Bar Subject: Civil Law

2019 Bar Examinations

2019 Civil Law, Q12

D, an Overseas Filipino Worker, was on his way home to the Philippines after working for so many years in the Middle East. He had saved ₱100,000.00 in his local savings account which he intended to use to start up a business in his home country. On his flight home, tragedy struck as a suicide bomber blew up the plane. All the passengers, including D, died. He left behind his widowed mother M; his common-law wife, W, who is the mother of his twin sons, T and S; and his brother, B. He left no will, no debts, no other relatives, and no other properties except the money in his savings account.
Who are the heirs entitled to inherit from D and how much should each receive? Explain. (5%)

Quick check

Under Article 991 of the Civil Code, how is an intestate estate divided when surviving heirs are legitimate ascendants and illegitimate children?

What is the successional right of a common-law spouse under the Philippine rules on intestate succession?

Under the Civil Code rules on intestacy, when do collateral relatives like brothers and sisters inherit?

In the given case, how much does the surviving widowed mother M receive from D's ₱100,000.00 intestate estate?

Choices available with full access.

How much does each of the twin illegitimate sons, T and S, receive from D's ₱100,000.00 estate?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Intestate Succession Concurrence
Under Article 991 of the Civil Code, when legitimate ascendants survive together with illegitimate children in intestate succession, the estate is divided equally between the two classes of compulsory heirs. The legitimate ascendants receive one-half of the net estate, regardless of their number, while the illegitimate children divide the remaining one-half equally among themselves. This rule applies in intestacy to balance the successional rights of legitimate ascendants with those of the decedent's illegitimate progeny.

2. Common-Law Wife Exclusion
Under Philippine succession law, a common-law spouse is not a compulsory or legal heir in intestate succession. Article 887 and Article 995 of the Civil Code grant successional rights exclusively to a surviving legal spouse whose marriage was validly celebrated. Consequently, no matter how long a cohabitation lasted, a common-law wife cannot claim a share in the deceased partner's intestate estate as an heir, though she may assert co-ownership rights over properties acquired through joint work or industry during cohabitation.

3. Collateral Relative Exclusion
Under the rules of intestate succession in the Civil Code, compulsory heirs exclude collateral relatives from inheriting. Relatives in the direct line, such as legitimate ascendants and illegitimate children, possess superior successional rights over brothers, sisters, nephews, and nieces. Under Article 1003, collateral relatives inherit only in the complete absence of compulsory heirs in the direct ascending and descending lines and surviving legal spouses. Therefore, the presence of a surviving mother and illegitimate children completely excludes the decedent's brother.

TopicsArticle 991 Civil Code1Illegitimate Children Concurrence1Intestate Succession Rules2

2019 Civil Law, Q13

M, single, named his sister N in his will, as a devisee over a certain parcel of land that he owned, with the obligation of preserving the land and transferring it, upon N’s death, to her illegitimate daughter 0, who was then only a year old.
Is the condition imposed on N to preserve the land and to transmit it upon her death to O a valid case of fideicommissary substitution? Explain. (3%)

Quick check

Under Article 863 of the Civil Code, what is the essential obligation imposed on the first heir in a fideicommissary substitution?

In Article 863 of the Civil Code, how is the phrase "one degree from the heir first instituted" legally interpreted?

Does an illegitimate child satisfy the one-degree relationship requirement under Article 863 of the Civil Code?

At what point in time must both the first heir and the second heir be alive for a fideicommissary substitution to be valid?

Choices available with full access.

What right does the second heir (fideicommissarius) acquire upon the death of the testator under Article 866?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Fideicommissary Substitution Requisites
Under Article 863 of the Civil Code, a fideicommissary substitution occurs when the testator charges the first heir, known as the fiduciarius, with the obligation to preserve and transmit the inheritance, estate, or a legacy to a second heir, known as the fideicommissarius. For the substitution to be valid, the obligation to preserve and transmit must be expressly imposed, the substitution must not go beyond one degree from the first heir, and both the first and second heirs must be living at the time of the testator's death.

2. One Degree Limit
The statutory requirement under Article 863 that fideicommissary substitution must not go beyond one degree from the heir first instituted has been authoritatively interpreted by jurisprudence to refer to one degree of relationship. This means the second heir must be either a child or a parent of the first heir. Furthermore, Philippine civil law does not distinguish between legitimate and illegitimate filiation for this purpose; an illegitimate child is one degree of relationship from her parent, satisfying the one-degree limitation.

