Bar Subject: Civil Law

2022 Bar Examinations

2022 Civil Law, Q26

During Remy’s pregnancy, her father Gavin executed a will bequeathing his rest house in Calatagan, Batangas to Remy’s unborn child. While Gavin and Remy, who was then seven months pregnant, were on their way to Calatagan, they figured in a car accident on December 1, 2021 which resulted in the instantaneous death of Gavin and the premature delivery of Remy on the same day. At 8:30 a.m. on December 3, 2021, the newborn baby died. Is the devise in favor of the baby valid? Explain briefly. (5 points)

Quick check

Under Article 41 of the Civil Code, when does a fetus with an intra-uterine life of at least seven months acquire civil personality?

Under Article 1025 of the Civil Code, what is required for a conceived child to be capable of succeeding to an estate?

What is the legal effect of a newborn surviving for two days after complete delivery if its intra-uterine life was seven months?

How does the Civil Code treat a fetus with an intra-uterine life of less than seven months compared to one of seven months or more?

Choices available with full access.

Why was the devise of the Calatagan rest house in favor of Gavin's unborn grandchild declared valid?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Fetus Civil Personality
Under Articles 40 and 41 of the Civil Code, a conceived child is considered born for all purposes that are favorable to it, provided it be born later with the conditions specified by law. For a fetus with an intra-uterine life of at least seven months, civil personality is acquired at the exact moment of its complete delivery from the maternal womb, provided it is alive at birth. Even if the child survives for only a short period after birth, it acquires full civil personality retrospectively from the moment of conception for all favorable civil purposes.

2. Capacity to Succeed
Under Article 1025 of the Civil Code, in order to be capable of succeeding, the heir, devisee, or legatee must be living at the time the succession opens, except in cases of representation when proper. A conceived child at the time of the death of the decedent is capable of succeeding, provided it is subsequently born alive under the conditions set forth in Article 41. The capacity to succeed is determined at the precise moment of the decedent's death, provided the legal requirements for acquiring civil personality are eventually satisfied.

3. Intra-Uterine Life Rules
Article 41 of the Civil Code distinguishes between a fetus with an intra-uterine life of less than seven months and one with an intra-uterine life of at least seven months. If the intra-uterine life was less than seven months, the fetus must survive for at least twenty-four hours after complete separation from the maternal womb to acquire personality. However, if the intra-uterine life was seven months or more, the child acquires civil personality immediately upon complete delivery, regardless of how brief its survival thereafter may be.

TopicsArticle 1025 Civil Code2Capacity to Succeed1Conceiving Fetus Civil Personality1

2022 Civil Law, Q27

[This item has two questions.] Miguel, who died single and childless, was survived by his two legitimate brothers Romy and Rolly, and his nephews Arno and Pabs, the legitimate sons of his predeceased legitimate brother Edgar. Before his death, Miguel executed a one-page notarial will, inclusive of an attestation clause and a notarial acknowledgment, with only one testamentary disposition bequeathing his entire estate to Romy and Rolly. The will was not paginated and was attested by four witnesses: Uno, Dos, Tres, and Quatro. It was the eve of Quatro’s 17 th birthday when the will was executed. The will was written in the Ilocano dialect which Miguel knew and understood, but the witnesses did not. Miguel and the witnesses signed at the end of the testamentary disposition. The attestation was also written in the Ilocano dialect which, when translated to the English language, reads as follows: “This will of Miguel was written in ONE page. We, the attesting witnesses, signed at the end of the will and at the bottom of this attestation in the presence of Miguel and of each of us.” Each of the four witnesses signed below the attestation clause. Because none of the witnesses knew and understood the Ilocano dialect, the attestation was interpreted to them by Miguel’s lawyer who was present to notarize the will.

Quick check

What is the legal effect if an attestation clause fails to state that the testator signed the will in the presence of the witnesses?

Under Article 820 of the Civil Code, what is the minimum age required for a person to be qualified as an instrumental witness to a will?

How does the presence of a 17-year-old witness affect a notarial will attested by four witnesses?

Under Article 804 of the Civil Code, in what language or dialect must a valid notarial will be written?

Choices available with full access.

