2018 Criminal Law, Q3
On February 5, 2017, Rho Rio Fraternity held initiation rites. Present were: (i) Redmont, the Lord Chancellor and head of the fraternity; (ii) ten (10) members, one (1) of whom was Ric, and (iii) five (5) neophytes, one (1) of whom was Ronald. Absent were: (i) Rollie, the fraternity’s Vice Chancellor and who actually planned the initiation; and (ii) Ronnie, the owner of the house where the initiation was conducted.
Due to the severe beating suffered by Ronald on that occasion, he lost consciousness and was brought to the nearest hospital by Redmont and Ric. However, Ronald was declared dead on arrival at the hospital.
During the investigation of the case, it was found out that, although Ronald really wanted to join the fraternity because his father is also a member of the same fraternity, it was his best friend Ric who ultimately convinced him to join the fraternity and, as a prerequisite thereto, undergo initiation. It was also shown that Redmont and Ric did not actually participate in the beating of the neophytes (hazing). The two (2) either merely watched the hazing or helped in preparing food. And, lastly, two (2) days prior thereto, Ronnie texted Rollie that the fraternity may use his house as the venue for the planned initiation.
Aside from those who actually participated in the hazing, Redmont, Rollie, Ric, and Ronnie were criminally charged for the hazing of Ronald that resulted in the latter’s death.
(a) Are the four criminally liable? (2.5%)
(b) Can all those criminally charged be exonerated upon proof that Ronald, knowing the risks, voluntarily submitted himself to the initiation? Will the absence of proof that the accused intended to kill the victim affect their liability? (2.5%)
Suggested answer only. Not an official answer and not legal advice.
(a) Yes, all four are criminally liable; and (b) no, neither Ronald's consent nor the lack of intent to kill will exonerate or affect their liability.
Under R.A. No. 8049, officers present, planners, inducers, and venue owners are criminally liable for hazing. Because hazing is malum prohibitum, criminal intent is immaterial, lack of intent to kill is not mitigating, and the victim's consent is void and no defense.
Here, Redmont is liable as principal for being present; Rollie as principal for planning; Ric as principal for inducing Ronald; and Ronnie as accomplice for allowing his house to be used. Ronald's voluntary consent and the absence of intent to kill do not exculpate or mitigate their liability.
Consequently, Redmont, Rollie, Ric, and Ronnie are criminally liable under R.A. No. 8049, unaffected by consent or lack of intent to kill.
This is not an official scoring system and carries no weight with the Supreme Court or any bar review provider. It measures how much of the suggested answer's wording your response covers, not whether your reasoning is correct. For practice only.
Quick check
Who among the following is criminally liable under RA 8049 for hazing resulting in death?
Under RA 8049, officers present, planners, inducers, and venue owners share criminal liability for hazing.
Why is the absence of intent to kill irrelevant in a prosecution for violation of RA 8049?
Hazing under RA 8049 is malum prohibitum, making proof of intent to kill unnecessary for conviction.
What is the legal effect of a neophyte's voluntary consent to undergo fraternity hazing rites?
A victim's consent to hazing is void and does not exculpate the accused from criminal liability.
What is the degree of participation of a house owner who knowingly allows his house for hazing?
A property owner who knowingly permits his premises to be used for hazing is liable as an accomplice.
What degree of liability attaches to a fraternity officer present during hazing who did not beat the victim?
Officers present during initiation rites are criminally liable as principals regardless of physical participation.
Learn more about these topics
1. Anti-Hazing Law Scope
Under Republic Act No. 8049, or the Anti-Hazing Law, criminal liability extends beyond the individuals who physically inflict harm during initiation rites. Fraternity officers present during the hazing, officers who planned the initiation, members who induced or persuaded the neophyte to undergo initiation, and property owners who knowingly permit their premises to be used as the venue are all held criminally liable as principals or accomplices for hazing resulting in death.
2. Malum Prohibitum Nature
Hazing punishable under Republic Act No. 8049 is classified as a malum prohibitum offense. Because the crime is defined by special law rather than common law dolo, criminal intent, evil motive, or intent to kill is not an essential element of the offense. The lack of intent to cause death or physical injury does not exempt the accused from criminal liability nor operate as a mitigating circumstance in sentencing.
3. Inefficacy of Consent
Under established penal principles governing statutory offenses, a victim's voluntary consent to undergo hazing or initiation rites is completely void and legally ineffective. Because hazing laws protect public order and human dignity, an individual cannot waive statutory protection. Proof that a neophyte voluntarily submitted himself to initiation rites with full knowledge of the inherent risks does not exculpate or lessen the criminal liability of the accused.