Bar Subject: Labor Law

2018 Bar Examinations

2018 Labor Law, Q7

Nico is a medical representative engaged in the promotion of pharmaceutical products and medical devices for Northern Pharmaceuticals, Inc. He regularly visits physicians’ clinics to inform them of the chemical composition and benefits of his employer’s products. At the end of every day, he receives a basic wage of PhP700.00 plus a PhP150.00 “productivity allowance.” For purposes of computing Nico’s 13th month pay, should the daily “productivity allowance” be included? (2.5%)

Quick check

What is the statutory basis for computing an employee's 13th month pay under P.D. No. 851?

According to Boie-Takeda Chemicals, Inc. v. De la Serna, are sales productivity allowances included in 13th month pay?

How is basic salary defined for 13th month pay computation under the Implementing Rules of P.D. No. 851?

Should Nico's daily productivity allowance of PhP150.00 be included in his 13th month pay computation?

Choices available with full access.

Which of the following items is included in the computation of statutory 13th month pay?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Labor Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Basic Salary Definition
Under Presidential Decree No. 851 and its implementing rules, 13th month pay is calculated based exclusively on an employee's basic salary. Basic salary includes all remuneration or earnings paid by an employer for services rendered, but explicitly excludes cost-of-living allowances, profit-sharing payments, productivity bonuses, and other monetary benefits that are not integrated into the basic wage structure. Consequently, allowances or bonuses paid separately from basic salary do not form part of the statutory basis for computing 13th month pay.

2. Boie-Takeda Doctrine
In Boie-Takeda Chemicals, Inc. v. De la Serna, the Supreme Court ruled that productivity bonuses, sales commissions, and performance allowances paid to medical representatives are excluded from basic salary for 13th month pay computations. The Court emphasized that statutory basic salary refers only to the fixed consideration paid for routine duties. Additional allowances contingent on productivity or sales performance constitute supplementary incentives, not regular basic salary, unless integrated into the basic pay scale by agreement or established company practice.

3. Productivity Incentive Exclusion
Productivity allowances given on top of basic daily wages serve as variable incentive compensation to encourage efficiency. Under Republic Act No. 6971 and settled labor jurisprudence, productivity incentives do not form part of the basic wage unless expressly stipulated in a Collective Bargaining Agreement or employment contract. Because Nico's basic daily salary of PhP700.00 is distinct from his PhP150.00 daily productivity allowance, the allowance cannot be included in determining his annual 13th month pay.

Topics13th Month Pay1Basic Salary vs Allowances1Boie-Takeda Doctrine1

2018 Labor Law, Q8

Nathaniel has been a salesman assigned by Newmark Enterprises (Newmark) for nearly two years at the Manila office of Nutrition City, Inc. (Nutrition City). He was deployed pursuant to a service agreement between Newmark and Nutrition City, the salient provisions of which were as follows:
a) the Contractor (Newmark) agrees to perform and provide the Client (Nutrition City), on a non-exclusive basis, such tasks or activities that are considered contractible under existing laws, as may be needed by the Client from time to time;
b) the Contractor shall employ the necessary personnel like helpers, salesmen, and drivers who are determined by the Contractor to be efficiently trained;
c) the Client may request replacement of the Contractor’s personnel if quality of the desired result is not achieved;
d) the Contractor’s personnel will comply with the Client’s policies, rules, and regulations; and
e) the Contractor’s two service vehicles and necessary equipment will be utilized in carrying out the provisions of this Agreement.
When Newmark fired Nathaniel, he filed an illegal dismissal case against the wealthier company, Nutrition City, Inc., alleging that he was a regular employee of the same. Is Nathaniel correct? (2.5%)

Quick check

What is the legal consequence when a contractor is declared a prohibited labor-only contractor under Article 106?

Which element is essential to establish a legitimate independent contracting arrangement under DO 174?

Under Coca-Cola Bottlers Phils., Inc. v. Agito, what indicates that a principal exercises the right of control over deployed workers?

