Bar Subject: Commercial Law

2015 Bar Examinations

2015 Mercantile Law, Q13

A. A commercial bank wants to acquire shares in a cement manufacturing company. Do you think it can do that? Why or why not? (2%)
B. A court found the interest charged by a bank as excessive and unconscionable and struck down the contractual stipulation on interest. If you were the judge, what would you impose as the applicable interest rate? State your legal basis. (2%)
C. What is the single borrower’s limit? (2%)

Quick check

May a commercial bank acquire equity shares in a cement manufacturing corporation under Republic Act Number 8791?

What legal interest rate should a judge impose after striking down a bank loan interest rate as unconscionable?

What is the statutory single borrower's limit under Section 35 of the General Banking Law of 2000?

Which banking institution type has statutory authority to invest in non-allied enterprises like cement manufacturing in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Which primary statute governs bank equity investments, interest rate regulation, and the single borrower's limit in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Bank Equity Restrictions
Under Section 30 of the General Banking Law of 2000 (Republic Act Number 8791), commercial banks are authorized to invest in the equity of financial and non-financial allied undertakings only. A commercial bank is statutorily prohibited from acquiring equity shares in non-allied enterprises such as a cement manufacturing company. Equity investments in non-allied enterprises are restricted exclusively to universal banking institutions that possess broader expanded banking authority granted by the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas.

2. Unconscionable Interest Rates
Under Article 2209 of the Civil Code of the Philippines and established Central Bank regulations, when a court strikes down a contractual interest rate for being excessive, iniquitous, and unconscionable, the interest stipulation is rendered void ab initio. In such cases, the court must replace the voided rate with the statutory legal interest rate of six percent per annum. The legal interest applies from judicial or extrajudicial demand until full satisfaction of the loan obligation.

3. Single Borrower Limit
Under Section 35 of the General Banking Law of 2000 (Republic Act Number 8791), the single borrower's limit restricts the total amount of credit accommodations, loans, and credit lines that a bank may extend to any single person, corporation, or entity to twenty-five percent of the bank's net worth. This regulatory ceiling prevents over-concentration of credit risk and safeguards bank solvency by ensuring that a single borrower's default does not jeopardize the institution's overall financial stability.

TopicsBank Equity Investments1Single Borrower Limit1Unconscionable Interest Rate3

2015 Mercantile Law, Q14

A. Differentiate trademark, copyright and patent from each other. (6%)
B. What is the doctrine of equivalents? (2%)
C. In what ways would a case for infringement of trademark be different from a case for unfair competition? (3%)

Quick check

What primary feature distinguishes a trademark from a copyright and a patent under Republic Act Number 8293?

What test is applied under the doctrine of equivalents to determine patent infringement under Section 75 of RA 8293?

What element is required to establish a case for unfair competition under Section 168 of the Intellectual Property Code?

Is prior trademark registration required to maintain an action for trademark infringement under Section 155 of RA 8293?

Choices available with full access.

Which primary statute governs trademarks, copyrights, patents, and unfair competition in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Intellectual Property Types
Under the Intellectual Property Code of the Philippines (Republic Act Number 8293), trademarks, copyrights, and patents protect distinct legal objects. A trademark is any visible sign capable of distinguishing the goods or services of an enterprise. A copyright protects original literary and artistic creations from the moment of their creation. A patent protects any technical solution of a problem in any field of human activity that is new, involves an inventive step, and is industrially applicable.

2. Doctrine of Equivalents
Under Section 75 of Republic Act Number 8293 and patent jurisprudence, the doctrine of equivalents determines patent infringement when an accused device or process does not literally infringe the patent claims. Under the function-means-result test, infringement occurs if the accused device performs substantially the same function in substantially the same way to achieve substantially the same result. The doctrine prevents infringers from making insubstantial changes to evade the literal language of patent claims.

3. Infringement Versus Unfair
Under Sections 155 and 168 of Republic Act Number 8293, trademark infringement and unfair competition differ fundamentally in registration requirements and fraudulent intent. Trademark infringement requires a registered mark, and liability attaches upon proving likelihood of confusion regardless of fraudulent intent. Conversely, unfair competition does not require trademark registration and focuses on deceptive passing off of goods, requiring proof of fraudulent intent to pass off one's goods as those of another.

