Bar Subject: Tax Law

2017 Bar Examinations

2017 Taxation Law, Q3

Vanderful, lnc.’s income tax return for taxable year 2015 showed an overpayment due to excess creditable withholding taxes in the amount of ₱750,000.00. The company opted to carry over the excess income tax credits as tax credit against its quarterly income tax liabilities for the next succeeding years. For taxable year 2016, the company’s income tax return showed an overpayment due to excess creditable withholding taxes in the amount of ₱1,100,000.00, which included the carry-over from year 2015 in the amount of ₱750,000.00 because its operations resulted in a net loss; hence, there was no application for any tax liability. This time, the company opted and marked the box “To be refunded’ in respect of the total amount of ₱1,100,000.00.
Vanderful, Inc. now files in the BIR a claim for refund of unutilized overpayments of ₱1,100,00.00. Is the claim meritorious? (4%)

Quick check

Under Section 76 of the Tax Code, what is the legal effect of choosing to carry over excess creditable withholding taxes?

If a corporation carries over excess tax credits from 2015 to 2016 and incurs a net loss in 2016, can it claim a cash refund for the 2015 excess credit on its 2016 return?

How is a refund claim treated when it combines ₱750,000 carried over from a prior year and ₱350,000 in new creditable withholding taxes generated in the current year?

What are the two mutually exclusive options available to a corporation under Section 76 for excess creditable withholding taxes?

What happens to excess creditable withholding taxes that are irrevocably carried over to succeeding taxable years?

Learn more about these topics

1. Irrevocability Rule
Under Section 76 of the National Internal Revenue Code, a corporate taxpayer that has excess creditable withholding tax for a taxable year has two mutually exclusive remedies: either to claim a cash refund or tax credit certificate, or to carry over the excess credit against income tax liabilities for succeeding taxable quarters. Once the option to carry over has been exercised, it becomes irrevocable for that taxable period. The taxpayer cannot subsequently change its mind and request a cash refund for the carried-over amount, even if its operations in subsequent years result in net operating losses.

2. Net Excess Calculation
When a corporate taxpayer generates new excess creditable withholding taxes in a subsequent taxable year, the irrevocability rule applies strictly to prior excess tax credits carried over from earlier years. The new creditable withholding taxes generated during the current taxable year represent distinct tax credits for which the taxpayer may freely choose between a cash refund or carry-over on its current annual income tax return. Therefore, a refund claim combining prior carried-over credits and newly generated credits is valid and allowable only to the extent of the newly generated excess credits.

3. Section 76 Remedies
Section 76 of the Tax Code seeks to prevent administrative confusion and speculative shifting between refund claims and tax credit carry-overs. Once a taxpayer elects the carry-over option on its annual return, the excess tax credit remains perpetually available in the taxpayer's account until fully utilized against future income tax liabilities. Because the statute establishes an absolute prohibition against refunding carried-over tax credits, any administrative or judicial claim for cash refund seeking to recover previously carried-over credits must be denied for lack of statutory entitlement.

TopicsExcess Creditable Withholding Tax1Irrevocability Rule4Section 76 NIRC4

2017 Taxation Law, Q4

On the basis of a warrant of seizure and detention issued by the Collector of Customs for the purpose of enforcing the Tariff and Customs Code, assorted brands of liquor and cigarettes said to have been illegally imported into the Philippines were seized from a store operating in a Freeport zone. The store owner moved for the quashal of the warrant on the ground that the Collector of Customs had no jurisdiction to enforce it within the Freeport zone.
Should the motion to quash be granted? (3%)

Quick check

Does the Bureau of Customs have jurisdiction to issue a warrant of seizure in a Freeport zone for illegal importations?

Which agency has exclusive original jurisdiction over seizure and forfeiture cases under customs law?

What is the legal effect of storing smuggled liquor and cigarettes inside a Freeport zone store?

Why is a motion to quash a customs warrant of seizure filed by a Freeport store owner properly denied?

Does a Freeport zone's status as a separate customs territory extend to illegal or untaxed importations?

Learn more about these topics

1. Freeport Customs Jurisdiction
Treating a Freeport zone as a separate customs territory does not completely divest the Bureau of Customs of its statutory authority to enforce customs laws. While Freeport zones enjoy preferential tax and duty treatment for legitimate goods, this legal fiction cannot be utilized to shield smuggled goods or illegal importations. When patent violations of tariff and customs laws occur within a Freeport zone, the Collector of Customs retains full enforcement jurisdiction.

