Bar Subject: Criminal Law

2018 Bar Examinations

2018 Criminal Law, Q3

On February 5, 2017, Rho Rio Fraternity held initiation rites. Present were: (i) Redmont, the Lord Chancellor and head of the fraternity; (ii) ten (10) members, one (1) of whom was Ric, and (iii) five (5) neophytes, one (1) of whom was Ronald. Absent were: (i) Rollie, the fraternity’s Vice Chancellor and who actually planned the initiation; and (ii) Ronnie, the owner of the house where the initiation was conducted.
Due to the severe beating suffered by Ronald on that occasion, he lost consciousness and was brought to the nearest hospital by Redmont and Ric. However, Ronald was declared dead on arrival at the hospital.
During the investigation of the case, it was found out that, although Ronald really wanted to join the fraternity because his father is also a member of the same fraternity, it was his best friend Ric who ultimately convinced him to join the fraternity and, as a prerequisite thereto, undergo initiation. It was also shown that Redmont and Ric did not actually participate in the beating of the neophytes (hazing). The two (2) either merely watched the hazing or helped in preparing food. And, lastly, two (2) days prior thereto, Ronnie texted Rollie that the fraternity may use his house as the venue for the planned initiation.
Aside from those who actually participated in the hazing, Redmont, Rollie, Ric, and Ronnie were criminally charged for the hazing of Ronald that resulted in the latter’s death.
(a) Are the four criminally liable? (2.5%)
(b) Can all those criminally charged be exonerated upon proof that Ronald, knowing the risks, voluntarily submitted himself to the initiation? Will the absence of proof that the accused intended to kill the victim affect their liability? (2.5%)

Quick check

Who among the following is criminally liable under RA 8049 for hazing resulting in death?

Why is the absence of intent to kill irrelevant in a prosecution for violation of RA 8049?

What is the legal effect of a neophyte's voluntary consent to undergo fraternity hazing rites?

What is the degree of participation of a house owner who knowingly allows his house for hazing?

What degree of liability attaches to a fraternity officer present during hazing who did not beat the victim?

Learn more about these topics

1. Anti-Hazing Law Scope
Under Republic Act No. 8049, or the Anti-Hazing Law, criminal liability extends beyond the individuals who physically inflict harm during initiation rites. Fraternity officers present during the hazing, officers who planned the initiation, members who induced or persuaded the neophyte to undergo initiation, and property owners who knowingly permit their premises to be used as the venue are all held criminally liable as principals or accomplices for hazing resulting in death.

2. Malum Prohibitum Nature
Hazing punishable under Republic Act No. 8049 is classified as a malum prohibitum offense. Because the crime is defined by special law rather than common law dolo, criminal intent, evil motive, or intent to kill is not an essential element of the offense. The lack of intent to cause death or physical injury does not exempt the accused from criminal liability nor operate as a mitigating circumstance in sentencing.

3. Inefficacy of Consent
Under established penal principles governing statutory offenses, a victim's voluntary consent to undergo hazing or initiation rites is completely void and legally ineffective. Because hazing laws protect public order and human dignity, an individual cannot waive statutory protection. Proof that a neophyte voluntarily submitted himself to initiation rites with full knowledge of the inherent risks does not exculpate or lessen the criminal liability of the accused.

TopicsAnti-Hazing Law1Malum Prohibitum3RA 80491

2018 Criminal Law, Q4

On the way home from work, Rica lost her necklace to a snatcher. A week later, she saw what looked like her necklace on display in a jewelry store in Raon. Believing that the necklace on display was the same necklace snatched from her the week before, she surreptitiously took the necklace without the knowledge and consent of the store owner. Later, the loss of the necklace was discovered, and Rica was shown on the CCTV camera of the store as the culprit. Accordingly, Rica was charged with theft of the necklace. Rica raised the defense that she could not be guilty as charged because she was the owner of the necklace and that the element of intent to gain was lacking.
What should be the verdict if:
(a) The necklace is proven to be owned by Rica? (2.5%)
(b) It is proven that the store acquired the necklace from another person who was the real owner of the necklace? (2.5%)

Quick check

What essential element of theft under Article 308 of the RPC is negated when the accused takes property under an honest claim of ownership?

What is the legal effect under Article 308 of the RPC if the property taken is proven to belong exclusively to the accused?

How does the doctrine of mistake of fact operate in a prosecution for theft?

Under the maxim actus non facit reum, nisi mens sit rea, why is a person not guilty of theft if she honestly believed the item was hers?

What should be the verdict for an accused charged with theft who surreptitiously takes another's property under an honest but mistaken belief of ownership?

