Bar Subject: Civil Law

2012 Bar Examinations

2012 Civil Law, Q6

a) Siga-an granted a loan to Villanueva in the amount of P 540, 000.00. Such agreement was not reduced to writing. Siga-an demanded interest which was paid by Villanueva in cash and checks. The total amount Villanueva paid accumulated to P 1, 200, 000.00. Upon advice of her lawyer, Villanueva demanded for the return of the excess amount of P 660, 000.00 which was ignored by Siga-an.
1) Is the payment of interest valid? Explain. (3%)
2) Is solution indebiti applicable? Explain. (2%)
b) Eulalia was engaged in the business of buying and selling large cattle. In order to secure the financial capital, she advanced for her employees (biyaheros). She required them to surrender TCT of their properties and to execute the corresponding Deeds of Sale in her favor. Domeng Bandong was not required to post any security but when Eulalia discovered that he incurred shortage in cattle procurement operation, he was required to execute a Deed of Sale over a parcel of land in favor of Eulalia. She sold the property to her grandneice Jocelyn who thereafter instituted an action for ejectment against the Spouses Bandong.
To assert their right, Spouses Bandong filed an action for annulment of sale against Eulalia and Jocelyn alleging that there was no sale intended but only equitable mortgage for the purpose of securing the shortage incurred by Domeng in the amount of P 70, 000.00 while employed as “biyahero” by Eulalia. Was the Deed of Sale between Domeng and Eulalia a contract of sale or an equitable mortgage? Explain. (5%)

Quick check

Under Article 1956 of the Civil Code, what is required for interest on a loan to be legally demandable?

What legal principle applies when a debtor pays loan interest that was never agreed upon in writing?

If Villanueva paid P1,200,000 on a P540,000 principal loan without a written interest stipulation, how much can she recover under solutio indebiti?

Under Article 1602 of the Civil Code, when is a contract of sale presumed to be an equitable mortgage?

Choices available with full access.

Why is the deed of sale executed by Domeng in favor of Eulalia classified as an equitable mortgage rather than a true sale?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Written Interest Requirement
Under Article 1956 of the Civil Code, no interest shall be due unless it has been expressly stipulated in writing. An oral agreement or demand for interest in a contract of simple loan or mutuum is void and legally unenforceable. Consequently, any interest paid pursuant to an unwritten stipulation is considered an undue payment rather than a valid fulfillment of a civil or natural obligation.

2. Solutio Indebiti Remedy
Under Articles 1960 and 2154 of the Civil Code, if a borrower pays interest when none has been stipulated in writing, the quasi-contractual principle of solutio indebiti applies. When something is received when there is no right to demand it, and it was unduly delivered through mistake, the recipient comes under the obligation to return it. The payor may recover the full amount of undue interest paid.

3. Equitable Mortgage Presumption
Under Article 1602 of the Civil Code, a contract purporting to be an absolute sale is presumed to be an equitable mortgage when the real intention of the parties is to secure the payment of a debt or the performance of an obligation. Indicia such as executing a deed of sale to cover an employee's financial shortage demonstrate that the transaction was intended merely as security, rendering it an equitable mortgage.

TopicsArticle 1956 Civil Code2Equitable Mortgage Presumption1Solutio Indebiti2

2012 Civil Law, Q7

a) Natividad’s holographic will, which had only one (1) substantial provision, as first written, named Rosa as her sole heir. However, when Gregorio presented it for probate, it already contained an alteration, naming Gregorio, instead of Rosa, as sole heir, but without authentication by Natividad’s signature. Rosa opposes the probate alleging such lack of proper authentication. She claims that the unaltered form of the will should be given effect. Whose claim should be granted? Explain. (5%)
b) John Sagun and Maria Carla Camua, British citizens at birth, acquired Philippine citizenship by naturalization after their marriage. During their marriage, the couple acquired substantial landholdings in London and in Makati. Maria begot three (3) children, Jorge, Luisito, and Joshur. In one of their trips to London, the couple executed a joint will appointing each other as their heirs and providing that upon the death of the survivor between them, the entire estate would go to Jorge and Luisito only but the two (2) could not dispose of nor divide the London estate as long as they live. John and Maria died tragically in the London subway terrorist attack in 2005. Jorge and Luisito filed a petition for probate of their parents’ will before a Makati Regional Trial Court. Joshur vehemently objected because he was preterited.
1) Should the will be admitted to probate? Explain. (2%)
2) Are the testamentary dispositions valid? Explain. (2%)
3) Is the testamentary prohibition against the division of the London estate valid? Explain. (1%)

Quick check

Under Article 814 of the Civil Code, what is required to validate an alteration or erasure in a holographic will?

