Bar Subject: Civil Law

2014 Bar Examinations

2014 Civil Law, Q11

An easement that can be acquired by prescription: (1%)
(A) Right of way
(B) Watering of an animal
(C) Lateral and subjacent support
(D) Light and view

Quick check

Under Article 620 of the Civil Code, which type of easement may be acquired by prescription of ten years?

Under Article 622 of the Civil Code, how may discontinuous easements be validly acquired?

Why is a right of way classified as a discontinuous easement under Philippine civil law?

Which of the following easements is classified as continuous and apparent, making it acquirable by prescription?

Choices available with full access.

How does the prescription period for an easement of light and view begin when a window is opened on a party wall?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Acquirable Easements
Under Article 620 of the Civil Code, continuous and apparent easements may be acquired either by virtue of a title or by prescription of ten years. A continuous easement is one whose use is or may be incessant without the intervention of any act of man, while an apparent easement is one that is made known and continually kept in view by external signs. Only easements possessing both qualities of continuity and apparentness can be acquired through acquisitive prescription under Philippine property law.

2. Discontinuous Easement Prohibition
Under Article 622 of the Civil Code, continuous non-apparent easements and discontinuous easements, whether apparent or not, can only be acquired by virtue of a title. Discontinuous easements are those used at intervals and depend upon the acts of man, such as a right of way or the watering of animals. Because their exercise relies on human intervention, long use or tolerance by the servient owner cannot ground acquisitive prescription, preventing title from being acquired without express grant.

3. Light and View
An easement of light and view is classified as a continuous and apparent easement under Philippine civil law. It allows the dominant estate to receive light and enjoy a view through openings or windows made in a wall. When opened in a party wall or on one's own wall adjoining a neighbor's property, the prescription period of ten years begins either from the time of opening or from the service of a formal prohibition, allowing acquisition of the easement by prescription.

TopicsAcquisition by Prescription1Article 620 Civil Code1Continuous Apparent Easements1

2014 Civil Law, Q12

J.C. Construction (J.C.) bought steel bars from Matibay Steel Industries (MSI) which is owned by Buddy Batungbacal. J.C. failed to pay the purchased materials worth P500,000.00 on due date. J.C. persuaded its client Amoroso with whom it had receivables to pay its obligation to MSI. Amoroso agreed and paid MSI the amount of P50,000.00. After two (2) other payments, Amoroso stopped making further payments.
Buddy filed a complaint for collection of the balance of the obligation and damages against J.C. J.C. denied any liability claiming that its obligation was extinguished by reason of novation which took place when MSI accepted partial payments from Amoroso on its behalf.
Was the obligation of J.C. Construction to MSI extinguished by novation? Why? (4%)

Quick check

Under Article 1292 of the Civil Code, what is required for an obligation to be extinguished by novation?

Under Article 1293 of the Civil Code, whose consent is indispensable for a valid novation by substitution of debtors?

What is the legal effect when a creditor accepts partial payments from a third person on behalf of the original debtor?

Why was J.C. Construction's obligation to Matibay Steel Industries NOT extinguished by novation?

Choices available with full access.

What legal relationship is created when a third party pays a debtor's obligation with the creditor's acceptance but without releasing the debtor?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Requisites of Novation
Under Article 1292 of the Civil Code, in order that an obligation may be extinguished by another which substitute the same, it is imperative that it be so declared in unequivocal terms, or that the old and the new obligations be on every point incompatible with each other. Novation is never presumed under Philippine civil law. For novation to extinguish an existing obligation, the intent to substitute the old obligation with a new legal relationship must be established by clear and convincing evidence, as animus novandi cannot be inferred from ambiguous acts.

2. Substitution of Debtors
Under Article 1293 of the Civil Code, novation which consists in substituting a new debtor in the place of the original one may be made even without the knowledge or against the will of the latter, but not without the consent of the creditor. Third-party payments or performance of an obligation do not automatically result in delegacion or expromision. For a valid substitution of debtor to release the original obligor from legal responsibility, the creditor must give express and unequivocal consent to release the old debtor from his obligation.

