Bar Subject: Criminal Law

2023 Bar Examinations

2023 Criminal Law, Q6

Pido, a private contractor, was convicted of Plunder in conspiracy with certain government officials. He was sentenced by the Sandiganbayan to serve the penalty of reclusion perpetua. Years later, his childhood friend, Benjamin, was appointed as Secretary of Justice and was able to convince the President to grant Pido a presidential pardon. Both the judgment of conviction and the presidential pardon were silent as to accessory penalties. Now a free man, Pido decided to give back to the community by running for public office as Mayor of his hometown in Bulacan. The incumbent Mayor sought your advice if he can challenge the candidacy of Pido. On what ground/s can the incumbent Mayor challenge the candidacy of Pido? Discuss.

Quick check

On what ground can the incumbent Mayor challenge Pido candidacy for Mayor of his hometown?

Under Article 41 of the Revised Penal Code, what accessory penalty inherently accompanies reclusion perpetua?

Under Article 36 of the Revised Penal Code, when does a presidential pardon restore political rights to hold public office?

What is the legal effect of a presidential pardon that is silent regarding accessory penalties?

Choices available with full access.

Which legal right is deprived under Article 30 of the Revised Penal Code by perpetual absolute disqualification?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Criminal Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Perpetual Absolute Disqualification
Under Article 41 of the Revised Penal Code, the principal penalty of reclusion perpetua carries with it the inherent accessory penalty of perpetual absolute disqualification. Under Article 30 of the Code, perpetual absolute disqualification deprives the offender of the right to vote or be voted upon, deprives him of public office, and perpetually bars him from holding any public employment or elective position, regardless of whether the accessory penalty is explicitly pronounced in the judgment of conviction.

2. Effect of Pardon
Under Article 36 and Article 41 of the Revised Penal Code, a presidential pardon restores the convict to liberty and remits the principal penalty, but it does not restore political rights or extinguish accessory penalties unless expressly stated. To restore the right to run for public office or hold public employment, the executive clemency must explicitly remit the accessory penalty of perpetual absolute disqualification or specifically state that political rights are restored to the pardoned individual.

3. Disqualification from Office
When a presidential pardon is silent regarding accessory penalties and political rights, the convict remains subject to perpetual absolute disqualification. Consequently, an incumbent Mayor or any interested party can validly challenge the candidacy of the pardoned individual before the Commission on Elections on the ground of statutory disqualification under election laws and Article 41 of the Revised Penal Code, as the individual lacks the legal eligibility to hold elective public office.

TopicsArticle 41 RPC1Perpetual Absolute Disqualification2Presidential Pardon1

2023 Criminal Law, Q7

Miguel was charged with Murder for the death of his neighbor, Nikkolas. During trial, the prosecution established that treachery and evident premeditation attended the killing of Nikkolas. Hence, the trial court found Miguel guilty as charged and sentenced him to suffer the penalty of reclusion perpetua. Upon the lapse of his 30th year in prison, Miguel filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus on the ground that under the three-fold rule, he had served the maximum of his sentence and that his continued imprisonment is a violation of his right to liberty. Will the petition of Miguel prosper? Explain.

Quick check

Why will Miguel petition for a writ of habeas corpus be denied after serving thirty years of reclusion perpetua?

Under Article 70 of the Revised Penal Code, when does the three-fold rule apply?

What is the legal nature of the thirty-year duration assigned to reclusion perpetua under Article 70 of the Code?

What is the primary purpose of the extraordinary writ of habeas corpus in Philippine remedial law?

Choices available with full access.

Why does Miguel thirty-year imprisonment not entitle him to automatic release from prison?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Criminal Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Three-Fold Rule Application
Under Article 70 of the Revised Penal Code, the three-fold rule regulates the maximum duration of a convict sentence when multiple penalties are imposed for distinct offenses. Under this rule, the maximum period of imprisonment shall not exceed three times the most severe penalty, and in no case shall it exceed forty years. However, the three-fold rule applies exclusively when an accused is sentenced to serve two or more penalties. It has no application where the convict is serving a single sentence for a single crime.

2. Reclusion Perpetua Duration
Reclusion perpetua is an indivisible penalty that carries perpetual imprisonment, subject to pardon after thirty years. The thirty-year period attributed to reclusion perpetua under Article 70 is merely an imputed duration used as a computational basis for applying the three-fold rule in cases of multiple convictions or determining eligibility for executive clemency. Serving thirty years does not automatically extinguish a single sentence of reclusion perpetua, nor does it entitle the convict to immediate release as a matter of right.

