaction. This interest represents the delay in the satisfaction of the judgment credit and applies to all monetary awards. The legal interest rate of six percent per annum is computed on the total judgment award, including damages, from the date the decision becomes final and executory.

TopicsArticle 1733 Civil Code1Common Carrier Extraordinary Diligence1Legal Interest Nacar Doctrine1

2017 Bar Examinations

2017 Civil Law, Q1

State whether the following marital unions are valid, void, or voidable, and give the corresponding justifications for your answer:
(a) Ador and Becky’s marriage wherein Ador was afflicted with AIDS prior to the marriage. (2%)
(b) Carlos’ marriage to Dina which took place after Dina had poisoned her previous husband Edu in order to free herself from any impediment in order to live with Carlos. (2%)
(c) Eli and Fely’s marriage solemnized seven years after the disappearance of Chona, Eli’s previous spouse, after the plane she had boarded crashed in the West Philippine Sea. (2%)
(d) David who married Lina immediately the day after obtaining a judicial decree annulling his prior marriage to Elisa. (2%)
(e) Marriage of Zoren and Carmina who did not secure a marriage license prior to their wedding, but lived together as husband and wife for 10 years without any legal impediment to marry. (2%)

Quick check

Under Article 45(6) of the Family Code, what is the legal status of a marriage where a spouse was afflicted with an incurable sexually transmitted disease prior to the wedding?

Under Article 38(9) of the Family Code, why is a marriage contracted after a party intentionally killed her prior spouse considered void ab initio?

Under Article 41 of the Family Code, what is required before a person whose spouse disappeared after an airplane crash can validly remarry?

Under Article 34 of the Family Code, when are a man and a woman exempt from obtaining a marriage license prior to their wedding?

Why is David's remarriage immediately after obtaining a judicial decree of annulment considered valid under Article 53 of the Family Code?

Learn more about these topics

1. Voidable Marriages Grounds
Under Article 45, paragraph 6 of the Family Code, a marriage may be annulled if either party was afflicted with a serious and incurable sexually transmitted disease existing at the time of the marriage. The affliction must be serious, existing prior to or at the solemnization, and incurable. Where a spouse was afflicted with AIDS prior to the wedding, the marriage is voidable, meaning it remains valid until annulled by a competent court in a direct proceeding filed by the unafflicted spouse.

2. Void Marriages Policy
Under Article 38, paragraph 9 of the Family Code, marriages contracted by any party who, with intention to marry, killed his or her spouse, or the spouse of the other party, are void ab initio for reasons of public policy. Furthermore, under Article 41, a subsequent marriage contracted by a person whose prior spouse disappeared is void for bigamy unless a judicial declaration of presumptive death was obtained prior to the celebration of the second marriage.

3. Marriage License Exemption
Under Article 34 of the Family Code, no marriage license is necessary if a man and a woman have lived together as husband and wife for at least five years without any legal impediment to marry each other during the entire period. The five-year cohabitation must be continuous, exclusive, and characterized by a public status of husband and wife. An affidavit of continuous cohabitation executed by the contracting parties and solemnizing officer substitutes for the regular marriage license requirement.

TopicsArticle 45 Family Code2Marriage License Exception1Void and Voidable Marriages1