Bar Subject: Commercial Law

2013 Bar Examinations

2013 Mercantile Law, Q8

In the November 2010 stockholders meeting of Greenville Corporation, eight (8) directors were elected to the board. The directors assumed their posts in January 20 ll. Since no stockholders’ meeting was held in November 2011, the eight directors served in a holdover capacity and thus continued discharging their powers.
In June 2012, two (2) of Greenville Corporation’s directors- Director A and Director B -resigned from the board. Relying on Section 29 of the Corporation Code, the remaining six (6) directors elected two (2) new directors to fill in the vacancy caused by the resignation of Directors A and B.
Stockholder X questioned the election of the new directors, initially, through a letter-complaint addressed to the board, and later (when his letter-complaint went unheeded), through a derivative suit filed with the court. He claimed that the vacancy in the board should be filled up by the vote of the stockholders of Greenville Corporation. Greenville Corporation’s directors defended the legality of their action, claiming as well that Stockholder X’s derivative suit was improper.
Rule on the issues raised. (8%)

Quick check

Who has the legal authority to fill a board vacancy created by the resignation of a director serving in a holdover capacity?

Under Section 28 of the Revised Corporation Code, when may remaining directors fill a vacancy on the board?

Is the holdover period considered part of a director's statutory term of office under Philippine corporate law?

Why is a derivative suit improper to challenge the election of directors by remaining board members?

Choices available with full access.

Which primary statute governs corporate governance, board vacancy rules, and stockholder voting rights in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Board Vacancy Filling
Under Section 28 of the Revised Corporation Code (Republic Act Number 11232), board vacancies resulting from the expiration of term must be filled exclusively by the stockholders in a meeting called for the purpose. Although remaining directors generally may fill board vacancies if they still constitute a quorum, this power is strictly limited to vacancies arising from causes other than expiration of term, removal, or increase in the number of directors. Resignation during a holdover period after term expiration constitutes a vacancy by term expiration.

2. Holdover Director Status
Under Philippine corporate law jurisprudence, the holdover period is not part of a director's fixed statutory term of office. A director holds over in a temporary capacity only until a successor is elected and qualified. When a director resigns while serving in a holdover capacity after their official term has already expired, the resulting vacancy is legally attributable to the expiration of the term rather than resignation. Consequently, only the stockholders, not the remaining board of directors, possess the authority to elect replacement directors.

3. Derivative Suit Propriety
Under the Interim Rules of Procedure for Intra-Corporate Controversies, a derivative suit is an action brought by a stockholder in the name of the corporation to redress a wrong committed against the corporation or to enforce a corporate cause of action. Where a stockholder challenges an illegal board election or asserts their individual voting right to elect directors, the cause of action is direct and personal to the stockholder rather than corporate. Therefore, bringing a derivative suit to contest director election is procedurally improper.

TopicsBoard Vacancy Filling1Derivative Suit Propriety1Holdover Director Resignation1

2013 Mercantile Law, Q9

Fil-Asia Air Flight 9 I 6 was on a scheduled passenger flight from Manila when it crashed as it landed at the Cagayan de Oro airport; the pilot miscalculated the plane’s approach and undershot the runway. Of the I 50 people on board, ten (10) passengers died at the crash scene.
Of the ten who died, one was a passenger who managed to leave the plane but was run over by an ambulance coming to the rescue. Another was an airline employee who hitched a free ride to Cagayan de Oro and who was not in the passenger manifest.
It appears from the Civil Aeronautics Authority investigation that the co-pilot who had control of the plane’s landing had less than the required flying and landing time experience, and should not have been in control of the plane at the time. He was allowed to fly as a co-pilot because of the scarcity of pilots – Philippine pilots have been recruited by foreign airlines under vastly improved flying terms and wages so that newer and less trained pilots are being locally deployed. The main pilot, on the other hand, had a very high level of blood alcohol at the time of the crash.
You are part of the team that the victims hired to handle the case for them as a group. In your case conference, the following questions came up:
(A) Explain the causes of action legally possible under the given facts against the airline and the pilots; whom will you specifically implead in these causes of action? (5%)
(B) How will you handle the cases of the passenger run over by the ambulance and the airline employee allowed to hitch a free ride to Cagayan de Oro? (3%)

Quick check

What degree of diligence is required of a common carrier towards paying passengers under Article 1755 of the Civil Code?

Against whom can heirs of a deceased passenger file a cause of action for breach of contract of carriage?

What degree of care does a common carrier owe to an employee carried gratuitously under Article 1758 of the Civil Code?

Who is primarily liable under quasi-delict for the death of a passenger run over by an emergency response ambulance?

Choices available with full access.

Which primary statute governs common carrier liabilities, quasi-delict obligations, and contract of carriage rules in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Common Carrier Liability
Under Article 1755 of the Civil Code of the Philippines, a common carrier is bound to carry passengers safely as far as human care and foresight can provide, using the utmost diligence of very cautious persons, with a due regard for all the circumstances. When a passenger dies or is injured during an aircraft crash, the common carrier is presumed to have been at fault or to have acted negligently. Liability for breach of contract of carriage arises directly against the airline company without need of proving specific officer negligence.