3. Writ of Habeas
A petition for a writ of habeas corpus is an extraordinary remedy available only when a person is illegally deprived of liberty or when his lawful detention has been prolonged beyond the lawful term. Where a convict is serving a single sentence of reclusion perpetua, his detention remains lawful even after thirty years until pardoned or granted executive clemency. Because his imprisonment is based on a valid judicial judgment, habeas corpus cannot be issued to order his release.

TopicsHabeas Corpus3Reclusion Perpetua2Three-Fold Rule3

2023 Criminal Law, Q8

Samuel, a Filipino citizen of Chinese descent, assisted the Chinese Government in surveying and determining the safest and most secure shores in the Philippines. He thought he was helping the Philippines in this endeavor since the geodetic maps he prepared would allegedly be transmitted to the Philippines for future use. Before the survey was completed, Chinese military vessels entered the Philippines’ Scarborough shores, set up a station secured by two warships, and populated two islets which the Chinese Government proclaimed as their own, all with the use of the geodetic maps. Samuel was then charged with Treason by the Philippine Government. The following testified against Samuel: 1) his helper, Therese, who saw Samuel in numerous meetings with the Chinese Government, though she did not understand their conversations since she does not know Chinese; and 2) his gardener, Rolando, who knows Chinese but has bad eyesight. Rolando was present in all these meetings and had a glimpse of the finished geodetic maps signed by Samuel. Is Samuel liable for Treason? Explain.

Quick check

Why is Samuel not criminally liable for Treason under Article 114 of the Revised Penal Code?

What evidentiary requirement must be satisfied to convict an accused of treason under Article 114?

Why did the testimonies of Therese and Rolando fail to satisfy the two-witness rule for treason?

When may a resident alien or Filipino citizen be prosecuted for the crime of treason?

Choices available with full access.

What is the legal status of preparing geodetic maps for a foreign nation during peacetime?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Criminal Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Treason Requirements
Under Article 114 of the Revised Penal Code, treason is a felony committed by a Filipino citizen or resident alien who levies war against the Philippines or adheres to its enemies, giving them aid or comfort within the Philippines or elsewhere. Treason is essentially a war crime that can only be committed during an actual state of war in which the Philippines is involved. In time of peace, acts of disloyalty, espionage, or giving aid to foreign powers cannot be prosecuted as treason under the Revised Penal Code.

2. Two-Witness Rule
To convict an accused of treason under Article 114, the law strictly requires the testimony of at least two witnesses to the same overt act, unless the accused makes an open confession in open court. The two-witness rule demands that both witnesses testify to the exact same physical act constituting treason. Each witness must possess direct personal knowledge of the entire overt act. If one witness only hears or partially observes the act without understanding its substance, the two-witness requirement is not satisfied.

3. Absence of War
When foreign military forces occupy or claim Philippine territory during peacetime, an individual assisting foreign agents cannot be held liable for treason due to the absence of a declared or actual state of war. Although the act of preparing geodetic maps for foreign military forces may harm national security, it does not constitute treason without a state of war. Criminal liability for treason requires both adherence to the enemy and giving aid or comfort during an existing war involving the Republic.

TopicsArticle 114 RPC2Treason3Two-Witness Rule3

2023 Criminal Law, Q9

Macario, a student activist known for his anti-government views, decided to take measures into his own hands and carried out the following activities: 1) he mobilized his barangay and instructed its members on the finer points of mass uprising; 2) he organized the People’s Liberation Organization against Poverty (PLOP) and led a march to Malacañan to air their grievances, chanting subversive words denouncing the lack of action by the government to alleviate their plight; 3) he divided PLOP into groups of four members and ordered them to commit theft, raising over a million pesos to finance their activities; and 4) he posted a threat on his highly popular social media account that he will bomb several malls in Metro Manila, if the government will not give in to his demands of providing temporary cash handouts to the unemployed by the end of the month. The police then arrested Macario and charged him with violation of the Anti-Terrorism Act. Will the charge prosper? Discuss.

Quick check

Why will the charge against Macario under the Anti-Terrorism Act of 2020 prosper?

Under Section 5 of Republic Act No. 11479, what acts constitute the crime of threat to commit terrorism?

