Bar Subject: Tax Law

2016 Bar Examinations

2016 Taxation Law, Q14

Lucky V Corporation (Lucky) owns a IO-storey building on a 2,000 square meter lot in the City of Makati. It sold the lot and building to Rainier. for P80 million. One month after, Rainier sold the lot and building to Healthy Smoke Company (HSC) for P200 million. Lucky filed its annual tax return and declared its gain from the sale of the lot and building in the amount of P750,000.00.
An investigation conducted by the BIR revealed that two months prior to the sale of the properties to Rainier, Lucky received P40 million from HSC and not from Rainier. Said amount of P40 million was debited by HSC and reflected in its trial balance as “other inv. – Lucky Bldg.” The month after, another P40 million was reflected in HSC’s trial balance as “other inv. – Lucky Bldg.” The BIR concluded that there is tax evasion since the real buyer of the properties of Lucky is HSC and not Rainier. It issued an assessment for deficiency income tax in the amount of P79 million against Lucky. Lucky argues that it resorted to tax avoidance or a tax saving device, which is allowed by the NIRC and BIR rules since it paid the correct taxes based on its sale to Rainier. On the other hand, Rainier and HSC also paid the prescribed taxes arising from the sale by Rainier to HSC. Is the BIR correct in assessing taxes on Lucky? Explain. (5%)

Quick check

In CIR versus Estate of Benigno Toda, Jr., what is the legal characterization of a multi-step sale using a dummy conduit to reduce corporate income tax?

How does tax evasion differ legally from tax avoidance under Philippine internal revenue laws?

What principle allows revenue authorities to disregard a dummy intermediary in a multi-step property sale?

What evidence indicated that Healthy Smoke Company was the true direct buyer from Lucky V Corporation?

Choices available with full access.

What is the tax consequence when a real property conveyance is declared a sham tax evasion scheme?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Tax Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Tax Evasion Doctrine
Under Philippine tax law, tax evasion is the illegal scheme or device used to defeat or lessen the payment of a tax. In Commissioner of Internal Revenue versus Estate of Benigno Toda, Jr., the Supreme Court ruled that a fraudulent multi-step transaction utilizing a dummy intermediary conduit to sell corporate real property to an ultimate buyer constitutes illegal tax evasion rather than permissible tax avoidance. Tax evasion is characterized by an accompanying state of mind indicating bad faith, intentional wrongdoing, or deliberate tax minimization schemes.

2. Intermediary Conduit Rule
When a transaction employs a dummy corporate or individual conduit solely to artificially create an intermediate sale and minimize tax liabilities, tax law disregards the simulated intermediary under the doctrine of substance over form. Where direct monetary payments flow directly from the ultimate buyer to the original seller prior to the purported intermediate conveyance, the intermediate transfer is treated as a sham. The tax liability is calculated based on the actual direct sale between the real seller and ultimate purchaser.

3. Tax Avoidance Distinction
Tax avoidance is the legal minimization of tax liabilities through legitimate tax saving devices allowed by the National Internal Revenue Code. Conversely, tax evasion involves willful misrepresentation, fraud, or deliberate concealment of material facts to evade full tax payment. While taxpayers may minimize taxes using legal means, structuring artificial multi-step conveyances to misstate taxable income and bypass corporate income tax rates crosses the threshold into unlawful tax evasion, rendering the assessment valid.

TopicsCIR v. Estate of Toda1Conduit Transaction Taxability1Tax Evasion vs Tax Avoidance1

2016 Taxation Law, Q15

Peter is the Vice-President for Sales of Golden Dragon Realty Conglomerate, Inc. (Golden Dragon). A group of five (5) foreign investors visited the country for possible investment in the condominium units and subdivision lots of Golden Dragon. After a tour of the properties for sale, the investors were wined and dined by Peter at the posh Conrad’s Hotel at the cost of Pl 50,000.00. Afterward, the investors were brought to a party in a videoke club which cost the company P200,000.00 for food and drinks, and the amount of P80,000.00 as tips for business promotion officers. Expenses at Conrad’s Hotel and the videoke club were receipted and submitted to support the deduction for representation and entertainment expenses. Decide if all the representation and entertainment expenses claimed by Golden Dragon are deductible. Explain. (5%)

Quick check

Under Section 34(A)(1)(a)(iv) of the NIRC, what is required for representation and entertainment expenses to be deductible?

