Bar Subject: Commercial Law

2018 Bar Examinations

2018 Mercantile Law, Q3

On November 23, 2017, Yas Ysmael (Ysmael) loaned the amount of PhP 5 million to Yarn & Thread Corporation (YTC), through its President, Ylmas Yektas (Yektas), which loan was evidenced by a Promissory Note (PN), which reads as follows:
Date: _______
Within one year from date hereof, I promise to pay to the order of YAS YSMAEL, the sum of PhP 5 million with interest at 120% per annum.
YARN & THREAD Corporation
By:
(Sgd.)
Ylmas Yektas
Yektas was the controlling stockholder of YTC at the time the PN was issued. As security for the payment of the PN, Yektas issued and delivered to Ysmael a postdated personal check covering the face value of the PN drawn from his account with Yellow Bell Bank and Trust Company. The proceeds of the loan under the PN were used by YTC as working capital.
A year later, Ysmael inserted the date of “November 23, 2017” on the date section of the PN, and made a formal demand upon YTC, through Yektas, to pay the note, but which was refused on the ground that Yektas was no longer the President and controlling shareholder of YTC. By this time, all the shares of YTC had already been sold to a new group of investors. Ysmael deposited the personal check issued by Yektas which was dishonored. He then filed a collection suit against YTC and Yektas including the accrued interest.
The defendants raised the following defenses in the collection suit. Rule on the merits of each defense. (2% each)
(a) A PN issued with a blank date is one that is not payable on demand or on a fixed or determinable future time, and therefore the insertion of the date constituted material alteration that nullified it, so that no cause of action arose.
(b) Yektas cannot be made liable on the PN since he signed in his capacity as President of YTC, which fact was known to Ysmael although not indicated on the PN.
(c) Yektas signed the PN merely as an accommodation to YTC. As he received no consideration for the PN, it is void for lack of consideration.
(d) YTC, now owned by new owners, cannot be held liable on the PN since it was entered into by its former owner and President, which act the new Board of Directors did not ratify.
(e) The PN .is void for being in violation of the Usury Law seeking interest at an unconscionable rate of 120% p.a.

Quick check

Under Section 13 of the Negotiable Instruments Law, what is the effect of inserting the true date in an undated promissory note?

Under Section 20 of the Negotiable Instruments Law, when is an officer who signs a promissory note on behalf of a corporation exempt from personal liability?

Does a change in corporate ownership or management extinguish valid debts previously contracted by the corporation?

What is the legal effect of stipulating an unconscionable interest rate of one hundred twenty percent per annum in a promissory note?

Which statute governs the negotiability of instruments, insertion of dates, and representative signatures in the Philippines?

Learn more about these topics

1. Date Insertion Authority
Under Section 13 of the Negotiable Instruments Law (Act Number 2031), where an instrument expressed to be payable at a fixed period after date is issued undated, any holder may insert therein the true date of issue or acceptance, and the instrument shall be payable accordingly. The insertion of the true date by the holder does not constitute a material alteration and does not avoid the instrument. Instead, it completes the negotiable instrument in accordance with the implied authority granted by law to the holder.

2. Corporate Juridical Personality
Under the Revised Corporation Code of the Philippines (Republic Act Number 11232), a corporation possesses a juridical personality separate and distinct from that of its stockholders, officers, and directors. Contracts legally entered into by authorized corporate officers bind the corporation itself, and such obligations remain fully valid and enforceable against the corporate entity regardless of subsequent changes in ownership, management, or shareholding structure. The acquisition of shares by new investors does not discharge pre-existing corporate liabilities.

3. Unconscionable Interest Rates
Under Article 1306 of the Civil Code of the Philippines (Republic Act Number 386), contracting parties may establish such stipulations, clauses, terms, and conditions as they may deem convenient, provided they are not contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order, or public policy. Stipulated interest rates that are iniquitous, exorbitant, or unconscionable—such as one hundred twenty percent per annum—are void for being contrary to morals. However, the nullity of the excessive interest clause does not invalidate the principal loan contract.