3. Rights of Fideicommissary
Under Article 866 of the Civil Code, the second heir or fideicommissarius acquires a right to the succession from the time of the testator's death, even if he or she should die before the first heir. The right of the fideicommissarius passes to his or her own heirs upon death. While the first heir enjoys the use and fruits of the property during her lifetime, ownership is ultimately vested in the second heir, who receives the property unencumbered upon the death of the first heir.

TopicsArticle 863 Civil Code1Fideicommissary Substitution1One Degree Relationship1

2019 Civil Law, Q14

Prior to his death, H, married to W, with children X, Y, and Z, executed a holographic will entirely written, dated, and signed by him. In his will, H instituted W, X, and Y as his heirs, and consequently, made testamentary dispositions in their favor. H, however, expressly disinherited Z on the ground that the latter once filed a civil case against him in order to collect a particular sum of money he previously owed Z.
(a) Was the disinheritance of Z proper? Explain. (3%)
(b) Assuming that the disinheritance of Z was improper, how will it affect the institution of heirs and testamentary dispositions made in H’s will? Explain. (3%)

Quick check

Under Article 916 of the Civil Code, how may a compulsory heir be validly disinherited?

Which of the following is a valid statutory ground for disinheriting a child under Article 919 of the Civil Code?

Why was H's disinheritance of his child Z legally improper?

What is the legal effect of an improper disinheritance under Article 918 of the Civil Code?

Choices available with full access.

What happens to devises and legacies made in a will when a compulsory heir is improperly disinherited?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Requisites of Disinheritance
Under Article 915 and Article 916 of the Civil Code, a compulsory heir may be deprived of his legitime through disinheritance only for causes expressly specified by law and effected through a valid will. The burden of proving the truth of the cause for disinheritance rests upon the other heirs of the testator if the disinherited heir denies it. If the cause relied upon by the testator is not among those enumerated under Articles 919, 920, or 921 of the Civil Code, the disinheritance is invalid and fails to deprive the heir of his compulsory legitime.

2. Collection Suit Effect
Under Article 919 of the Civil Code, the statutory grounds for disinheriting a child or descendant include an groundless accusation of a crime, attempt against life, or refusal to provide support. Filing a civil action to collect a lawful debt previously owed by the parent is a legitimate exercise of a legal right and does not constitute any of the exclusive grounds for disinheritance recognized by law. Consequently, disinheriting a child simply because he initiated a civil collection suit against his parent is legally improper and produces no legal effect against the child's compulsory right.

3. Improper Disinheritance Effect
Under Article 918 of the Civil Code, an improper or ineffective disinheritance does not render the entire will void. Instead, it annuls the institution of heirs made in the will only insofar as such institution prejudices or impairs the compulsory legitime of the improperly disinherited heir. Devises, legacies, and other testamentary dispositions made in favor of other persons remain valid and effective to the extent that they do not impair the disinherited compulsory heir's rightful share in the legitime under the law.

TopicsArticle 916 Civil Code2Article 919 Disinheritance1Improper Disinheritance Effect1

2019 Civil Law, Q15

Mr. P offered to sell his Manila Polo Club shares to Ms. Q for ₱2,500,000.00. Ms. Q accepted on the condition that their agreement will not take effect until after one (1) year. Mr. P then acceded and both of them shook hands. Excited about the prospect of acquiring Mr. P’s shares, Ms. Q approached the former and offered to pay him an earnest money equivalent to 1 % of the purchase price, which Mr. P accepted. After one (1) year, Ms. Q approached Mr. P seeking the enforcement of their agreement for Mr. P to sell his shares to her. Mr. P refused to honor their agreement, claiming that the same was covered by the Statute of Frauds because it was not reduced into writing and hence, unenforceable.
Is the position of Mr. P correct? Explain. (3%)

Quick check

Under Article 1403(2) of the Civil Code, to what type of contracts does the Statute of Frauds exclusively apply?

Under Article 1482 of the Civil Code, what is the legal significance of giving earnest money in a contract of sale?

How does the acceptance of earnest money affect an oral contract for the sale of personal property worth more than ₱500.00?

Why is the Statute of Frauds inapplicable to contracts that have been partially executed?

Choices available with full access.