What is the statutory minimum paid-up capital required for a contractor to be registered under Department Order No. 174?

Choices available with full access.

Why is Nutrition City, Inc. considered the direct employer of Nathaniel despite his deployment by Newmark Enterprises?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Labor Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Labor-Only Contracting
Under Article 106 of the Labor Code and Department Order No. 174, labor-only contracting refers to an arrangement where the contractor does not have substantial capital or investment in the form of tools, equipment, or work premises, and merely supplies workers to the principal. Furthermore, if the principal exercises the right of control over the performance and manner of work of the contractor's employees, labor-only contracting is conclusively presumed. In such cases, the arrangement is prohibited by law, and the principal is statutorily treated as the direct employer of the supplied workers.

2. Right of Control
The right of control is the most crucial determinant of an employer-employee relationship. Where a service agreement permits the client-principal to enforce its own policies, rules, and regulations directly upon the contractor's deployed personnel, or allows the principal to demand replacement of workers based on performance quality, control is effectively exercised by the principal. Under settled labor jurisprudence, including Coca-Cola Bottlers Phils., Inc. v. Agito, when a principal retains direct control over the manner and execution of work, the contractor functions as a mere manpower supplier.

3. Substantial Capital Requirement
To qualify as a legitimate independent contractor, an entity must possess substantial capital or investment in tools, equipment, machineries, or work premises directly related to the service rendered. Substantial capital refers to paid-up capital stock or net worth amounting to at least five million pesos under current labor regulations. The mere provision of minor assets, such as two service vehicles, does not satisfy the statutory requirement of substantial capital or investment, thereby classifying the contractor as a prohibited labor-only contractor.

TopicsArticle 106 Labor Code3Elements of Legitimate Contracting1Labor-Only Contracting10

2018 Labor Law, Q9

Sgt. Nemesis was a detachment non-commissioned officer of the Armed Forces of the Philippines in Nueva Ecija. He and some other members of his detachment sought permission from their Company Commander for an overnight pass to Nueva Vizcaya to settle some important matters. The Company Commander orally approved their request and allowed them to carry their firearms as the place they were going to was classified as a “critical place.” They arrived at the place past midnight; and as they were alighting from a tricycle, one of his companions accidentally dropped his rifle, which fired a single shot, and in the process hit Sgt. Nemesis fatally. The shooting was purely accidental. At the time of his death, he was still legally married to Nelda, but had been separated de facto from her for 17 years. For the last 15 years of his life, he was living in with Narda, with whom he has two minor children. Since Narda works as a kasambahay, the two children lived with their grandparents, who provided their daily support. Sgt. Nemesis and Narda only sent money to them every year to pay for their school tuition.
Nelda and Narda, both for themselves and the latter, also on behalf of her minor children, separately filed claims for compensation as a result of the death of Sgt. Nemesis. The Line of Duty Board of the AFP declared Sgt. Nemesis’ death to have been “in line of duty”, and recommended that all benefits due to Sgt. Nemesis be given to his dependents. However, the claims were denied by GSIS because Sgt. Nemesis was not in his workplace nor performing his duty as a soldier of the Philippine Army when he died.
(a) Are the dependents of Sgt. Nemesis entitled to compensation as a result of his death? (2.5%)
(b) As between Nelda and Narda, who should be entitled to the benefits? (2.5%)
(c) Are the minor children entitled to the benefits considering that they were not fully dependent on Sgt. Nemesis for support? (2.5%)

Quick check

Under the 24-hour duty doctrine in Hinoguin v. ECC, when are active military personnel deemed to be on official duty?

Who is considered a primary beneficiary legal spouse entitled to military death benefits under GSIS laws?

Does a common-law partner qualify as a primary beneficiary under the Labor Code and GSIS laws?

Under Malate Taxicab v. Del Villar, what degree of financial support is required to establish child dependency?

Choices available with full access.

