Bar Subject: Commercial Law

2012 Bar Examinations

2012 Mercantile Law, Q3

X borrowed money from Y in the amount of Php1Million and as payment, issued a check. Y then indorsed the check to his sister Z for no consideration. When Z deposited the check to her account, the check was dishonored for insufficiency of funds.
Is Z a holder in due course? Explain your answer. (5%)
Who is liable on the check. The drawer or the indorser? Explain your answer. (5%)

Quick check

Is a transferee who receives a negotiable check without paying any consideration a holder in due course under Act 2031?

Who is primarily or secondarily liable to pay a check that is dishonored due to insufficient funds?

When is notice of dishonor dispensed with as to the drawer under Section 114 of the Negotiable Instruments Law?

What defenses may a drawer raise against a holder who is not a holder in due course?

Which primary statute governs negotiable checks, holder in due course requisites, and drawer liability in the Philippines?

Learn more about these topics

1. Value Requirement
Under Section 52(c) of the Negotiable Instruments Law (Act Number 2031), a holder in due course is one who takes the instrument for value. Value is any consideration sufficient to support a simple contract. Where an instrument is transferred without any consideration, the transferee fails to satisfy the statutory requisites of a holder in due course. Consequently, the transferee holds the instrument subject to original defenses available between immediate parties.

2. Drawer Secondary Liability
Under Section 61 of the Negotiable Instruments Law (Act Number 2031), the drawer by drawing the instrument admits the existence of the payee and engages that on due presentment the instrument will be accepted or paid, or both. If the check is dishonored upon presentment due to insufficiency of funds, the drawer becomes directly liable to pay the amount of the check to the holder.

3. Notice of Dishonor
Under Section 114(d) of the Negotiable Instruments Law (Act Number 2031), notice of dishonor is not required to be given to the drawer where the drawer has no right to expect or require that the drawee will honor the instrument. When a check is drawn against insufficient funds, the drawer lacks any reasonable expectation of payment, thereby dispensing with notice of dishonor as a prerequisite for liability.

TopicsDrawer Liability on Dishonor1Holder in Due Course (NIL)1Value Requirement in NIL1

2012 Mercantile Law, Q4

Indicate and explain whether the promissory note is negotiable or non-negotiable.
I promise to pay A or bearer Php100,000.00 from my inheritance which I will get after the death of my father. (2%)
I promise to pay A or bearer Php100,000 plus the interest rate of ninety (90) – day treasury bills. (2%)
I promise to pay A or bearer the sum of Php100,000 if A passes the 2012 bar exams. (2%)
I promise to pay A or bearer the sum of Php100.000 on or before December 30, 2012. (2%)
I promise to pay A or bearer the sum of Php100,000. (2%)

Quick check

Which of the following promissory notes complies with the requisites of negotiability under Section 1 of Act 2031?

Why is a promissory note payable out of a expected inheritance non-negotiable under Section 3 of Act 2031?

What is the legal effect of promising to pay an interest rate based on fluctuating ninety-day treasury bills without a fixed rate formula?

Is a promissory note payable upon the condition that the payee passes the bar examination negotiable?

Which statute sets the formal requisites for negotiability of promissory notes and checks in the Philippines?

Learn more about these topics

1. Requisites of Negotiability
Under Section 1 of the Negotiable Instruments Law (Act Number 2031), an instrument must be in writing and signed by the maker or drawer, contain an unconditional promise or order to pay a sum certain in money, be payable on demand or at a fixed or determinable future time, and be payable to order or to bearer. Failure to satisfy any of these mandatory statutory requisites deprives the instrument of negotiability under Philippine commercial law.

2. Unconditional Promise Rule
Under Section 3 and Section 4 of Act Number 2031, an order or promise to pay out of a particular fund, or subject to a contingency, is conditional and renders the instrument non-negotiable. An instrument payable upon an event that may or may not happen is non-negotiable even if the event actually occurs later. Payment from a specific inheritance or conditioned upon passing a bar examination creates a conditional promise that destroys negotiability.

3. Sum Certain Requirement
Under Section 2 of Act Number 2031, the sum payable is certain if it is a sum face value with interest or by stated installments. However, promising to pay an interest rate tied to fluctuating market benchmarks, such as ninety-day treasury bills without a fixed rate formula, renders the sum uncertain at the time of execution. Uncertainty in the principal or interest payable invalidates negotiability under the Negotiable Instruments Law.

