A, B, and C are co-owners of a three-hectare agricultural land with a fair market value of PHP 9 million or PHP 3 million per hectare. A offered to sell his share to B and C for a total amount of PHP 10 million. B and C declined the offer and asked A to reduce the purchase price to PHP 3 million, the prevailing fair market value of the land per hectare. A refused and instead sold his one-hectare share to X for PHP 10 million. May B and C go to court for the reduction of the purchase price so they can exercise their right of legal redemption? Reason(s).
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
Yes, B and C may go to court for the reduction of the purchase price.
Under Article 1620 of the Civil Code, a co-owner may exercise the right of legal redemption when the share of another co-owner is sold to a third person. The law explicitly provides that if the price of the alienation is grossly excessive, the redemptioner shall pay only a reasonable price.
Here, A sold his one-hectare share, valued at PHP 3 million, to X for PHP 10 million—an amount more than three times its market value, making the price grossly excessive. To prevent collusion or evasion designed to defeat the right of legal redemption, B and C are entitled to seek judicial determination to reduce the price to a reasonable amount.
Therefore, B and C may go to court to reduce the purchase price to a reasonable one so they can exercise legal redemption.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
Under Article 1620 of the Civil Code, when may a co-owner exercise the right of legal redemption?
Article 1620 grants a co-owner the right of legal redemption when another co-owner's share is sold to a third person.
What amount must a redeeming co-owner pay under Article 1620 if the price of the sale to a third person is grossly excessive?
Article 1620 explicitly provides that if the price of the alienation is grossly excessive, the redemptioner shall pay only a reasonable price.
What is the underlying public policy behind granting co-owners the right of legal redemption under Philippine civil law?
The law favors reducing co-ownership and preventing strangers from entering the co-ownership community.
What remedy is available to co-owners if a selling co-owner and a buyer collude to fix an exorbitant price to block legal redemption?
Co-owners may seek judicial determination to reduce a grossly excessive purchase price to a reasonable amount.
Which of the following is a requisite for the exercise of legal redemption by a co-owner under Article 1620?
For legal redemption under Article 1620 to apply, the sale of the undivided share must be made to a third person.
Learn more about these topics
1. Legal Redemption
Under Article 1620 of the Civil Code, a co-owner has the legal right to redeem the share of another co-owner that is sold to a third person. Legal redemption among co-owners aims to minimize co-ownership, which the law considers inherently precarious, and to avoid introducing an unwanted stranger into the co-ownership. To exercise this right, the property must be owned in common, the share must be sold to a non-co-owner, and the redemption must be exercised within the statutory thirty-day period following written notice of the sale.
2. Grossly Excessive Price
Under Article 1620 of the Civil Code, if the purchase price of the alienated co-owner's share is grossly excessive, the redemptioner is not obligated to pay the inflated contract price but shall pay only a reasonable price. This provision prevents a selling co-owner and a third-party buyer from colluding to fix an exorbitant or simulated purchase price specifically designed to frustrate and defeat the remaining co-owners' legal right of redemption. In such instances, the court may intervene upon proper petition to determine and fix the fair and reasonable redemption price.
3. Co-Ownership Redemption
The primary policy underlying the right of legal redemption among co-owners is to reduce the number of co-owners and ultimately terminate the community of property. Co-ownership is often a source of discord and inefficient property administration. By granting co-owners a preferential right to acquire a selling co-owner's undivided share at a reasonable price, the law seeks to consolidate ownership in fewer hands. This public policy rationale justifies judicial intervention to adjust unconscionable contract prices that would otherwise effectively bar co-owners from exercising their statutory redemption privilege.