Bar Subject: Civil Law

2015 Bar Examinations

2015 Civil Law, Q6

Kardo met Glenda as a young lieutenant and after a whirlwind courtship, they were married. In the early part of his military career, Kardo was assigned to different places all over the country but Glenda refused to accompany him as she preferred to live in her hometown. They did not live together until the 12th year of their marriage when Kardo had risen up the ranks and was given his own command. They moved to living quarters in Fort Gregorio. One day, while Kardo was away on official business, one of his military aides caught Glenda having sex with the corporal assigned as Kardo’s driver. The aide immediately reported the matter to Kardo who rushed home to confront his wife. Glenda readily admitted the affair and Kardo sent her away in anger. Kardo would later come to know the true extent of Glenda’s unfaithfulness from his aides, his household staff, and former neighbors who informed him that Glenda has had intimate relations with various men throughout their marriage whenever Kardo was away on assignment.
Kardo filed a petition for declaration of nullity of marriage under Article 36. Based on interviews from Kardo, his aide, and the housekeeper, a psychologist testified that Glenda’s habitual infidelity was due to her affliction with Histrionic Personality Disorder, an illness characterized by excessive emotionalism and uncontrollable attention-seeking behavior rooted in Glenda’s abandonment as a child by her father. Kardo himself, his aide, and his housekeeper also testified in court. The RTC granted the petition, relying on the liberality espoused by Te v. Te and Azcueta v. Republic. However, the OSG filed an appeal, arguing that sexual infidelity was only a ground for legal separation and that the RTC failed to abide by the guidelines laid down in the Molina case. How would you decide the appeal? (5%)

Quick check

Under Article 36 of the Family Code as re-examined in Tan-Andal v. Andal, how is psychological incapacity defined?

When does sexual infidelity constitute psychological incapacity under Article 36 rather than a mere ground for legal separation?

Is a personal psychiatric examination of the respondent spouse mandatory to prove psychological incapacity under current jurisprudence?

What character of incurability is required to establish psychological incapacity under Article 36 of the Family Code?

Choices available with full access.

Why did the RTC correctly grant Kardo's petition for declaration of nullity of marriage against Glenda?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Psychological Incapacity Requisites
Under Article 36 of the Family Code, as refined in Tan-Andal v. Andal, psychological incapacity is a legal concept referring to durable personality structures that render a spouse truly incognizant of essential marital obligations. It is no longer required to be a medical illness. The incapacity must be proven by the totality of evidence showing that it was antecedent, grave, and legally incurable. Although sexual infidelity alone is a ground for legal separation, it may manifest psychological incapacity when caused by an underlying personality disorder.

2. Totality of Evidence
In actions for declaration of absolute nullity of marriage under Article 36, personal examination of the respondent spouse by a physician or psychologist is not an indispensable requirement. The testimony of the petitioning spouse, along with corroborating witnesses such as household staff and military aides, combined with expert psychiatric evaluation based on comprehensive third-party interviews, can sufficiently establish the presence of psychological incapacity.

3. Molina Guidelines Modification
The rigid evidentiary guidelines set forth in the Molina case have been modified by subsequent jurisprudence to embrace a more holistic legal approach. Psychological incapacity does not require clinical permanence in the medical sense, but rather legal incurability, meaning the enduring personality structure of the spouse is so deeply rooted that compliance with essential marital duties is legally impossible.

TopicsArticle 36 Family Code8Psychological Incapacity3Tan-Andal v. Andal2

2015 Civil Law, Q7

Mr. and Mrs. X migrated to the US with all their children. As they had no intention of coming back, they offered their house and lot for sale to their neighbors, Mr. and Mrs. A (the buyers) who agreed to buy the property for 128 Million. Because Mr. and Mrs. A needed to obtain a loan from a bank first, and since the sellers were in a hurry to migrate, the latter told the buyers that they could already occupy the house, renovate it as it was already in a state of disrepair, and pay only when their loan is approved and released. While waiting for the loan approval, the buyers spent .Pl Million in repairing the house. A month later, a person carrying an authenticated special power of attorney from the sellers demanded that the buyers either immediately pay for the property in full now or vacate it and pay damages for having made improvements on the property without a sale having been perfected.
a) What are the buyers’ options or legal rights with respect to the expenses they incurred in improving the property under the circumstances? (3%)
b) Can the buyers be made to immediately vacate on the ground that the sale was not perfected? Explain briefly. (3%)

Quick check

What legal right is enjoyed by a possessor in good faith who incurs necessary and useful expenses on real property?

Under Article 1475 of the Civil Code, when is a contract of sale perfected between contracting parties?

