Bar Subject: Commercial Law

2016 Bar Examinations

2016 Mercantile Law, Q18

B Bank, a large universal bank, regularly extends revolving credit lines to business establishments under what it terms as socially responsible banking and private business partnership relations. All loans that are extended to clients have a common “Escalation Clause,” to wit: “B Bank hereby reserves its right to make successive increases in interest rates in accordance with the bank’s adopted policies as approved by the Monetary Board; Provided that each successive increase shall be with the written assent of the depositor.”
[a] X, a regular client of the bank, contends that the “Escalation Clause” is unfair, unconscionable and contrary to law, morals, public policy and customs. Rule on the issue and explain. (2.5%)
[b] Suppose that the “Escalation Clause” instead reads: “B Bank hereby reserves the right to make reasonable increases in interest rates in accordance with bank policies as approved by the Monetary Board; Provided, there shall be corresponding reasonable decreases in interest rates as approved by the Monetary Board.” Would this be valid? Explain. (2.5%)

Quick check

Under Article 1308 of the Civil Code, what fundamental principle governs interest escalation clauses in contracts?

Why is an interest escalation clause requiring the borrower's written assent for each rate increase legally valid?

Why is an escalation clause allowing unilateral rate hikes based on bank policy void despite containing a de-escalation clause?

Under Philippine banking law, what is required for an interest rate escalation clause to be legally enforceable?

Choices available with full access.

Which primary statute governs contract mutuality, interest rate stipulations, and loan obligations in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Mutuality of Contracts
Under Article 1308 of the Civil Code of the Philippines, the contract must bind both contracting parties, and its validity or compliance cannot be left to the sole will of one of them. This foundational principle of mutuality of contracts dictates that any modification, adjustment, or escalation of contractual terms must be mutually agreed upon by both the creditor bank and the borrower. Unilateral determination of essential elements such as interest rates by a banking institution violates contract mutuality and renders the unilateral escalation provision void ab initio.

2. Valid Escalation Clause
Under Philippine banking jurisprudence, an interest escalation clause in a revolving credit line agreement is legally valid provided it requires the explicit written assent of the borrower for each successive interest rate increase. Where the contract explicitly conditions rate increases upon securing the borrower's written consent prior to implementation, the mutuality of contracts is fully preserved. The requirement of written assent prevents the lender bank from arbitrarily imposing unconscionable interest rate hikes upon the debtor.

3. De-escalation Clause Rule
Under established Supreme Court rulings, including Juico v. China Banking Corporation, the inclusion of a de-escalation clause does not automatically validate an escalation provision that grants the bank sole discretion to raise interest rates. If an escalation clause permits the bank to increase interest rates based on internal policies without obtaining the borrower's prior written consent, the clause remains void for violating Article 1308 of the Civil Code, notwithstanding the presence of a corresponding de-escalation clause.

TopicsDe-escalation Clause1Escalation Clause1Mutuality of Contracts1

2016 Mercantile Law, Q19

In 2015, R Corp., a domestic company that is wholly owned by Filipinos, filed its opposition to the applications for Mineral Production Sharing Agreements (MPSA) of O Corp., P Corp., and Q Corp. which were pending before the Panel of Arbitrators (POA) of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR). The three corporations wanted to undertake exploration and mining activities in the province of Isabela. The oppositor alleged that at least 60% of the capital shareholdings of the applicants are owned by B Corp., a 100% Chinese corporation, in violation of Sec. 2, Art. XII of the Constitution. The applicants countered that they are qualified corporations as defined under the Philippine Mining Act of 1995 and the Foreign Investments Act of 1991 since B Corp. holds only 40% of the capital stocks in each of them and not 60% as alleged by R Corp.
The Summary of Significant Accounting Policies statement of B Corp. reveals that the joint venture agreements of B Corp. with Sigma Corp. and Delta Corp. involve the 0 Corp., P Corp., and Q Corp. The ownership of the layered corporations and joint venture agreements show that B Corp. practically exercises control over the 0, P and Q corporations. 0, P and Q corporations contend that the control test should be applied and its MPSA applications granted. On the other hand, R Corp. argues that the “grandfather rule” should be applied. Decide with reasons. (5%)

Quick check

When does the Grandfather Rule apply to determine compliance with constitutional foreign equity limits?

Under Section 2, Article XII of the Constitution, what minimum Filipino ownership is required for MPSA applicants?

What was the landmark ruling in Narra Nickel Mining & Development Corp. versus Redmont Consolidated Mines Corp.?

Under the Control Test, how is a corporate shareholder classified if Filipinos own sixty percent of its capital stock?

Choices available with full access.

