Bar Subject: Labor Law

2014 Bar Examinations

2014 Labor Law, Q16

Samahang East Gate Enterprises (SEGE) is a labor organization composed of the rank-and-file employees of East Gate Enterprises (EGE), the leading manufacturer of all types of gloves and aprons.
EGE was later requested by SEGE to bargain collectively for better terms and conditions of employment of all the rank -and-file employees of EGE. Consequently, EGE filed a petition for certification election before the Bureau of Labor Relations (BLR).
During the proceedings, EGE insisted that it should participate in the certification process. EGE reasoned that since it was the one who filed the petition and considering that the employees concerned were its own rankand-file employees, it should be allowed to take an active part in the certification process.
Is the contention of EGE proper? Explain. (5%)

Quick check

What is the legal status of an employer during a certification election proceeding among its rank-and-file employees?

When an uncertified union requests an employer to bargain collectively, what procedural action may the employer take?

Does filing a petition for certification election allow an employer to actively campaign against union representation?

What is the primary responsibility of an employer during certification election proceedings?

Choices available with full access.

Why is employer interference strictly prohibited during certification election proceedings?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Labor Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Employer Bystander Rule
Under Article 271 of the Labor Code and established jurisprudence, an employer is considered a mere bystander in certification election proceedings. The choice of a collective bargaining agent is the sole, exclusive concern of the employees. Except when the employer files a petition for certification election following a request to bargain collectively from an uncertified union, the employer's role is strictly limited to receiving notices and submitting the certified payroll list of employees in the bargaining unit.

2. Employer Petition Role
When an unorganized labor union requests an employer to bargain collectively, the employer may file a petition for certification election before the Bureau of Labor Relations. However, filing the petition does not confer upon the employer the right to actively participate, oppose, or campaign during the certification election process. The employer's role remains non-adversarial, and its initiative is designed merely to initiate the statutory mechanism to determine the exclusive bargaining representative of the employees.

3. Management Interference Prohibition
Management interference during certification election proceedings is strictly prohibited to guarantee that workers freely exercise their right to self-organization. Active participation, campaigning, or opposing particular labor organizations by the employer during the election process violates the principle of union independence and may constitute unfair labor practice. The election must reflect the uncoerced will of the bargaining unit, ensuring that employees select their sole collective bargaining representative without management pressure or improper influence.

TopicsBystander Rule2Certification Election6Employer Participation Restriction1

2014 Labor Law, Q17

Philhealth is a government-owned and controlled corporation employing thousands of Filipinos. Because of the desire of the employees of Philhealth to obtain better terms and conditions of employment from the government, they formed the Philhealth Employees Association (PEA) and demanded Philhealth to enter into negotiations with PEA regarding terms and conditions of employment which are not fixed by law. (4%)
(A) Are the employees of Philhealth allowed to self-organize and form PEA and thereafter demand Philhealth to enter into negotiations with PEA for better terms and conditions of employment?
(B) In case of unresolved grievances, can PEA resort to strikes, walkouts, and other temporary work stoppages to pressure the government to accede to their demands?

Quick check

Do employees of government-owned and controlled corporations with original charters enjoy the right to self-organization?

May a public sector employees' association negotiate financial terms that are already fixed by statute?

Are government employees legally permitted to stage strikes or work stoppages to enforce labor demands?

Which government body has jurisdiction to resolve unresolved labor disputes and impasses in the public sector?

Choices available with full access.

What type of employment terms may be validly negotiated by a government employees' association?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Labor Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Public Sector Self-Organization
Under Article IX-B, Section 2(5) of the 1987 Philippine Constitution and Executive Order No. 180, employees of government-owned and controlled corporations with original charters possess the constitutional right to self-organization. Government workers may form, join, or assist employees' associations for the promotion and protection of their interests. However, their right to collective bargaining is limited, as terms and conditions of employment that are fixed by law, civil service rules, or congressional appropriations cannot be negotiated through collective agreements.

2. Collective Negotiation Scope
Collective negotiations in the public sector are strictly restricted to terms and conditions of employment that are not fixed by statute or civil service standardization laws. Government employees' associations may negotiate on matters such as workplace amenities, schedule arrangements, health and safety measures, and grievance procedures. Financial terms, salary scales, retirement benefits, and statutory allowances established by legislation are excluded from collective negotiations between public sector employee unions and government agencies.