Are illegitimate minor children entitled to death benefits if their deceased father only paid their annual school tuition?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Labor Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Twenty-Four Hour Duty
Under the twenty-four hour duty doctrine laid down in Hinoguin v. ECC, members of the Armed Forces of the Philippines are considered on official duty twenty-four hours a day, anywhere in the Philippines, unless they are officially on leave. Where a soldier dies from an accidental firearm discharge while on authorized pass in a critical area carrying official weapons, the death is deemed to have occurred in the performance of duty. Consequently, GSIS cannot deny death compensation benefits simply because the soldier was outside the physical military barracks when the fatal accident occurred.

2. Primary Beneficiary Rules
Under Article 173 of the Labor Code and GSIS regulations, primary beneficiaries entitled to death benefits include the legitimate surviving spouse until remarriage and dependent legitimate, legitimated, legally adopted, or illegitimate minor children. De facto separation from the legitimate spouse for seventeen years does not extinguish her legal status as a primary beneficiary. Conversely, a common-law partner, regardless of cohabitation length, is strictly excluded from statutory primary beneficiary coverage under the law.

3. Dependent Minor Children
Under labor standards and social legislation, a child is considered dependent if the worker contributes regularly to the child's support, even if such support is not full or exclusive. As established in Malate Taxicab v. Del Villar, legal dependency does not require total financial reliance or physical cohabitation with the deceased parent. Regular annual payments for school tuition and educational expenses satisfy the legal test of partial dependency, entitling minor illegitimate children to primary death benefits under GSIS and employees' compensation laws.

Topics24-Hour Duty Doctrine1Dependent Minor Children1Primary Beneficiaries GSIS1

2018 Labor Law, Q10

Nonato had been continuously employed and deployed as a seaman who performed services that were necessary and desirable to the business of N-Train Shipping, through its local agent, Narita Maritime Services (Agency), in accordance with the 2010 Philippine Overseas Employment Administration Standard Employment Contract (2010 POEA-SEC). Nonato’s last contract (for five months) expired on November 15, 2016. Nonato was then repatriated due to a “finished contract.” He immediately reported to the Agency and complained that he had been experiencing dizziness, weakness, and difficulty in breathing. The Agency referred him to Dr. Neri, who examined, treated, and prescribed him with medications. After a few months of treatment and consultations, Nonato was declared fit to resume work as a seaman. Nonato went back to the Agency to ask for re-deployment but the Agency rejected his application. Nonato filed an illegal dismissal case against the Agency and its principal, with a claim for total disability benefits based on the ailments that he developed on board N-Train Shipping vessels. The claim was based on the certification of his own physician, Dr. Nunez, that he was unfit for sea duties because of his hypertension and diabetes.
a) Was Nonato a regular employee of N-Train Shipping? (2.5%)
b) Can Nonato successfully claim disability benefits against N-Train Shipping and its agent Narita Maritime Services? (2.5%)

Quick check

What is the legal employment status of Filipino seafarers under Philippine labor law and POEA regulations?

What procedural step is mandatory under the 2010 POEA-SEC when a seafarer's doctor disagrees with the company doctor's medical finding?

What is the legal consequence if a seafarer fails to abide by the mandatory third-doctor referral procedure under the POEA-SEC?

Does a manning agency's refusal to re-deploy a seafarer after the expiration of a five-month POEA contract constitute illegal dismissal?

Choices available with full access.

When does the employer-employee relationship between a seafarer and a foreign maritime principal officially terminate?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Labor Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Seafarer Contractual Status
Under Philippine labor jurisprudence, particularly Millares v. NLRC and Industrial Personnel & Management Services, Inc. v. De Vera, seafarers are contractual fixed-term employees whose employment is governed strictly by the POEA Standard Employment Contract. Seafarers do not attain regular employment status regardless of the length of their service, the continuous re-hiring by the same Manning Agency, or the necessary and desirable nature of their work to the principal's maritime business. Employment automatically terminates upon the expiration of the agreed contract term specified in the POEA-SEC.