Learn more about these topics

1. Elements of Theft
Under Article 308 of the Revised Penal Code, the crime of theft requires five essential elements: that there be taking of personal property; that said property belongs to another; that the taking be done with intent to gain; that the taking be accomplished without the use of violence against or intimidation of persons, nor force upon things; and that the taking be done without the owner's consent. Taking one's own property or taking under a bona fide claim of ownership negates theft.

2. Intent to Gain
Intent to gain, or animus lucrandi, is an essential mental element of theft and is presumed from the unlawful taking of personal property belonging to another. However, this presumption is successfully rebutted when the accused takes property under a bona fide belief that she is the lawful owner or is entitled to its possession. Without animus lucrandi, no felony of theft can exist under Article 308 of the Revised Penal Code because the criminal mind is absent.

3. Mistake of Fact
Under the doctrine of mistake of fact, an honest and reasonable mistake as to a fact which, if true, would have made the act lawful, negates criminal intent or dolo. The fundamental legal maxim actus non facit reum, nisi mens sit rea dictates that an act does not make a person guilty unless the mind is also guilty. Believing in good faith that displayed property belongs to oneself eliminates felonious intent, warranting an acquittal from criminal charges.

TopicsIntent to Gain5Mistake of Fact2Theft7

2018 Criminal Law, Q5

With a promise of reward, Robert asked Romy to bring him a young girl that he (Robert) can have carnal knowledge with. Romy agreed, seized an eight-year old girl and brought her to Robert. After receiving his reward, Romy left while Robert proceeded to have carnal knowledge with the girl.
(a) For what felony may Robert and Romy be charged? (2.5%)
(b) Will your answer in (a) be the same if the victim is a 15-year old lass who was enticed, through cunning and deceit of Romy, to voluntarily go to the house of Robert where the latter subsequently had carnal knowledge with her? (2.5%)

Quick check

What felony is committed by having carnal knowledge of an eight-year-old child under Article 266-A of the RPC?

What crime is committed under Section 5(a) of RA 7610 by a person who procures a child for sexual acts in exchange for reward?

Does a fifteen-year-old minor's apparent consent to sexual intercourse negate liability under RA 7610?

Under RA 7610, what is the age threshold for a person to be classified and protected as a child?

How does enticing a fifteen-year-old through deceit to go to an offender's house for sexual acts affect criminal liability?

Learn more about these topics

1. Statutory Rape Provisions
Under Article 266-A of the Revised Penal Code, as amended by Republic Act No. 11648, rape is committed by having carnal knowledge of a person under the age of statutory rape, or through force, threat, or intimidation. When the victim is under twelve years of age, or under the statutory age of consent, the law conclusively presumes lack of consent due to the victim's tender age and legal incapacity to give valid sexual consent.

2. Child Prostitution Offenses
Under Section 5(a) of Republic Act No. 7610, otherwise known as the Special Protection of Children Against Abuse, Exploitation and Discrimination Act, child prostitution is committed by any person who engages in, hires, employs, uses, persuades, induces, or procures a child for sexual intercourse or lascivious conduct. Acting as a procurer or broker who delivers a child to another for sexual exploitation in exchange for a fee or reward constitutes the crime of child prostitution.

3. Inefficacy of Consent
Under Republic Act No. 7610, the consent of a child under eighteen years of age to sexual exploitation, prostitution, or abuse is completely void and legally ineffective. Even if a fifteen-year-old minor is enticed through deceit, cunning, or persuasion to voluntarily submit to sexual acts, the statutory protection remains absolute. The offender cannot invoke the minor's apparent voluntary agreement as a defense to escape criminal prosecution.

TopicsChild Prostitution1RA 76104Statutory Rape1

2018 Criminal Law, Q6

A group of homeless and destitute persons invaded and occupied the houses built by the National Housing Authority (NHA) for certain military personnel. To gain entry to the houses, the group intimidated the security guards posted at the entrance gate with the firearms they were carrying and destroyed the padlocks of the doors of the houses with the use of crowbars and hammers. They claimed that they would occupy the houses and live therein because the houses were idle and they were entitled to free housing from the government.
For the reason that the houses were already awarded to military personnel who have been found to have fully complied with the requirements for the award thereof, NHA demanded the group to vacate within ten (10) days from notice the houses they occupied and were still occupying. Despite the lapse of the deadline, the group refused to vacate the houses in question.
What is the criminal liability of the members of the group, if any, for their actions? (5%)

Quick check

What crime under Article 312 of the RPC is committed by taking possession of another's real property using violence or intimidation?

