Bar Subject: Tax Law

2014 Bar Examinations

2014 Taxation Law, Q27

In January 2013, your friend got his first job as an o ffice clerk. He is single and lives with his family who depends upon him for financial support. His parents have long retired from their work, and his two (2) siblings are still minors and studying in grade school. In February 2014, he consulted you as he wanted to comply with all the rules pertaining to the preparation and filing of his income tax return. He now asks you the following:
(A) Is he entitled to personal exemptions? If so, how much? (1%)
(B) Is he entitled to additional exemptions? If so, how much? (1%)
(C) What is the effect of the taxes withheld from his salaries on his taxable income? (2%)

Quick check

Under Section 35(A) of the NIRC prior to TRAIN Law amendments, how much basic personal exemption was allowed to an individual taxpayer?

Which of the following family members qualifies as a dependent for additional exemption under Section 35(B) of the NIRC?

What is the legal effect of taxes withheld from an employee's salary on their income tax computation?

Can a single employee supporting retired parents and minor siblings claim additional personal exemptions under Section 35(B)?

Choices available with full access.

What is the statutory ceiling on the number of qualified dependent children allowed for additional personal exemptions?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Tax Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Basic Personal Exemption
Under Section 35(A) of the National Internal Revenue Code prior to amendments by the TRAIN Law, an individual taxpayer is entitled to a basic personal exemption of fifty thousand pesos regardless of marital status. This exemption allows an individual worker to deduct a fixed statutory amount from gross compensation income to arrive at net taxable income. For an individual employee earning salary income during the relevant taxable period, the basic personal exemption applies automatically as an allowable personal deduction.

2. Additional Exemption Rules
Under Section 35(B) of the Tax Code, an individual taxpayer is allowed an additional exemption of twenty-five thousand pesos for each qualified dependent child, up to a maximum of four children. To qualify as a dependent child, the person must be a legitimate, illegitimate, or legally adopted child chief dependent upon and living with the taxpayer, chief dependent, unmarried, and not gainfully employed. Dependent parents and minor siblings do not qualify as dependent children for additional personal exemption purposes.

3. Tax Credit Effect
Creditable withholding taxes deducted from an employee's compensation by an employer do not reduce taxable income. Instead, withholding taxes act as direct tax credits that are deducted from the total income tax due computed on net taxable income. Because withholding taxes represent advance payments of the employee's tax liability, they operate as a credit against final tax due rather than an allowable deduction from gross income.

TopicsAdditional Personal Exemption1Basic Personal Exemption2Creditable Withholding Tax1

2014 Taxation Law, Q28

Choose the correct answer. Tax laws – (1%)
(A) may be enacted for the promotion of private enterprise or business for as long as it gives incidental advantage to the public or the State
(B) are inherently legislative; therefore, may not be delegated
(C) are territorial in nature; hence, they do not recognize the generally-accepted tenets of international law
(D) adhere to uniformity and equality when all taxable articles or kinds of property of the same class are taxable at the same rate

Quick check

What does the constitutional requirement of uniformity in taxation mean?

Why is a tax measure enacted primarily to benefit a private business constitutionally invalid?

Which entity is constitutionally authorized to exercise delegated taxing power in the Philippines?

Does the territorial nature of Philippine tax law exclude the recognition of international comity?

Choices available with full access.

Which exception permits administrative agencies to issue revenue regulations enforcing tax laws?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Tax Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Uniformity in Taxation
Under Section 28(1), Article VI of the 1987 Constitution, the rule of taxation shall be uniform and equitable. Uniformity requires that all taxable articles or kinds of property of the same class shall be taxed at the same rate within the same taxing jurisdiction. It does not demand absolute equality across different classes of subjects or objects, provided that the statutory classification is reasonable, germane to the purpose of the law, applies equally to all members of the same class, and is not arbitrary or discriminatory.

2. Public Purpose Rule
Taxation is an inherent power of the State exercised exclusively for public purposes. Revenue generated through taxes must be devoted to government operations, public services, or general welfare. A tax measure enacted primarily for the promotion or financial benefit of a private enterprise or private business is constitutionally invalid. Incidental or indirect public benefit resulting from the private advantage conferred is insufficient to satisfy the fundamental requirement that tax revenue must be exacted and expended strictly for public purposes.