Which primary statute governs mineral exploration, development, and MPSA allocations in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Grandfather Rule Supplemental
Under Section 2, Article XII of the 1987 Philippine Constitution and Narra Nickel Mining & Development Corp. v. Redmont Consolidated Mines Corp., the Control Test is the primary rule for determining foreign equity compliance. However, where doubt exists as to the true locus of beneficial ownership and control of corporate shares, the Grandfather Rule applies as a mandatory supplement. By tracing the ultimate nationality of stock held through corporate layers and joint venture agreements, courts determine whether the required sixty percent Filipino equity ownership is genuinely satisfied.

2. Control Test Application
Under the Foreign Investments Act of 1991 (Republic Act Number 7042), the Control Test considers a corporation Filipino-owned if at least sixty percent of its capital stock outstanding and entitled to vote is held by Philippine citizens. If a corporate shareholder is sixty percent Filipino-owned, its entire shareholding in a project company is tallied as Filipino capital. Nevertheless, when corporate layering is intentionally utilized to circumvent constitutional foreign equity restrictions, the Control Test yields to the Grandfather Rule.

3. Mining Equity Limits
Under Section 2, Article XII of the Constitution and the Philippine Mining Act of 1995 (Republic Act Number 7942), the exploration, development, and utilization of natural resources are reserved exclusively to Philippine citizens or corporations whose capital is at least sixty percent owned by Filipinos. Mineral Production Sharing Agreements (MPSA) granted to entities failing to satisfy this constitutional minimum are null and void. Corporate structures that surrender effective control to foreign entities violate constitutional mining restrictions.

TopicsControl Test7Grandfather Rule1Mining Law Foreign Equity1

2016 Mercantile Law, Q20

Company X issued a Bank A Check No. 12345 in the amount of P500,000.00 payable to the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) for the company’s taxes for the third quarter of 1997. The check was deposited with Bank B, the collecting bank with which the BIR has an account. The check was subsequently cleared and the amount of P500,000.00 was deducted from the company’s balance. Thereafter, Company X was notified by the BIR of its non-payment of its unpaid taxes despite the P500,000.00 debit from its account. This prompted the company to seek assistance from the proper authorities to investigate on the matter.
The results of the investigation disclosed that unknown then to Company X, its chief accountant Bonifacio Santos is part of a syndicate that devised a scheme to syphon its funds. It was discovered that though deposited, the check was never paid to the BIR but was passed on by Santos to Winston Reyes, Bank B’s branch manager and Santos’ co-conspirator. Instead of bringing the check to the clearing house, Reyes replaced Check No. 12345 with a worthless check bearing the same amount, and tampered documents to cover his tracks. No amount was then credited to the BIR. Meanwhile, Check No. 12345 was subsequently cleared and the amount therein credited into the accounts of fictitious persons, to be later withdrawn by Santos and Reyes.
Company X then sued Bank B for the amount of P500,000.00 representing the amount deducted from its account. Bank B interposed the defense that Company X was guilty of contributory negligence since its confidential employee Santos was an integral part of the scheme to divert the proceeds of Check No. 12345. Is Company X entitled to reimbursement from Bank B, the collecting bank? Explain. (5%)

Quick check

What is the primary legal obligation of a collecting bank that receives a crossed check payable to the Bureau of Internal Revenue?

Why is Bank B liable to Company X for the diverted check proceeds despite the involvement of Company X's accountant?

What is the legal effect of crossing a check under Philippine negotiable instruments jurisprudence?

Under Article 2180 of the Civil Code, why is a bank held responsible for the fraudulent acts of its branch manager?

Choices available with full access.

Which primary statute governs negotiable checks, endorsements, and collecting bank obligations in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Collecting Bank Liability
Under Philippine banking law and the Negotiable Instruments Law (Act Number 2031), a collecting bank that accepts a crossed check payable to a specific payee owes a statutory duty to ensure that the proceeds are deposited exclusively into the account of the designated payee. When a collecting bank allows a check payable to the Bureau of Internal Revenue to be diverted and credited into unauthorized or fictitious accounts, it breaches its duty of extraordinary diligence. The collecting bank assumes full financial liability for the diverted funds regardless of secondary defenses.

2. Bank Officer Liability
Under Article 2180 of the Civil Code of the Philippines, employers are liable for damages caused by their employees acting within the scope of their assigned tasks. A banking institution is bound by the fraudulent acts committed by its branch manager in the performance of official clearing functions. Even if an employee of the drawer corporation participated in the fraudulent conspiracy, the bank manager's active role in replacing the check and tampering with bank clearing records constitutes the proximate cause of the loss, holding the bank primarily liable.

3. Crossed Check Effects
Under Philippine commercial jurisprudence, crossing a check imposes a legal mandate upon the collecting bank to deposit the instrument solely into the account of the named payee. Crossing a check serves as a clear warning to the bank that the instrument is issued for a specific purpose. Where a collecting bank ignores the restrictive crossing and permits its branch manager to divert check proceeds to unauthorized individuals, the bank is guilty of gross negligence and cannot invoke contributory negligence against the drawer.

