Bar Subject: Commercial Law

2010 Bar Examinations

2010 Mercantile Law, Q13

Paolo, the owner of an ocean-going vessel, offered to transport the logs of Constantino from Manila to Nagoya. Constantino accepted the offer, not knowing that the vessel was manned by an irresponsible crew with deep-seated resentments against Paolo, their employer.
Constantino insured the cargo of logs against both perils of the sea and barratry. The logs were improperly loaded on one side, thereby causing the vessel to tilt on one side. On the way to Nagoya, the crew unbolted the sea valves of the vessel causing water to flood the ship hold. The vessel sank.
Constantino tried to collect from the insurance company which denied liability, given the unworthiness of both the vessel and its crew.
Constantino countered that he was not the owner of the vessel and he could therefore not be responsible for conditions about which he was innocent.
a. Is the insurance company liable? Why or why not? (3%)
b. What is “barratry” in marine insurance? (2%)

Quick check

What does the implied warranty of seaworthiness under Section 115 of the Insurance Code mandate?

Does the implied warranty of seaworthiness apply to cargo owners who insure their goods under a marine policy?

How is barratry defined in marine insurance law?

What is the legal effect on a marine insurance policy if a vessel is improperly loaded and manned by an incompetent crew?

Choices available with full access.

Which landmark Supreme Court decision affirmed that a cargo owner's innocence does not excuse a breach of seaworthiness?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Implied Seaworthiness Warranty
Under Section 115 of the Insurance Code (Republic Act Number 10607), an implied warranty of seaworthiness exists in every contract of marine insurance. Seaworthiness requires that the vessel be fit, properly loaded, and equipped with a competent master and crew to withstand the ordinary perils of the sea. In Roque v. Intermediate Appellate Court, the Supreme Court ruled that this implied warranty applies to cargo owners taking out marine insurance on their cargo, regardless of whether they own the vessel or are innocent of the crew's incompetency or improper loading.

2. Marine Insurance Barratry
Under Philippine marine insurance law, barratry is defined as any willful misconduct, fraud, or illegal act committed by the master or crew of a vessel for an unlawful or fraudulent purpose, without the consent of the shipowner, causing injury or loss to the owner or charterer. Barratry requires a willful or fraudulent act done with criminal intent rather than mere negligence or incompetence. Where a vessel's loss is fundamentally caused by a breach of the implied warranty of seaworthiness, coverage for barratry cannot be invoked to override the policy's failure.

3. Cargo Owner Responsibility
Under Section 115 of Republic Act Number 10607, a cargo owner who insures his goods under a marine policy warrants that the transporting vessel is seaworthy at the commencement of the voyage. The law makes no exception for cargo owners who have no control over the vessel's crew or loading operations. When a vessel sinks because it was improperly loaded or manned by an incompetent crew, the breach of the implied warranty of seaworthiness releases the insurer from liability, regardless of the cargo owner's personal innocence or lack of knowledge.

TopicsCargo Owner Warranty1Implied Warranty Seaworthiness1Marine Insurance Barratry1

2010 Mercantile Law, Q14

When OCCIDENTAL Bank folded up due to insolvency, Manuel had the following separate deposits in his name: P200,000 in savings deposit; P250,000 in time deposit; P50,000 in a current account; P1 million in a trust account; and P3 million in money market placement. Under the Philippine Deposit Insurance Corporation Act, how much could Manuel recover? Explain. (2%)

Quick check

What is the maximum deposit insurance coverage (MDIC) provided by the PDIC per depositor per bank under R.A. 3591, as amended?

Under Section 4 of the PDIC Charter, how are multiple deposit accounts held by a depositor in the same right and capacity treated?

Which of the following financial products is expressly EXCLUDED from PDIC deposit insurance coverage?

Why are trust accounts excluded from PDIC deposit insurance coverage upon bank insolvency?

Choices available with full access.

If a depositor holds P200,000 in savings, P250,000 in time deposit, and P50,000 in a current account in a closed bank, how much can he recover from PDIC?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. PDIC Coverage Limit
Under Republic Act Number 3591 (PDIC Charter), as amended, the Maximum Deposit Insurance Coverage provided by the Philippine Deposit Insurance Corporation is Five Hundred Thousand Pesos (P500,000.00) per depositor per bank. The deposit insurance scheme is designed to protect small retail depositors and maintain public confidence in the banking system. Regardless of the total aggregate amount or number of legitimate deposit accounts maintained by an individual in a single closed bank, PDIC's statutory liability to that depositor cannot exceed the P500,000.00 maximum ceiling.

