Bar Subject: Practical Exercises

2018 Bar Examinations

2018 Legal and Judicial Ethics, Q16

On March 1, 2017, sisters and business partners Carmina and Celeste Corominas borrowed PhP 500,000 from Carmen Carunungan. It was agreed that the amount will be paid in full one (1) year after, or on March 1, 2018, with interest at the rate of 10% per annum, without necessity of a demand. They also agreed to be bound jointly and severally. For this purpose, they executed a promissory note, secured by a postdated check in the amount of PhP 550,000 drawn from their joint account, which check was dated March 1, 2018.
When the debt became due, Carmen deposited the check but it was dishonored for insufficient funds. Carmen then sued Carmina and Celeste for estafa through falsification of a commercial document. After finding probable cause, the prosecutor filed a criminal case in court, where the sisters were required to file their joint judicial affidavit. In their affidavit, they raised the defense that they could not be guilty of estafa because: (i) the check was issued only as a form of security; (ii) even if issued as payment, it was for a pre-existing debt; and (iii) it was only upon Carmen’s insistence that they issued the check.
Before the case could be decided, the sisters offered to settle their debt through a dacion en pago. They offered a Honda CRV which they jointly owned in full settlement of the loan. Carmen agreed.
Prepare the following documents in legally acceptable and enforceable forms, based on the above facts:
(a) The promissory note (5% );
(b) The judicial affidavit (10%); and
(c) The dacion en pago (10%).

Quick check

Under Article 315, paragraph 2(d) of the Revised Penal Code, when is the issuance of a bouncing check NOT considered estafa?

What legal effect does a valid dacion en pago produce regarding a pre-existing loan obligation?

Which legal rule governs contracts of dacion en pago in Philippine jurisdiction?

What element is indispensable to hold a drawer criminally liable for estafa through postdated checks?

Choices available with full access.

Under a solidary promissory note, what is the extent of liability of each co-borrower?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Practical Exercises answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Estafa Defense Elements
In prosecutions for estafa under Article 315, paragraph 2(d) of the Revised Penal Code, deceit and damage are essential elements. Issuing a postdated check as a mere guarantee or security for a pre-existing obligation does not constitute estafa, as the check was not the efficient cause that induced the creditor to grant the loan. When a check is issued for a pre-existing debt upon the creditor's insistence, fraudulent intent at the time of issuance is absent, negating criminal liability.

2. Dacion en Pago
Dacion en pago is a special mode of payment whereby property is alienated to the creditor in satisfaction of a debt in money. Governed by the law on sales, it requires the consent of both debtor and creditor, an object certain, and a cause or consideration. Upon the delivery and transfer of ownership of the agreed property to the creditor, the monetary obligation is completely extinguished, along with any accessory security arrangements or pending civil claims arising from the underlying debt.

3. Essential Legal Forms
Legal drafting requires strict compliance with statutory requisites for enforceability. A promissory note must clearly express an unconditional promise to pay a sum certain in money with specified interest and maturity. A judicial affidavit must contain the required sworn statements and jurat under the Judicial Affidavit Rule. A deed of dacion en pago must explicitly state the pre-existing debt, describe the property transferred, and declare the total discharge of the debt upon mutual agreement.

TopicsDacion en Pago2Estafa Through Postdated Checks1Legal Forms Drafting1

2017 Bar Examinations

2017 Legal and Judicial Ethics, Q13

Herbert Madasalin, a 25-year old Bar candidate, surrendered his driver’s license to the security guard at the Arlegui Gate when he entered the Malacanang compound to pray at the National Shrine of St. Jude Thaddeus. After praying the novena to St. Jude, Herbert went to the Arlegui Gate to retrieve his driver’s license. However, he was not able to get the license because the security guard was then elsewhere. He returned the next day only to be told that the security guard had misplaced the license. The security guard concerned could not anymore remember where he had placed the license.
Herbert immediately requests your assistance in the preparation of an affidavit of loss. His address is at 143 Zuzuaregui Street, Don Antonio Heights, Quezon City. As his friend, prepare Herbert’s affidavit of loss. (5%)

Quick check

What is the primary legal purpose of executing an affidavit of loss?

Which essential element distinguishes a jurat from an acknowledgment in legal forms?