3. Third Party Payments
The mere acceptance by a creditor of partial payments made by a third person on behalf of the original debtor does not constitute a valid novation by substitution of debtors. Under settled jurisprudence, a creditor's acceptance of payments from a third party is regarded as a mere addition of a performance source or secondary obligor, rather than a release of the principal debtor. Without an explicit agreement releasing the original debtor from liability, the principal obligor remains fully liable for the unpaid balance of the debt.

TopicsArticle 1292 Civil Code3Article 1293 Civil Code1Novation Personal Substitution1

2014 Civil Law, Q13

Esteban and Martha had four (4) children: Rolando, Jun, Mark, and Hector. Rolando had a daughter, Edith, while Mark had a son, Philip. After the death of Esteban and Martha, their three (3) parcels of land were adjudicated to Jun. After the death of Jun, the properties passed to his surviving spouse Anita, and son Cesar. When Anita died, her share went to her son Cesar. Ten (10) years after, Cesar died intestate without any issue. Peachy, Anita’s sister, adjudicated to herself the properties as the only surviving heir of Anita and Cesar. Edith and Philip would like to recover the properties claiming that they should have been reserved by Peachy in their behalf and must now revert back to them.
Is the contention of Edith and Philip valid? (4%)

Quick check

Under Article 891 of the Civil Code, who among the following is legally capable of being a reservista in reserva troncal?

Why did no reserva troncal arise when Peachy inherited the properties upon Cesar's death?

What degree of relationship must reservatarios have relative to the prepositus under Article 891 of the Civil Code?

How must the prepositus acquire the property from an ascendant or sibling for reserva troncal to potentially apply?

Choices available with full access.

What is the legal status of property inherited by a collateral relative from a deceased nephew who died intestate without issue?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Reserva Troncal Concept
Under Article 891 of the Civil Code, reserva troncal is a special reserve created by law to preserve property within a family line. It requires that an ascendant inherit by operation of law property which a descendant acquired by gratuitous title from another ascendant or a brother or sister. The law obliges the inheriting ascendant to reserve such property for the benefit of relatives who are within the third degree and who belong to the line from which said property came.

2. Reservista Qualifications
For reserva troncal to exist, the person obliged to reserve, known as the reservista, must strictly be an ascendant of the deceased descendant or prepositus. If the property is inherited by a collateral relative, such as an aunt or uncle, rather than an ascendant, no obligation to reserve arises under Article 891. A collateral relative who succeeds to the estate takes full absolute ownership of the property free from any reservable encumbrance or statutory obligation to revert title to the line of origin.

3. Reservatarios Rights
Reservatarios are relatives within the third degree belonging to the line from which the property came who survive the prepositus. However, their contingent right to inherit reserved property depends entirely on the prior existence of a valid reserva troncal. Where the property was not inherited by an ascendant reservista, no reserve is created, and alleged reservatarios acquire no legal standing or right to demand reconveyance or reservation of the property from collateral heirs.

TopicsArticle 891 Civil Code2Reserva Troncal Requisites2Reservista Ascendant Requirement1

2014 Civil Law, Q14

A pedestrian, who was four (4) months pregnant, was hit by a bus driver while crossing the street. Although the pedestrian survived, the fetus inside her womb was aborted. Can the pedestrian recover damages on account of the death of the fetus? (1%)
(A) Yes, because of Article 2206 of the Civil Code which allows the surviving heirs to demand damages for mental anguish by reason of the death of the deceased.
(B) Yes, for as long as the pedestrian can prove that she was not at fault and the bus driver was the one negligent.
(C) No, because a fetus is not a natural person.
(D) No, if the fetus did not comply with the requirements under Article 41 of the Civil Code.

Quick check

Under Article 40 of the Civil Code, when does birth determine civil personality?

Under Article 41 of the Civil Code, what condition applies to a fetus with an intrauterine life of less than seven months?

Why can a mother NOT recover damages for the death of her four-month aborted fetus under Article 2206?

What type of civil personality does a conceived child possess prior to complete birth under Philippine law?

Choices available with full access.

While a mother cannot recover damages for the death of an unborn fetus, for what may she recover damages resulting from an aborted pregnancy caused by negligence?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Birth and Personality
Under Article 40 of the Civil Code, birth determines personality, but a conceived child shall be considered born for all purposes that are favorable to it, provided it be born later with the conditions specified in Article 41. Provisional personality is granted to an unborn fetus solely for rights that benefit it, such as receiving donations or inheritances. However, this provisional personality remains incomplete and contingent until complete separation from the mother's womb occurs under the legal conditions prescribed by law.

