Bar Subject: Commercial Law

2017 Bar Examinations

2017 Mercantile Law, Q5

A. Under the Nell Doctrine, so called because it was first pronounced by the Supreme Court in the 1965 ruling in Nell v. Pacific Farms, Inc. (15 SCRA 415), the general rule is that where one corporation sells or otherwise transfers all of its assets to another corporation, the latter is not liable for the debts and liabilities of the transferor.
State the exceptions to the Nell Doctrine. (4%)
B. Santorini Corporation (Santorini) was in dire straits. In order to firm up its financial standing, it agreed to entertain the merger and takeover offer of Proficient Corporation (Proficient), the leading company in their line of business. Erica, the major stockholder of Santorini, strongly opposed the merger and takeover. The matter of the merger and takeover by Proficient was included in the agenda of the next meeting of Santorini’s Board of Directors. However, owing to Erica’s serious illness that required her to seek urgent medical treatment and care in Singapore, she failed to attend the meeting and was consequently unable to cast her vote. The Board of Directors approved the merger and takeover. At the time of the meeting, Santorini had been in the red for a number of years owing to its recurring business losses and reverses.
Erica seeks your legal advice regarding her right as a stockholder opposed to the corporate action. Explain your answer. (4%)
C. Samito is the President and a Director of Lucky Bank (Lucky}, a commercial bank holding its main office in Makati. His brother, Othello, owned a big fishing business based in Malabon. Othello applied for a loan of PSO Million with Lucky. Othello followed the ordinary banking procedures in all the stages of the processing of his application. When required, he made the necessary arrangements to guarantee the loan. Thus, in addition to the real estate mortgage, Othello executed a joint and solidary suretyship, issued postdated checks, and submitted all other requirements prescribed by Lucky.
When the loan application was about to be approved and the proceeds released, BG Company, a keen competitor of Othello in the fishing industry, wrote to the Board of Directors and the management of Lucky questioning the loan on the ground of conflict of interest due to Samito and Othello being brothers, citing the legal restriction against bank exposure of directors, officers, stockholders or their related interests (DOSRI).
(a) What are the three restrictions imposed by law on DOSRI transactions? (4%)
(b) Is BG Company’s opposition based on conflict of interest and violation of the restrictions on DOSRI transactions legally and factually correct? Explain your answer. (4%)

Quick check

Under the Nell Doctrine, when does an asset-buyer corporation become liable for the transferor's corporate debts?

What condition must a dissenting stockholder satisfy to validly exercise her appraisal right in a corporate merger?

What are the three main statutory restrictions imposed on DOSRI transactions under Section 36 of R.A. No. 8791?

Why is BG Company's opposition to Othello's loan application based on DOSRI restrictions legally unmeritorious?

Which primary statutes govern corporate mergers, appraisal rights, and bank DOSRI restrictions in the Philippines?

Learn more about these topics

1. Nell Doctrine Exceptions
Under the Nell Doctrine established in jurisprudence and the Revised Corporation Code, a corporation that purchases or acquires all the assets of another corporation is generally not liable for the seller's liabilities. However, four well-defined exceptions exist where liability attaches: first, where the purchasing corporation expressly or impliedly agrees to assume such debts; second, where the transaction amounts to a consolidation or merger; third, where the buyer corporation is a mere continuation of the seller corporation; and fourth, where the transaction is fraudulently entered into to escape liability for corporate obligations.

2. Stockholder Appraisal Right
Under Section 80 and Section 81 of the Revised Corporation Code of the Philippines (Republic Act Number 11232), a stockholder has the right to dissent and demand payment of the fair value of his shares in specific major corporate actions, including a merger or consolidation. To validly exercise this appraisal right, the stockholder must have voted against the proposed corporate action or submitted a written dissent. If a stockholder fails to attend the meeting or cast a vote against the merger due to illness or absence, she must submit a formal written dissent to preserve her appraisal right.

3. DOSRI Loan Restrictions
Under Section 36 of the General Banking Law of 2000 (Republic Act Number 8791), directors, officers, stockholders, and their related interests (DOSRI) are subject to three strict legal restrictions: procedural approval by the majority of the board of directors excluding the borrowing director, individual and aggregate ceiling limits on total accommodation, and arm's-length commercial terms. Related interests include a director's spouse and relatives within the first degree of consanguinity or affinity. A sibling, being a second-degree relative, is not covered under statutory DOSRI rules unless BSP rules apply.