3. Delegated Taxing Power
Although the power of taxation is inherently legislative and non-delegable under the doctrine of separation of powers, certain exceptions are constitutionally recognized. Legislative taxing power may be validly delegated to local government units under Article X of the Constitution to foster local autonomy, to the President under tariff and flexible tax provisions, and to administrative agencies for executive implementation through administrative rules. Delegated administrative tax issuances must remain within statutory boundaries and cannot exceed, restrict, or modify legislative tax enactments.

TopicsDelegated Taxing Power1Public Purpose Rule1Uniformity in Taxation1

2014 Taxation Law, Q29

Doña Evelina, a rich widow engaged in the business of currency exchange, was assessed a considerable amount of local business taxes by the City Government of Bagnet by virtue of Tax Ordinance No. 24. Despite her objections thereto, Doña Evelina paid the taxes. Nevertheless, unsatisfied with said Tax Ordinance, Doña Evelina, through her counsel Atty. ELP, filed a written claim for recovery of said local business taxes and contested the assessment. Her claim was denied, and so Atty. ELP elevated her case to the Regional Trial Court (RTC).
The RTC declared Tax Ordinance No. 24 null and void and without legal effect for having been enacted in violation of the public ation requirement of tax ordinances and revenue measures under the Local Government Code (LGC) and on the ground of double taxation. On appeal, the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) affirmed the decision of the RTC. No motion for reconsideration was filed and the decision became final and executory. (4%)
(A) If you are Atty. ELP, what advice will you give Doña Evelina so that she can recover the subject local business taxes?
(B) If Doña Evelina eventually recovers the local business taxes, must the same be considered as income taxable by the national government?

Quick check

What is the appropriate procedural remedy to recover local business taxes after a CTA decision voiding a tax ordinance becomes final and executory?

Under Section 34(C)(1) of the NIRC, how is a tax refund treated for income tax purposes under the tax benefit rule?

Why is a local business tax ordinance declared null and void if it fails to meet statutory publication requirements?

If a taxpayer did not claim a refunded local business tax as a deduction in previous tax returns, is the refund taxable?

Choices available with full access.

Which government entity has statutory authority to issue a writ of execution for a final tax refund judgment?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Tax Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Execution of Judgment
When a judgment of the Court of Tax Appeals declaring a local tax ordinance null and void becomes final and executory, the prevailing taxpayer cannot obtain an automatic cash refund without procedural enforcement. The appropriate legal remedy is to file a motion for execution before the court of origin or the CTA pursuant to its revised rules of procedure. Execution compels the local treasurer to refund the unconstitutionally collected local business taxes from municipal funds.

2. Tax Benefit Rule
Under Section 34(C)(1) of the National Internal Revenue Code, local taxes paid or accrued within the taxable year in connection with the taxpayer's trade or business are allowable deductions from gross income. However, under the tax benefit rule, if a previously deducted local business tax is subsequently refunded or credited, the amount recovered must be included as part of gross income in the taxable year of receipt to the extent of the income tax benefit derived from the prior deduction.

3. Local Business Tax
Local government units possess delegated authority to levy local business taxes under the Local Government Code. However, tax ordinances must comply with mandatory statutory requirements, including mandatory publication and constitutional limits against double taxation. When a tax ordinance is declared void ab initio for non-compliance with statutory publication requirements, all tax collections executed under the invalid ordinance lack legal foundation and are subject to full recovery by the aggrieved taxpayer.

TopicsExecution of Judgment6Local Business Tax7Tax Benefit Rule1

2013 Bar Examinations

2013 Taxation Law, Q1

In its final adjustment return for the 2010 taxable year, ABC Corp. had excess tax credits arising from its over-withholding of income payments. It opted to carry over the excess tax credits to the following year. Subsequently, ABC Corp. changed its mind and applied for a refund of the excess tax credits.
Will the claim for refund prosper? (6%)

Quick check

What happens once a corporation exercises the option to carry over its excess tax credits under Section 76 of the NIRC?

Under Section 76 of the Tax Code, what choices are available to a corporation with excess income tax credits?