2. Customs Seizure Authority
Under the Tariff and Customs Code and the Customs Modernization and Tariff Act, the Bureau of Customs possesses exclusive original jurisdiction over seizure and forfeiture proceedings involving illegally imported merchandise. The Collector of Customs is legally authorized to issue warrants of seizure and detention against contraband items found anywhere within Philippine territory, including special economic and freeport zones, to enforce compliance with national customs laws.

3. Illegal Importation Liability
Goods introduced into a Freeport zone without proper compliance with statutory importation requirements or applicable duty-free allowances remain subject to confiscation. Freeport status protects legitimate tax-exempt commercial activities but does not grant immunity from administrative seizure when unmanifested, undeclared, or smuggled goods like untaxed liquor and cigarettes are stored or offered for sale within the zone.

TopicsFreeport Zone Customs Jurisdiction1Tariff and Customs Code Enforcement1Warrant of Seizure and Detention1

2017 Taxation Law, Q5

On March 30, 2016, XL Co. filed an administrative claim for refund of unutilized input VAT for taxable year 2014, together with supporting documents. XL Co. claimed that its sale of generated power and delivery of electric capacity and energy was VAT zero-rated. Due to the inaction of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue (CIR), XL Co. filed with the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) the following judicial claims for refund:
Period Covered
Date Filed
1st Quarter of 2014
March 31, 2016
2nd Quarter of 2014
June 30, 2016
3rd and 4th Quarter of 2014
August 12, 2016
Is XL Co.’s claim for VAT refund timely filed? Explain your answer. (5%)

Quick check

Under Section 112(A) of the Tax Code, within what period must an administrative claim for VAT refund be filed?

How many days does the Commissioner of Internal Revenue have to decide an administrative VAT refund claim under Section 112(C)?

What is the legal effect of filing a petition for review with the CTA before the CIR's 120-day period expires?

Within what period must a taxpayer appeal to the CTA after the lapse of the CIR's 120-day period without a decision?

If an administrative VAT refund claim for all quarters of 2014 is filed on March 30, 2016, when does the CIR's 120-day period lapse?

Learn more about these topics

1. Two-Year Prescriptive Period
Under Section 112(A) of the National Internal Revenue Code, an administrative claim for refund or tax credit of unutilized input Value-Added Tax must be filed within two years after the close of the taxable quarter when the sales were made. This two-year period governs only the filing of the administrative application with the Bureau of Internal Revenue. Compliance with this statutory deadline is mandatory to preserve the taxpayer's right to seek recovery of unutilized input VAT.

2. 120-Day Administrative Inaction
Under Section 112(C) of the Tax Code, the Commissioner of Internal Revenue is granted a mandatory period of one hundred twenty days from administrative claim filing to grant or deny the refund. The Commissioner possesses exclusive jurisdiction during this 120-day window. Any judicial appeal filed with the Court of Tax Appeals before the expiration of the full 120-day period is premature and must be dismissed for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction.

3. 30-Day Judicial Appeal
Following the lapse of the 120-day administrative period without action from the Commissioner, the taxpayer has thirty days to file a petition for review with the Court of Tax Appeals. This 30-day period is mandatory and jurisdictional. A judicial claim filed within the 30-day window following the 120-day inaction period vests jurisdiction in the court, whereas premature or belated appeals deprive the court of jurisdiction.

Topics120+30 Day Rule2Two-Year Prescriptive Period1Value-Added Tax Refund2

2017 Taxation Law, Q6

Heeding the pronouncement of the President that the worsening traffic condition in the metropolis was a sign of economic progress, the Congress enacted Republic Act No. 10701 (RA 10701), also known as An Act Imposing a Transport Tax on the Purchase of Private Vehicles.
Under RA 10701, buyers of private vehicles are required to pay a transport tax equivalent to 5°/o of the total purchase price per vehicle purchased. RA 10701 provides that the Land Transportation Office (LTO) shall not accept for registration any new vehicles without proof of payment of the 5% transport tax. RA 10701 further provides that existing owners of private vehicles shall be required to pay a tax equivalent to 5% of the current fair market value of every vehicle registered with the LTO. However, RA 10701 exempts owners of public utility vehicles and the Government from the coverage of the 5% transport tax.
A group of private vehicle owners sue on the ground that the law is unconstitutional for contravening the Equal Protection Clause of the Constitution.
Rule on the constitutionality and validity of RA 10701. (5%)

Quick check

What is required for a tax classification to be valid under the Equal Protection Clause?

Why does exempting public utility vehicles from a private vehicle transport tax NOT violate equal protection?

Which requirement for a valid classification ensures that a tax law applies to future vehicle buyers and owners?

What legislative power permits Congress to select which entities or transactions to tax and exempt?

Choices available with full access.