TopicsDOSRI Loan Restrictions1Nell Doctrine1Stockholder Appraisal Right1

2017 Mercantile Law, Q6

A. Hortencio owned a modest grocery business in Laguna. Because of the economic downturn, he incurred huge financial liabilities. He remained afloat only because of the properties inherited from his parents who had both come from landed families in Laguna. His main creditor was Puresilver Company (Puresilver), the principal supplier of the merchandise sold in his store. To secure his credit with Puresilver, he executed a real estate mortgage with a dragnet clause involving his family’s assets worth several millions of pesos.
Nonetheless, Hortencio, while generally in the black, now faces a situation where he is unable to pay his liabilities as they fall due in the ordinary course of business. What will you advise him to do to resolve his dire financial condition? Explain your answer. (5%)
B. Wyatt, an internet entrepreneur, engaged in a sideline business of creating computer programs for selected clients on a per project basis and for servicing basic computer problems of his friends and family members. His main job was being an IT consultant at Futurex Co., a local computer company.
Because of his ill-advised investments in the stock market and the fraud perpetrated against him by his trusted confidante, Wyatt was already drowning in debt, that is, he had far more liabilities than his entire assets.
What legal recourse remained available to Wyatt? Explain your answer. (5%)

Quick check

Under Section 94 of the Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act, when may an individual debtor file for suspension of payments?

What is the proper legal remedy under Section 103 of R.A. No. 10142 for an individual debtor whose liabilities exceed his assets?

Why is suspension of payments the appropriate remedy for Hortencio under the Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act?

Why is voluntary liquidation the appropriate legal recourse for Wyatt?

Choices available with full access.

Which primary statute governs suspension of payments, individual liquidation, and court-supervised rehabilitation in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Suspension of Payments
Under Section 94 of the Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act of 2010 (Republic Act Number 10142), an individual debtor who possesses sufficient property to cover all his debts but foresees the impossibility of meeting them when they respectively fall due may file a petition for suspension of payments. This court-supervised procedure allows an illiquid individual debtor to petition the court for a temporary suspension of payments and a stay of execution proceedings while agreeing with creditors on a feasible payment schedule or debt adjustment plan, thereby protecting his solvent assets from premature liquidation.

2. Voluntary Insolvency Liquidation
Under Section 103 of Republic Act Number 10142, an individual debtor whose liabilities exceed his total assets and who is financially insolvent may file a petition for voluntary liquidation with the Regional Trial Court. The filing of the petition establishes an act of insolvency, leading to the liquidation of the debtor's non-exempt assets by a court-appointed liquidator for equitable distribution among creditors. Upon completion of the liquidation proceedings and distribution of assets, the insolvent individual debtor obtains a full discharge from all dischargeable debts and financial liabilities.

3. Sole Proprietorship Rehabilitation
Under Section 12 of the Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act, a sole proprietorship registered with the Department of Trade and Industry may petition for court-supervised corporate rehabilitation if it meets the statutory criteria of a debtor enterprise. While individual debtors generally utilize suspension of payments or voluntary liquidation, a sole proprietorship operating an ongoing commercial business may seek financial rehabilitation to suspend claims and restructure its commercial obligations under a court-approved rehabilitation plan, provided it demonstrates operational viability.

TopicsFinancial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act4Suspension of Payments2Voluntary Liquidation1

2017 Mercantile Law, Q7

A. Virtucio was a composer of llocano songs who has been quite popular in the llocos Region. Pascuala is a professor of music in a local university with special focus on indigenous music. When she heard the musical works of Virtucio, she purchased a CD of his works. She copied the CD and sent the second copy to her Music instructions for the class to listen to the CD and analyze the works of Virtucio.
Did Pascuala thereby infringe Virtucio’s copyright? Explain your answer. (4%)
B. Super Biology Corporation (Super Biology) invented and patented a miracle medicine for the cure of AIDS. Being the sole manufacturer, Super Biology sold the medicine at an exorbitant price. Because of the sudden prevalence of AIDS cases in Metro Manila and other urban areas, the Department of Health (DOH) asked Super Biology for a license to produce and sell the AIDS medicine to the public at a substantially lower price. Super Biology, citing the huge costs and expenses incurred for research and development, refused.
Assuming you are asked your opinion as the legal consultant of the DOH, discuss how you will resolve the matter. (4%)

Quick check

Under Section 185 of the Intellectual Property Code, what constitutes non-infringing fair use of a copyrighted work?

Under Section 93 of Republic Act Number 8293, under what condition may the Intellectual Property Office grant a compulsory patent license?