If a corporation opts to carry over excess tax credits, until when may those credits be applied against income tax liabilities?

Which rule prevents a corporation from claiming a cash refund after opting to carry over excess creditable withholding tax?

What is an essential statutory prerequisite for a corporation to successfully claim a refund of excess income tax credits?

Learn more about these topics

1. Irrevocability Rule
Under Section 76 of the National Internal Revenue Code, a corporate taxpayer entitled to excess creditable withholding tax has two alternative options: to carry over the excess tax credits to the succeeding taxable years, or to apply for a cash refund or tax credit certificate. Once the corporate taxpayer exercises the option to carry over excess credits in its final adjustment return, that election becomes irrevocable for that taxable period. The corporation cannot subsequently revoke its choice and claim a cash refund or tax credit certificate for the same overpaid amount.

2. Excess Tax Credits
Excess tax credits arise when the creditable taxes withheld from a corporation's gross income exceed its total income tax liability for the taxable year. While taxpayers are legally entitled to relief from overpayment, Section 76 mandates a strict choice between carry-over and refund. If carry-over is selected, the excess credits do not expire and remain credited against future corporate income tax liabilities until fully utilized. This statutory mechanism prevents administrative confusion and dual recovery claims against government revenue.

3. Tax Refund Prerequisites
To successfully claim a cash tax refund or tax credit certificate under Section 76, the corporate taxpayer must satisfy specific statutory requisites. First, the claim must be filed within the two-year prescriptive period from the date of payment of tax. Second, the taxpayer must show on the return that a refund was expressly requested. Most importantly, the taxpayer must not have exercised the option to carry over the excess tax credits, as selecting carry-over serves as an absolute statutory bar to any subsequent refund claim.

TopicsExcess Tax Credits1Irrevocability Rule4Section 76 NIRC4

2013 Taxation Law, Q2

A group of philanthropists organized a non-stock, non-profit hospital for charitable purposes to provide medical services to the poor. The hospital also accepted paying patients although none of its income accrued to any private individual; all income were plowed back for the hospital’s use and not more than 30% of its funds were used for administrative purposes.
Is the hospital subject to tax on its income? If it is, at what rate? (6%)

Quick check

Under the St. Luke's doctrine, how is a non-stock, non-profit hospital taxed on income derived from paying patients?

Which statutory provision grants a preferential income tax rate to proprietary and non-profit hospitals?

What occurs if a non-stock hospital's gross income from unrelated trade or business exceeds fifty percent of its total gross income?

What is required under Section 30 of the NIRC for a charitable entity to retain its non-profit status?

How is income devoted strictly to free medical services for indigent patients treated for tax purposes?

Learn more about these topics

1. Hospital Tax Status
Under Section 30(E) of the National Internal Revenue Code, a non-stock, non-profit charitable hospital is exempt from corporate income tax on income generated from its charitable activities. However, under Section 27(B) as interpreted in Commissioner of Internal Revenue versus St. Luke's Medical Center, Inc., revenues derived from for-profit activities, such as admitting and treating paying patients, are subject to a preferential ten percent income tax rate, provided the hospital's revenues from unrelated trade or business do not exceed fifty percent of its total gross income.

2. St. Luke's Doctrine
The Supreme Court in St. Luke's Medical Center established that tax exemption under Section 30(E) requires exclusive charitable operation. While a non-stock, non-profit hospital does not lose its charitable character simply by accepting paying patients, revenues generated from paying patients constitute income derived from activities conducted for profit. Consequently, income from paying patients is taxable at the preferential corporate rate of ten percent, while income devoted strictly to charitable care for indigent patients remains tax-exempt.

3. Administrative Expense Limit
For non-stock, non-profit charitable institutions claiming tax exemption under Section 30 of the Tax Code, no part of the net income may inure to the benefit of any private stockholder or individual. Furthermore, statutory regulations mandate that administrative expenses must not exceed thirty percent of total funds. Where a charitable hospital plows back all earnings into operational upkeep and restricts administrative costs within the thirty percent ceiling, it satisfies the non-inurement and administrative expense conditions required to preserve its statutory organization status.

TopicsNon-Profit Hospital Taxation1Proprietary Educational and Hospital Tax1Section 30(E) NIRC1