Is Republic Act No. 10701 imposing a transport tax on private vehicles constitutional?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Tax Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Equal Protection Test
Under the 1987 Constitution, the Equal Protection Clause does not require absolute equality in taxation nor prohibit legislative classification. A tax classification is valid if it rests on substantial distinctions, is germane to the purpose of the law, applies to both present and future conditions, and applies equally to all members belonging to the same class. Congress possesses broad discretion in selecting the subjects of taxation, and courts will uphold tax classifications unless they are shown to be manifestly arbitrary or discriminatory.

2. Substantial Distinctions Basis
Substantial distinctions exist between private motor vehicles and exempted public utility or government vehicles. Private vehicles are primarily used for personal convenience and significantly contribute to urban traffic congestion, whereas public utility vehicles provide essential public transportation services to the commuting public and government vehicles execute public administrative functions. Exempting public utilities and government vehicles from a transport tax aimed at mitigating traffic congestion rests on reasonable economic and public welfare grounds rather than arbitrary discrimination.

3. Legislative Taxation Discretion
The power of taxation is an inherent attribute of sovereignty that is inherently legislative in character. Congress enjoys wide latitude in choosing what objects, transactions, or privileges to tax and which ones to exempt from taxation. In exercising this legislative power, statutory exemptions granted to public transport operators and state instrumentalities fall well within constitutional boundaries. As long as all private vehicle owners within the designated class are taxed uniformly at the same rate, the statutory scheme satisfies constitutional equal protection requirements.

TopicsEqual Protection Clause10Transport Tax Constitutionality1Valid Tax Classification1

2017 Taxation Law, Q7

Calvin Dela Pisa was a Permits and Licensing Officer (rank-and-file) of Sta. Portia Realty Corporation (SPRC). He invited the Regional Director of the Housing and Land Use Regulatory Board (HLURB) to lunch at the Sulo Hotel in Quezon City to discuss the approval of SPRC’s application for a development permit in connection with its subdivision development project in Pasig City. At breakfast the following day, Calvin met a prospective client interested to enter into a joint venture with SPRC for the construction of a residential condominium unit in Cainta, Rizal.
Calvin incurred expenses for the lunch and breakfast meetings he had with the Regional Director of HLURB and the prospective client, respectively. The expenses were duly supported by official receipts issued in his name. At month’s end, he requested the reimbursement of his expenses, and SPRC granted his request.
(a) Can SPRC claim an allowable deduction for the expenses incurred by Calvin? Explain your answer. (2.5%)
(b) Is the reimbursement received by Calvin from SPRC subject to tax? Explain your answer. (2.5%)

Quick check

Under Section 34(A)(1)(c) of the Tax Code, are meal expenses incurred for a government official deductible as business representation?

Are ordinary representation expenses incurred during meals with prospective private clients deductible by a corporation?

How is a substantiated business expense reimbursement received by an employee treated for income tax purposes?

Which requirement must be satisfied for an employee's meal reimbursement to be exempt from withholding tax?

Choices available with full access.

If a company reimburses an employee for both an illegal government meal and a valid client meal, which portion is deductible by the company?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Tax Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Illegal Payments Non-Deductibility
Under Section 34(A)(1)(c) of the National Internal Revenue Code, no deduction from gross income is allowed for any payment made directly or indirectly to an official or employee of the government if the payment constitutes a bribe or illegal kickback. Entertainment, meal, or representation expenses incurred for public officials in connection with securing permits or regulatory approvals are strictly non-deductible. Even if supported by official receipts, funds spent on government officers to facilitate official business cannot be claimed as ordinary and necessary corporate expenses.

2. Representation Expense Deductibility
Under Section 34(A)(1)(a) of the Tax Code and relevant revenue regulations, ordinary and necessary representation and entertainment expenses incurred in developing business or entertaining prospective private clients are deductible from corporate gross income. To be deductible, these expenses must be directly connected to or follow a substantial and bona fide business discussion, reasonable in amount, and supported by adequate receipts. Expenses incurred during meals with prospective private joint venture partners qualify as legitimate representation expenses.

3. Employee Expense Reimbursements
Under Revenue Regulations No. 2-98, advances or reimbursements received by an employee for ordinary and necessary representation expenses paid or incurred on behalf of the employer are not subject to income tax or withholding tax. For reimbursement to be tax-exempt to the employee, the employee must be required to account and substantiate the expenses with official receipts issued in the name of the employee or employer, and the expenses must be incurred strictly in the pursuit of the employer's business.

TopicsBribes and Illegal Payments Non-Deductibility1Employee Taxable Reimbursements1Representation and Entertainment Expenses1