Bar Subject: Tax Law

2015 Bar Examinations

2015 Taxation Law, Q19

In 2014, M City approved an ordinance levying customs duties and fees on goods coming into the territorial jurisdiction of the city. Said city ordinance was duly published on February 15, 2014 with effectivity date on March 1, 2014.
a. Is there a ground for opposing said ordinance? (2%)
b. What is the proper procedural remedy and applicable time periods for challenging the ordinance? (4%)

Quick check

Under Section 133(e) of the Local Government Code, which of the following taxes is a local government unit prohibited from levying?

Within what period from its effective date must an appeal challenging the legality of a local tax ordinance be filed with the Secretary of Justice?

How many days does the Secretary of Justice have to decide an administrative appeal challenging a local tax ordinance under Section 187 of the LGC?

If the Secretary of Justice fails to decide the appeal within sixty days, within what period may the taxpayer file an appeal with the court?

Choices available with full access.

What is the effect of filing an appeal with the Secretary of Justice under Section 187 on the collection of the challenged local tax?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Tax Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Local Taxing Limitations
Under Section 133(e) of the Local Government Code, local government units are explicitly prohibited from levying customs duties, registration fees of vessels, wharfage, tonnage dues, and all other kinds of customs fees, charges, and imposts. The power to impose customs duties is reserved exclusively for the National Government under the Tariff and Customs Code. Consequently, any local tax ordinance enacted by a city council that attempts to levy customs duties or fees on goods entering its territorial jurisdiction is ultra vires, unconstitutional, and completely void ab initio for exceeding statutory authority.

2. Secretary Appeal Procedure
Section 187 of the Local Government Code lays down the mandatory administrative procedure for challenging the constitutionality or legality of a local tax ordinance. Any aggrieved taxpayer must file a formal appeal with the Secretary of Justice within thirty days from the effective date of the questioned tax ordinance. The filing of an appeal with the Secretary of Justice does not suspend the accrual and collection of the local tax. The Secretary of Justice is granted a statutory period of sixty days from receipt of the appeal to render a final administrative decision.

3. Judicial Review Appeal
If the Secretary of Justice fails to decide the administrative appeal within sixty days from receipt, or if the Secretary renders a decision affirming the validity of the questioned tax ordinance, the aggrieved taxpayer may seek judicial relief. The taxpayer has thirty days from receipt of the adverse decision or thirty days from the lapse of the sixty-day administrative decision period to file a petition with a court of competent jurisdiction. Direct resort to the courts without exhausting administrative remedies before the Secretary of Justice renders the judicial petition prematurely filed.

TopicsLocal Taxing Limitations2Section 187 LGC Appeal1Ultra Vires Tax Ordinance1

2015 Taxation Law, Q20

After filing an Information for violation of Section 254 of the National Internal Revenue Code (Attempt to Evade or Defeat Tax) with the CTA, the Public Prosecutor manifested that the People is reserving the right to file the corresponding civil action for the recovery of the civil liability for taxes. As counsel for the accused, comment on the People’s manifestation. (3%)

Quick check

What is the statutory rule regarding the civil action for tax liability when a criminal tax case is filed with the CTA?

Is the Public Prosecutor permitted to reserve the right to file a separate civil action for tax liability in the CTA?

Which landmark Supreme Court decision reiterated that civil tax liability is jointly determined with the criminal action in the CTA?

What is the effect of filing a criminal Information for tax evasion under Section 254 of the NIRC before the CTA?

Choices available with full access.

What is the jurisdictional threshold of principal tax claimed for the CTA to exercise exclusive original jurisdiction over tax crimes?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Tax Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Joint Tax Institution
Under Section 7(b)(1) of Republic Act Number 9282 and Rule 9, Section 1 of the Revised Rules of the Court of Tax Appeals, the criminal action and the corresponding civil action for the recovery of civil liability for taxes shall at all times be simultaneously instituted and jointly determined in the same proceeding. Unlike ordinary criminal prosecutions under the Rules of Court, no reservation of the right to institute the civil action separately is recognized or allowed in tax cases before the Court of Tax Appeals.

2. Prohibition on Reservation
In Santos versus People, the Supreme Court affirmed that the civil action for collection of taxes is automatically deemed instituted upon the filing of the criminal Information before the Court of Tax Appeals. Consequently, any manifestation by the public prosecutor reserving the right to file a separate civil action for tax collection is procedurally improper, legally untenable, and directly violates statutory mandates governing tax litigation.