TopicsCorporate Juridical Personality1Negotiable Instruments Law4Unconscionable Interest Rates2

2018 Mercantile Law, Q4

Ysidro, a paying passenger, was on board Bus No. 904 owned and operated by Yatco Transportation Company (Yatco). He boarded the bus at Munoz, Nueva Ecija with Manila as his final destination. He was seated on the first row, window seat on the left side of the bus. As the bus was negotiating the national highway in front of the public market of Gerona, Tarlac, the bus came to a full stop because of the traffic. The driver of the bus took this opportunity to check on the tires of the bus and to relieve himself. As he was alighting from the bus to do these, an unidentified man standing along the highway hurled a huge rock at the left side of the bus and hit Ysidro between his eyes. He lost consciousness and immediately the driver, with the conductor, drove the bus to bring him to the nearest hospital. He expired before the bus could reach the hospital.
Ysidro’s wife and children brought a civil action to collect damages from Yatco, alleging that as a common carrier, it was required to exercise extraordinary diligence in ensuring the safety of its passengers. They contended that, in case of injuries and/or death on the part of any of its passengers, the common carrier is presumed to be at fault. In its defense, Yatco alleged that it is not an absolute insurer of its passengers and that Ysidro’s death was not due to any defect in the means of transport or method of transporting passengers, or the negligent acts of its employees. Since the accident was due to the fault of a stranger over whom the common carrier had no control, or of which it did not have any prior knowledge to be able to prevent it, the cause of Ysidro’s death should be considered a fortuitous event and not the liability of the common carrier.
(a) Is a common carrier presumed to be at fault whenever there is death or injury to its passengers, regardless of the cause of death or injury? (2.5%)
(b) What kind of diligence is required of common carriers like Yatco for the protection of its passengers? (2.5%)
(c) Will your answer be the same as your answer in (b) above, if the assailant was another paying passenger who boarded the bus and deliberately stabbed Ysidro to death? (2.5%)

Quick check

Under Article 1755 of the Civil Code, what standard of diligence is generally required of common carriers for passenger safety?

Under Article 1756 of the Civil Code, what is the statutory presumption when a passenger dies or suffers injury during carriage?

Why is Yatco Transportation Company exempt from liability for the death of Ysidro caused by a stranger throwing a stone from the national highway?

Under Article 1763 of the Civil Code, what standard of diligence must common carrier employees exercise to prevent violence by fellow passengers?

Which primary code contains the statutory provisions governing common carrier diligence, fortuitous events, and liability for passenger acts in the Philippines?

Learn more about these topics

1. Common Carrier Diligence
Under Article 1733 and Article 1755 of the Civil Code of the Philippines (Republic Act Number 386), common carriers are bound to carry passengers safely as far as human care and foresight can provide, using the utmost diligence of very cautious persons, with due regard for all circumstances. In case of death of or injury to passengers, Article 1756 creates a statutory presumption that the common carrier was at fault or acted negligently, unless the carrier proves that it observed extraordinary diligence or that the injury resulted from a fortuitous event or independent act of a stranger.

2. Fortuitous Event Exception
Under Article 1174 and established jurisprudence, a common carrier is not an absolute insurer of the safety of its passengers. When a passenger suffers injury or death due to the willful or negligent act of a stranger outside the vehicle—such as an unidentified person hurling a stone from the highway—over whom the carrier has no control and which could not be foreseen or prevented even through extraordinary diligence, the occurrence is considered a fortuitous event. Consequently, the presumption of fault is rebutted, and the common carrier is exempt from civil liability.

3. Acts of Passengers
Under Article 1763 of the Civil Code, a common carrier is responsible for injuries inflicted upon a passenger by co-passengers or strangers if the employees of the common carrier, through the exercise of the diligence of a good father of a family, could have prevented or stopped the act. Unlike carriage safety duties requiring extraordinary diligence, the statutory standard of care required of common carrier employees to prevent intentional torts or violent assaults committed by fellow passengers or strangers inside the vehicle is ordinary diligence, or the diligence of a good father of a family.

TopicsCommon Carrier Diligence2Fortuitous Event Defense2Liability for Passenger Acts1

2018 Mercantile Law, Q5

Yellow Fin Tuna Corporation (Yellow Fin), a domestic corporation, applied for a credit facility in the amount of PhP 50 million with Yengzi Financial Corporation (YFC). The application was approved and the Credit Agreement was signed and took effect. Ysko and Yuan, Yellow Fin Chairman and President, respectively, executed a Continuing Suretyship Agreement in favor of YFC wherein they guaranteed the due and full payment and performance of Yellow Fin’s guarantee obligations under the credit facility. YFC soon discovered material inconsistencies in the financial statements given by Yellow Fin, drawing YFC to conclude that Yellow Fin committed misrepresentation. Under the Credit Agreement, any misrepresentation by Yellow Fin or its sureties will constitute an event of default. YFC thus called an event of default and filed a complaint for sum of money against Yellow Fin, Ysko, and Yuan. Immediately thereafter, Yellow Fin filed a petition for rehabilitation. The court suspended the proceedings in YFC’s complaint until the rehabilitation court disposed of the petition for rehabilitation. YFC posits that the suspension of the proceedings should only be with respect to Yellow Fin but not with respect to Ysko and Yuan.
Is YFC correct? (2.5%)

Quick check

Under Section 18(c) of R.A. No. 10142, what is the effect of a rehabilitation stay order on sureties solidarily liable with the debtor?