TopicsNegotiable Instruments Law (NIL)1Requisites of Negotiability2Sum Certain in Money1

2012 Mercantile Law, Q5

X borrowed from CCC Bank. She mortgaged her house and lot in favor of the bank. X insured her house. Tt1e bank also got the house insured.
Is this double insurance? Explain your answer. (3%)
Is this legally valid? Explain your answer. (3%)
In case of damage, can X and CCC Bank separately claim for the insurance proceeds? (4%)

Quick check

What essential requisite under Section 95 of the Insurance Code must be present to constitute double insurance?

What is the extent of a mortgagee's separate insurable interest in a mortgaged property under the Insurance Code?

If a mortgagor and mortgagee separately insure their respective interests in the same property, is the arrangement legally valid?

In the event of total loss by fire, how may insurance proceeds be claimed when both mortgagor and mortgagee held separate policies?

Which primary statute governs insurance policies, insurable interests, and double insurance rules in the Philippines?

Learn more about these topics

1. Double Insurance Requisites
Under Section 95 of the Insurance Code of the Philippines (Republic Act Number 10607), double insurance exists where the same person is insured by several insurers in respect to the same subject and interest. To constitute double insurance, all these requisites must concur: same subject matter, same interest insured, same risk or peril, and same person insured. If the insurances cover distinct insurable interests held by different parties, such as a mortgagor and a mortgagee, double insurance does not arise under Philippine commercial law.

2. Separate Insurable Interests
Under Section 8 and Section 9 of the Insurance Code of the Philippines (Republic Act Number 10607), both the mortgagor and mortgagee have separate and distinct insurable interests in the mortgaged property. The mortgagor's insurable interest is based on ownership and extends to the full value of the property. Conversely, the mortgagee's insurable interest is limited to the extent of the credit or debt secured by the mortgage. Both parties may independently insure their respective interests up to their legal maximums.

3. Independent Claim Recovery
Under Philippine insurance jurisprudence, when a mortgagor and mortgagee independently insure their distinct interests in the same property, each policy constitutes a separate contract. In the event of loss or damage, both the mortgagor and mortgagee may separately claim and recover insurance proceeds up to the limit of their respective insurable interests. Recovery by the mortgagee does not extinguish the mortgagor's right to collect under their own separate policy, subject to indemnity rules preventing over-recovery beyond actual loss.

TopicsDouble Insurance Requisites1Mortgagor and Mortgagee Insurable Interest1Separate Insurance Recovery1

2012 Mercantile Law, Q6

X is a Filipino immigrant residing in Sacramento, California. Y is a Filipino residing in Quezon City, Philippines. Z is a resident alien residing in Makati City. GGG Corporation is a domestic corporation – 40% owned by foreigners and 60% owned by Filipinos, with T as authorized representative. CCC Corporation is a foreign corporation registered with the Philippine Securities and Exchange Commission. KKK Corporation is a domestic corporation (100%) Filipino owned. S is a Filipino, 16 years of age, arid the daughter of Y.
Who can be incorporators? Who can be subscribers? (2%)
What are the differences between an incorporator and a subscriber, if there are any? (2%)
Who are qualified to become members of the board of directors of the corporation? (2%)
Who are qualified to act as Treasurer of the company? (2%)
Who can be appointed Corporate Secretary? (2%)

Quick check

Who among the following is qualified to be an incorporator of a domestic corporation under R.A. 11232?

What is a primary legal distinction between an incorporator and a subscriber under the Revised Corporation Code?

Under Section 22 of R.A. 11232, who is qualified to be elected as a member of the board of directors?

What are the mandatory statutory qualifications for a Corporate Secretary under Section 24 of R.A. 11232?

Choices available with full access.

Which statutory requirement applies to the Corporate Treasurer under Section 24 of the Revised Corporation Code?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Incorporators vs Subscribers
Under Section 10 of the Revised Corporation Code (Republic Act Number 11232), any person, partnership, association, or corporation, singly or jointly with others but not more than fifteen in number, may organize a corporation. Incorporators must be of legal age if natural persons, and must sign and acknowledge the articles of incorporation. In contrast, subscribers are persons who agree to take and pay for unissued shares of stock. While all incorporators are originally subscribers, not all subscribers are incorporators, as subscribers do not sign the charter and may include minors represented by legal guardians.