Why was Mr. P's refusal to honor his oral agreement to sell his Manila Polo Club shares legally untenable?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Statute of Frauds
Under Article 1403, paragraph 2 of the Civil Code, the Statute of Frauds requires certain contracts, such as agreements not to be performed within a year or sales of personal property priced at not less than five hundred pesos, to be in writing. However, the Statute of Frauds applies exclusively to executory contracts. It does not apply to contracts that have been partially or totally executed, as partial performance takes the contract out of the Statute's coverage.

2. Earnest Money Effect
Under Article 1482 of the Civil Code, whenever earnest money is given in a contract of sale, it is considered as part of the purchase price and as proof of the perfection of the contract. Payment and acceptance of earnest money demonstrate that the parties have entered into a binding, perfected contract of sale. Consequently, the giving of earnest money constitutes partial execution of the contract, rendering the agreement enforceable even if made orally.

3. Partial Performance Exception
Partial performance takes an oral contract outside the operation of the Statute of Frauds because the purpose of the statute is to prevent fraud, not to permit a party to perpetrate fraud. When one party accepts benefits, such as earnest money or partial payment, under an oral agreement, equity prevents that party from repudiating the agreement based on lack of written form. The contract becomes fully enforceable through an action for specific performance or damages.

TopicsArticle 1403 Civil Code2Earnest Money in Sale1Statute of Frauds3

2019 Civil Law, Q16

C Corp. entered into a contract with D, Inc. for the construction of the latter’s production warehouse. In consideration thereof, D, Inc. was obliged to pay C Corp. the amount of ₱50,000,000.00 within a period of one (1) month from the time of the project’s completion. To secure the payment of the said sum, D, Inc. entered into a surety agreement with S Company.
After more than a month from the completion date of the project, C Corp. remained unpaid. Claiming that it was suffering from serious financial reverses, D, Inc. asked C Corp. for an extension of three (3) months to pay the ₱50,000,000.00 it still owed, to which C Corp. agreed. However, after more than three (3) months, D, Inc. still refused to pay. Hence, C Corp. proceeded to collect the above sum from the surety, S Company.
For its part, S Company refused the claim and raised the defense that the extension of time granted by C Corp. to D, Inc. without its consent released it from liability.
(a) Will the defense of S Company against the claim bold water? Explain. (3%)
(b) Assuming that S Company instead refused the claim on the ground that C Corp. has yet to exhaust D, Inc.’s property to satisfy the claim before proceeding against it, will this defense prosper? Explain. (2%)

Quick check

Under Article 2079 of the Civil Code, what is the legal effect when a creditor grants an extension of time to the principal debtor without the consent of the surety?

Why does an unconsented extension of time release a surety under Article 2079 of the Civil Code?

Does a surety enjoy the benefit of excussion under Philippine civil law?

What is the principal distinction between a guarantor and a surety regarding liability?

Choices available with full access.

Why was S Company released from liability to C Corp., but unable to raise the defense of excussion?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Unconsented Extension Effect
Under Article 2079 of the Civil Code, an extension granted to the principal debtor by the creditor without the consent of the guarantor or surety extinguishes the guaranty or suretyship. The rationale is that the extension alters the original obligation and deprives the surety of the right to pay the creditor upon maturity and immediately seek reimbursement from the principal debtor. Consequently, an unconsented extension granted by the creditor releases the surety from liability.

2. Benefit of Excussion
Under Article 2059, paragraph 2, in relation to Article 2047 of the Civil Code, the benefit of excussion—which requires the creditor to exhaust all properties of the principal debtor before proceeding against the guarantor—does not apply to a surety. A surety binds himself solidarily with the principal debtor, making his liability direct, primary, and absolute. Thus, a surety cannot compel the creditor to first execute against the principal debtor's assets before demanding payment.

3. Guaranty Versus Suretyship
While both guaranty and suretyship are accessory contracts securing a principal obligation, they differ fundamentally in the nature of liability and available defenses. A guarantor is secondarily liable and enjoys the benefit of excussion unless waived or excluded by law. In contrast, a surety is solidarily liable with the principal debtor and cannot claim excussion. However, both guarantors and sureties are released from liability under Article 2079 when the creditor grants an extension of time to the debtor without their consent.

TopicsArticle 2079 Civil Code1Benefit of Excussion1Suretyship Unconsented Extension1