What is the statutory ceiling on deductible representation expenses for real property sellers under Revenue Regulations 10-2002?

Why are tips paid to business promotion officers disallowed as tax deductions if contrary to law or morals?

How does Revenue Regulations 10-2002 treat receipted hotel dining expenses incurred for prospective foreign investors?

Choices available with full access.

What is the tax consequence if a real estate corporation's total receipted representation expenses exceed 0.50% of net sales?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Tax Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Representation Expense Deductibility
Under Section 34(A)(1)(a)(iv) of the National Internal Revenue Code and Revenue Regulations No. 10-2002, representation and entertainment expenses are deductible from gross income if directly connected to or related to the conduct of trade, business, or profession. To be allowable, such expenses must be reasonable, properly supported by official receipts or adequate records, and not contrary to law, public policy, or morals. Entertainment expenses incurred in hosting prospective foreign investors at a hotel or dining facility qualify as legitimate business representation expenses.

2. Net Sales Ceiling
Revenue Regulations No. 10-2002 imposes a statutory ceiling on deductible representation and entertainment expenses to prevent tax avoidance. For taxpayers engaged in the sale of goods or properties, including real estate developers selling condominium units and subdivision lots, the deductible expense cap is set at zero point fifty percent of net sales. Even if representation expenses are fully receipted and directly business-related, any amount exceeding this statutory threshold is non-deductible and must be disallowed during tax audit assessments.

3. Public Policy Prohibition
Under general principles of tax law and Section 34 of the Tax Code, expenses that are contrary to law, public policy, or morals are strictly disallowed as tax deductions. Payments such as unreceipted tips given to business promotion officers or kickbacks disguised as promotional expenses fail the statutory test of deductibility. Employers cannot claim tax deductions for disbursements that lack proper substantiation or violate public morals. Revenue authorities validly disallow improper promotional payments.

TopicsNet Sales Ceiling Rule1Public Policy Expense Prohibition1Representation Expense Deductibility1

2016 Taxation Law, Q16

Amor Powers, Inc. (API) is a domestic corporation registered with the BIR as a value-added taxpayer. API incurred excess input VAT in the amount of P500,000,000.00 on August 3, 2008. Hence, it filed with the BIR an administrative claim for the refund or credit of these input taxes on August 15, 2010. Without waiting for the CIR to act on its claim, API filed a Petition for Review with the CT A on September 15, 2010 before the lapse of two years after the close of the taxable quarter concerned.
In its Comment on the Petition, the CIR argues that API’s Petition should be dismissed as it was filed before the lapse of the 120-day period given to the CIR by Sec. 112(D) of the NIRC, which became effective on January 1, 1998. For the CIR, the 120- day period is mandatory and jurisdictional so that any suit filed before its expiration is premature and, therefore, dismissible.
API, on the other hand, invokes BIR Ruling No. DA-489-03 issued by the CIR on December 10, 2003 in answer to a query posed by the Department of Finance regarding the propriety of the actions taken by Lazi Bay Resources Development, Inc., which filed an administrative claim for refund with the CIR and, before the lapse of the 120-day period from its filing, filed a judicial claim with the CTA. BIR Ruling No. DA-489-03 stated that the taxpayer-claimant need not wait for the lapse of the 120-day period before it could seek judicial relief with the CTA.
Will API’s Petition for Review prosper? Decide with reasons. (5%)

Quick check

What is the general rule regarding the 120-day administrative waiting period under Section 112(D) of the NIRC?

What exception to the strict 120-day rule was recognized in CIR versus San Roque Power Corporation?

What is the exact window period during which taxpayers are protected by BIR Ruling Number DA-489-03?

Why did the Court of Tax Appeals acquire jurisdiction over API's judicial claim filed on September 15, 2010?

Choices available with full access.

What legal doctrine prevents the government from penalizing taxpayers who relied in good faith on BIR Ruling Number DA-489-03?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Tax Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Mandatory 120-Day Period
Under Section 112(D) of the National Internal Revenue Code, compliance with the 120-day administrative waiting period given to the Commissioner of Internal Revenue to decide an input Value-Added Tax refund claim is mandatory and jurisdictional. Prior to the expiration of the 120-day period, or a notice of denial within said period, a judicial appeal filed before the Court of Tax Appeals is premature. Premature filing deprives the Tax Court of jurisdiction, as judicial review requires an exhaustion of administrative remedies or expiration of the statutory period granted to the revenue commissioner.

