2025 Labor Law, Q6
XYZ Company was engaged in the construction of luxury multi-storey homes and midrise condominiums. One of its projects was a three-storey mansion of Senator A. XYZ Company was about to do concrete pouring of slab and beams on the second floor of the mansion, and this process would take at least 20 hours straight with no interruption or break; otherwise, the structural integrity of the second floor and beams would be compromised. More, the process would need 25 workers to finish. B, one of the workers assigned to the project, refused to render overtime work, claiming that he cannot be compelled to do so. Is B correct? Reason(s).
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
No, B is not correct. He can be legally compelled to render overtime work. Under Article 89(e) of the Labor Code, while overtime is generally voluntary, an employer may compel an employee to perform overtime work when the
Unlock the full Labor Law answers365 days of full access. GCash, Maya and card accepted.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
Under what general rule does Philippine labor law regulate overtime work rendered by employees?
Overtime work is generally voluntary under the Labor Code, but an employer may compel overtime performance under specific statutory exceptions provided by law.
Which provision of the Labor Code authorizes an employer to require compulsory overtime work to prevent serious obstruction or prejudice to business operations?
Article 89 of the Labor Code lists the specific emergency and operational exceptions where compulsory overtime work may be lawfully required.
Why was employee B legally obligated to render overtime work during the continuous concrete pouring project?
Concrete pouring requires continuous execution to preserve structural integrity, placing it under the Article 89 exception preventing serious obstruction or prejudice to the employer's business.
What is the legal consequence if an employee unjustifiably refuses to comply with a lawful order to render compulsory overtime under Article 89?
Choices available with full access.
Which of the following scenarios constitutes a valid ground for compelling emergency overtime work under Article 89 of the Labor Code?
Choices available with full access.
Learn more about these topics
1. Compulsory Overtime Work
Under Article 89 of the Labor Code, overtime work is generally voluntary, based on the principle that employees cannot be forced to render labor beyond agreed working hours. However, the law provides statutory exceptions authorizing employers to require compulsory overtime work in urgent or critical situations. These exceptions include urgent work on machines or installations, prevention of loss or damage to perishable goods, cases of emergency or disaster, and situations where completing work started before the eighth hour is necessary to avoid serious obstruction or prejudice to company operations.
2. Preventing Serious Prejudice
Article 89(e) of the Labor Code specifically permits compulsory overtime when the completion or continuation of work started before the eighth hour is necessary to prevent serious obstruction or prejudice to the employer's business. In construction and engineering operations, continuous processes like concrete pouring cannot be halted halfway without destroying structural integrity. When interrupting work would cause severe financial damage, material loss, or operational disruption, the employer's directive to render overtime constitutes a valid and enforceable order under management prerogative.
3. Insubordination and Disobedience
An employee who unjustifiably refuses to obey a lawful order to render compulsory overtime during a statutory emergency or critical exception may be subjected to administrative disciplinary action. Under Article 297 of the Labor Code, willful disobedience of a lawful order issued by an employer in connection with the employee's work constitutes a just cause for termination. Because an order for compulsory overtime under Article 89 is backed by law, an employee's arbitrary refusal constitutes insubordination, provided the directive is reasonable, work-related, and communicated in good faith.
TopicsArticle 89 of the Labor Code1Compulsory Overtime1Management Prerogative11