3. Government Strike Prohibition
Public sector employees are statutorily prohibited from staging strikes, walkouts, slow-downs, or mass demonstrations to enforce labor demands against the government. Under Civil Service Commission regulations and settled jurisprudence, government service is paramount to public interest, and work stoppages disrupt essential public services. Unresolved labor grievances or bargaining impasses in government agencies must be submitted to the Public Sector Labor-Management Council for conciliation, mediation, or binding resolution rather than economic strike action.

TopicsExecutive Order 1801Government Employee Unionization1Public Sector Strike Prohibition1

2014 Labor Law, Q18

The procedural requirements of a valid strike include: (1%)
(A) a claim of either unfair labor practice or deadlock in collective bargaining
(B) notice of strike filed at least 15 days before a ULP-grounded strike or at least 30 days prior to the deadlock in a bargaining grounded strike
(C) majority of the union membership must have voted to stage the strike with notice thereon furnished to the National Conciliation and Mediation Board (NCMB) at least 24 hours before the strike vote is taken
(D) strike vote results must be furnished to the NCMB at least seven (7) days before the intended strike

Quick check

What is the required notice period for filing a notice of strike based on an unfair labor practice?

How many days prior to an intended strike must the notice of strike be filed in cases of bargaining deadlock?

What voting threshold among union members is required to lawfully authorize a strike under the Labor Code?

How many days before an intended strike must strike vote results be submitted to the NCMB?

Choices available with full access.

What is the primary purpose of the statutory cooling-off period following a notice of strike?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Labor Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Strike Cooling-Off Period
Under Article 278(c) of the Labor Code, a labor union must observe statutory cooling-off periods after filing a notice of strike with the National Conciliation and Mediation Board. For economic strikes grounded on collective bargaining deadlocks, the cooling-off period is at least thirty days. For strikes grounded on unfair labor practices, the period is reduced to at least fifteen days. These mandatory periods allow the labor department to intervene and conciliate the dispute before any work stoppage occurs.

2. Strike Vote Requirements
To conduct a valid strike, a majority of the total union membership in the bargaining unit must vote in favor of staging the strike via secret ballot. The union is required to notify the National Conciliation and Mediation Board at least twenty-four hours before taking the strike vote. This procedural requirement guarantees that the strike decision reflects the democratic intent of the general membership rather than the arbitrary directive of union officers.

3. Seven-Day Strike Ban
After conducting a valid strike vote, the union must submit the detailed results of the vote to the National Conciliation and Mediation Board at least seven days before the intended date of the strike. This mandatory seven-day period, often called the strike ban, affords the government a final opportunity to conciliate the labor dispute or assume jurisdiction to enjoin the impending strike in public interest cases.

TopicsCooling-Off Period2Notice of Strike1Procedural Requirements of Strike1

2014 Labor Law, Q19

Lincoln was in the business of trading broadcast equipment used by television and radio networks. He employed Lionel as his agent. Subsequently, Lincoln set up Liberty Communications to formally engage in the same business. He requested Lionel to be one of the incorporators and assigned to him 100 Liberty shares. Lionel was also given the title Assistant Vice-President for Sales and Head of Technical Coordination. After several months, there were allegations that Lionel was engaged in “under the table dealings” and received “confidential commissions” from Liberty’s clients and suppliers. He was, therefore, charged with serious misconduct and willful breach of trust, and was given 48 hours to present his explanation on the charges. Lionel was unable to comply with the 48 -hour deadline and was subsequently barred from entering company premises. Lionel then filed a complaint with the Labor Arbiter claiming constructive dismissal. Among others, the company sought the dismissal of the complaint alleging that the case involved an intra-corporate controversy which was within the jurisdiction of the Regional Trial Court (RTC).
If you were the Labor Arbiter assigned to the case, how would you rule on the company’s motion to dismiss? (5%)

Quick check

Which tribunal has jurisdiction over an illegal dismissal complaint filed by an executive whose position is not created by the corporate by-laws?

Which specific positions are explicitly recognized as corporate officers directly by the Corporation Code?