2. Deposit Aggregation Rule
Under Section 4 of Republic Act Number 3591, as amended, all deposit accounts maintained in the same bank by a depositor in the same right and capacity are aggregated for deposit insurance purposes. Savings deposits, time deposits, demand or current accounts, and negotiable order of withdrawal accounts belonging to the same individual owner are added together to determine total insured coverage. If the aggregated balance of these eligible deposit accounts exceeds the maximum statutory limit, the depositor receives insurance payment only up to Five Hundred Thousand Pesos (P500,000.00).

3. Uninsured Investment Exclusions
Under Republic Act Number 3591, as amended by Republic Act Number 9576 and Republic Act Number 10846, deposit insurance coverage applies exclusively to deposit obligations. Non-deposit products, including trust accounts, money market placements, bond investments, and derivative instruments, are expressly excluded from PDIC coverage. Trust funds and money market placements create investment or fiduciary relationships rather than ordinary bank deposit liabilities. Consequently, when a bank suffers insolvency and enters liquidation, holders of money market placements and trust accounts cannot claim insurance reimbursement from the PDIC.

TopicsBank Deposit Aggregation1Insured Deposit Exclusions1PDIC Insurance Coverage1

2010 Mercantile Law, Q15

While vacationing in Boracay, Valentino surreptitiously took photographs of his girlfriend Monaliza in her skimpy bikini. Two weeks later, her photographs appeared in the Internet and in a national celebrity magazine.
Monaliza found out that Valentino had sold the photographs to the magazine and, adding insult to injury, uploaded them to his personal blog on the Internet.
a. Monaliza filed a complaint against Valentino for damages based on, among other grounds, violation of her intellectual property rights. Does she have any cause of action? Explain. (2%)
b. Valentino’s friend Francesco stole the photographs and duplicated them and sold them to a magazine publication. Valentino sued Francesco for infringement and damages. Does Valentino have any cause of action? Explain. (2%)
c. Does Monaliza have any cause of action against Francesco? Explain. (2%)

Quick check

Under Section 178.1 of R.A. 8293, who owns the copyright over a photograph taken by a photographer?

Can a person whose photograph was surreptitiously taken sue the photographer for copyright infringement?

What legal cause of action can a person bring if her private bikini photos are published without consent?

Under Philippine copyright law, what is the effect when a photographer sells his original photo copy to a magazine?

Choices available with full access.

Can a subject whose private photos were stolen and sold by a third party sue that third party for damages?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Copyright Ownership Rules
Under Section 178.1 of the Intellectual Property Code of the Philippines (Republic Act Number 8293), copyright ownership over a photographic work belongs fundamentally to the photographer who created the visual work, rather than the person who serves as the subject of the photograph. Although the subject holds constitutional and statutory privacy rights against unauthorized publication, the subject does not acquire copyright ownership merely by appearing in the photograph. Consequently, the subject cannot maintain an action for copyright infringement against the photographer or third parties.

2. Right to Privacy
Under Article 26 of the Civil Code of the Philippines, every person has a statutory right to personal privacy, dignity, and peace of mind. Surreptitiously taking intimate photographs of an individual and subsequently publishing or uploading them on public internet blogs and commercial magazines without express consent constitutes an actionable tortious invasion of privacy. Both the original photographer and any third-party publishers who unauthorizedly distribute or commercialize such private photographs are civilly liable for moral damages and injunctive relief.

3. Copyright First Sale
Under Section 177 and Section 200 of the Intellectual Property Code (Republic Act Number 8293), copyright ownership grants the creator exclusive economic rights to reproduce, distribute, or transfer the work. Under the first sale doctrine, when the copyright owner voluntarily sells or transfers a physical copy of the photograph to a commercial magazine publication without retaining exclusive distribution rights, his control over that particular copy is exhausted. He cannot subsequently sue a third party for copyright infringement regarding that sold physical copy.