Under the Rules on Notarial Practice, what is required before a notary public may execute a jurat?

What allegation must be included in an affidavit of loss for a driver's license?

Choices available with full access.

Where should the venue or caption of an affidavit be located?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Practical Exercises answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Affidavit of Loss
An affidavit of loss is a sworn written statement executed by a person who has lost a document, license, title, or valuable instrument. It sets forth the facts surrounding the possession, custody, and subsequent loss or destruction of the instrument. The affiant declares under oath that the item was lost beyond recovery, was not pledged, assigned, or confiscated by law enforcement authorities, and that the statement is executed to secure a replacement document or for other legal purposes.

2. Jurat Requirements
A jurat is the part of an affidavit where the notary public certifies that the document was subscribed and sworn to before him by the affiant. Under the Rules on Notarial Practice, the affiant must personally appear before the notary public, be identified through competent evidence of identity, and sign the affidavit in the notary's presence. The jurat includes the date, location, notary's signature and seal, as well as the document, page, book, and series numbers recorded in the notary's register.

3. Legal Form Execution
Drafting legal forms like affidavits requires strict adherence to essential formal requisites to ensure legal validity and enforceability. An affidavit must contain a proper venue or caption indicating where it was executed, a formal preamble stating the affiant's full name, age, citizenship, and residential address, followed by numbered factual allegations in clear, direct language. It concludes with an execution clause, the affiant's signature, and a complete jurat executed by a commissioned notary public.

TopicsAffidavit of Loss1Jurat and Acknowledgment1Legal Form Execution1

2017 Legal and Judicial Ethics, Q14

Kyle Angelo was served with summons and a copy of the complaint of Ciara Jane for collection of the amount of ₱1,000,000.00 as evidenced by a promissory note signed by Kyle Angelo. She alleged that the debt was overdue; and that Kyle Angelo refused to pay despite repeated demands.
Kyle Angelo engaged the services of Atty. Carlos Sa bit, who decided to file a motion to dismiss on the ground of lack of cause of action and prescription. Atty. Carlos Sabit drafted the motion and sent the draft to Kyle Angelo for his perusal. Kyle Angelo, being himself a law graduate, quickly noticed that the draft did not contain a notice of hearing.
Draft the notice of hearing that Atty. Carlos Sabit should include in the motion to dismiss. (3%)

Quick check

What is the primary function of a notice of hearing in a written motion?

To whom is the notice of hearing in a litigious motion addressed?

Under civil procedure rules, what is the legal effect of a motion filed without proper service or notice to the adverse party?

Under the 2019 Amended Rules of Civil Procedure, how are litigious motions generally resolved by the court?

Choices available with full access.

What essential formal element must be appended at the end of a written motion to show service upon opposing counsel?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Practical Exercises answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Notice of Hearing
A notice of hearing in a motion is a formal written request directing the clerk of court and the adverse counsel to take notice that a motion will be submitted for the consideration and approval of the court on a specified date and time. Under traditional civil procedure rules, litigious motions require a notice of hearing to satisfy due process requirements by affording the opposing party reasonable opportunity to appear and present objections before the court rules on the motion.

2. Litigious Motions
Under the amended Rules of Civil Procedure, motions are classified as either non-litigious or litigious. Litigious motions, such as a motion to dismiss, are those that affect the substantive rights of the adverse party. Although recent rule amendments have modified the traditional requirement of setting oral arguments for litigious motions at the discretion of the court, a motion must still properly notify the adverse party and the clerk of court of its submission for resolution.

3. Service and Proof
Proper service of pleadings, motions, and notices upon the opposing party or counsel of record is mandatory under Rule 13 of the Rules of Court. A copy of the motion and its notice of hearing must be served on the adverse party with proof of service attached. Failure to serve the motion or give proper notice renders the application a mere scrap of paper that cannot be acted upon by the trial court.

