State whether the following marital unions are valid, void, or voidable, and give the corresponding justifications for your answer:
(a) Ador and Becky’s marriage wherein Ador was afflicted with AIDS prior to the marriage. (2%)
(b) Carlos’ marriage to Dina which took place after Dina had poisoned her previous husband Edu in order to free herself from any impediment in order to live with Carlos. (2%)
(c) Eli and Fely’s marriage solemnized seven years after the disappearance of Chona, Eli’s previous spouse, after the plane she had boarded crashed in the West Philippine Sea. (2%)
(d) David who married Lina immediately the day after obtaining a judicial decree annulling his prior marriage to Elisa. (2%)
(e) Marriage of Zoren and Carmina who did not secure a marriage license prior to their wedding, but lived together as husband and wife for 10 years without any legal impediment to marry. (2%)
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
(a) Voidable; (b) Void; (c) Void; (d) Valid; (e) Valid.
Under Article 45(6) of the Family Code, an incurable sexually transmitted disease renders marriage voidable. Article 38(9) voids marriages where a party killed a spouse. Article 41 voids bigamous marriages without a presumptive death decree. Article 53 voids remarriages non-compliant with Article 52. Article 34 exempts 5-year cohabitants from a license.
Here, Ador's AIDS renders the union voidable. Dina's poisoning voids her marriage for public policy. Eli's marriage is void for lacking a presumptive death decree. David's union is valid absent unpartitioned property or children, while Zoren and Carmina's 10-year cohabitation exempts them from a license.
Therefore, (a) is voidable, (b) and (c) are void, whereas (d) and (e) are valid.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
Under Article 45(6) of the Family Code, what is the legal status of a marriage where a spouse was afflicted with an incurable sexually transmitted disease prior to the wedding?
Under Article 45(6) of the Family Code, an incurable sexually transmitted disease existing prior to marriage renders the union voidable.
Under Article 38(9) of the Family Code, why is a marriage contracted after a party intentionally killed her prior spouse considered void ab initio?
Under Article 38(9), a marriage contracted by one who killed a spouse to marry another is void for reasons of public policy.
Under Article 41 of the Family Code, what is required before a person whose spouse disappeared after an airplane crash can validly remarry?
Article 41 requires obtaining a judicial declaration of presumptive death before celebrating a valid subsequent marriage.
Under Article 34 of the Family Code, when are a man and a woman exempt from obtaining a marriage license prior to their wedding?
Article 34 exempts couples from securing a marriage license if they have cohabited for at least five years without legal impediment.
Why is David's remarriage immediately after obtaining a judicial decree of annulment considered valid under Article 53 of the Family Code?
David's marriage is valid under Article 53 because there were no property or child custody obligations requiring prior recording under Article 52.
Learn more about these topics
1. Voidable Marriages Grounds
Under Article 45, paragraph 6 of the Family Code, a marriage may be annulled if either party was afflicted with a serious and incurable sexually transmitted disease existing at the time of the marriage. The affliction must be serious, existing prior to or at the solemnization, and incurable. Where a spouse was afflicted with AIDS prior to the wedding, the marriage is voidable, meaning it remains valid until annulled by a competent court in a direct proceeding filed by the unafflicted spouse.
2. Void Marriages Policy
Under Article 38, paragraph 9 of the Family Code, marriages contracted by any party who, with intention to marry, killed his or her spouse, or the spouse of the other party, are void ab initio for reasons of public policy. Furthermore, under Article 41, a subsequent marriage contracted by a person whose prior spouse disappeared is void for bigamy unless a judicial declaration of presumptive death was obtained prior to the celebration of the second marriage.
3. Marriage License Exemption
Under Article 34 of the Family Code, no marriage license is necessary if a man and a woman have lived together as husband and wife for at least five years without any legal impediment to marry each other during the entire period. The five-year cohabitation must be continuous, exclusive, and characterized by a public status of husband and wife. An affidavit of continuous cohabitation executed by the contracting parties and solemnizing officer substitutes for the regular marriage license requirement.