Bar Subject: Commercial Law

2025 Bar Examinations

2025 Commercial Law, Q1

XYZ Corp. filed an administrative complaint for patent infringement against ABC Company. XYZ Corp. was the patentee of Philippine Patent No. I-12345, which boasts of the innovative step of curing ham by exposing it to a filtered smoke cooled in a cooling unit between 10° and 12°C while retaining ingredients exerting highly preservative and sterilizing effects. ABC Company employs a similar method, the only difference being that it cools down its filtered smoke between 20° and 24°C instead of 10° and 12°C. ABC Company maintained that it is not guilty of infringing Patent No. I-12345 because its process is not exactly the same as XYZ Corp.’s. XYZ Corp. countered, however, that infringement was committed because ABC Company’s process performs substantially the same function and achieves substantially the same result as its own. Decide with reason(s).

Quick check

Under Section 75 of the Intellectual Property Code (R.A. No. 8293), how is the scope of protection conferred by a patent determined?

What is required to prove literal patent infringement under Philippine intellectual property law?

Under the doctrine of equivalents, what three elements must be established under the function-means-and-result test?

Why does achieving the same commercial result alone fail to establish patent infringement under the doctrine of equivalents?

A patent claims a ham-curing process by cooling smoke between 10° and 12°C. An accused company cools smoke between 20° and 24°C. Why is there no patent infringement?

Learn more about these topics

1. Literal Infringement
Under Section 75 of the Intellectual Property Code, literal infringement occurs when an accused product or process falls clearly and exactly within the literal language of the patent claims. Every material element specified in the patent claim must be present in the alleged infringing device or method. If an essential element or numerical limitation claimed in the patent is altered, substituted, or missing in the accused process, literal infringement does not lie. Courts adhere strictly to the patent claims to determine literal identity.

2. Doctrine of Equivalents
The doctrine of equivalents prevents an infringer from evading liability through minor or colorable variations of a patented invention. Under Philippine law, applying this doctrine requires satisfying the function-means-and-result test. The patentee must prove that the accused process performs substantially the same function, in substantially the same way, to achieve substantially the same result. Proving merely that two processes yield the same result is insufficient without establishing that they operate in substantially the same manner.

3. Function-Means-Result Test
The function-means-and-result test requires a triple identity to establish patent infringement under the doctrine of equivalents. The patentee bears the burden of showing substantial identity in function, means, and result between the patented invention and the accused process. When the accused process utilizes a substantially different method or operating condition—such as a distinct temperature range—the element of means is not satisfied. Consequently, achieving a similar end result alone will not sustain a claim of equivalency infringement.

TopicsDoctrine of Equivalents2Intellectual Property Code11Patent Infringement1

2025 Commercial Law, Q2

X, a German national, was a devout follower of BBB religion. He came to the Philippines to spread the teachings of BBB religion. He soon gained thousands of followers, and formed a corporation sole, ABC Corporation, in accordance with Philippine laws. ABC Corporation, through X, purchased a building where the followers of BBB religion can perform their rituals and ceremonies. Y, a concerned citizen, assailed the acquisition of real property by ABC Corporation since its leader, X, is a foreigner. X countered that since all its members are Filipino citizens, ABC Corporation is qualified to own real property in the Philippines. Decide with reason(s).

Quick check

What is the primary legal nature and purpose of a corporation sole under Section 109 of the Revised Corporation Code?

How is the nationality of a corporation sole determined for private land ownership under the 1987 Constitution?

Under Article XII, Section 7 of the Constitution, what minimum percentage of Filipino membership is required for a corporation sole to acquire private land?

What is the role of the presiding head of a corporation sole with respect to real properties acquired by the corporation?

A foreign minister incorporates a corporation sole in the Philippines whose entire congregation consists of Filipino citizens. Can the corporation sole acquire private land?

Learn more about these topics

1. Corporation Sole Nature
Under Section 109 of the Revised Corporation Code, a corporation sole is formed by the chief archbishop, bishop, priest, minister, rabbi, or presiding elder of any religious denomination. It is created to administer and manage the temporalities, estate, and properties of the religious denomination. A corporation sole has no stockholders or board of directors. The single presiding officer acts as an administrator and trustee for the religious community. Consequently, property acquired by a corporation sole is held in trust for the benefit of the entire religious congregation rather than for the personal benefit of the presiding head.