TopicsBanking Extraordinary Diligence2Collecting Bank Liability1Crossed Checks1

2015 Bar Examinations

2015 Mercantile Law, Q1

A. Nadine has a checking account with Fair & Square Bank. One day, she lost her checkbook and the finder was able to forge her signature and encash the forged check. Will Nadine be able to recover the amount debited from her checking account from Fair & Square Bank? Justify your answer. (3%)
B. Is a manager’s check as good as cash? Why or why not? (2%)
C. When can you treat a bill of exchange as a promissory note? (3%)

Quick check

Under Section 23 of the Negotiable Instruments Law (Act No. 2031), what is the legal effect of a forged signature on a check?

Why is a drawee bank liable to its depositor when it pays a check bearing the depositor's forged signature?

Why is a manager's check regarded as standing on the same footing as cash in commercial practice?

Under Section 130 of the Negotiable Instruments Law, when may a bill of exchange be treated as a promissory note?

Which primary statute governs negotiable checks, manager's checks, and bills of exchange in the Philippines?

Learn more about these topics

1. Forged Check Liability
Under Section 23 of the Negotiable Instruments Law (Act Number 2031), a forged signature is wholly inoperative, and no right to enforce payment against any party thereto can be acquired through such forged signature. A drawee bank is bound to know the genuine signature of its depositors and must bear the loss when it pays a check bearing a forged signature. Unless the depositor is guilty of gross negligence that facilitated the forgery, the drawee bank cannot debit the depositor's account for the forged instrument and must restore the debited funds.

2. Manager's Check Nature
Under Philippine commercial jurisprudence, a manager's check is a check drawn by the bank's manager upon the bank itself. It is regarded as standing on the same footing as a bank draft and is accepted in advance by the act of its issuance. By issuing a manager's check, the bank commits its full credit and pledges its primary liability to pay the amount stated upon presentment. Consequently, in commercial practice, a manager's check is deemed as good as cash, serving as a reliable medium of exchange in commercial transactions.

3. Bill as Note
Under Section 130 of the Negotiable Instruments Law (Act Number 2031), a holder has the option to treat a bill of exchange as a promissory note under three specific statutory circumstances: when the drawer and drawee are the same person, when the drawee is a fictitious person, or when the drawee is a person not having capacity to contract. In addition, under Section 17(e) of the same statute, where the instrument is so ambiguous that there is doubt whether it is a bill or note, the holder may treat it as either at his election.

TopicsBill of Exchange as Note1Forged Check Liability1Manager's Check1

2015 Mercantile Law, Q2

A. Novette entered into a contract for the purchase of certain office supplies. The goods were shipped. While in transit, the goods were insured by Novette. Does she have an insurable interest over the goods even before delivery of the same to her? Explain. (2%)
B. Will an insurance policy be binding even if the premium is unpaid? What if it were partially paid? (3%)

Quick check

Does a buyer under a perfected contract of sale possess an insurable interest over goods in transit prior to actual delivery?

What is the general rule under Section 77 of the Insurance Code regarding unpaid insurance premiums?

What is the legal effect of partial premium payment under an agreed installment scheme?

Under Section 14 of Republic Act Number 10607, which of the following may constitute a valid insurable interest in property?

Which primary statute governs insurable interest, premium payment rules, and insurance policy validity in the Philippines?

Learn more about these topics

1. Buyer Insurable Interest
Under Section 14 of the Insurance Code of the Philippines (Republic Act Number 10607), an insurable interest in property may consist in an existing interest, an inchoate interest founded on an existing interest, or an expectancy coupled with an existing interest. A buyer under a perfected contract of sale acquires an insurable interest in the purchased goods while in transit even prior to actual physical delivery. The buyer's existing contractual right and financial exposure to potential damage or destruction of the goods during transit constitute a lawful insurable interest under Philippine insurance law.

2. Premium Payment Rule
Under Section 77 of the Insurance Code (Republic Act Number 10607), known as the cash-and-carry rule, an insurance policy is generally not valid and binding until the premium thereof has been fully paid. The statutory requirement ensures that the insurer receives consideration before assuming contractual risk. However, established jurisprudence recognizes specific exceptions to this rule, such as when the insurer extends credit terms, when the parties agree to payment in installments, or when estoppel prevents the insurer from denying policy validity after accepting partial payment.

3. Partial Premium Payment
Under Philippine insurance jurisprudence, partial payment of an insurance premium renders the policy binding if the insurer agreed to an installment payment structure or accepted partial payment without reservation prior to a loss. Where an insurer accepts partial premium payment under an agreed installment schedule, it is estopped from invoking Section 77 to defeat liability upon the occurrence of an insured risk. The insurer must honor the policy, subject to deducting the remaining unpaid premium balance from the insurance proceeds due.

TopicsInsurable Interest5Insurance Code2Premium Payment Rules1