Why is Professor Pascuala not liable for copyright infringement when she copied Virtucio's CD for her music class?

What legal action should the Department of Health take to address Super Biology Corporation's exorbitant pricing of patented AIDS medicine?

Choices available with full access.

Which primary statute governs copyrights, patents, fair use, and compulsory licensing in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Copyright Fair Use
Under Section 185 of the Intellectual Property Code of the Philippines (Republic Act Number 8293), the fair use of a copyrighted work for criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching including multiple copies for classroom use, scholarship, or research is not an infringement of copyright. In determining whether the use made of a work in any particular case is a fair use, factors such as the purpose and character of the use, the nature of the copyrighted work, the amount used, and the effect upon the potential market are considered. Educational, non-profit copying for classroom analysis qualifies as non-infringing fair use.

2. Compulsory Patent License
Under Section 93 of Republic Act Number 8293, as amended, the Director General of the Intellectual Property Office may grant a compulsory license to exploit a patented invention without the agreement of the patent owner under specified statutory circumstances. Compulsory licensing is authorized when a national emergency or other circumstances of extreme urgency exist, or where public interest, particularly national security, nutrition, health, or the development of other vital sectors so requires. The patent owner receives reasonable remuneration, but cannot block the government from licensing the life-saving medicine to address a public health crisis.

3. Government Patent Use
Under Section 74 of Republic Act Number 8293, a government agency or third person authorized by the government may exploit a patented invention even without agreement of the patent owner where the public interest, particularly national security, nutrition, health, or the development of other vital sectors so requires. In cases of public health necessity, the Department of Health may petition the Intellectual Property Office for government use or compulsory licensing of patented pharmaceuticals to ensure public access to affordable miracle medicines during widespread health emergencies.

TopicsCompulsory Licensing1Copyright Fair Use1Intellectual Property Code11

2017 Mercantile Law, Q8

A. Flora, a frequent traveller, found a purse concealed between the cushions of a large sofa inside the VIP lounge in NAIA while she was waiting for her flight to be called. Inside the purse was a very valuable diamond-studded necklace. She decided not to turn over the purse to the airport management, and instead to keep it. On her return from her travels, she had a dependable jeweller appraise the necklace, and the latter told her that the necklace was easily worth at least ₱5,000,000.00 in the open market. To test the appraisal, she pawned the necklace for ₱2,000,000.00. She then deposited the entire amount in her checking account with Metro Bank. Promptly, Metro Bank reported the transaction to the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC).
Given that her appropriation of the necklace was theft, may Flora be successfully prosecuted for money laundering? Explain briefly your answer. (4%)
B. Prosperous Bank is a domestic bank with head office in Makati. It handles the banking requirements of thousands of clients.
The AMLC initiated a discreet investigation of the financial transactions of Lorenzo, a suspected drug trafficker based in Naga City. The intelligence group of the AMLC, in coordination with the counterpart group from the PDEA and the NBI, gathered ample evidence establishing Lorenzo’s unlawful drug activities. The AMLC had probable cause that his deposits and investments in various banks, including Prosperous Bank, were related to money laundering.
Accordingly, the AMLC now transmits to Prosperous Bank a formal demand to allow its agents to examine the banking transactions of Lorenzo, but Prosperous Bank refuses the demand.
Is Prosperous Bank’s refusal justified? Explain your answer. (4%)

Quick check

Under Section 3(i) of the Anti-Money Laundering Act, why can a person who commits simple theft not be prosecuted for money laundering?

Under Section 11 of R.A. No. 9160, as amended, when may the AMLC examine bank deposits without securing a Court of Appeals order?

Why is Prosperous Bank's refusal to allow AMLC agents to examine Lorenzo's bank accounts legally unjustified?

Which theft offense is explicitly enumerated as a predicate crime or unlawful activity under the Anti-Money Laundering Act?

Choices available with full access.

Which statute governs money laundering offenses, predicate crimes, and bank inquiry powers in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Predicate Offenses Requirement
Under Section 3(i) of the Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2001 (Republic Act Number 9160, as amended), money laundering is a crime whereby proceeds of an unlawful activity are transacted or converted. Unlawful activities or predicate crimes are specifically enumerated by law. While qualified theft is explicitly included as a predicate offense under the statute, simple theft is not included. Consequently, funds or proceeds derived solely from simple theft do not originate from an unlawful activity under the Anti-Money Laundering Act, and transacting such funds cannot sustain a prosecution for money laundering.