What is the primary purpose of a stay order or Commencement Order in corporate rehabilitation proceedings under FRIA?

Why can YFC proceed with its collection suit against Ysko and Yuan despite Yellow Fin's rehabilitation petition?

Under Republic Act Number 10142, which entity enjoys the protection of a court-issued rehabilitation stay order?

Which statute governs financial rehabilitation, insolvency proceedings, and stay order rules in the Philippines?

Learn more about these topics

1. Corporate Rehabilitation
Under Section 18 of the Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act of 2010 (Republic Act Number 10142), upon the appointment of a rehabilitation receiver or the issuance of a Commencement Order, all actions or proceedings in court for the enforcement of claims against the debtor corporation shall be suspended. The stay order seeks to preserve corporate assets, afford the rehabilitation receiver an opportunity to formulate a viable recovery plan, and ensure equal treatment of creditors during corporate distress.

2. Stay Order Exceptions
Under Section 18(c) of Republic Act Number 10142, the stay or suspension order issued by a rehabilitation court does not apply to the enforcement of claims against sureties and other persons solidarily liable with the debtor corporation. While the principal debtor enjoys temporary protection against execution and collection suits to facilitate business recovery, solidary guarantors and sureties remain directly and immediately liable to creditors under their independent contractual undertakings.

3. Continuing Suretyship
A continuing suretyship agreement binds the surety solidarily with the principal debtor for present and future obligations. Because the liability of a surety is direct, primary, and absolute, a creditor may proceed against the surety independently of the principal debtor. The insolvency or corporate rehabilitation of the principal debtor does not extinguish, diminish, or suspend the primary contractual obligation of the surety to satisfy the creditor's claim upon default.

TopicsCorporate Rehabilitation8Stay Order Exceptions2Surety Liability1

2018 Mercantile Law, Q6

Shortly after Yin and Yang were wed, they each took out separate life insurance policies on their lives, and mutually designated one another as sole beneficiary. Both life insurance policies provided for a double indemnity clause, the cost for which was added to the premium rate. During the last 10 years of their marriage, the spouses had faithfully paid for the annual premiums over the life policies from both their salaries. Unfortunately, Yin fell in love with his officemate, Vessel, and they carried on an affair. After two years, their relationship bore them a daughter named Vinsel. Without the knowledge of Yang, Yin changed the designation of the beneficiary to an “irrevocable designation” of Vinsel and Vessel jointly. When Yang learned of the affair, she was so despondent that, having chanced upon Yin and Vessel on a date, she rammed them down with the car she was driving, resulting in Vin’s death and Vessel’s complete loss of mobilization. Yang was sued for parricide, and while the case was pending, she filed a claim on the proceeds of the life insurance of Yin as irrevocable beneficiary, or at least his legal heir, and opposed the claims on behalf of Vessel and her daughter Vinsel. Yang claimed that her designation as beneficiary in Vin’s life insurance policy was irrevocable, in the nature of one “coupled with interest,” since it was made in accordance with their mutual agreement to designate one another as sole beneficiary in their respective life policies. She also claimed that the beneficiary designation of Vessel and the illegitimate minor child Vinsel was void being the product of an illicit relationship, and therefore without “insurable interest.”
(a) Is Yang correct in saying that her designation as beneficiary was irrevocable? (2.5%)
(b) Do Vessel and Vinsel have “insurable interest” on the life of Yin? (2.5%)

Quick check

Under Section 11 of the Insurance Code, what is the default rule regarding changing life insurance beneficiaries?

Which statutory provision disqualifies a person guilty of concubinage or adultery from being designated as a life insurance beneficiary?

Does an illegitimate child have an insurable interest in the life of her father under Philippine law?

Why is the designation of Vessel as a beneficiary in Vin's life insurance policy void?

Choices available with full access.

Which statute contains the primary provisions governing insurable interest and beneficiary revocability in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Beneficiary Revocability
Under Section 11 of the Insurance Code of the Philippines (Republic Act Number 10607), the insured shall have the right to change the beneficiary designated in the policy, unless the right to change has been expressly waived in the policy. A mere mutual oral or unwritten agreement between spouses to name each other as sole beneficiary does not convert a revocable designation into an irrevocable one. Without an explicit waiver written directly into the insurance contract, the insured retains full legal authority to alter the beneficiary designation at any time during the policy term.