2. Intrauterine Life Requisites
Under Article 41 of the Civil Code, for civil personality to be acquired, the fetus must be alive at the time it is completely delivered from the mother's womb. If the fetus had an intrauterine life of less than seven months, it is not deemed born if it dies within twenty-four hours after its complete separation from the maternal womb. If the aborted fetus fails to survive these statutory conditions, it never acquires civil personality, rendering any derivative right of action non-existent.

3. Action for Damages
Because an aborted fetus that fails to satisfy Article 41 never acquires civil personality, no cause of action for its death or loss of life can accrue to the fetus or pass derivatively to its parents under Article 2206. However, while parents cannot recover damages for the loss of life of an unborn fetus per se, the mother may recover damages for the physical injuries and moral anguish directly inflicted upon her person due to the involuntary abortion caused by a tortfeasor's negligence.

TopicsArticle 40 Civil Code1Article 41 Civil Code2Provisional Civil Personality1

2014 Civil Law, Q15

Mr. Bong owns several properties in Pasig City. He decided to build a condominium named Flores de Manila in one of his lots. To fund the project, he obtained a loan from the National Bank (NB) secured by a real estate mortgage over the adjoining property which he also owned.
During construction, he built three (3) pumps on the mortgaged property to supply water to the condominium. After one (1) year, the project was completed and the condominium was turned over to the buyers. However, Mr. Bong failed to pay his loan obligation to NB. Thus, NB foreclosed the mortgaged property where the pumps were installed. During the sale on public auction of the mortgaged property, Mr. Simon won in the bidding. When Mr. Simon attempted to take possession of the property, the condominium owners, who in the meantime constituted themselves into Flores de Manila Inc. (FMI), claimed that they have earlier filed a case for the declaration of the existence of an easement before the Regional Trial Court (RTC) of Pasig City and prayed that the easement be annotated in the title of the property foreclosed by NB. FMI further claimed that when Mr. Bong installed the pumps in his adjoining property, a voluntary easement was constituted in favor of FMI.
Will the action prosper? (4%)

Quick check

Under Article 624 of the Civil Code, what serves as title for the continuation of an easement when two estates owned by one person are divided?

When does an apparent sign of easement NOT create an easement by title upon the division of two estates?

Does a foreclosure sale of a mortgaged servient lot constitute alienation within the meaning of Article 624 of the Civil Code?

Why will FMI's action for declaration of easement prosper against Mr. Simon regarding the water pump lot?

Choices available with full access.

What is the legal effect of failing to annotate an apparent sign easement on the title prior to a foreclosure sale?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Apparent Sign Easement
Under Article 624 of the Civil Code, the existence of an apparent sign of easement established by the owner of two estates is considered a title for the easement to continue actively and passively. For this legal effect to take place, two conditions must be met upon the alienation of either estate: there must be no stipulation to the contrary in the title of conveyance, and the apparent sign must not have been removed before the execution of the deed. Consequently, the easement arises by operation of law upon transfer of ownership.

2. Foreclosure and Alienation
The alienation of an estate contemplated under Article 624 includes involuntary transfers of ownership, such as mortgage foreclosures and execution sales. When a property owner mortgages one of two adjoining lots burdened by an apparent sign of easement created during unified ownership, the buyer who acquires title at a foreclosure auction takes the property subject to the existing apparent sign. Unless the sign was removed prior to the foreclosure sale or contrary provisions were stipulated in the mortgage, the easement remains fully binding upon the purchaser.

3. Easement Annotation Remedies
While an easement created under Article 624 arises by title of law upon division of ownership, the dominant estate owner may file a judicial action to declare the existence of the easement and demand its annotation on the servient estate's certificate of title. Annotation serves to provide constructive notice to third parties and future transferees. The failure to register the easement prior to foreclosure does not extinguish the right, provided the apparent sign existed openly prior to alienation and remained unremoved at the time of transfer.

TopicsArticle 624 Civil Code2Easement Apparent Sign1Water Pump Easement1