Bar Subject: Civil Law

2014 Bar Examinations

2014 Civil Law, Q16

A congregation for religious women, by way of commodatum, is using the real property owned and registered in the name of Spouses Manuel as a retreat house.
Maria, a helper of the congregation discovered a chest in the backyard. When she opened the chest, it contained several pieces of jewelry and money. (4%)
(A) Can the chest containing the pieces of jewelry and money be considered as hidden treasure?
(B) Who has the right to claim ownership of it?

Quick check

Under Article 439 of the Civil Code, what constitutes hidden treasure?

Under Article 1933 of the Civil Code, who retains ownership of real property lent under a contract of commodatum?

Under Article 438 of the Civil Code, when is a finder entitled to a one-half share of discovered hidden treasure?

Why is the chest containing jewelry found by Maria NOT considered hidden treasure under civil law?

Choices available with full access.

Who has the legal right to claim ownership of the chest of jewelry found in the backyard of the retreat house?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Hidden Treasure Requisites
Under Article 439 of the Civil Code, hidden treasure consists of any hidden and unknown deposit of money, jewelry, or other precious objects, the lawful ownership of which does not appear. For an object to be legally classified as hidden treasure, its deposit must be both hidden and unknown, and its legal owner must be undiscoverable. Where the owner of the land or deposit can be identified or presumed under property rules, the statutory presumption of hidden treasure does not apply.

2. Commodatum Bailor Rights
Under Article 1933 of the Civil Code, commodatum is a contract where one of the parties delivers to another something not consumable so that the latter may use the same for a certain time and return it. The bailor retains ownership of the property loaned. Consequently, any accession, natural fruit, or object found on the real property subject of commodatum remains under the legal ownership of the bailor-owner, as commodatum transfers only the temporary use and possession, not ownership.

3. Property Finder Rules
Under Article 438 of the Civil Code, hidden treasure belongs to the owner of the land, building, or other property on which it is found. However, when the discovery is made on the property of another or of the State or any of its subdivisions, and by chance, one-half thereof shall be allowed to the finder. If the object found is not hidden treasure because ownership is established or presumed, the finder acquires no legal right to any portion of the discovered items.

TopicsArticle 439 Civil Code1Commodatum Ownership Rights1Hidden Treasure Requisites1

2014 Civil Law, Q17

On March 30, 2000, Mariano died intestate and was survived by his wife, Leonora, and children, Danilo and Carlito. One of the properties he left was a piece of land in Alabang where he built his residential house.
After his burial, Leonora and Mariano’s children extrajudicially settled his estate. Thereafter, Leonora and Danilo advised Carlito of their intention to partition the property. Carlito opposed invoking Article 159 of the Family Code. Carlito alleged that since his minor child Lucas still resides in the premises, the family home continues until that minor beneficiary becomes of age.
Is the contention of Carlito tenable? (4%)

Quick check

Under Article 154 of the Family Code, which of the following is an indispensable requisite to be a beneficiary of a family home under Article 159?

Under Article 159 of the Family Code, how long does a family home continue after the death of the founder if there are no minor beneficiaries?

Why is Carlito's minor child Lucas NOT considered a beneficiary of Mariano's family home?

Under the Family Code, who bears the primary legal obligation to provide support to a minor child?

Choices available with full access.

What is the legal effect on the family home when the founder dies leaving heirs who are not dependent beneficiaries?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Family Home Beneficiaries
Under Article 154 of the Family Code, the beneficiaries of a family home include the husband and wife, or an unmarried head of a family, and their parents, ancestors, brothers and sisters, and legitimate or illegitimate descendants. However, to be legally recognized as a beneficiary under Article 159, three requisites must concur: the person must be among those enumerated in Article 154, must actually reside in the family home, and must depend for legal support upon the head of the family who constituted the family home.

2. Continuation of Home
Under Article 159 of the Family Code, the family home continues as such despite the death of one or both spouses or the unmarried head of the family for a period of ten years or for as long as there is a minor beneficiary. This statutory prohibition against partition aims to protect dependent beneficiaries who rely on the head of the family for support. If no qualified minor beneficiary exists who depends for support on the deceased founder, the co-heirs may demand partition upon the founder's death.

3. Legal Support Obligation
The obligation to provide legal support follows a statutory order of liability under Article 199 of the Family Code. A child's primary obligation of support rests upon his parents, not his grandparents. Consequently, a grandchild living in a family home constituted by a deceased grandparent cannot be deemed a dependent beneficiary under Article 159 when his own parent is alive and legally obligated to support him, as the grandchild does not depend on the grandparent for support.

TopicsArticle 159 Family Code1Family Home Beneficiaries1Partition of Estate1

2014 Civil Law, Q18

Spouses Magtanggol managed and operated a gasoline station on a 1,000 sq.m. lot which they leased from Francisco Bigla-awa. The contract was for a period of three (3) years. When the contract expired, Francisco asked the spouses to peacefully vacate the premises. The spouses ignored the demand and continued with the operation of the gasoline station.
One month after, Francisco, with the aid of a group of armed men, caused the closure of the gasoline station by constructing fences around it.
Was the act of Francisco and his men lawful? Why? (4%)

Quick check

Under Article 539 of the Civil Code, what right is granted to every possessor of real property?

Under Article 536 of the Civil Code, how must a person seeking to recover possession proceed against an objecting possessor?

Why was Francisco's act of using armed men to fence off the gasoline station unlawful?

What is the proper legal remedy of a lessor against a lessee who refuses to vacate after the expiration of the lease?

Choices available with full access.

