Bar Subject: Criminal Law

2015 Bar Examinations

2015 Criminal Law, Q8

A typhoon destroyed the houses of many of the inhabitants of X Municipality. Thereafter, X Municipality operated a shelter assistance program whereby construction materials were provided to the calamity victims, and the beneficiaries provided the labor. The construction was partially done when the beneficiaries stopped helping with the construction for the reason that they needed to earn income to provide food for their families. When informed of the situation, Mayor Maawain approved the withdrawal of ten boxes of food from X Municipality’s feeding program, which were given to the families of the beneficiaries of the shelter assistance program. The appropriations for the funds pertaining to the shelter assistance program and those for the feeding program were separate items on X Municipality’s annual budget.
a) What crime did Mayor Maawain commit? Explain. (2.5%)
b) May Mayor Maawain invoke the defense of good faith and that he had no evil intent when he approved the transfer of the boxes of food from the feeding program to the shelter assistance program? Explain. (2.5%)

Quick check

What crime is committed when a mayor transfers earmarked feeding program food boxes to a shelter assistance project?

Why is good faith NOT a valid defense in a prosecution for technical malversation under Article 220 RPC?

What is an essential element of technical malversation under Article 220 of the Revised Penal Code?

Can a municipal mayor unilaterally reallocate separate items in the annual municipal budget without legislative approval?

Choices available with full access.

How does technical malversation under Article 220 differ from traditional malversation under Article 217 RPC?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Criminal Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Technical Malversation
Under Article 220 of the Revised Penal Code, technical malversation, also known as illegal application of public funds or property, is committed when a public officer applies public funds or property under their administration to a public use other than that for which such funds or property were appropriated by law or ordinance. The essential element of the offense is the application of public property or money to a public purpose different from its specific statutory appropriation, regardless of whether the new use is also beneficial to the public.

2. Good Faith Defense
Technical malversation under Article 220 of the Revised Penal Code is classified as malum prohibitum. In offenses classified as mala prohibita, criminal intent or dolo is not an essential element of the crime, and the mere commission of the prohibited act constitutes the offense. Consequently, good faith, lack of evil intent, or noble humanitarian motives cannot be successfully invoked by a public officer to avoid criminal liability when public funds or property are diverted from their designated statutory purpose.

3. Public Funds Allocation
Public appropriations passed by municipal councils or legislative bodies strictly bind administrative officers to apply public assets solely to their designated budget items. Even if an emergency or calamity occurs, a local chief executive has no legal authority to unilaterally reallocate earmarked property or funds from one budget item to another without prior statutory authorization or a supplemental budget ordinance. Diverting earmarked relief goods to a different assistance project, even within the same municipality, violates budget laws.

TopicsArticle 220 RPC3Mala Prohibita2Technical Malversation3

2015 Criminal Law, Q9

The Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency (PDEA) had intelligence reports about the drug pushing activities of Rado, but could not arrest him for lack of concrete evidence. SP03 Relio, a PDEA team leader, approached Emilo and requested him to act as poseur-buyer of shabu and transact with Rado. Emilo refused, saying that he had completely been rehabilitated and did not want to have anything to do with drugs anymore. But he was prevailed upon to help when SP03 Relio explained that only he could help capture Rado because he used to be his customer. SP03 Relio then gave Emilo the marked money to be used in buying shabu from Rado. The operation proceeded. After Emilo handed the marked money to Rado in exchange for the sachets of shabu weighing 50 grams, and upon receiving the pre-arranged signal from Ernilo, SP03 Relio and his team members barged in and arrested Rado and Ernilo, who were both charged with violation of R.A. 9165, otherwise known as the Comprehensive Dangerous Drugs Act of 2002.
a) What defense, if any, may Ernilo invoke to free himself from criminal liability? Explain. (2.5%)
b) May Rado adopt as his own Ernilo’s defense? Explain. (2.5%)

Quick check

What legal defense exempts a poseur-buyer acting under police direction from criminal liability under RA 9165?

How does entrapment differ from instigation under Philippine criminal law jurisprudence?

Why is Rado barred from adopting Ernilo's defense of instigation or statutory immunity?

Which element is essential for a valid buy-bust operation targeting illegal drug pushers?

Choices available with full access.

What is the criminal liability of a drug seller caught in flagrante delicto during a PDEA buy-bust operation?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Criminal Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Poseur-Buyer Immunity
Under Section 33 of Republic Act No. 9165, or the Comprehensive Dangerous Drugs Act of 2002, any person who acts as a poseur-buyer under the direct supervision of law enforcement officers is granted immunity from prosecution and criminal liability for their involvement in the buy-bust operation. This statutory immunity protects informants and poseur-buyers who assist law enforcement in apprehending illegal drug pushers. Because the poseur-buyer acts without criminal intent and purely under official authorization to secure evidence against the seller, no criminal liability attaches to their participation in the illegal drug transaction.