TopicsDoctrine of Equivalents2Intellectual Property Rights1Trademark Infringement vs Unfair Competition1

2015 Mercantile Law, Q15

CHEN, Inc., a Taiwanese company, is a manufacturer of tires with the mark Light Year. From 2009 to 2014, Clark Enterprises, a Philippine registered corporation, imported tires from CHEN, Inc. under several sales contracts and sold them here in the Philippines. In 2015, CHEN, Inc. filed a trademark application with the Intellectual Property Office (IPO) for the mark Light Year to be used for tires. The IPO issued CHEN, Inc. a certificate of registration (COR) for said mark. Clark Enterprises sought the cancellation of the COR and claimed it had a better right to register the mark Light Year. CHEN, Inc. asserted that it was the owner of the mark and Clark Enterprises was a mere distributor. Clark Enterprises argued that there was no evidence on record that the tires it imported from CHEN, Inc. bore the mark Light Year and Clark Enterprises was able to prove that it was the first to use the mark here in the Philippines. Decide the case. (4%)

Quick check

Under Section 122 of Republic Act Number 8293, how is ownership of a trademark acquired in the Philippines?

What regime governs trademark acquisition in the Philippines under the Intellectual Property Code?

Does a mere distributor or importer acquire proprietary ownership over a foreign manufacturer's trademark by selling the goods locally?

What is the legal effect of a certificate of registration issued by the Intellectual Property Office under RA 8293?

Choices available with full access.

Which primary statute governs trademark registration, ownership acquisition, and cancellation in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. First to File
Under Section 122 of the Intellectual Property Code of the Philippines (Republic Act Number 8293) and established jurisprudence, ownership of a trademark is acquired solely through valid registration made in good faith. The Philippines follows the first-to-file regime, discarding the prior actual use rule. An applicant who first files a trademark application in good faith acquires exclusive rights over the mark, and prior local commercial use by another party does not defeat a validly issued certificate of registration.

2. Distributor Trademark Limitations
Under Philippine intellectual property jurisprudence, a mere importer, distributor, or sales agent does not acquire proprietary rights over the manufacturer's trademark. Even if the distributor was the first entity to introduce, market, or sell the trademarked goods within the domestic Philippine market, such commercial activity inures to the benefit of the foreign manufacturer. Consequently, a distributor cannot register the manufacturer's mark in its own name or seek cancellation of the manufacturer's valid registration.

3. Trademark Registration Rights
Under Republic Act Number 8293, a certificate of registration serves as prima facie evidence of the registrant's ownership of the mark, the validity of the registration, and the registrant's exclusive right to use the mark. Cancellation of a registered trademark requires clear proof of bad faith or fraudulent registration. Where a foreign manufacturer registers its proprietary mark in good faith, local distributors lack legal standing to cancel the registration based on prior local distribution.

TopicsDistributor Trademark Rights1First-to-File Rule1Trademark Registration1

2015 Mercantile Law, Q16

A. On the anti-money laundering laws:
1. What is the distinction between a “covered transaction report” and a “suspicious transaction report”? (2%)
2. Does the Anti-Money Laundering Council have the authority to freeze deposits? Explain. (2%)
B. On foreign investments:
1. A foreign company has a distributor in the Philippines. The latter acts in his own name and account. Will this distributorship be considered as doing business by the foreign company in the Philippines? (3%)
2. ABC Corporation was organized in Malaysia but has a branch in the Philippines. It is entirely owned by Filipino citizens. Can you consider ABC Corporation a Philippine national? (2%)

Quick check

What distinguishes a covered transaction from a suspicious transaction under Republic Act Number 9160?

Which judicial body possesses exclusive authority to issue a freeze order on bank deposits under the Anti-Money Laundering Act?

When does an independent distributor's local commercial activity constitute 'doing business' by a foreign corporation under RA 7042?

Under Section 3 of the Foreign Investments Act of 1991, can a corporation organized under foreign laws be considered a Philippine national?