2. Quasi-Delict Liability
Under Article 2176 and Article 2180 of the Civil Code of the Philippines, any person who by act or omission causes damage to another, there being fault or negligence, is obliged to pay for the damage done. Employers are primary and solidarily liable for quasi-delicts committed by their employees acting within the scope of their assigned tasks. In aviation accidents caused by pilot gross incompetence or intoxication, injured parties or third-party victims may institute quasi-delict actions jointly against the negligent pilots and the airline employer.

3. Gratuitous Passenger Duty
Under Article 1758 of the Civil Code of the Philippines, a stipulation limiting the common carrier's liability for negligence is valid if the passenger is carried gratuitously, but not for willful misconduct or gross negligence. However, even in gratuitous carriage or hitchhiking by an airline employee, the common carrier owes at least ordinary diligence to ensure safety. Failure to exercise ordinary care in pilot selection and flight operations renders the airline liable for damages resulting from an aviation crash.

TopicsCommon Carrier Liability2Gratuitous Passenger Care1Quasi-Delict Causes of Action1

2013 Mercantile Law, Q10

Bell Philippines, Inc. (BelPhil) is a public utility company, duly incorporated and registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Its authorized capital stock consists of voting common shares and non-voting preferred shares, with equal par values of P100.00/share. Currently, the issued and outstanding capital stock of BelPhil consists only of common shares shared between Bayani Cruz, a Filipino with 60% of the issued common shares, and Bernard Fleet, a Canadian, with 40%.
To secure additional working fund, BelPhil issued preferred shares to Bernard Fleet equivalent to the currently outstanding common shares. A suit was filed questioning the corporate action on the ground that the foreign equity holdings in the company would now exceed the 40% foreign equity limit allowed under the Constitution for public utilities.
Rule on the legality of Bernard Fleet’s current holdings. (8%)

Quick check

Under Section 11, Article XII of the Constitution, what minimum percentage of a public utility's capital must be owned by Philippine citizens?

How is the word 'capital' in Section 11, Article XII of the Constitution interpreted under the Gamboa v. Teves doctrine?

If a foreign national holds forty percent of voting common shares and subsequently acquires all newly issued non-voting preferred shares equal to the common shares, what is the result?

Which government body registers articles of incorporation and monitors compliance with foreign equity limits for public utilities?

Choices available with full access.

Which primary constitutional provision limits foreign equity ownership in public utility corporations operating in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Constitutional Equity Limitation
Under Section 11, Article XII of the Constitution of the Philippines, no franchise, certificate, or authorization for the operation of a public utility shall be granted except to citizens of the Philippines or to corporations organized under the laws of the Philippines at least sixty percent of whose capital is owned by such citizens. The sixty percent Filipino ownership requirement is a continuous constitutional limit designed to preserve effective Filipino control over nationalized public utility enterprises.

2. The Gamboa Doctrine
Under the landmark doctrine laid down in Gamboa v. Teves and affirmed in Roy v. Herbosa, the term 'capital' in Section 11, Article XII of the Constitution refers to both the total number of shares of stock entitled to vote in the election of directors and the total number of outstanding shares of stock, whether voting or non-voting. A public utility corporation must satisfy the sixty percent Filipino ownership requirement separately in both categories to comply with constitutional equity restrictions.

3. Non-Voting Preferred Shares
Under Philippine corporate law and constitutional jurisprudence, non-voting preferred shares are counted as part of the total outstanding capital stock when determining compliance with foreign equity limitations. Issuing non-voting preferred shares to foreign nationals increases overall foreign capital participation. If the total foreign holdings exceed forty percent of the aggregate outstanding shares, whether voting or non-voting, the corporate equity structure violates constitutional ownership caps.

TopicsConstitutional 60-40 Rule1Public Utility Foreign Equity1Voting and Non-Voting Shares Ownership1

2012 Bar Examinations

2012 Mercantile Law, Q1

ABC Company filed a Petition for Rehabilitation with the Court. An Order was issued by the Court, (1) staying enforcement of all claims, whether money or otherwise against ABC Company, its guarantors and sureties not solidarily liable with the company; and (2) prohibiting ABC Company from making payments of its liabilities, outstanding as of the date of the filing of the Petition. XYC Company is a holder of an irrevocable Standby Letter of Credit which was previously procured by ABC Company in favor of XYC Company to secure performance of certain obligations. In the light of the Order issued by the Court.
Can XYC Company still be able to draw on their irrevocable Standby Letter of Credit when due? Explain your answer. (5%)
Explain the nature of Letters of Credit as a financial devise. (5%)

Quick check

Does a rehabilitation stay order under Section 18 of FRIA prevent a beneficiary from drawing on an irrevocable standby letter of credit?