2. Instigation versus Entrapment
Under Philippine criminal law, instigation occurs when law enforcers induce an innocent person to commit a crime that they had no intention of committing, thereby rendering the instigator co-culpable and exempting the accused from criminal liability. In contrast, entrapment is a lawful law enforcement scheme where ways and means are resorted to for the purpose of capturing a person already engaged in criminal activity. When the criminal intent originates in the mind of the drug seller, the buy-bust operation is a valid entrapment, and the seller cannot invoke instigation to escape liability.

3. Inapplicability of Defense
The legal defenses of statutory immunity under Section 33 of RA 9165 and instigation are personal to the poseur-buyer who acted without criminal intent under police supervision. A drug seller caught in flagrante delicto selling illegal drugs during a buy-bust operation cannot adopt or invoke the poseur-buyer's statutory immunity or defense of instigation. Since the criminal design and intent to sell prohibited drugs originated directly from the seller, the buy-bust operation against him constitutes valid entrapment, making him fully liable for the sale of dangerous drugs under Section 5 of RA 9165.

TopicsInstigation vs Entrapment1Poseur-Buyer Immunity1Section 33 RA 91651

2015 Criminal Law, Q10

Honesto and Wilma were married but had been living separately due to irreconcilable differences. Honesto later met Celia and fell in love with her. Thinking that he could marry Celia if Wilma were to die, Honesto decided to kill Wilma. He secretly followed Wilma for weeks to learn her daily routine. He decided to kill her at night on her way home. On the night he was to kill Wilma, Honesto wore dark clothes so that he would not be easily seen. He waited in the dark alley for Wilma to pass by. He saw someone whom he thought looked like Wilma and shot her with a revolver. The bullet passed through the person’s head and grazed another passerby’s arm. Some bystanders who heard the shot were able to stop Honesto.
It turned out that Wilma did not report for work on that day, and the one who was shot in the head was Melba, who died. The passerby whose arm was grazed by the bullet required medical attendance for two days.
a) What crime(s) did Honesto commit? Explain. (2.5%)
b) Will your answer be the same, assuming that the other passerby was hit in the left eye which caused his/her blindness? Explain. (2.5%)

Quick check

What crime is committed when an offender kills an unintended victim due to a mistake in identity?

What occurs in aberratio ictus under Philippine criminal law jurisprudence?

Why can slight physical injuries NOT be complexed with murder under Article 48 of the RPC?

What complex crime is formed when a single gunshot results in both murder and serious physical injuries?

Choices available with full access.

Which element qualifies the killing of Melba to murder despite Honesto's mistaken belief that she was Wilma?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Criminal Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Error in Personae
Under Article 4(1) of the Revised Penal Code, criminal liability is incurred by any person committing a felony, although the wrongful act done be different from that which he intended. Error in personae, or mistake in identity, occurs when an offender intends to commit a crime against a specific person but executes it against a different person due to mistaken identity. The mistake in identity does not relieve the offender of criminal liability. If treachery attended the planned killing, it qualifies the actual killing to murder even if the victim killed was not the intended target.

2. Aberratio Ictus
Aberratio ictus, or mistake in the blow, occurs when an offender directs a felonious act toward a targeted victim, but due to poor aim or unforeseen physical trajectory, the stroke or bullet also strikes an unintended third party. Under Article 4(1) of the Revised Penal Code, the offender remains criminally liable for all direct logical consequences of his unlawful act. When a single gunshot kills the mistaken victim and injures a bystander, the offender is criminally responsible for both the resulting murder and the physical injuries inflicted on the innocent passerby.

3. Article 48 RPC
Under Article 48 of the Revised Penal Code, a complex crime exists when a single act constitutes two or more grave or less grave felonies. Light felonies, such as slight physical injuries requiring medical attendance for less than nine days, cannot be complexed with grave felonies like murder; thus, separate crimes are committed. However, if the single act results in a grave felony such as murder and a less grave felony such as serious physical injuries, Article 48 applies, creating a single compound complex crime where the penalty for the most serious crime is imposed in its maximum period.

TopicsAberratio Ictus5Article 48 RPC3Error in Personae2

2015 Criminal Law, Q11

Nel learned that Elgar, the owner of the biggest house in the place, would be out of town for three days with no one left to watch the house. He called his friends Ben, Ardo and Gorio and they planned to take the valuables in the house while Elgar was away. Nel and Ben would go inside the house, Ardo would serve as the lookout, while Gorio would stay in the getaway car. When Elgar left, they carried out their plan to the letter. Nel and Ben went inside the house through the backdoor which was left unlocked. None of the rooms and drawers inside were locked. They took the money, jewelry and other valuables therefrom and immediately left using the getaway car.
After driving for about one kilometer, Nel realized he left his bag and wallet with IDs in the house and so he instructed Gorio to drive back to the house. Nel just went in thinking that the house was still empty. But to his surprise, Nel found Fermin seated on a bench with Nel’s bag and wallet beside him and appeared to be texting using his smart phone. Nel took a golf club near him and hit Fermin with it. Fermin shouted for help, but Nel kept hitting him until he stopped making noise. The noise alerted the neighbor who called the police. Nel, Ben, Ardo and Gorio were caught. Fermin died. What is the criminal liability of Nel, Ben, Ardo and Gorio? Explain. (5%)

Quick check

What crime is committed when offenders enter an unlocked house and take valuables without using force or violence?