2. Constitutional Land Capacity
Article XII, Section 7 of the 1987 Philippine Constitution restricts private land ownership to Filipino citizens or corporations with at least sixty percent Filipino capital. In evaluating land ownership capacity for a corporation sole, courts look beyond the nationality of the presiding head. In Roman Catholic Administrator of Davao v. LRC, the Supreme Court ruled that a corporation sole is a mere administrator of temporalities. Because beneficial ownership resides in the members of the religious denomination, the corporate nationality for constitutional land ownership purposes is determined by the citizenship of the congregation rather than the bishop or minister.

3. Beneficial Ownership Rule
The doctrine of beneficial ownership dictates that the legal title held by a trustee is subordinated to the equitable title enjoyed by the beneficiaries. In religious corporations sole, the presiding head holds legal title strictly as a trustee. If the vast majority or entirety of the religious congregation consists of Filipino citizens, the constitutional requirement of sixty percent Filipino ownership is fully satisfied. The foreign citizenship of the individual serving as the corporation sole does not disqualify the entity from acquiring private lands, because the ultimate economic and beneficial ownership remains entirely with the Filipino faithful.

TopicsCorporation Sole1Land Ownership1Revised Corporation Code9

2025 Commercial Law, Q3

X sells luxury bags on her Facebook page. Interested buyers were required to comment “mine” together with the codename of the product to express their offer to buy. The first one to comment, evidenced by a screenshot, would get the item. During one of her Facebook livestreams, X offered for sale a luxury bag of a well-known brand from Italy for which the code name “Italy” was assigned. Y, an interested viewer, was the first to post her comment, “Mine Italy.” She then took a screenshot of her message with the item still shown in the background. Despite this, X sold the bag to her sister, Z. Y demanded that X sell her the bag, contending that the screenshot of her comment was adequate proof of the existence of a perfected contract of sale under the Electronic Commerce Act. Is Y correct? Reason(s).

Quick check

Under Section 16 of the Electronic Commerce Act (R.A. No. 8792), how may the offer and acceptance of a contract be expressed?

Under Article 1475 of the Civil Code, when is a contract of sale perfected between contracting parties?

How does the Rules on Electronic Evidence treat screenshots of social media comments used to prove an online transaction?

An online seller conducts a livestream auction requiring buyers to post specific codenames to purchase items. What is the legal effect when a viewer posts the required codename first?

If an online seller sells an item to a third party after a contract of sale was already perfected with the first buyer, what is the legal status of the first buyer's claim?

Learn more about these topics

1. Electronic Contract Formation
Under Section 16 of the Electronic Commerce Act (R.A. No. 8792), contracts formed through electronic data messages or electronic documents are valid and legally binding. Unless the parties agree otherwise, an offer, acceptance, and all other essential requisites for contract formation may be expressed, demonstrated, and proved by electronic means. Electronic communication satisfies statutory writing and signature requirements, provided the message or document remains authentic and accessible for subsequent reference. Consequently, electronic interactions on digital commerce platforms possess full legal force and effect.

2. Perfection of Sale
Under Article 1475 of the Civil Code, a contract of sale is perfected at the moment there is a meeting of minds upon the thing which is the object of the contract and upon the price. As a consensual contract, a sale does not require delivery of the item or payment of the purchase price for its perfection. When a seller makes a definite public offer during an online livestream and a buyer validly communicates acceptance following the seller's prescribed procedure, consent concurs, and the contract immediately becomes binding on both parties.

3. Electronic Evidence Validity
Under the Rules on Electronic Evidence, electronic data messages and electronic documents, including screenshots of digital messaging or social media comments, are admissible as functional equivalents of original written documents. To be admissible, the electronic document must be authenticated by showing that a reliable security procedure or verification process was used to capture and preserve the data. A screenshot displaying the buyer's comment, timestamp, and product details serves as competent proof to establish the concurrence of offer and acceptance in court.

TopicsContract of Sale2Electronic Commerce Act6Electronic Evidence2

2025 Commercial Law, Q5

X obtained an insurance policy for her Porsche Carrera GT from XYZ Insurance Company. The same car was insured by her creditor-mortgagee, Y, with ABC Insurance Company. When the car was damaged because of an accident, X filed a claim with XYZ Insurance Company. The latter denied the claim since it discovered that the car was also insured with ABC Insurance Company. According to XYZ Insurance Company, double insurance is prohibited by law. Decide with reason(s).

Quick check

Under Section 95 of the Insurance Code (R.A. No. 10607), when does double insurance exist?

What is the extent of a mortgagee's insurable interest in mortgaged property?

Why does no double insurance exist when both a mortgagor and a mortgagee separately insure the same mortgaged vehicle?