3. Exclusive CTA Jurisdiction
The Court of Tax Appeals exercises exclusive original jurisdiction over criminal offenses arising from violations of the National Internal Revenue Code where the principal amount of taxes or fees claimed is one million pesos or more. Because civil tax liability is inextricably intertwined with criminal tax evasion under Section 254 of the Tax Code, split jurisdiction is prohibited, ensuring that assessment, collection, and criminal prosecution are resolved in a unified judicial forum.

TopicsCTA Criminal Jurisdiction1Mandatory Institution of Civil Action1Section 254 NIRC1

2015 Taxation Law, Q21

MMM, Inc., a domestic telecommunications company, handles incoming telecommunications services for non-resident foreign companies by relaying international calls within the Philippines. To broaden the coverage of its telecommunications services throughout the country, MMM, Inc. entered into various interconnection agreements with local carriers. The non-resident foreign corporations pay MMM, Inc. in US dollars inwardly remitted through Philippine banks, in accordance with the rules and regulations of the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas.
MMM, Inc. filed its Quarterly VAT Returns for 2000. Subsequently, MMM, Inc. timely filed with the BIR an administrative claim for the refund of the amount of P6,321,486.50, representing excess input VAT attributable to its effectively zero-rated sales in 2000. The BIR ruled to deny the claim for refund of MMM, Inc. because the VAT official receipts submitted by MMM, Inc. to substantiate said claim did not bear the words “zero-rated” as required under Section 4.108-1 of Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 7-95. On appeal, the CTA division and the CT A en bane affirmed the BIR ruling.
MMM, Inc. appealed to the Supreme Court arguing that the NIRC itself did not provide for such a requirement. RR No. 7-95 should not prevail over a taxpayer’s substantive right to claim tax refund or credit.
a. Rule on the appeal of MMM, Inc. (3%)
b. Will your answer in (a) be any different if MMM, Inc. was claiming refund of excess input VAT attributable to its effectively zero-rated sales in 2012? (2%)

Quick check

What is the effect of failing to imprint the word zero-rated on official receipts when claiming an input VAT refund for zero-rated sales?

Under Section 4.108-1 of RR No. 7-95 and Section 113 of the NIRC, why must zero-rated receipts be explicitly imprinted?

Which landmark Supreme Court doctrine affirmed that RR No. 7-95 invoicing rules were incorporated into statutory law by RA 9337?

How are statutory provisions granting tax refunds or tax credit certificates construed under Philippine tax jurisprudence?

Choices available with full access.

Would a 2012 claim for refund of excess input VAT succeed if official receipts lack the imprinted word zero-rated?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Tax Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Zero-Rated Invoicing Requirement
Under Section 4.108-1 of Revenue Regulations Number 7-95 and Section 113 of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended by Republic Act Number 9337, the imprinting of the word zero-rated on value-added tax invoices or official receipts is mandatory for zero-rated sales. Failure to imprint the term zero-rated on official receipts invalidates a claim for input value-added tax refund or tax credit certificate because tax exemptions and tax refunds are strictly construed against the taxpayer and in favor of the taxing authority.

2. Legislative Reenactment Doctrine
In Kepco Philippines Corporation versus Commissioner of Internal Revenue, the Supreme Court held that the administrative invoicing requirement under Revenue Regulations Number 7-95 was subsequently incorporated into statutory law under Section 113 of the Tax Code through Republic Act Number 9337. Under the doctrine of legislative reenactment, when Congress reenacts a law incorporating administrative regulations issued by executive agencies, such regulations acquire statutory force and validate earlier administrative interpretations requiring strict compliance.

3. Strict Construction Rule
Tax refunds and tax credit certificates derived from unutilized input value-added tax are in the nature of tax exemptions. Statutory provisions granting tax refunds are strictly construed against the claimant taxpayer. Failure to strictly comply with mandatory administrative and statutory invoicing requirements, such as printing zero-rated on official receipts, is fatal to an administrative or judicial claim for refund, regardless of whether foreign currency payments were inwardly remitted through banking channels.

TopicsRR No. 7-95 Imprinting Requirement1Section 113 NIRC1VAT Zero-Rated Invoicing1

2015 Taxation Law, Q22

State the conditions for allowing the following as deductions from the gross estate of a citizen or resident alien for the purpose of imposing estate tax:
a. Claims against the estate (2%)
b. Medical expenses (2%)

Quick check

What is required for a claim against the estate to be deductible from the gross estate under Section 86(A)(2) of the NIRC?

Under the TRAIN Law (RA 10963), what is the current tax treatment of medical expenses incurred prior to the decedent's death?

If a loan claimed as a deduction against the estate was contracted within three years prior to death, what additional document is required?

What is the allowable standard deduction for a citizen or resident alien decedent under the TRAIN Law?