Why are Ben, Ardo, and Gorio NOT criminally liable for the death of Fermin?

Is there a special complex crime of theft with homicide under the Revised Penal Code?

What is the criminal liability of Nel for his acts in the scenario?

Choices available with full access.

What element distinguishes robbery with force upon things from theft under Article 308 of the RPC?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Criminal Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Crime of Theft
Under Article 308 of the Revised Penal Code, theft is committed by any person who, with intent to gain but without violence against or intimidation of persons nor force upon things, takes personal property of another without the latter's consent. Entering a house through an unlocked door and taking valuables without using physical force to gain entry or breaking locks constitutes theft rather than robbery. Because the taking was executed completely without force or violence against persons or property, all participants who conspired to take the valuables incur criminal liability for the crime of theft.

2. Scope of Conspiracy
Under Philippine criminal law, co-conspirators are criminally liable only for acts committed within the scope of their common criminal design or those that are the direct and natural consequence thereof. When a co-conspirator commits an independent felony outside the agreed plan after the original crime has already been consummated, the other co-conspirators who did not participate in, consent to, or foresee the subsequent act cannot be held criminally liable for it. Conspiracy cannot be extended to cover separate, independent criminal acts performed by one conspirator alone.

3. Separate Felonies
Under the Revised Penal Code, there is no special complex crime of theft with homicide. Unlike robbery with homicide under Article 294(1), where killing committed on the occasion or by reason of robbery forms a single special complex crime, a killing committed in connection with theft constitutes a separate and distinct felony. When an offender commits homicide after completing a theft, he is held criminally liable for two separate offenses: theft and homicide. His co-conspirators in the theft remain liable only for theft.

TopicsArticle 308 RPC9Scope of Conspiracy1Theft and Homicide1

2015 Criminal Law, Q12

Ando, an Indonesian national who just visited the Philippines, purchased a ticket for a passenger vessel bound for Hong Kong. While on board the vessel, he saw his mortal enemy Iason, also an Indonesian national, seated at the back portion of the cabin and who was busy reading a newspaper. Ando stealthily approached Iason and when he was near him, Ando stabbed and killed Iason. The vessel is registered in Malaysia. The killing happened just a few moments after the vessel left the port of Manila. Operatives from the PNP Maritime Command arrested Ando. Presented for the killing of Iason, Ando contended that he did not incur criminal liability because both he and the victim were Indonesians. He likewise argued that he could not be prosecuted in Manila because the vessel is a Malaysian-registered ship. Discuss the merits of Ando’s contentions. (4%)

Quick check

Under Article 14 of the Civil Code, to whom do Philippine penal laws apply within Philippine territory?

Which international maritime rule does the Philippines follow regarding crimes on foreign merchant vessels in its waters?

Why does the Malaysian registry of the vessel NOT exempt Ando from prosecution in Philippine courts?

Under the English Rule, when are local courts deprived of criminal jurisdiction over offenses on foreign vessels?

Choices available with full access.

What principle of criminal law under Article 2 RPC subjects offenses committed within Philippine territory to local laws?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Criminal Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Generality Principle
Under Article 14 of the Civil Code of the Philippines, penal laws and those of public security and safety are binding upon all who live or sojourn in Philippine territory. Subject to specific principles of public international law and treaty stipulations, Philippine criminal laws apply equally to all individuals regardless of their nationality or citizenship. Consequently, an alien who commits a crime within Philippine territory is subject to prosecution and criminal liability under the Revised Penal Code, and cannot invoke foreign citizenship to claim exemption from local criminal jurisdiction.

2. English Rule
Under international maritime law, two rules govern criminal jurisdiction over foreign merchant vessels: the French Rule and the English Rule. The Philippines adheres to the English Rule, under which crimes committed aboard a foreign merchant vessel within the territorial waters of a coastal state are triable by the local courts of that state, unless the offense affects purely the internal discipline of the ship. Because murder or homicide inherently disturbs the public peace and order of the host nation, local courts retain full criminal jurisdiction to try and punish the offender.

3. Territoriality Principle
Article 2 of the Revised Penal Code embodies the fundamental principle of territoriality, establishing that Philippine penal laws are enforceable against all offenses committed within the territorial boundaries of the Philippine archipelago, including its internal waters, territorial sea, and atmosphere. When a foreign passenger vessel is within Philippine territorial waters, such as a port or bay, it is subject to the territorial jurisdiction of the coastal state. Any felony committed aboard such a vessel while anchored or navigating within territorial waters falls within the criminal jurisdiction of Philippine trial courts.

TopicsEnglish Rule Maritime Law1Generality Principle4Territoriality Principle3