What constitutes the element of intent to gain in the crime of Occupation of Real Property under Article 312?

Does claiming entitlement to free government socialized housing justify forced entry and occupation of NHA property?

What is the legal effect of executing acts of violence or property damage while forcing entry into real property under Article 312?

Choices available with full access.

What essential element must accompany the taking of real property to constitute a violation of Article 312 of the RPC?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Criminal Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Occupation Elements
Under Article 312 of the Revised Penal Code, the crime of occupation of real property or usurpation of real rights in property is committed when an offender takes possession of any real property or usurps any real rights in property belonging to another, employing violence against or intimidation of persons, with intent to gain. The essential requisites require that the property belongs to another person or entity, and that force, violence, or intimidation is applied directly to secure or maintain possession.

2. Intent to Gain
Intent to gain, or animus lucrandi, in the crime of occupation of real property under Article 312 of the Revised Penal Code, is demonstrated by the unlawful taking and continuous physical enjoyment of another's real estate without legal right or authority. Claiming entitlement to free government socialized housing or asserting that public housing structures are idle does not negate intent to gain. The personal benefit derived from occupying and using another's real property without compensation satisfies the legal requirement of intent to gain.

3. Complexing and Liability
Under Article 312 of the Revised Penal Code, the penalty imposed for occupation of real property is without prejudice to the criminal liability incurred for acts of violence executed by the offender. When perpetrators employ armed intimidation against security guards, commit grave threats, or cause malicious mischief by destroying locks and doors with crowbars to force entry, they incur independent criminal liability for those distinct offenses or complex crimes in addition to Article 312.

TopicsArticle 312 RPC1Occupation of Real Property1Usurpation of Real Rights1

2018 Criminal Law, Q7

Robbie and Rannie are both inmates of the National Penitentiary, serving the maximum penalty for robbery which they committed some years before and for which they have been sentenced by final judgment. One day, Robbie tried to collect money owed by Rannie. Rannie insisted that he did not owe Robbie anything, and after a shouting episode, Rannie kicked Robbie in the stomach. Robbie fell to the ground in pain, and Rannie left him to go to the toilet to relieve himself. As Rannie was opening the door to the toilet and with his back turned against Robbie, Robbie stabbed him in the back with a bladed weapon that he had concealed in his waist. Hurt, Rannie ran to the nearest “kubol” where he fell. Robbie ran after him· and, while Rannie was lying on the ground, Robbie continued to stab him, inflicting a total of 15 stab wounds. He died on the spot. Robbie immediately surrendered to the Chief Warden. When prosecuted for the murder of Rannie, Robbie raised provocation and voluntary surrender as mitigating circumstances. The prosecution, on the other hand, claimed that there was treachery in the commission of the crime.
(a) Is Robbie a recidivist, or a quasi-recidivist? (2.5%)
(b) Can the mitigating circumstances raised by Robbie, if proven, lower the penalty for the crime committed? (2.5%)

Quick check

What defines quasi-recidivism under Article 160 of the Revised Penal Code?

Why is an inmate serving sentence for robbery who commits murder not a recidivist?

How does quasi-recidivism affect the penalty for a newly committed felony under Article 160?

Can ordinary mitigating circumstances offset the special aggravating circumstance of quasi-recidivism?

Choices available with full access.

What status attaches to an inmate who stabs a fellow prisoner while serving sentence for robbery?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Criminal Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Quasi-Recidivism Requisites
Under Article 160 of the Revised Penal Code, quasi-recidivism occurs when a person commits any felony after having been convicted by final judgment, before beginning to serve such sentence, or while serving the same. Unlike ordinary recidivism, quasi-recidivism applies regardless of whether the second crime falls under the same title of the code as the first conviction.

2. Recidivism Distinctions
Under Article 14, paragraph 9 of the Revised Penal Code, recidivism requires that the offender, at the time of his trial for one crime, shall have been previously convicted by final judgment of another crime embraced in the same title of the code. Because robbery falls under crimes against property while murder falls under crimes against persons, an offender committing murder while serving sentence for robbery is not a recidivist.

3. Special Aggravating Effect
Quasi-recidivism is a special aggravating circumstance that mandates the imposition of the maximum period of the penalty prescribed by law for the new felony. Under Article 160 of the Revised Penal Code, quasi-recidivism cannot be offset by ordinary mitigating circumstances, such as voluntary surrender or sufficient provocation, ensuring that the maximum statutory penalty applies to offenders who reoffend while serving sentence.

TopicsArticle 160 RPC1Quasi-Recidivism2Recidivism4