Why is formal pagination not required for a one-page notarial will containing all dispositions and signatures?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Attestation Clause Requirements
Under Article 805 of the Civil Code, an attestation clause of a notarial will must explicitly state that the testator signed the will in the presence of the instrumental witnesses, and that the witnesses signed the will and every page thereof in the presence of the testator and of one another. The attestation clause serves as statutory proof of the due execution of the will. While legal rules permit liberal interpretation under Article 809, the complete omission of the statement that the testator signed in the presence of the witnesses constitutes a fatal defect that invalidates the will.

2. Qualification of Witnesses
Under Article 820 of the Civil Code, any person of sound mind and of the age of eighteen years or more, and not blind, deaf or dumb, and able to read and write, may be a witness to the execution of a will. Minors below eighteen years of age are disqualified from acting as instrumental witnesses. However, under Article 805, only three credible witnesses are required. The presence of a disqualified minor witness does not invalidate the will if there remain at least three other fully qualified instrumental witnesses who attested and signed the document.

3. Will Execution Dialect
Under Article 804 of the Civil Code, every will must be in writing and executed in a language or dialect known to the testator. It is not required that the attesting witnesses know or understand the language or dialect in which the will or the attestation clause is written, provided that the contents of the attestation clause are interpreted or translated to them at the time of execution. Where the attestation clause is interpreted to non-Ilocano speaking witnesses by the notarizing lawyer, the statutory requirement regarding language comprehension is satisfied.

TopicsArticle 805 Civil Code1Attestation Clause Defects1Notarial Will Execution1

2020-21 Bar Examinations

2020-21 The Law Pertaining to Private, Personal, and Commercial Relations, Q1

A couple executes a prenuptial agreement which principally provides that their marriage shall be valid for only five years but that it can be renewed through mutual consent negotiated at least six months before its expiration. Is this contract valid? Explain briefly.

Quick check

Under Article 1 of the Family Code, how is marriage legally defined in the Philippines?

What is the lawful subject matter that may be stipulated in a prenuptial agreement under Article 74 of the Family Code?

What is the legal effect of a prenuptial stipulation limiting the validity of a marriage to five years?

Why are parties prohibited from stipulating the duration of their marriage in a marriage settlement?

Why was the prenuptial agreement providing for a five-year marriage term declared invalid?

Learn more about these topics

1. Nature of Marriage
Under Article 1 of the Family Code, marriage is defined as a special contract of permanent union between a man and a woman. Unlike ordinary civil contracts whose terms, duration, and conditions may be freely stipulated by the contracting parties, marriage is an inviolable social institution. Its essential nature, validity, legal consequences, and incidents are governed strictly by law and public policy. Consequently, any private agreement or contractual stipulation attempting to modify, restrict, or alter the permanent nature of the marital union is void ab initio.

2. Marriage Settlements Scope
Under Article 74 of the Family Code, future spouses may execute a marriage settlement prior to the celebration of marriage exclusively to fix their property relations during the coverture. Marriage settlements are strictly limited by law to financial and property arrangements, such as choosing absolute community, conjugal partnership of gains, or complete separation of property. Spouses are legally prohibited from utilizing a prenuptial agreement to govern personal relations, alter marital duties, or impose resolutory conditions or time limits on the existence of the marriage itself.

3. Freedom of Contract
Under Article 1306 of the Civil Code, contracting parties may establish stipulations and clauses provided they are not contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order, or public policy. A prenuptial clause stipulating that a marriage expires after five years directly violates the statutory definition of marriage as a permanent union. Because the marital bond is a matter of paramount public interest, public policy prohibits individuals from treating marriage as a temporary lease or time-bound commercial agreement subject to periodic renegotiation or expiration.

TopicsArticle 1 Family Code1Marriage Settlement Limitations1Permanent Union Nature1

2020-21 The Law Pertaining to Private, Personal, and Commercial Relations, Q2

A corporation which owns a hospital was sued along with a physician for medical malpractice. The corporation moved to dismiss the case, arguing that it was only the physician, as the natural person, who could be the subject of any kind of suit. In other words, the corporation argued that it was not a legal person. Is the position of the corporation owning the hospital legally tenable? Explain briefly.

Quick check

Under Article 44 of the Civil Code, what is the legal nature of a corporation?

Under Article 46 of the Civil Code, what legal capacity is granted to corporate juridical persons?

Under Article 2180 of the Civil Code, on what legal basis may a hospital corporation be held vicariously liable for a physician's negligence?