TopicsLitigious Motions1Motion to Dismiss4Notice of Hearing1

2017 Legal and Judicial Ethics, Q15

Believing that an onerous transfer would result in lesser taxes than a gratuitous transfer, Nenita Villo, a widow, decided to sell her lone asset worth ₱3,000,000.00 to her daughters, Andrea, Carina and Carissa, all of legal age, gainfully employed and still unmarried. The asset consisted of the house and the lot registered under Transfer Certificate of Title No. 67890 of the Register of Deeds of Paranaque City and situated at No. 3156 Bayswater Street, Metro Ville Subdivision, Paranaque City where Nenita and her daughters presently resided.
Nenita required her daughters to make a down payment of ₱1,000,000.00, and the balance to be paid once the title to the property was transferred to her daughters’ names. All the taxes, fees, and costs related to the sale would be for the account of Nenita, while those related to the transfer of title would be paid by Andrea, Carina and Carissa.
Draft the contract to be executed by Nenita and her daughters in connection with the transfer of the house and lot. Omit details other than those stated in the question. (10%)

Quick check

What distinguishes a deed of conditional sale from an absolute deed of sale?

Under a deed of conditional sale, when does the seller become obligated to transfer title?

Can the parties to a real estate sale contract validly agree on the allocation of taxes and transfer fees?

Which law requires contracts for the sale of real property to be in writing to be enforceable?

Choices available with full access.

Why is notarization necessary for a deed conveying real estate in the Philippines?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Practical Exercises answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Conditional Sale Nature
A deed of conditional sale is a contract where ownership over the real property remains with the vendor and does not automatically pass to the vendees until full payment of the stipulated purchase price. The agreement creates a suspensive condition where title reservation protects the seller. Upon satisfaction of the agreed monetary terms, the vendor becomes legally obligated to execute a final deed or transfer title to the buyers.

2. Allocation of Expenses
In contracts of sale involving real property, parties possess contractual freedom to allocate liability for taxes, fees, and administrative costs. Typically, sellers bear expenses directly related to the sale itself, such as capital gains tax or documentary stamp tax, while buyers assume expenses associated with title registration and transfer taxes. Clear contractual stipulations prevent future legal disputes regarding tax assessments and registration fees.

3. Formal Requisites
Conveyance of real property requires compliance with formal legal requisites under the Statute of Frauds and Notarial Law. A deed of conditional sale must be in writing, clearly describe the property using its Transfer Certificate of Title number and location, state the full consideration, and detail the payment terms. A public instrument acknowledged before a notary public is required for registration with the Register of Deeds.

TopicsDeed of Conditional Sale1Real Estate Conveyance1Transfer of Title1

2010 Bar Examinations

2010 Legal and Judicial Ethics, Q1

Prepare the following:
a. Verification and Certification against Forum Shopping. (5%)
b. Petition for Letters Rogatory. (5%)

Quick check

What is the primary purpose of a verification in a civil pleading under Rule 7 of the Rules of Court?

Who must execute the certification against forum shopping attached to an initiatory pleading?

Under Rule 23 of the Rules of Court, what is a Letter Rogatory?

When is the issuance of Letters Rogatory appropriate for taking a deposition abroad?

What is the mandatory legal consequence of the complete absence of a certification against forum shopping?

Learn more about these topics

1. Verification and Certification
Under Rule 7, Section 4 and Section 5 of the Rules of Court, a pleading required to be verified must contain an affidavit stating that the affiant has read the pleading and that the allegations therein are true and correct of his personal knowledge or based on authentic records. Additionally, the certification against forum shopping is a mandatory requirement executed by the plaintiff or principal party certifying under oath that no other similar action or claim has been commenced or is pending in any court, tribunal, or quasi-judicial agency.

2. Forum Shopping Certification
The certification against forum shopping seeks to prevent the repetitive filing of identical actions across different judicial forums to obtain a favorable judgment. Failure to comply with the requirement of attaching a certification against forum shopping is generally non-curable and constitutes a cause for the dismissal of the complaint or initiatory pleading upon motion and hearing. The certification must be executed personally by the party-litigant unless compelling reasons exist justifying an authorized representative.

3. Letters Rogatory Procedure
Under Rule 23, Section 11 of the Rules of Court, when a deposition is to be taken in a foreign country, it may be taken on notice before a secretary of embassy or legation, consul general, consul, vice consul, or consular agent, or by commission or letters rogatory. A letter rogatory is an instrument issued by a local court requesting a foreign judicial authority to cause the examination of a witness within its foreign territorial jurisdiction when taking a deposition by commission is impracticable or ineffective.

TopicsForum Shopping Rules1Letters Rogatory Deposition1Verification and Certification2