2. Disqualification of Beneficiaries
Under Article 2012 in relation to Article 739 of the Civil Code of the Philippines (Republic Act Number 386), any person who is forbidden from receiving donations cannot be named beneficiary of a life insurance policy by the person who cannot make any donation to him. Specifically, donations made between persons who were guilty of adultery or concubinage at the time of the donation are void. Consequently, a married person cannot validly designate an adulterous partner as a life insurance beneficiary, rendering any such designation completely void.

3. Insurable Interest
Under Section 10(a) of the Insurance Code, every person has an insurable interest in the life and health of himself, of his spouse, and of his children. An illegitimate child possesses an inherent insurable interest in the life of her father under Section 10(a) regardless of her parents' marital status or illicit relationship. Unlike the adulterous partner whose designation is prohibited under Article 739 of the Civil Code, an illegitimate minor child is not disqualified by law and may validly be designated as a life insurance beneficiary.

TopicsDisqualification of Beneficiaries2Insurable Interest in Life2Insurance Beneficiary Revocability1

2018 Mercantile Law, Q7

Yelp Pictures Inc. (Yelp Pictures), a movie production company based in California, USA, entered into a contract with Yehey Movies Inc., a Filipino movie production and distribution company which is registered in the Philippines under the Securities Regulation Code (SRC) and listed in the Philippine Stock Exchange Inc. (PSE), for the exclusive distribution in the Philippines of movies produced in the USA by Yelp Pictures. Yehey Movies is currently owned 85% by Yavic Yamson, and the balance, by the public in the Philippines. For purposes of entering into the contract, suing for breach of such contract, and prosecuting unauthorized showing of movies produced by Yelp Pictures, it appointed Atty. Yson, a local lawyer, as its attorney-in-fact.
Simultaneously with the execution of the film distribution agreement, Yehey Movies also granted Yelp Pictures an option to acquire up to 40% of the total outstanding capital stock in Yehey Movies post-exercise of the option, at the option price of PhP .01 per number of shares covered by the option, exercisable within a period of one (1) year from the date of the grant, at the exercise price of PhP 100 per share. Once exercised, Yelp Pictures was granted the right to nominate two (2) directors to the Board of Yehey Movies, and Yavic Yamson agreed to vote all his shares for the election of directors to be nominated by Yelp Pictures.
(a) May the acts of entering into the film distribution contract, the subsequent execution and performance of the terms of the contract in the Philippines, and the appointment of Atty. Yson, be considered as act of “doing business” in the Philippines that will require Yelp Pictures to register as a foreign corporation and obtain a license to do business in the Philippines? (2.5%)
(b) Will your answer in (a) be the same if Yelp Pictures exercises the option, becomes a substantial shareholder, and is able to elect two (2) directors in the Board of Yehey Movies? (2.5%)
(c) Must the option granted to Yelp Pictures be registered under the SRC? (2.5%)

Quick check

Under the Foreign Investments Act, which act does NOT constitute doing business in the Philippines?

Does acquiring 40% equity and nominating two directors in a domestic company constitute doing business by a foreign firm?

Why is a stock option granted exclusively to a single foreign corporate partner exempt from SEC registration under the SRC?

Which law defines the concept and scope of doing business by foreign corporations in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Which statute governs the registration of securities and exempt transactions in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Doing Business Concept
Under the Foreign Investments Act of 1991 (Republic Act Number 7042, as amended) and the Revised Corporation Code, doing business implies continuity of commercial dealings or performance of acts incident to the organization's enterprise. Appointing a local representative or attorney-in-fact solely to protect intellectual property, prosecute copyright infringements, or enforce distribution agreements does not constitute doing business requiring a license. Isolated transactions or acts protecting property rights do not subject a foreign corporation to local licensing requirements.

2. Passive Shareholder Equity
Under Philippine foreign investment jurisprudence, subscribing to shares of stock in a domestic corporation, exercising voting rights, and electing directors to the corporate board constitute passive equity investment. Merely acquiring up to forty percent stock ownership and nominating corporate directors do not transform a foreign investor into an entity doing business locally. So long as the domestic corporation operates independently, the foreign stockholder does not engage in doing business in the Philippines.

3. Private Option Exemption
Under Section 8 in relation to Section 10 of the Securities Regulation Code (Republic Act Number 8799), securities, including stock options, cannot be sold or offered for sale without prior registration with the Securities and Exchange Commission. However, an option granted privately to a single entity, without any public distribution, solicitation, or offering, constitutes an exempt transaction under Section 10. Consequently, a stock option issued exclusively to a foreign corporate partner does not require registration.

TopicsDoing Business Rule1Foreign Investment Act1Securities Regulation Code7