What legal doctrine provides that the issuing bank's obligation to pay a letter of credit is separate from the main contract?

Under Philippine commercial law, what is the primary nature of an issuing bank's obligation to the beneficiary of a letter of credit?

Which entity's liability remains enforceable despite a Stay Order issued in favor of an insolvent corporate debtor under RA 10142?

Which primary statute governs corporate rehabilitation, insolvency proceedings, and stay order scope in the Philippines?

Learn more about these topics

1. Independence Principle
Under Section 18(c) of the Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act (Republic Act Number 10142) and settled commercial jurisprudence, a letter of credit is governed by the Independence Principle. Under this doctrine, the obligation of the issuing bank to pay the beneficiary upon presentation of the required documents is primary, direct, and independent of the underlying transaction or contract between the applicant debtor and the beneficiary. Defenses available to the applicant against the beneficiary cannot be raised by the issuing bank to withhold payment.

2. Stay Order Exceptions
Under Section 18(c) of Republic Act Number 10142, a Stay Order issued by a rehabilitation court does not apply to the enforcement of claims against issuers of letters of credit, guarantors, and sureties solidarily liable with the debtor. Because the standby letter of credit creates an independent third-party commitment by the issuing financial institution, the beneficiary may draw upon the instrument when due without violating the court order staying claims against the insolvent corporate applicant.

3. Nature of LC
A letter of credit is a financial device designed to facilitate commercial transactions and assure prompt performance. It involves three distinct contracts: the underlying contract between the applicant and the beneficiary, the contract between the applicant and the issuing bank, and the letter of credit itself between the bank and the beneficiary. By substituting the creditworthiness of a stable banking institution for that of the buyer or debtor, it provides the beneficiary secure payment upon strict compliance with documentary requirements.

TopicsIndependence Principle5Letters of Credit4Stay Order Exceptions (FRIA)1

2012 Mercantile Law, Q2

CCC Car, Inc. obtained a loan from BBB Bank, which fund was used to import ten (10) units of Mercedes Benz S class vehicles. Upon arrival of the vehicles and before release of said vehicles to CCC Car, Inc., X and Y, the President and Treasurer, respectively, of CCC Car, Inc. signed the Trust Receipt to cover the value of the ten (10) units of Mercedes Benz S class vehicles after which, the vehicles were all delivered to the Car display room of CCC Car, Inc. Sale of the vehicles were slow, and it took a month to dispose of the ten (10) units. CCC Car, Inc. wanted to be in business and to save on various documentations required by the bank, decided that instead of turning over the proceeds of the sales, CCC Car, Inc. used the proceeds to buy another ten (10) units of BMW 3 series.
Is the action of CCC Car, Inc. legally justified? Explain your answer. (5%)
Will the corporate officers of CCC Car, Inc. be held liable under the circumstances? Explain your answer. (5%)

Quick check

Under Section 9 of Presidential Decree 115, what is the primary obligation of an entrustee who sells goods covered by a trust receipt?

Who is criminally liable under Section 13 of P.D. 115 when a corporation fails to turn over trust receipt proceeds?

Does the failure to turn over sale proceeds under a valid trust receipt constitute criminal estafa?

Is good faith or business necessity a valid defense against a charge of violating the Trust Receipts Law?

Which primary statute governs trust receipt agreements, entrustee duties, and penal sanctions for non-turnover of proceeds in the Philippines?

Learn more about these topics

1. Trust Receipt Obligations
Under Section 4 and Section 9 of the Trust Receipts Law (Presidential Decree Number 115), the entrustee receives goods or proceeds in trust for the entruster. The entrustee is bound to hold the proceeds of the sale of the goods in trust for the entruster and to turn over such proceeds to the extent of the amount owing to the entruster. Using the proceeds to purchase other inventory instead of turning them over to the bank constitutes a direct violation of the trust receipt agreement and commercial law.

2. Corporate Officer Liability
Under Section 13 of Presidential Decree Number 115, if the violation of the Trust Receipts Law is committed by a corporation, partnership, association, or other juridical entity, the penalty of imprisonment shall be imposed upon the directors, officers, employees, or other officials responsible for the offense. Corporate officers who sign the trust receipt agreement on behalf of the corporation, such as the President and Treasurer, are personally and criminally liable for the misapplication or non-turnover of the sale proceeds.

3. Criminal Estafa Sanction
Under Section 13 of Presidential Decree Number 115 in relation to Article 315 of the Revised Penal Code, the failure of an entrustee to turn over the proceeds of the sale of goods covered by a trust receipt, or to return the goods if unsold, constitutes the crime of estafa. Criminal intent is not an essential element because violation of the Trust Receipts Law is malum prohibitum. Good faith or the desire to keep the business operational cannot serve as a valid legal defense.

TopicsCorporate Officer Criminal Liability1Misappropriation of Proceeds1Trust Receipts Law (P.D. 115)2