Choices available with full access.

Prior to its repeal by the TRAIN Law, what was the statutory cap on deductible medical expenses incurred within one year before death?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Tax Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Claims Against Estate
Under Section 86(A)(2) of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended by Republic Act Number 10963, claims against the estate are deductible from the gross estate provided they represent a bona fide obligation contracted for adequate and full consideration in money or money's worth. The debt instrument must be duly notarized, and if the loan was contracted within three years prior to the decedent's death, the executor or administrator must submit a notarized statement detailing the disposition of the loan proceeds to substantiate the deduction.

2. Medical Expenses Repeal
Prior to the enactment of Republic Act Number 10963, commonly known as the TRAIN Law, medical expenses incurred by the decedent within one year prior to death were deductible up to five hundred thousand pesos, provided they were duly substantiated with receipts. However, the TRAIN Law explicitly repealed medical expenses as an allowable deduction from the gross estate. Consequently, for estates of decedents dying on or after January 1, 2018, no deduction for medical expenses may be claimed against the gross estate.

3. Standard Estate Deduction
To simplify estate tax administration and compensate for the repeal of medical and funeral expense deductions, Republic Act Number 10963 increased the standard deduction for citizen or resident alien decedents to five million pesos. Unlike itemized claims, the standard deduction is allowable as a statutory deduction from the gross estate without requiring proof or official receipts. This streamlined deduction structure simplifies net estate computation while eliminating administrative disputes over substantiating final medical costs and funeral bills.

TopicsClaims Against Estate2Estate Tax Deductions6TRAIN Law Estate Tax1

2014 Bar Examinations

2014 Taxation Law, Q1

On March 27, 2012, the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) issued a notice of assessment against Blue Water Industries Inc. (BWI), a domestic corporation, informing the latter of its alleged deficiency corporate income tax for the year 2009. On April 20, 2012, BWI filed a letter protest before the BIR contesting said assessment and demanding that the same be cancelled or set aside.
However, on May 19, 2013, that is, after more than a year from the filing of the letter protest, the BIR informed BWI that the latter’s letter protest was denied on the ground that the assessment had already become final, executory and demandable. The BIR reasoned that its failure to decide the case within 180 days from filing of the letter protest should have prompted BWI to seek recourse before the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) by filing a petition for review within thirty (30) days after the expiration of the 180-day period as mandated by the provisions of the last paragraph of Section 228 of the National Internal Revenue Code (NIRC). Accordingly, BWI’s failure to file a petition for review before the CTA rendered the assessment final, executory and demandable. Is the contention of the BIR correct? Explain. (5%)

Quick check

Under Section 228 of the NIRC, what options does a taxpayer have if the CIR fails to decide a protest within 180 days?

Which landmark case established that failure to appeal the CIR's 180-day inaction does not render the assessment final?

Within how many days from receipt of the CIR's final decision on a disputed assessment must the taxpayer appeal to the CTA?

What is the legal effect if the CIR fails to act on a protest within 180 days from submission of supporting documents?

If a taxpayer chooses to await the CIR's final decision after 180 days of inaction, when does the CTA appeal period begin?

Learn more about these topics

1. Disputed Assessment Options
Under Section 228 of the National Internal Revenue Code, if the Commissioner of Internal Revenue fails to act on a disputed tax assessment within one hundred eighty days from the submission of supporting documents, the taxpayer is granted two mutually exclusive options. The taxpayer may either appeal the administrative inaction to the Court of Tax Appeals within thirty days from the lapse of the one hundred eighty-day period, or await the final decision of the Commissioner and appeal that decision within thirty days from receipt.

2. Lascona Land Doctrine
In Lascona Land, Incorporated versus Commissioner of Internal Revenue, the Supreme Court clarified that a taxpayer's failure to appeal the Commissioner's one hundred eighty-day inaction to the Court of Tax Appeals does not render the tax assessment final, executory, or demandable. The administrative remedy to await the final decision of the Commissioner remains available, and the assessment only becomes final if the taxpayer fails to appeal the actual decision within thirty days from receipt.

3. Inaction Appeal Period
The option to appeal administrative inaction within thirty days after the lapse of the one hundred eighty-day period is merely permissive and intended for the taxpayer's benefit. Inaction by the tax authority does not constitute a denial of the protest by operation of law. Therefore, forcing the taxpayer to appeal immediately upon the expiration of the one hundred eighty-day period would divest the Commissioner of the statutory jurisdiction to decide protests on disputed assessments.

TopicsDisputed Assessment1Lascona Land Doctrine1Section 228 NIRC5