Choices available with full access.

Which primary statutes govern anti-money laundering reporting, deposit freeze orders, and foreign investment definitions in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Covered Versus Suspicious
Under Section 3 of the Anti-Money Laundering Act (Republic Act Number 9160), a covered transaction report involves a transaction in cash or other equivalent monetary instrument exceeding Five Hundred Thousand Pesos within one banking day. Conversely, a suspicious transaction report applies regardless of the amount involved whenever there is no underlying economic justification, the client is not properly identified, or the transaction deviates from the client's profile.

2. Bank Deposit Freeze
Under Section 10 of Republic Act Number 9160, as amended, the Anti-Money Laundering Council does not possess the direct statutory authority to issue freeze orders against bank deposits. The authority to issue a freeze order rests exclusively with the Court of Appeals upon verified ex parte application by the Council. The Court of Appeals may issue a freeze order effective immediately for twenty days when probable cause exists that deposit accounts are related to unlawful activities.

3. Foreign Investments Act
Under Section 3 of the Foreign Investments Act of 1991 (Republic Act Number 7042), an independent distributor purchasing and selling goods in their own name and account does not constitute doing business by the foreign manufacturer. Furthermore, a corporation organized under foreign laws that registers a branch in the Philippines and is wholly owned by Filipino citizens qualifies as a Philippine national under the law.

TopicsAnti-Money Laundering Act8Foreign Investments Act2Philippine National1

2014 Bar Examinations

2014 Mercantile Law, Q1

Carlo and Bianca met in the La Boracay festivities. Immediately, they fell in love with each other and got married soon after. They have been cohabiting blissfully as husband and wife, but they did not have any offspring. As the years passed by, Carlo decided to take out an insurance on Bianca’slife for P1,000,000.00 with him (Carlo) as sole beneficiary, given that he did not have a steady source of income and he always depended on Bianca both emotionally and financially. During the term of the insurance, Bianca died of what appeared to bea mysterious cause so that Carlo immediately requested for an autopsy tobe conducted. It was established that Bianca died of a natural cause. More than that, it was also established that Bianca was a transgender all along – a fact unknown to Carlo. Can Carlo claim the insurance benefit? (5%)

Quick check

Under Section 10(b) of the Insurance Code (RA 10607), what creates an insurable interest in another person's life?

When must an insurable interest in a life insurance policy exist under Philippine insurance law?

Does the invalidity of a marriage defeat a life insurance claim where the beneficiary depended financially on the insured at policy inception?

Under Section 11 of Republic Act Number 10607, when does a beneficiary forfeit the right to receive life insurance proceeds?

Which primary statute governs insurable interest, policy beneficiaries, and life insurance claims in the Philippines?

Learn more about these topics

1. Life Insurable Interest
Under Section 10 of the Insurance Code of the Philippines (Republic Act Number 10607), every person has an insurable interest in the life and health of themselves, of any person on whom they depend wholly or in part for education or support, of any person under legal obligation to pay them money or respect property, and of any person upon whose life an estate or interest depends. Insurable interest in life must exist at the time the insurance takes effect, but need not exist when the loss occurs.

2. Financial Dependence Grounds
Under Section 10(b) of Republic Act Number 10607, insurable interest in life does not depend exclusively on a legally valid spousal relationship or blood kinship. A person who depends wholly or in part upon another for support or financial assistance possesses an independent pecuniary insurable interest in that person's life. Even if the underlying marriage between the parties is legally void ab initio, actual financial dependence at the policy's inception creates a valid insurable interest capable of supporting a life insurance contract.

3. Beneficiary Designation Rights
Under Philippine insurance law and Section 11 of Republic Act Number 10607, an insured or policyholder who takes out an insurance policy on another person's life based on a valid pecuniary insurable interest may designate themselves as the sole beneficiary. Where the contract is procured in good faith and without fraudulent intent or unlawful causation of death, the designated beneficiary is legally entitled to collect the full policy proceeds upon the insured's death from natural causes.

TopicsInsurable Interest in Life2Life Insurance Beneficiary1Void Marriage Insurable Interest1