2. BIR Ruling DA-489-03
In Commissioner of Internal Revenue versus San Roque Power Corporation, the Supreme Court recognized BIR Ruling Number DA-489-03 as a valid administrative issuance creating an exception to the strict 120-day rule. Issued on December 10, 2003, the ruling allowed taxpayers to seek immediate judicial relief with the Court of Tax Appeals without waiting for the lapse of the 120-day period. Taxpayers who relied on this administrative interpretation in good faith while it was in force are protected under the doctrine of equitable estoppel.

3. Window Period Protection
The protective umbrella of BIR Ruling Number DA-489-03 applies strictly to judicial claims filed during the window period from December 10, 2003 to October 6, 2010, when Acoje Mining was promulgated reiterating the mandatory nature of the 120-day period. Judicial claims filed within this specific window period are deemed timely and valid even if prematurely elevated to the Court of Tax Appeals. Consequently, taxpayers who filed administrative refund claims and subsequent judicial appeals within this window period are protected from dismissal on jurisdictional grounds.

TopicsBIR Ruling DA-489-031CIR v. San Roque1VAT Refund Period1

2016 Taxation Law, Q17

The requisites for a valid waiver of the three-year (3-year) prescriptive period for the BIR to assess taxes due in the taxable year are prescribed by Revenue Memorandum Order (RMO) No. 20-90:
1. The waiver must be in the proper form prescribed by RMO 20-90.
2. The waiver must be signed by the taxpayer himself or his duly authorized representative. In the case of a corporation, the waiver must be signed by any of its responsible officials. In case the authority is delegated by the taxpayer to a representative, such delegation should be in writing and duly notarized.
3. The waiver should be duly notarized.
4. The CIR or the revenue official authorized by him must sign the waiver indicating that the BIR has accepted and agreed to the waiver. The date of such acceptance by the BIR should be indicated. However, before signing the waiver, the CIR or the revenue official authorized by him must make sure that the waiver is in the prescribed form, duly notarized, and executed by the taxpayer or his duly authorized representative.
5. Both the date of execution by the taxpayer and date of acceptance by the Bureau should be before the expiration of the period of prescription or before the lapse of the period agreed upon in case a subsequent agreement is executed.
6. The waiver must be executed in three copies, the original copy to be attached to the docket of the case, the second copy for the taxpayer and the third copy for the Office accepting the waiver. The fact of receipt by the taxpayer of his/her file copy must be indicated in the original copy to show that the taxpayer was notified of the acceptance of the BIR and the perfection of the agreement.
After being assessed by the BIR with alleged deficiency income taxes, VVV Corporation (VVV) through Enrique, its President, executed a waiver of the prescriptive period. The waiver was signed by Revenue District Officer (RDO) Alfredo. However, the waiver did not state the date of execution by the taxpayer and date of acceptance by the BIR. Enrique was also not furnished a copy of the waiver by the BIR.
VVV claims that the waiver is void due to non-compliance with RMO 20-90. Hence, the period for assessment had already prescribed. Moreover, since the assessment involves P2 million, the waiver should have been signed by the CIR and instead of a mere RDO. On the other hand, the BIR contends that the requirements ofRMO No. 20-90 are merely directory; that the execution of the waiver by VVV was a renunciation of its right to invoke prescription and that the government cannot be estopped by the mistakes committed by its revenue officers. Is VVV liable? Explain. (5%)

Quick check

What is the legal nature of a waiver of the statute of limitations under RMO Number 20-90?

What is the legal effect of failing to state the date of execution and acceptance on a tax waiver?

Why is the BIR prohibited from invoking estoppel to validate a defective waiver executed by its revenue officers?

What requirement regarding taxpayer notification is essential for the perfection of a tax waiver under RMO 20-90?

Choices available with full access.