Can buyers who occupied and renovated a house with the owners' express consent be immediately evicted as trespassers?

Under Article 546 of the Civil Code, what expenses are possessors in good faith entitled to be reimbursed for?

Choices available with full access.

What is the status of the sale between Mr. and Mrs. X and Mr. and Mrs. A upon agreeing on the price and property?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Good Faith Possessor
Under Article 448 and Article 546 of the Civil Code, a possessor or builder in good faith is one who occupies land and builds or makes improvements thereon with the belief that he has a valid right to do so, or under express authorization from the owner. Possessors in good faith are entitled to reimbursement for all necessary and useful expenses incurred on the property. Furthermore, they enjoy the statutory right of retention, allowing them to retain possession of the premises until full reimbursement is paid.

2. Right of Retention
Under Article 546 of the Civil Code, the right of retention serves as a security device for possessors in good faith who have introduced necessary or useful improvements on another's real property. Until the landowner reimburses the full amount of necessary and useful expenses, or elects to appropriate the useful improvements by paying their indemnity, the possessor in good faith cannot be legally compelled to vacate the premises or pay rent for their temporary occupation.

3. Perfection of Sale
Under Article 1475 and Article 1319 of the Civil Code, a contract of sale is consensual and is perfected at the moment there is a meeting of minds upon the object of the contract and upon the price. The delivery of physical possession to the buyers, coupled with an agreement on a definite purchase price and deferred payment terms pending bank loan release, confirms that a valid and binding contract of sale was perfected, preventing unilateral demand for immediate eviction.

TopicsPerfection of Sale2Possessor in Good Faith1Right of Retention2

2015 Civil Law, Q8

X, Y, Z are siblings who inherited a IO-storey building from their parents. They agreed in writing to maintain it as a co-owned property for leasing out and to divide the net profits among themselves equally for a period of 20 years. On the 8th year, X wanted to get out of the co-ownership so he could get his 1/3 share in the property. Y and Z refused, saying X is bound by their agreement to keep the co-ownership for 20 years. Are Y and Z correct? Explain. (3%)

Quick check

Under Article 494 of the Civil Code, what is the maximum allowable period for co-owners to validly agree to keep property undivided?

What is the legal effect of an agreement among co-owners prohibiting partition for twenty years?

When may a co-owner demand partition of common property if an agreement prohibits partition for ten years?

How may co-owners extend an agreement prohibiting partition beyond the initial ten-year limit?

Choices available with full access.

Why are Y and Z only partly correct in refusing X's demand for partition on the 8th year of their 20-year agreement?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Co-ownership Partition Limit
Under Article 494 of the Civil Code, no co-owner is obliged to remain in a co-ownership, as each co-owner may demand the partition of the common property at any time. However, co-owners may validly execute an agreement to keep the property undivided for a period not exceeding ten years. If the co-owners stipulate a prohibition against partition for a period longer than ten years, the agreement is not entirely void; rather, it remains valid up to the statutory ten-year limit and is void only as to the excess period.

2. Partition Prohibition Renewal
While Article 494 of the Civil Code caps any single agreement prohibiting partition at ten years, the co-owners may extend or renew the agreement by executing a new contract upon the expiration of the original term. This extension allows co-owners to continue maintaining the property undivided for another period not exceeding ten years. Without a formal renewal or extension executed after the ten-year period expires, any individual co-owner recovers the immediate legal right to demand the judicial or extrajudicial partition of the common property.

3. Inherited Estate Partition
Under Article 1083 of the Civil Code, co-heirs who inherit real property from a common estate may agree to keep the inherited property undivided for a period not exceeding ten years, renewable by a new agreement. This rule mirrors Article 494 to maintain a balance between contractual freedom among co-heirs and the policy against perpetual co-ownership. Therefore, an agreement among co-heirs to maintain an inherited building undivided for twenty years legally binds them only for the first ten years, allowing partition thereafter.

TopicsArticle 494 Civil Code2Co-ownership Partition Limit1Stipulation Against Partition1

2015 Civil Law, Q9

Jose, single, donated a house and lot to his only niece, Maria, who was of legal age and who accepted the donation. The donation and Maria’s acceptance thereof were evidenced by a Deed of Donation. Maria then lived in the house and lot donated to her, religiously paying real estate taxes thereon. Twelve years later, when Jose had already passed away, a woman claiming to be an illegitimate daughter of Jose filed a complaint against Maria. Claiming rights as an heir, the woman prayed that Maria be ordered to reconvey the house and lot to Jose’s estate. In her complaint she alleged that the notary public who notarized the Deed of Donation had an expired notarial commission when the Deed of Donation was executed by Jose. Can Maria be made to reconvey the property? What can she put up as a defense? (4%)

Quick check

Under Article 749 of the Civil Code, what is the formal requirement for the validity of a donation of real property?

