Lex Rex Ph

Heirs of Mesina vs. Heirs of Fian Digest


The heirs of Fian refused to vacate the lot that they possess despite repeated demands by the Mesinas. One of the Mesinas filed an action against the heirs of Fian, naming only Theresa as the representative of the heirs. Theresa filed a Motion to Dismiss on the ground that the names of all the heirs of the late spouses of Mesina and Fina were not individually named. She contends that the complaint is infirmed and warrants dismissal in violation of Rule 3 Sections 1 and 2 of the Rules of Court. RTC dismissed the case. Norman Mesina appealed.

Issue 1: Non-Joinder

Is Norman’s failure to include Theresa’s co-heirs a ground for the case’s dismissal?

Ruling 1

The High Court: No, because Norman’s failure is not a failure to state a cause of action but a non-joinder of an indispensable party/ies (i.e. the other Fian heirs). Non-joinder of the indispensable party is not a ground for dismissal of action because such parties may be added to the motion of the party or the initiative of the court concerned.

What the RTC should have done was to direct Norman to implead all the heirs of Fian as defendants within a reasonable time with a warning that failure to do so shall mean dismissal.

The dismissal by the lower courts is improper because there is no failure to state a cause of action.

Issue 2: Verification

Is Norman’s verification valid when he says “based on personal knowledge.”

Ruling 2

Yes. It is not defective

Verification may be based only on either personal knowledge or authentic records.

Purpose of verification: that the pleading submitted by the counsel is verified to be true by his client the person alleging the complaints (i.e. the counsel’s client).

There is no defective verification because Rule 7 uses the word “or” which means that verification may be based on either personal knowledge or authentic records.

Norman’s petition is granted.

Other Content You May Be Interested In:

The Paquete Habana Case Digest

175 U.S. 677 (1900) [on custom] Facts The case involved fishing vessels called the Paquete Habana and Lola, which navigated near Cuba but were seized by the U.S. government for alleged violations

Read More »

Culpa Aquiliana

Responsibility without a written contract, on the basis of a wrongful act. “Culpa” or culpability means responsibility arising from a wrongful act. Aquiliana – Latin “a” means without; “quill” means a pen

Read More »


a bailee is a person who receives a non-consumable thing for the purpose of using it for a certain period of time and with the obligation of returning it. If there are

Read More »

Silverio v. Republic Digest

MY TITLE Petitioner Silverio underwent sex change CASE TAGS Male and Female in MarriageHomosexuality CITATION  Silverio vs Republic G.R. 174689 | October 22, 2007 ROMMEL JACINTO DANTES SILVERIO, petitioner,vs.REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, respondent. FACTS Petitioner filed

Read More »


Defamation, which includes libel and slander, means the offense of injuring a person’s character, fame or reputation through false and malicious statements.5 It is that which tends to injure reputation or to

Read More »

Chua Keng Giap vs TAC

When the mother herself denies someone as her son, no one else, even the Supreme Court, can question that. It is only her who knows if that person came out from her

Read More »