How does the Anti-Terrorism Act of 2020 distinguish protected political advocacy from unlawful terrorism?

What is the legal effect of Macario social media post threatening to bomb Metro Manila malls?

Choices available with full access.

Under Republic Act No. 11479, what purpose must accompany a threat of violence to classify it as a terrorist threat?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Criminal Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Threat of Terrorism
Under Section 5 of Republic Act No. 11479, or the Anti-Terrorism Act of 2020, threatening to commit terrorism is a distinct punishable felony. A person commits this offense when he threatens to execute acts that intend to cause death, serious bodily injury, or extensive destruction to public or private places, with the purpose of intimidating the public, creating an atmosphere of fear, or coercing the government. Publicly posting a credible threat to bomb commercial malls to force government policy concessions directly satisfies all statutory elements of terrorism threat.

2. Acts of Terrorism
Under Section 4 of Republic Act No. 11479, terrorism is committed by any person who engages in acts intended to cause death, serious bodily injury, or massive destruction to critical infrastructure or public places. To constitute terrorism, the act must be carried out with the intent to provoke or influence the government by intimidation, or to create a state of public emergency. Threatening to detonate explosive devices in crowded shopping malls falls squarely under the statutory definition of terrorist acts.

3. Freedom of Speech
While the Constitution guarantees freedom of speech and the right to peacefully assemble to petition the government for redress of grievances, this protection does not extend to illegal acts or threats of mass violence. Subversive speech denouncing government inaction during a peaceful rally is protected expression. However, threatening to bomb public spaces to extort government cash handouts transcends protected political advocacy and constitutes a punishable terrorist threat under penal statutes.

TopicsAnti-Terrorism Act1Republic Act No. 114791Threat to Commit Terrorism1

2023 Criminal Law, Q10

Noel, Omar, and Dennis were all convicted of Illegal Possession of Drug Paraphernalia and sentenced to seven months in jail. On their third month, a typhoon caused flood waters to rise up to five feet in the jail facility. Fearing for the lives of the prisoners in the facility, the Jail Warden released all 30 prisoners, with a directive that they should return when the storm ceases. When the storm passed, only Noel, Omar, and Dennis turned themselves in, with the explanation that they would have starved if they did not return. Later, Noel, Omar, and Dennis were charged with Evasion of Service of Sentence because they returned not to continue to serve their sentence but for fear of starving. The Jail Warden was likewise charged with Infidelity in the Custody of Prisoners. Rule on the respective criminal liabilities of Noel, Omar, and Dennis, and the Jail Warden, if any.

Quick check

Why are Noel, Omar, and Dennis not criminally liable for Evasion of Service of Sentence?

Under Article 158 of the Revised Penal Code, when does a convict incur increased penalty during a calamity?

Why is the Jail Warden not criminally liable for Infidelity in the Custody of Prisoners?

What are the requisites of State of Necessity as a justifying circumstance under Article 11(4) of the Code?

Choices available with full access.

Does the subjective motive of prisoners for returning to jail affect their liability under Article 158?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Criminal Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Evasion of Sentence
Under Article 158 of the Revised Penal Code, evasion of service of sentence on the occasion of a calamity occurs when a convict escapes during a disaster and fails to give himself up to the authorities within forty-eight hours following the issuance of a proclamation announcing the passing away of the calamity. Where convicts voluntarily return to custody upon the cessation of the typhoon, they commit no evasion of sentence, as their physical surrender within the prescribed period negates criminal liability regardless of their subjective motive for returning.

2. State of Necessity
Under Article 11, paragraph 4 of the Revised Penal Code, an act is justified if done to avoid an evil or injury, provided the evil sought to be avoided actually exists, the injury feared is greater than that caused to avoid it, and there is no other practical and less harmful means of preventing it. A jail warden who releases prisoners trapped in rising five-foot floodwaters acts under a legitimate state of necessity to prevent loss of human life, which is a far greater injury than temporary release.

3. Infidelity in Custody
Under Article 223 of the Revised Penal Code, infidelity in the custody of prisoners requires that a public officer consented to the escape of a prisoner under his charge. Where a jail warden releases inmates strictly to save them from imminent drowning during a severe flood, there is no criminal intent or illegal consent to an escape. The warden's action is covered by the justifying circumstance of state of necessity, completely exempting him from criminal liability.

TopicsEvasion of Service of Sentence2Infidelity in Custody1State of Necessity1