What is the legal effect on a deed of donation if the notarizing notary public had an expired commission?

Under Article 1134 of the Civil Code, how many years of adverse possession in good faith are required for ordinary acquisitive prescription of real property?

What serves as just title for ordinary acquisitive prescription in favor of a donee who possesses real property under a void deed of donation?

Choices available with full access.

Why is Maria protected against the reconveyance suit filed by Jose's alleged illegitimate daughter twelve years after taking possession?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Donation Public Instrument
Under Article 749 of the Civil Code, a donation of real property must be made in a public document specifying the property donated and the value of charges. If the notary public who notarized the deed had an expired notarial commission at the time of execution, the document fails to qualify as a valid public instrument. Consequently, the donation of the real property is rendered void for failure to comply with statutory solemnities. However, the void deed still constitutes a written contract capable of serving as colorable title for acquisitive prescription.

2. Acquisitive Prescription Requisites
Under Articles 1117, 1134, and 1137 of the Civil Code, ownership over real property may be acquired through acquisitive prescription. Ordinary acquisitive prescription requires continuous, uninterrupted, open, adverse, and public possession of an immovable in good faith and with just title for a period of ten years. Just title does not mean a valid title, but one that is colorable or sufficient to transfer ownership had the grantor been the true owner. Good faith consists of the reasonable belief that the person from whom the property was received was the owner.

3. Reconveyance Bar
An action for reconveyance of real property based on implied trust or succession rights is barred when the possessor has already acquired title over the property by acquisitive prescription. Where a donee possesses a house and lot in good faith under a defective deed of donation for twelve years, her ten-year possession ripens into absolute ownership. Consequently, the legal heirs of the deceased donor can no longer compel the donee to reconvey the property to the estate, as prescription extinguishes the estate's reversionary claims.

TopicsAcquisitive Prescription2Article 749 Civil Code2Void Donation Colorable Title1

2015 Civil Law, Q10

X, a dressmaker, accepted clothing materials from Karla to make two dresses for her. On the day X was supposed to deliver Karla’s dresses, X called up Karla to say that she had an urgent matter to attend to and will deliver them the next day. That night, however, a robber broke into her shop and took everything including Karla’s two dresses. X claims she is not liable to deliver Karla’s dresses or to pay for the clothing materials considering she herself was a victim of the robbery which was a fortuitous event and over which she had no control. Do you agree? Why? (3%)

Quick check

Under Article 1718 of the Civil Code, who bears the loss of materials destroyed by a fortuitous event before delivery in a contract for a piece of work where the customer provided the materials?

Under Article 1174 of the Civil Code, what is the general legal effect of a fortuitous event on a contractual obligation?

When does a debtor incur in legal delay (mora) under Article 1169 of the Civil Code?

Why was X not in legal delay when the robbery occurred at her dressmaking shop?

Choices available with full access.

What is the status of X's obligation to deliver Karla's dresses after the shop was robbed without X's fault or delay?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Civil Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Contract Piece Work
Under Article 1717 and Article 1718 of the Civil Code, a contract for a piece of work occurs when a person executes work for another for a price. If the contractor furnishes only her labor or skill and the customer supplies the materials, the risk of loss of the materials prior to delivery is borne by the owner of the materials. If the materials are lost or destroyed by a fortuitous event without fault or delay on the part of the contractor, the contractor's obligation to complete and deliver the work is extinguished.

2. Fortuitous Event Effect
Under Article 1174 of the Civil Code, no person shall be responsible for events which could not be foreseen or which, though foreseen, were inevitable. To exempt an obligor from liability due to a fortuitous event, the cause of the breach must be independent of human will, the event must render it impossible to fulfill the obligation in a normal manner, and the obligor must be free from concurrent negligence or delay. Robbery with force or violence constitutes a fortuitous event that extinguishes contractual obligations.

3. Mora Solvendis Delay
Under Article 1169 of the Civil Code, obligors incur in delay from the time the obligee judicially or extrajudicially demands the fulfillment of their obligation. If the creditor agrees or consents to a postponed delivery date, the debtor is not in legal delay (mora). Because an obligor who is not in delay is not liable for loss due to fortuitous events under Article 1165, an agreed postponement protects the contractor when a robbery occurs during the extended delivery period.

TopicsArticle 1718 Civil Code1Contract for Piece of Work1Fortuitous Event Loss1