2. Third Doctor Requirement
Under Section 20(A)(3) of the 2010 POEA-SEC and Philippine Hammonia Ship Agency, Inc. v. Dumadag, if a physician appointed by the seafarer disagrees with the fit-to-work assessment or disability rating issued by the company-designated physician, the parties must jointly agree to refer the evaluation to a neutral third doctor. The third doctor's medical assessment is final and binding on both parties. Failure of the seafarer to initiate or comply with the mandatory third-doctor referral procedure renders the company-designated physician's fit-to-work certification final and conclusive.

3. POEA Contract Expiration
Upon the expiration of a seafarer's POEA Standard Employment Contract, the employer-employee relationship between the seaman and the vessel principal automatically ceases. The refusal of a local manning agency or foreign principal to re-hire or re-deploy a seafarer after contract completion does not constitute illegal dismissal. A seafarer has no vested statutory or contractual right to automatic re-employment or continuous deployment after completing the stipulated contract period, as each deployment constitutes an independent contractual engagement.

TopicsPOEA Standard Employment Contract3Seafarer Employment Status2Third Doctor Referral Conflict1

2018 Labor Law, Q11

Your favorite relative, Tita Nilda, approaches you and seeks your advice on her treatment of her kasambahay, Noray. Tita Nilda shows you a document called a “Contract of Engagement” for your review. Under the Contract of Engagement, Noray shall be entitled to a rest day every week, provided that she may be requested to work on a rest day if Tita Nilda should need her services that day. Tita Nilda also claims that this Contract of Engagement should embody all terms and conditions of Noray’s work as the engagement of a kasambahay is a private matter and should not be regulated by the State.
a) Is Tita Nilda correct in saying that this is a private matter and should not be regulated by the State? (2.5%)
b) Is the stipulation that she may be requested to work on a rest day legal? (2.5%)
c) Are stay-in family drivers included under the Kasambahay Law? (2.5%)

Quick check

Is the employment contract of a domestic worker subject to regulation by the State under R.A. No. 10361?

Under Section 21 of R.A. No. 10361, how many consecutive hours of weekly rest is a kasambahay entitled to receive?

Is a contractual stipulation permitting an employer to request a kasambahay to work on her rest day legally valid?

Under Atienza v. Saluta, which law governs the employment relationship of stay-in family drivers?

Choices available with full access.

Why are stay-in family drivers excluded from the coverage of the Kasambahay Law (R.A. No. 10361)?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Labor Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Domestic Work Regulation
Under the police power of the State and Republic Act No. 10361, otherwise known as the Domestic Workers Act or Batas Kasambahay, employment contracts involving domestic workers are imbued with public interest and subject to State regulation. Domestic work is an employer-employee relationship governed by mandatory statutory minimum standards, including wage protection, social security coverage, and humane working conditions. An employer cannot claim that engaging a kasambahay is a purely private affair exempt from State labor legislation, as any contractual stipulation below statutory minimum standards is declared void.

2. Weekly Rest Day
Under Section 21 of Republic Act No. 10361, a domestic worker is entitled to an uninterrupted weekly rest period of at least twenty-four consecutive hours. However, the law allows the employer and the kasambahay to agree on custom rest day schedules, including working on a scheduled rest day, provided that the work is requested with mutual agreement and compensated accordingly through premium pay or offsetting rest periods. A contractual provision stating that the worker may be requested to work on a rest day is valid, as long as performance remains voluntary.

3. Family Drivers Exclusion
In Atienza v. Saluta, the Supreme Court clarified that stay-in family drivers are expressly excluded from the coverage of Republic Act No. 10361. Although family drivers perform services in a personal household, their employment is governed separately under the pertinent provisions of the Civil Code of the Philippines rather than the Kasambahay Law. Consequently, statutory benefits specifically created under the Batas Kasambahay, such as thirteenth-month pay and five-day service incentive leave, cannot be automatically claimed by family drivers unless provided by contract or established company policy.

TopicsBatas Kasambahay3Family Driver Excluded Status1Weekly Rest Day Rules1