2. Director Eligibility Rules
Under Section 22 of the Revised Corporation Code (Republic Act Number 11232), a director must be a natural person of legal age who owns at least one share of the capital stock of the corporation registered in their name on the corporate books. A juridical entity such as a domestic or foreign corporation cannot directly serve as a director, though it may designate a natural person as its authorized representative to hold a qualifying share and sit on the board. Residency and citizenship requirements for directors are no longer mandatory unless provided by special laws.

3. Corporate Officer Qualifications
Under Section 24 of the Revised Corporation Code (Republic Act Number 11232), the board of directors must elect the corporate officers. The Corporate Secretary must be a citizen and resident of the Philippines. The Treasurer must be a resident of the Philippines and may be required to post a bond. Neither officer may hold the position of President concurrently. While a director may serve as Treasurer, a non-resident cannot be Treasurer, and a non-citizen or non-resident cannot serve as Corporate Secretary under Philippine law.

TopicsCorporate Officer Qualifications2Director Qualifications1Incorporators and Subscribers1

2012 Mercantile Law, Q7

X obtained a loan for Php50Million from SSS Bank. The collateral is his vacation house in Baguio City under a real estate mortgage. X needed more funds for his business so he again borrowed another Php10Million, this time from BBB Bank, another bank, using the same collateral. The loan secured from SSS Bank fell due and X defaulted.
If SSS Bank forecloses the real estate mortgage, what rights, if any, are left with 888 Bank as mo1igagee also? (2%)
If the value of the Baguio property is less than the amount of loan, what would be the recourse of SSS Bank? BBB Bank? (2%)
If the value of the property is more that the amount of the loan, who will benefit from the excess value of the property? (2%)
If X defaulted with its loan in favor of BBB Bank but fully paid his loan with SSS Bank, can BBB Bank foreclose the real mortgage executed in its favor? (2%)
Does X have any legal remedy after the foreclosure in the event that later on he has the rnoney to pay for the loan? (1%)
If SSS Bank and BBB Bank abandon their rights under the real estate mortgage, is there any legal recourse available to them? (1%)

Quick check

What legal rights are retained by a junior mortgagee if the senior mortgagee forecloses the real estate mortgage under Act 3135?

If the foreclosure sale proceeds are insufficient to pay the senior mortgage debt, what is the recourse of the senior mortgagee?

Who is entitled to receive the excess proceeds if the foreclosure sale fetches a price higher than the senior mortgage debt?

May a junior mortgagee foreclose its second real estate mortgage if the debtor defaults on the second loan but fully pays the first loan?

Choices available with full access.

What is the legal consequence if a mortgagee bank decides to abandon its rights under a real estate mortgage upon default?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Junior Mortgagee Rights
Under Act Number 3135, as amended, a junior mortgagee holds secondary rights over mortgaged real property. If the senior mortgagee forecloses on the property upon default, the junior mortgagee loses its lien on the real estate. However, the junior mortgagee retains two primary legal rights: the right to redeem the foreclosed property within the statutory one-year redemption period, and the right to receive any surplus proceeds arising from the foreclosure sale after the senior mortgagee's obligation and foreclosure costs have been fully satisfied.

2. Foreclosure Deficiency Recourses
Under Philippine mortgage law jurisprudence, an extrajudicial foreclosure sale resulting in proceeds insufficient to cover the underlying loan balance entitles the senior mortgagee to institute a judicial action for deficiency against the principal debtor. Conversely, a junior mortgagee whose mortgage lien is extinguished without full satisfaction of the debt cannot claim a foreclosure deficiency; instead, the junior mortgagee may file an independent civil action for sum of money to collect the remaining unpaid loan balance based on the underlying promissory note.

3. Mortgage Security Abandonment
Under Philippine credit transaction law, a mortgage contract is merely an accessory contract securing a principal obligation. Mortgagees are not compelled to foreclose on the security upon default. A mortgagee bank may explicitly abandon or waive its mortgage lien over the real property and instead file an ordinary civil action for collection of sum of money against the debtor. Once the creditor elects to file a personal action for collection, it is deemed to have irrevocably waived its real estate mortgage security.

TopicsJunior Mortgagee Rights1Mortgage Foreclosure Recourses1Real Estate Mortgage4