In Kalaw v. Relova, what is the legal effect if the sole heir named in a holographic will is erased by the testator and a new heir is written without authentication?

Under Articles 818 and 819 of the Civil Code, what is the status of a joint will executed by Filipino citizens in a foreign country?

What is the maximum period for which a testator may prohibit the partition of his estate under Article 1083 of the Civil Code?

Choices available with full access.

What happens to a testamentary prohibition that forbids co-heirs from dividing an estate property for as long as they live?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Will Alteration Rules
Under Article 814 of the Civil Code, any insertion, cancellation, erasure, or alteration in a holographic will must be authenticated by the full signature of the testator. As held in Kalaw v. Relova, if the alteration substitutes the sole heir and is unauthenticated, the change is void. If the cancellation of the original heir's name was made by the testator, the entire will is revoked because no heir remains. However, if the erasure was committed by a third party without authorization, the alteration is void and the original disposition in favor of the first heir remains effective.

2. Joint Will Prohibition
Under Articles 818 and 819 of the Civil Code, two or more persons cannot make a will jointly, or in the same instrument, either for their reciprocal benefit or for the benefit of a third person. This prohibition applies to Filipino citizens even if the joint will is executed in a foreign country where such wills are recognized by law. Because joint wills executed by Filipinos abroad violate public policy, they are void ab initio and cannot be admitted to probate in Philippine courts, rendering all testamentary dispositions contained therein completely void.

3. Estate Partition Limit
Under Article 1083 of the Civil Code, a testator may prohibit the partition of his estate, but such prohibition cannot extend beyond a period of twenty years. A testamentary condition or prohibition imposing a lifetime ban on the division or disposition of estate properties exceeds the statutory maximum limit. Consequently, the condition is invalid insofar as it exceeds the twenty-year period allowed by law, permitting the co-heirs to demand partition of the property after twenty years from the opening of the succession.

TopicsArticle 814 Civil Code1Joint Will Prohibition1Prohibition Against Partition1

2012 Civil Law, Q8

a) Ricky and Arlene are married. They begot Franco during their marriage. Franco had an illicit relationship with Audrey and out of which, they begot Arnel. Frnaco predeceased Ricky, Arlene and Arnel. Before Ricky died, he executed a will which when submitted to probate was opposed by Arnel on the ground that he should be given the share of his father, Franco. Is the opposition of Arnel correct? Why? (5%)
b) How can RJP distribute his estate by will, if his heirs are JCP, his wife; HBR and RVC, his parents; and an illegitimate child, SGO?

Quick check

Under Article 992 of the Civil Code, what is the legal effect of the iron curtain rule on an illegitimate grandchild's right to inherit from a legitimate grandparent?

Why is Arnel barred from opposing Ricky's will and claiming Franco's share in Ricky's estate?

When legitimate parents, an illegitimate child, and a surviving spouse concur as compulsory heirs, what is the statutory legitime of the legitimate parents under Article 889?

Under Articles 889 and 899 of the Civil Code, what share of the estate is reserved for the surviving spouse when concurring with legitimate parents and an illegitimate child?

Choices available with full access.

If RJP's compulsory heirs are his legitimate parents, surviving spouse, and an illegitimate child, what portion of his estate can he freely dispose of by will?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Iron Curtain Rule
Under Article 992 of the Civil Code, an illegitimate child has no right to inherit ab intestato from the legitimate children and relatives of his father or mother; nor shall such children or relatives inherit in the same manner from the illegitimate child. This statutory barrier, known as the iron curtain rule, prevents reciprocal intestate succession between illegitimate children and legitimate relatives of their parents. Consequently, an illegitimate child cannot represent his deceased parent in inheriting from his legitimate grandparents.

2. Concurring Compulsory Heirs
Under the Civil Code rules on testamentary succession, when legitimate parents concur with a surviving spouse and an illegitimate child, each group of compulsory heirs is entitled to a fixed statutory legitime. The legitimate parents receive one-half of the estate, the illegitimate child receives one-fourth, and the surviving spouse receives one-eighth. The total reserved legitimes amount to seven-eighths of the estate, leaving only the remaining one-eighth as the free portion.

3. Free Portion Calculation
Under Articles 889 and 899 of the Civil Code, the testator can freely dispose by will only of the remaining free portion after satisfying all compulsory legitimes. Where legitimate parents, a surviving spouse, and an illegitimate child concur, seven-eighths of the estate is strictly reserved by law for their legitimes. Consequently, the testator may freely bequeath to any person or institution only the remaining one-eighth free portion of his estate.