What is the statutory period within which a lessor must file an action for unlawful detainer after the demand to vacate?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Protection of Possession
Under Article 539 of the Civil Code, every possessor has a right to be respected in his possession. Should he be disturbed therein, he shall be protected in or restored to said possession by the means established by the laws and the Rules of Court. This legal protection extends even to possessors in bad faith or lessees whose contracts have expired, as long as they retain actual physical possession of the property.

2. Self Help Prohibition
Under Article 536 of the Civil Code, possession cannot be acquired through force or intimidation as long as there is a possessor who objects thereto. A landowner or lessor who wishes to recover physical possession from a holdover tenant cannot resort to self-help, force, or intimidation. Taking the law into one's own hands by erecting fences or employing armed men is strictly prohibited by law.

3. Unlawful Detainer Remedy
When a lessee continues to occupy the leased premises after the expiration of the lease period and despite a demand to vacate, the lessor's legal remedy is to file an action for unlawful detainer. Under the Rules of Court, this summary action must be brought in the proper municipal trial court within one year from the date of the last demand to vacate, ensuring judicial settlement of possession.

TopicsArticle 539 Civil Code1Protection of Possession1Unlawful Detainer Action1

2014 Civil Law, Q19

Who enjoys the Right of Retention? (1%)
(A) Depositary until full payment of what may be due him in deposit.
(B) Lessee if he advances the expenses for the repair of the leased premises.
(C) Bailee if bailor owes him something.
(D) Builder in bad faith for the recovery of necessary and useful expenses.

Quick check

Under Article 1994 of the Civil Code, who among the following is expressly granted the legal right of retention over property?

Under Article 1944 of the Civil Code, why is a bailee in commodatum denied the right of retention?

What is the legal status of a builder in bad faith regarding the right of retention under Article 546 of the Civil Code?

Does a lessee enjoy a legal right of retention over leased property if he advances repair expenses?

Choices available with full access.

What type of security right does Article 1994 of the Civil Code create in favor of a depositary?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Depositary Retention Right
Under Article 1994 of the Civil Code, the depositary may retain the thing pledged until full payment of what may be due him by reason of the deposit. This right of retention operates as a statutory lien created by law to protect the depositary for indemnity, expenses, or unpaid deposit fees incurred in preserving the deposited property. Until the depositor satisfies these legal obligations in full, the depositary cannot be compelled to surrender possession of the property.

2. Bailee Retention Limitation
Under Article 1944 of the Civil Code, the bailee in a commodatum cannot retain the thing loaned on the ground that the bailor owes him something, even if it be for expenses. The law strictly limits the bailee's remedy to a personal action for recovery of debt or reimbursement. Because commodatum is essentially gratuitous and founded on personal trust, the bailee is legally denied any right of retention over the movable or immovable property.

3. Builder Lessee Exclusions
Under Article 546 and Article 1678 of the Civil Code, neither a builder in bad faith nor a lessee enjoys a right of retention over property. A builder in bad faith forfeits improvements without indemnity or retention rights. Similarly, a lessee who makes useful improvements or repairs has no right to retain the leased premises upon lease expiration, being entitled only to reimbursement or removal under specific statutory conditions.

TopicsArticle 1994 Civil Code1Depositary Lien Rights1Right of Retention2

2014 Civil Law, Q20

Mabuhay Elementary School organized a field trip for its Grade VI students in Fort Santiago, Manila Zoo, and Star City. To be able to join, the parents of the students had to sign a piece of paper that reads as follows:
“I allow my child (name of student), Grade – Section, to join the school’s field trip on February 14, 2014.
I will not file any claim against the school, administrator or teacher in case something happens to my child during the trip.”
Joey, a 7-year-old student of Mabuhay Elementary School was bitten by a snake while the group was touring Manila Zoo. The parents of Joey sued the school for damages. The school, as a defense, presented the waiver signed by Joey’s parents.
Was there a valid waiver of right to sue the school? Why? (4%)

Quick check

Under Article 6 of the Civil Code, when is a waiver of legal rights considered void and unenforceable?

Under Article 218 of the Family Code, who exercises special parental authority over minor students during a school field trip?

Why is a waiver signed by parents barring any claim against a school for field trip injuries void under Philippine law?

What standard of diligence is required of school authorities exercising special parental authority over students?

Choices available with full access.

Can a school invoke a signed parental exculpatory liability waiver as a defense against a suit for damages arising from a student's injury?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Waiver of Rights
Under Article 6 of the Civil Code, rights may be waived, unless the waiver is contrary to law, public policy, morals, good customs, or public order, or prejudicial to a third person with a right recognized by law. Waivers of liability for future negligence are generally viewed with disfavor and declared void when they conflict with statutory duties or public interest. Consequently, a broad waiver that seeks to absolve a party from exercising due diligence required by law cannot produce legal effect.

2. Special Parental Authority
Under Article 218 of the Family Code, the school, its administrators, and teachers exercise special parental authority and responsibility over minor children while under their supervision, instruction, or custody. This authority applies to all authorized school activities, whether conducted inside or outside school premises, such as field trips. School authorities are bound to exercise the proper diligence of a good father of a family to protect students from harm and injury during these school-sponsored events.

3. Exculpatory Clause Invalidity
A waiver signed by parents releasing a school from liability for any incident that may occur during a field trip is void for being contrary to public policy. Such exculpatory clauses attempt to completely extinguish the statutory special parental authority and duty of care imposed on school authorities by law. Because public policy demands the protection of minors under school custody, parents cannot validly contract away the school's legal liability for future negligence or failure to exercise required diligence.

TopicsArticle 218 Family Code2Article 6 Civil Code1Waiver of Future Negligence1