2. Warrantless Bank Inquiry
Under Section 11 of Republic Act Number 9160, as amended by Republic Act Number 10167, the Anti-Money Laundering Council is generally required to obtain a bank inquiry order from the Court of Appeals upon ex parte application to examine bank deposits. However, the law explicitly establishes specific exceptions where a prior judicial order is not required. When there is probable cause that the deposits or investments are related to specified dangerous drug offenses under Republic Act Number 9165, the council possesses statutory authority to examine bank records directly without first securing a court order.

3. Bank Cooperation Duty
Under Section 11 of the Anti-Money Laundering Act, covered institutions such as domestic commercial banks have a mandatory legal duty to allow authorized council agents to examine banking records when an exception to the judicial order requirement applies. When the council investigates suspected illegal drug activities based on established probable cause, the statutory exception applies automatically. Consequently, a commercial bank cannot legally refuse the council's formal demand to inspect bank accounts related to drug trafficking, and any refusal by bank officers constitutes a violation of statutory AMLA provisions.

TopicsAnti-Money Laundering Act8Bank Inquiry Order2Predicate Offenses2

2017 Mercantile Law, Q9

A. Alfred issued a check for ₱1,000.00 to Benjamin, his friend, as payment for an electronic gadget. The check was drawn against Alfred’s account with Good Bank. Benjamin then indorsed the check specially in favor of Cesar. However, Cesar misplaced the check. Dexter, a dormmate of Cesar, found the check, altered its amount to ₱91,000.00, and forged Cesar’s indorsement by way of a blank indorsement in favor of Felix, a known jeweler. Felix then caused the deposit of the check in his account with Solar Bank. As collecting bank, Solar Bank stamped “all previous indorsements guaranteed” on the check. Seeing such stamp of the collecting bank, Good Bank paid the amount of ₱91,000.00 on the check.
May Good Bank claim reimbursement from Alfred? Explain your answer. (4%)
B. In 2006, Donald, an American temporarily residing in Cebu City, issued to Rhodora a check for $50,000.00 drawn against Wells Fargo Bank with offices in San Francisco, California. Rhodora negotiated the check and delivered it to Yaasmin, a Filipina socialite who frequently travelled locally and internationally. Because of her frequent travels, Yaasmin misplaced the check. It was only 11 years later on, in 2017, when she found the check inside a diary kept in her vault in her Hollywood, California house.
Discuss and explain the rights of Yaasmin on the check. (4%)

Quick check

Under Section 124 of the Negotiable Instruments Law, to what extent may a drawee bank debit a drawer's account for a materially altered check?

What is the legal effect when a collecting bank stamps 'all previous indorsements guaranteed' on an altered check?

Under Philippine banking practice and Section 186 of Act Number 2031, when does a check become stale?

Why is Yaasmin barred from enforcing the $50,000.00 check against Donald and Rhodora after holding it for eleven years?

Choices available with full access.

Which statutes primary govern negotiable instruments, material alteration, check presentment, and prescription in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Material Alteration Liability
Under Section 124 of the Negotiable Instruments Law (Act Number 2031), where a negotiable instrument is materially altered without the assent of all parties liable thereon, it is avoided, except as against a party who has himself made, authorized, or assented to the alteration and subsequent indorsers. However, when an altered instrument is in the hands of a holder in due course not a party to the alteration, he may enforce payment thereof according to its original tenor. Consequently, a drawee bank that pays an altered check can debit the drawer's account only for the original amount.

2. Collecting Bank Guarantee
Under established commercial banking jurisprudence and clearing regulations, a collecting bank that places its clearing stamp on a check declaring all prior indorsements guaranteed becomes liable for any forgery or material alteration preceding its endorsement. By guaranteeing all prior indorsements, the collecting bank warrants the genuineness of the instrument and assumes responsibility to the drawee bank for any fraudulent alteration or forged indorsement. If the drawee bank pays the altered amount, it may recover the excess amount paid from the collecting bank based on this express clearing guarantee.

3. Stale Check Prescription
Under Section 186 of Act Number 2031, a check must be presented for payment within a reasonable time after its issue, or the drawer will be discharged from liability thereon to the extent of the loss caused by the delay. In Philippine banking practice, a check not presented within six months from its date becomes stale. Furthermore, under Article 1144 of the Civil Code of the Philippines (Republic Act Number 386), an action upon a written contract prescribes ten years from the time the cause of action accrues, discharging prior endorsers from liability.

TopicsCollecting Bank Guarantee2Material Alteration of Checks1Stale Checks1