Is double insurance prohibited per se under Philippine insurance law?

Under Section 98 of the Insurance Code, what rule governs recovery when over-insurance occurs by double insurance?

Learn more about these topics

1. Double Insurance Requisites
Under Section 95 of the Insurance Code (R.A. No. 10607), double insurance exists where the same person is insured by several insurers separately in respect to the same subject matter and same interest. For double insurance to exist, five requisites must concur: the person insured must be the same, there must be two or more insurers, the subject matter must be identical, the risk or peril insured against must be the same, and the interest insured must be identical. If any requisite is lacking, double insurance does not lie.

2. Insurable Interest Distinction
A mortgagor and a mortgagee possess separate and distinct insurable interests over mortgaged property. The mortgagor's insurable interest is based on full ownership and extends to the entire value of the property. Conversely, the mortgagee's insurable interest is limited strictly to the extent of the debt secured by the mortgage. Because the mortgagor and mortgagee insure distinct economic interests, policies obtained separately by each on the same property do not constitute double insurance.

3. Double Insurance Validity
Double insurance is not prohibited by law per se unless the insurance policy explicitly contains an over-insurance or other-insurance clause. In the absence of a contractual prohibition, a property owner may obtain multiple insurance policies on the same subject matter. However, under Section 98 of the Insurance Code, the insured cannot recover more than the actual loss suffered. In cases of over-insurance by double insurance, the ratable contribution rule applies among the insurers to prevent unjust enrichment.

TopicsDouble Insurance2Insurable Interest5Insurance Code2

2025 Commercial Law, Q7

To celebrate her 70th birthday, A hired F Travel & Tours to arrange and facilitate her booking, ticketing, and accommodation for a two-week foreign tour, which included visits to Italy and Greece, for the total amount of PHP 145,000.00. On Wednesday, August 14, 2024, B, an employee of F Travel & Tours, went to A’s house to deliver the travel documents and plane ticket. She told A to be at the Ninoy Aquino International Airport (NAIA) on Saturday, August 17, 2024 two hours before her flight schedule. Without checking her travel documents, A went to NAIA on Saturday, August 17, 2024. When she got there, she was informed that the flight she was supposed to take had already left the previous day. A demanded that F Travel & Tours refund her payment. She claimed that F Travel & Tours did not observe the standard of care required of a common carrier when its employee, B, informed her of the wrong flight schedule. Is F Travel & Tours liable as a common carrier? Reason(s).

Quick check

Under Article 1732 of the Civil Code, what primary characteristic defines a common carrier?

Why is a travel agency excluded from classification as a common carrier under Philippine civil law?

What standard of diligence is required of a travel agency in performing its contractual obligations?

In Crisostomo v. Court of Appeals, what was the legal consequence of a travel agency employee providing an incorrect flight departure schedule to a passenger?

Choices available with full access.

Under Article 1170 of the Civil Code, on what legal ground may a travel agency be held civilly liable to a customer?

Choices available with full access.

Unlock the full Commercial Law answers

Learn more about these topics

1. Common Carrier Definition
Under Article 1732 of the Civil Code, common carriers are persons, corporations, firms, or associations engaged in the business of carrying or transporting passengers or goods or both, by land, water, or air, for compensation, offering their services to the public. To be classified as a common carrier, the primary obligation of the entity must be the actual transportation of persons or property from one place to another. Entities that merely arrange, facilitate, or contract for transportation services provided by third-party carriers do not fall under the statutory definition of a common carrier.

2. Travel Agency Nature
As laid down in Crisostomo v. Court of Appeals, a travel agency is not a common carrier because its legal business is limited to arranging and facilitating travel bookings, ticket issuances, and tour accommodations. A travel agency does not own, operate, or control the aircraft, vessels, or vehicles used for passenger transportation, nor does it undertake the physical carriage of travelers. Consequently, the object of a contract between a traveler and a travel agency is the procurement of travel services rather than the actual carriage of passengers across geographical destinations.

3. Required Diligence Standard
Because a travel agency is not a common carrier, it is not bound to observe the extraordinary diligence mandated by Article 1733 of the Civil Code. Instead, a travel agency is governed by the general provisions on obligations and contracts under Article 1173 of the Civil Code, requiring only the diligence of a good father of a family. Although a travel agency may be held liable for breach of contract due to negligence under Article 1170, its liability is evaluated under ordinary diligence rather than the rigorous standard imposed upon common carriers.

TopicsCommon Carriers5Standard of Diligence1Travel Agency Liability1