What evidentiary test determines whether an employee holding shares is a corporate officer for jurisdictional purposes?

Does an employee's nominal ownership of one hundred corporate shares automatically divest the Labor Arbiter of jurisdiction?

Choices available with full access.

What are the two dual tests applied to determine the existence of an intra-corporate controversy?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Labor Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Corporate Officer Test
Under Presidential Decree No. 902-A and the Corporation Code, an intra-corporate controversy involving the removal of an officer falls within the jurisdiction of the Regional Trial Court only if the position is explicitly created by the Corporation Code or expressly designated as a corporate officer in the corporate by-laws. Officers appointed by the board of directors or executive officers whose positions are created merely by managerial appointment or general management decisions remain regular employees. Consequently, disputes regarding their dismissal belong exclusively to the jurisdiction of the Labor Arbiter.

2. Intra-Corporate Controversy Nature
To determine whether a dispute constitutes an intra-corporate controversy under Regional Trial Court jurisdiction, courts apply the relationship test and the nature of the controversy test. Under the relationship test, the dispute must arise between the corporation and its stockholders, directors, or officers. Under the nature of the controversy test, the dispute must intrinsically involve corporate governance, enforcement of corporate rights under the Corporation Code, or internal regulatory affairs. Dismissal of non-corporate officer employees, even if nominal shareholders, remains a labor dispute.

3. Labor Arbiter Jurisdiction
Under Article 228 of the Labor Code, Labor Arbiters possess exclusive original jurisdiction over all illegal dismissal and constructive dismissal complaints filed by regular workers. When an employer moves to dismiss a labor complaint based on alleged intra-corporate jurisdiction, the employer bears the evidentiary burden of proving that the dismissed worker was a corporate officer created by the corporate by-laws. In the absence of such proof, the Labor Arbiter must deny the motion to dismiss and adjudicate the termination dispute.

TopicsCorporate Officer Test1Intra-Corporate Controversy4Labor Arbiter Jurisdiction4

2014 Labor Law, Q20

Lito was anticipating the bonus he would receive for 2013. Aside from the 13th month pay, the company has been awarding him and his other co-employees a two to three months bonus for the last 10 years. However, because of poor over-all sales performance for the year, the company unilaterally decided to pay only a one month bonus in 2013. Is Lito’s employer legally allowed to reduce the bonus? (4%)

Quick check

Is an employer legally obligated to pay a performance bonus during a year of poor sales performance?

Under what circumstance does a bonus become a demandable employee right under labor law?

Does reducing a multi-month performance bonus due to low sales violate the non-diminution of benefits rule?

What legal characterization distinguishes a voluntary bonus from regular statutory wages?

Choices available with full access.

What option is available to management when company sales decline significantly after years of bonus grants?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Labor Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Bonus Management Prerogative
Under Philippine labor jurisprudence, a bonus is a gratuity granted by an employer to inspire workers toward business productivity and profit realization. As a general rule, the grant of a bonus is an act of generosity rooted in management prerogative rather than a demandable statutory obligation. An employer cannot be compelled to pay bonuses when the enterprise suffers poor sales performance or financial losses, unless the bonus has been converted into an unconditional contractual obligation or wage component by agreement or long-standing practice regardless of profitability.

2. Non-Diminution Exception
The principle of non-diminution of benefits under Article 100 of the Labor Code prohibits employers from unilaterally eliminating or reducing benefits already enjoyed by workers. However, for a bonus to fall under the protection of non-diminution, it must be proven that the benefit was granted consistently, deliberately, and unconditionally over a long period without dependence on business profits. If a bonus has historically been contingent upon business prosperity or sales performance, reducing or withholding it during lean years does not violate the non-diminution rule.

3. Profit Contingency Rules
When a bonus is tied to company earnings, financial milestones, or sales targets, it retains its character as a profit-sharing gratuity rather than a fixed wage component. An employer's continuous payment of multi-month bonuses during prosperous years does not automatically transform the benefit into a demandable right if company earnings decline. In times of poor overall sales performance, management retains the inherent authority to adjust or scale down bonus amounts in accordance with the enterprise's reduced financial capacity without committing an illegal reduction of benefits.

TopicsBonus Non-Diminution1Gratuity vs Wage1Management Prerogative11