How are rules governing the execution of waivers of the statute of limitations construed under Philippine tax law?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Tax Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Waiver Requirements
Under Revenue Memorandum Order Number 20-90 and Revenue Delegation Authority Order Number 05-01, a waiver of the statute of limitations is not a unilateral act of the taxpayer but a bilateral agreement between the taxpayer and the Bureau of Internal Revenue. Strict compliance with the procedures set forth in RMO 20-90 is mandatory. Among these mandatory requirements are indicating the exact dates of execution and acceptance, properly notarizing the document, and furnishing the taxpayer a copy showing receipt of acceptance. Failure to satisfy these mandatory procedural requirements renders the waiver void and ineffective.

2. Strict Construction Rule
A waiver of the statute of limitations extends the government's right to assess taxes beyond the statutory three-year prescriptive period. Because it derogates the taxpayer's statutory protection against prolonged tax audits, rules governing the execution of waivers are strictly construed against the revenue authorities. The Bureau of Internal Revenue cannot claim that waiver requirements are merely directory or that non-compliance is cured by estoppel. When revenue officers fail to observe mandatory waiver formalities, the waiver is completely invalid, and the period to assess tax liabilities continues to run.

3. Prescription Defense
When a waiver of prescription is declared void due to non-compliance with statutory and administrative requirements, the government loses its legal authority to issue a deficiency tax assessment after the three-year period expires. An assessment issued after the lapse of the prescriptive period is void. The government cannot invoke the general principle that estoppel does not run against the State to validate a void waiver, because the State cannot profit from the negligence or omission of its own revenue officers in failing to comply with mandatory regulations.

TopicsPrescription of Tax Assessment1RMO No. 20-90 Compliance1Waiver of Statute of Limitations2

2016 Taxation Law, Q18

Henry, a U.S. naturalized citizen, went home to the Philippines to reacquire Philippine citizenship under RA 9225. His mother left him a lot and building in Makati City and he wants to make use of it in his trading business. Considering that he needs money for the business, he wants to sell his lot and building and make use of the consideration. However, the lot has sentimental value and he wants to reacquire it in the future. A friend of Henry told him of the “sale-leaseback transaction” commonly used in the U.S., which is also used for tax reduction. Under said transaction, the lot owner sells his property to a buyer on the condition that he leases it back from the buyer. At the same time, the property owner is granted an option to repurchase the lot on or before an agreed date. Henry approaches you as a tax lawyer for advice.
Explain what tax benefits, if any, can be obtained by Henry and the buyer from the sale-leaseback transaction? (5%)

Quick check

How are rental payments treated for tax purposes by a seller-lessee in a sale-leaseback transaction?

Under Section 32(A)(5) of the NIRC, how is rental income received by the buyer-lessor classified?

What tax deductions can a buyer-lessor claim against gross rental income derived from a leased building?

Why does a sale-leaseback transaction often provide greater tax deductions to a business seller than retaining ownership?

Choices available with full access.

What statutory requirement must be met for lease payments in a sale-leaseback to be deductible by the lessee?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Tax Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Sale Leaseback Concept
A sale-leaseback transaction is a financial arrangement where an owner sells real property used in business to a buyer and simultaneously leases it back from the purchaser. This transaction provides immediate capital liquidity to the seller without interrupting continuous business operations on the premises. In Philippine tax law, rental payments paid by the seller-lessee are recognized as legitimate ordinary and necessary business expenses. The seller can deduct full lease rentals from gross business income, which often yields greater tax deductions than annual property depreciation allowances.

2. Seller Tax Advantages
For the seller-lessee engaged in trade or business, rental payments under a leaseback agreement are fully deductible from gross income under Section 34(A)(1)(a) of the National Internal Revenue Code. By converting a real property asset into lease payments, the seller maximizes business deductions against gross revenue. Furthermore, capital generated from the property sale provides immediate working capital for commercial expansion. Provided the transaction reflects genuine economic substance, the seller lawfully minimizes overall tax liability through allowable statutory deductions.

3. Buyer Tax Treatment
For the buyer-lessor, rental payments received from the seller-lessee constitute taxable gross income under Section 32(A)(5) of the Tax Code. However, the buyer as legal property owner is entitled to claim property-related deductions under Section 34. These allowable deductions include annual depreciation of the building, structural maintenance expenses, and local real property taxes paid to municipal authorities. These statutory expense deductions offset the buyer's taxable rental income, thereby lowering net tax liability while maintaining a steady income-generating real estate investment.

TopicsDeductible Rental Expense1Property Rental Income Taxability1Sale-Leaseback Transaction1