TopicsArticle 992 Civil Code2Barrier Principle Succession1Legitime Concurrently Concurring Heirs1

2012 Civil Law, Q9

a) Does the right to request for the issuance of a writ of possession over a foreclosed real property prescribe in five (5) years? (5%)
b) A petition for declaration of nullity of a void marriage can only be filed by either the husband or the wife? Do you agree? Explain your answer. (5%)

Quick check

Under Rule 39 of the Rules of Court, within what period must a motion for a writ of possession over a foreclosed property be filed?

What is the proper remedy of a foreclosure purchaser seeking possession after the five-year prescriptive period for a motion has expired?

Under A.M. No. 02-11-10-SC, who has exclusive legal standing to file a direct petition for declaration of absolute nullity of a void marriage?

Why are compulsory heirs precluded from filing a direct petition for declaration of nullity of marriage during the spouses' lifetime under A.M. No. 02-11-10-SC?

Choices available with full access.

Which Supreme Court issuance governs the procedure and legal standing for petitions for declaration of absolute nullity of void marriages?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Writ of Possession
Under Rule 39 of the Rules of Court and established jurisprudence, a purchaser in an extrajudicial foreclosure sale who has consolidated title may apply for a writ of possession. If the application is filed by ex parte motion, it must be requested within five years from the entry of judgment or consolidation of title. After the lapse of the five-year period, the purchaser can no longer secure a writ of possession by mere motion; instead, enforcement must be sought through an independent judicial action for recovery of possession.

2. Standing in Nullity
Under A.M. No. 02-11-10-SC, titled the Rule on Declaration of Absolute Nullity of Void Marriages and Annulment of Voidable Marriages, a direct petition for declaration of absolute nullity of a void marriage may be filed solely by the husband or the wife. This procedural rule restricts the standing to initiate a direct action for nullity strictly to the spouses during their lifetime. Third parties, such as heirs or creditors, cannot file a direct petition for declaration of nullity of marriage under this special rule.

3. Post-Prescription Remedy
When a foreclosing creditor fails to move for a writ of possession within the mandatory five-year period under Rule 39, the right to obtain possession via ex parte motion prescribes. However, the purchaser does not lose ownership or the right to possess the property. Rather, the remedy shifts from a summary motion to a plenary action such as accion publiciana or accion reivindicatoria. This independent action requires a full trial on the merits to determine lawful possession and enforce the purchaser's property rights.

TopicsAM No 02-11-10-SC Nullity1Foreclosure Writ Prescription1Rule 39 Writ of Possession1

2012 Civil Law, Q10

a) A contract to sell is the same as a conditional contract of sale. Do you agree? Explain your answer. (5%)
b) A partner cannot demand the return of his share (contribution) during the existence of a partnership. Do you agree? Explain your answer. (5%)

Quick check

What is the primary difference between a conditional contract of sale and a contract to sell regarding ownership transfer?

In a contract to sell real property, what is the legal effect of full payment of the purchase price by the buyer?

Can a general partner demand the return of his capital contribution while the partnership is actively operating?

Under Article 1857 of the Civil Code, when may a limited partner demand the return of his contribution during the partnership's existence?

Choices available with full access.

If no time is specified in the certificate for the return of a limited partner's contribution, how may the limited partner demand its return under Article 1857?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Sales Distinction
Under Philippine sales law, a contract to sell differs fundamentally from a conditional contract of sale. In a conditional contract of sale, ownership automatically passes to the buyer upon full payment of the purchase price, provided delivery has been made. Conversely, in a contract to sell, title remains with the vendor regardless of delivery until full payment, whereupon the vendor is obligated to execute a definitive deed of absolute sale.

2. General Partner Contribution
Under Article 1811 of the Civil Code, a general partner's contribution becomes part of the partnership capital and property. A general partner cannot demand the return of his capital contribution during the existence of the partnership prior to its dissolution and liquidation. The partner's right to capital is subordinate to the payment of partnership liabilities owed to third-party creditors and the satisfaction of all partnership debts.

3. Limited Partner Exception
Under Article 1857 of the Civil Code, a limited partner may rightfully demand the return of his capital contribution during the existence of the partnership under specific statutory conditions. Provided that all partnership liabilities to third parties have been paid or secured, a limited partner may demand his contribution upon the arrival of the specified dissolution date, after six months' written notice if no time is fixed, or with the consent of all partners.

TopicsArticle 1857 Partnership Contribution1Conditional Contract of Sale1Contract to Sell5