TopicsCopyright Ownership Rules1Intellectual Property Infringement1Right to Privacy Violation1

2010 Mercantile Law, Q16

An importer of Christmas toys loaded 100 boxes of Santa Claus talking dolls aboard a ship in Korea bound for Manila. With the intention of smuggling one-half of his cargo, he took a bill of lading for only 50 boxes. On the voyage to Manila, 50 boxes were jettisoned to save the more precious cargo.
a. Is the importer entitled to receive any indemnity for average? Explain. (2%)
b. What are the types of averages in marine commerce? (3%)

Quick check

What is the statutory effect under Article 816 of the Code of Commerce if unmanifested or smuggled goods are jettisoned?

Under Philippine maritime law, what are the two general classifications of averages in marine commerce?

How are losses from a simple or particular average borne under Article 810 of the Code of Commerce?

What key condition must be satisfied under Article 816 for jettisoned cargo to claim general average contribution?

Choices available with full access.

If unmanifested goods are successfully saved from a maritime peril after a jettison, what is their legal status regarding general average?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. General Average Requisites
Under Article 811 and Article 816 of the Code of Commerce, general average includes all damages and expenses deliberately caused to save the vessel, its cargo, or both, from a real and known maritime peril. To entitle a cargo owner to indemnity under general average, the goods jettisoned or sacrificed must be properly documented and proven by a valid bill of lading. Goods loaded on board secretly or without being declared in the bill of lading are excluded from general average contributions if jettisoned.

2. Unmanifested Cargo Jettison
Under Article 816 of the Code of Commerce, unmanifested or smuggled goods loaded aboard a vessel without being entered into the cargo manifest or bill of lading do not enjoy the benefit of general average indemnity if they are sacrificed or jettisoned during a sea voyage. The law penalizes the fraudulent concealment of cargo by denying reimbursement to the dishonest shipper. However, if unmanifested goods are saved from a maritime peril, they remain liable to contribute proportionally to the general average expenses incurred.

3. Marine Commerce Averages
Under Articles 806 to 811 of the Code of Commerce, averages in marine commerce are classified into simple or particular averages, and gross or general averages. Particular averages comprise all expenses and damages caused to the vessel or cargo that have not inured to the common benefit of all interests involved, and are borne exclusively by the owner of the damaged property. General averages encompass deliberate sacrifices or extraordinary expenses intentionally incurred for the common safety of the ship, freight, and cargo.

TopicsGeneral Average Requisites1Marine Commerce Averages1Unmanifested Cargo Jettison1

2010 Mercantile Law, Q17

The Supreme Court has held that fraud is an exception to the “independence principle” governing letters of credit. Explain this principle and give an example of how fraud can be an exception. (3%)

Quick check

What does the independence principle dictate regarding a letter of credit transaction?

Under Transfield Philippines v. Luzon Hydro Corp., when may payment under a letter of credit be enjoined?

What is the primary duty of an issuing bank upon the presentation of documents under a letter of credit?

Which landmark Supreme Court decision defines the independence principle and fraud exception in letters of credit?

Choices available with full access.

Does a simple breach of contract by the seller justify invoking the fraud exception to enjoin a letter of credit?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Independence Principle
Under Philippine commercial law and Transfield Philippines, Inc. v. Luzon Hydro Corporation, the independence principle establishes that a letter of credit is distinct and independent from the underlying contract between the buyer and the seller. The issuing bank's obligation to pay the beneficiary upon timely presentation of facially compliant documents is primary, absolute, and definite. The bank is not required or permitted to inquire into whether the underlying commercial contract has been fulfilled, breached, or performed, thereby ensuring swift and reliable settlement in international trade transactions.

2. Fraud Exception Rule
Under established jurisprudence, the fraud exception serves as a narrow limitation to the independence principle governing letters of credit. When the beneficiary fraudulently presents spurious, forged, or materially false documents, or when the beneficiary's demand for payment lacks any basis in fact such that payment would amount to fraudulent abuse, courts may issue an injunction to restrain the issuing bank from paying. The fraud exception prevents the letter of credit mechanism from being weaponized to perpetrate illegal financial deceit.

3. Injunction Requisites
Under Transfield Philippines, Inc. v. Luzon Hydro Corporation, enjoining payment under a letter of credit based on the fraud exception requires meeting strict evidentiary standards. The applicant must demonstrate clear and convincing proof of explicit fraud committed by the beneficiary in the procurement or presentation of commercial documents. Mere breach of the main contract or contract performance disputes between buyer and seller do not constitute fraud sufficient to invoke the exception or restrain bank payment.

TopicsFraud Exception Rule2Independence Principle5Letters of Credit4