Under the doctrine of corporate negligence, what direct duty does a hospital corporation owe to its patients?

Why was the hospital corporation's defense that it is not a legal person subject to suit rejected by the court?

Learn more about these topics

1. Juridical Person Capacity
Under Article 44 in relation to Article 46 of the Civil Code, corporations are recognized as juridical persons endowed with a legal personality separate and distinct from that of their individual members or officers. As juridical persons, corporations possess the full capacity to enter into contracts, acquire and possess property of all kinds, incur legal obligations, and bring or defend civil and criminal actions in courts of justice. Consequently, a corporate entity cannot claim immunity from suit on the ground that it is not a natural person.

2. Hospital Vicarious Liability
Under Article 2180 of the Civil Code, employers are held vicariously liable for damages caused by their employees acting within the scope of their assigned tasks. In medical malpractice litigation, a hospital corporation may be held vicariously liable for the negligent acts or omissions of attending physicians, nurses, and staff members when an employer-employee relationship exists between the hospital and the healthcare professional, or when the hospital holds out the physician as its agent under the doctrine of ostensible agency.

3. Corporate Negligence Doctrine
Under the doctrine of corporate negligence, a hospital corporation owes direct and independent duties to its patients, separate from the duties owed by individual physicians. These corporate duties include exercising reasonable care in selecting and retaining competent medical staff, supervising medical treatment provided within its facilities, and maintaining safe and adequate equipment and infrastructure. A hospital corporation that breaches these direct duties is independently liable for medical malpractice, irrespective of the individual liability of the attending physician.

TopicsArticle 44 Civil Code1Hospital Corporate Negligence2Juridical Person Capacity1

2020-21 The Law Pertaining to Private, Personal, and Commercial Relations, Q3

A wife was able to validly obtain a judicial declaration of her husband’s presumptive death after he had disappeared for 10 years. She then remarried in accordance with law. To her surprise, a few years after her remarriage, her first husband reappeared. Does the first husband’s reappearance automatically, without need of any further act, terminate the second marriage? Explain briefly.

Quick check

Under Article 42 of the Family Code, what is required to legally terminate a subsequent marriage contracted after a declaration of presumptive death?

Under Article 41 of the Family Code, what judicial remedy must a spouse obtain before contracting a valid subsequent marriage during the spouse's absence?

In SSS v. Vda. de Bailon, what was the ruling of the Supreme Court regarding the physical reappearance of an absent spouse?

Where must the affidavit of reappearance be officially recorded to terminate a subsequent marriage under Article 42?

Why was the first husband's contention that his physical reappearance automatically terminated his wife's second marriage legally incorrect?

Learn more about these topics

1. Presumptive Death Declaration
Under Article 41 of the Family Code, a marriage contracted by any person during the subsistence of a previous marriage is generally void. However, a subsequent bigamous marriage is valid if contracted after a spouse has been absent for four consecutive years, or two years in cases of danger of death, and the present spouse has a well-founded belief that the absent spouse is dead. To contract a valid subsequent marriage, the present spouse must institute a summary judicial proceeding for the declaration of presumptive death of the absent spouse without prejudice to the latter's unexpected reappearance.

2. Affidavit of Reappearance
Under Article 42 of the Family Code, the physical reappearance of the absent spouse does not automatically invalidate or terminate the subsequent marriage. For the subsequent marriage to be legally terminated, an affidavit of reappearance must be executed by the reappearing absent spouse or any interested person and recorded in the civil registry of the residence of the parties to the subsequent marriage. Statutory recording serves as notice to the public and the spouses, formally operating to dissolve the second marriage and restore the legal effects of the first marriage.

3. Presumption of Validity
In SSS v. Vda. de Bailon, the Supreme Court clarified that the physical reappearance of the absent spouse, even if known to the spouses, does not produce the legal effect of terminating the subsequent marriage in the absence of an affidavit of reappearance duly recorded in the proper civil registry. Until the statutory requirement of recording is complied with, or unless the second marriage is judicially annulled or declared void in a proper proceeding, the second marriage enjoys the presumption of validity, and the second spouse retains all rights appertaining to a lawful spouse.

TopicsAffidavit of Reappearance1Article 42 Family Code1Termination of Subsequent Marriage1